Photo Slideshows

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

By • February 23, 2012 • 0 Comments

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies by Midge

WHO: Midge, a well-rounded, well-traveled journalist, and beloved veteran food52-er. 

WHAT: Buckeye-inspired sandwich cookies -- a kiddy treat for grown-up tastes.

HOW: Smooth peanut butter made that much creamier by the addition of, well, cream, smooshed between spiced cocoa cookies. 

WHY WE LOVE IT: With all that cayenne and ancho bringing a pleasantly slow but undeniable burn from the cookie side of things, the creamified peanut butter filling presents a welcome, soothing contrast. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 1 of 18

Ancho, chipotle, cayenne, salt, cocoa powder, egg, cream, vanilla, butter, peanut butter, black pepper. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 2 of 18

First things first. Puree chipotles. Marvel at their vibrant color. Ooo la la. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 3 of 18

Warm the cream, and whip it up with a little creamy peanut butter, those pureed chipotles and salt. Doesn't sound very cookie-ish yet, does it?

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 4 of 18

Pour the mixture into a bowl and let it chill at least a few hours or even over night. You know, enough time for a good nap, or a full night's sleep. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 5 of 18

Instead of napping, you could opt make the cookie part now. If so, drop your softened butter into the bowl of a mixer. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 6 of 18

Cream. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 7 of 18

Assemble the dry ingredients - cocoa powder and sugar and LOTS of cayenne, ancho chili and black pepper. Fantastically firey and not for the faint of heart. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 8 of 18

This is why you must always sift cocoa powder: sneaky cocoa nubbins! 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 9 of 18

Ahh, that's better. Thank you sifter for helping us transform the naughty cocoa into a cookie-friendly powdery dust! 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 10 of 18

Combine and mix. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 11 of 18

Let there be dough! 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 12 of 18

Roll the dough into chocolatey rolls. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 13 of 18

And wrap up the roll for a little chill time in the fridge. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 14 of 18

It comes out just so sliceable! 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 15 of 18

Chilled & chili-ed polka dots of chocolate. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 16 of 18

After a quick bake in the oven, it is at last time to apply the creamy PB filling. Like so. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 17 of 18

And to bask in their adorableness. 

Two-Bite Buckeye Cookies

Photo 18 of 18

You can eat a few, too. There are plenty of these lovelies to go around. 

Jump to Comments (0)

Tags: chocolate and spice, contest,

Comments (0)

Default-small
Default-small