Small Batch

Homemade Tootsie Rolls

By • October 19, 2012 • 33 Comments

255 Save

Every week, a DIY expert spares us a trip to the grocery store and shows us how to make small batches of great foods at home.

Today, Heather Baird, the photographer and blogger behind Sprinkle Bakes, shows how to make an at-home version of Tootsie Rolls. Heather is the author of SprinkleBakes: Dessert Recipes to Inspire Your Inner Artist.

When Halloween rolls around, I’m usually stuck in the candy aisle trying to decide what kids like nowadays. Besides a tangle of spider rings and an economy-size sack of chocolate bars, I usually leave with a bag of Tootsie Rolls -- more for me than for the trick-or-treaters. It’s something I always received in my treat bag as a kid.

I love re-creating nostalgic candies at home, and the idea of making homemade Tootsie Rolls has always appealed to me. I came up with my own Tootsie Roll recipe after trying several that seemed too sweet. I ditched the corn syrup for honey and traded in the semisweet chocolate for good quality unsweetened cocoa powder. The end result is a lightly chocolate-flavored chewy candy that is reminiscent of the real thing. And besides melting a little butter, it’s a no cook and no bake recipe!

The texture of a homemade Tootsie Roll is slightly less firm than its classic counterpart, but no less delicious. The honey is mostly masked by the cocoa flavor but I really love the little nuance it gives the candy. I used wildflower honey but different types of honey will impart different subtleties, so have fun choosing what to use! You can also add a little espresso powder to enhance the chocolate flavor, though this is a more grown-up option and not recommended for kiddie treats.

Homemade Tootsie Rolls
Makes 22-24 pieces

½ cup honey
¼ cup plus 2 tablespoons unsweetened cocoa powder, sifted
1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
1 tablespoon unsalted butter, melted
¼ cup powdered sugar, sifted
Pinch of salt
1 to 1 ¼ cup instant non-fat dry milk powder


In a large bowl, combine honey, cocoa powder and vanilla using a whisk. Add the melted butter and whisk until well incorporated. Add in the powdered sugar and pinch of salt; whisk again until well combined.

Using a wooden spoon, mix in the instant milk powder ¼ cup at a time until a dough forms. When you can no longer stir the mixture with a spoon, knead it with your hands. Keep adding in milk powder until a firm dough forms. You may not have to use all the milk powder. The finished dough should be firm and a little sticky but not so sticky that you can’t handle it. Roll the dough into a ball and place on waxed paper lightly sprayed with cooking oil or coated with butter or vegetable oil.

Let dough rest uncovered on the wax paper for 5-10 minutes. As the candy stands it will relax from a ball shape into a disc. Cut candy into ¾-inch strips and then into 2-inch lengths. If candy sticks to the knife, spray it with cooking oil or coat it with butter.



Cut wax paper into 3 ½ x 5 inch pieces. Wrap candies with the wax paper pieces.

Store candies in an air-tight container in the refrigerator. Bring to room temperature before serving.

Save and print the recipe here.


Heather will be answering questions about Tootsie Rolls on the Hotline for those of you who want to take on this project at home. For the quickest response, go to her recipe and ask a question from there -- we'll email her your question right away!

Tags: DIY, small batch, heather baird, sprinklebakes, candy, tootsie roll, halloween, how-to & diy

Comments (33)

Default-small
Default-small
Default-small

11 months ago KathyHorniak

I would try putting the powdered milk in the very powerful Vitamix blender on it's own to make it finer before using. It should work fine and give a better texture for this reciped. I use my vintage Vitamix to make powdered sugar out of regular grain sugar. It works instantly. By the way you can make flours out of any nuts, grains, popcorn, etc. If you cook gluten free it is fantastic as you create all kinds of flours! When you use the Vitamix the motor goes in one direction very fast and then you hit the switch and it slams the particles into the opposite directions. It works great! My husband refurbishes them if anyone is interested in one. I adore mine! Contact my husband [email protected] if you interested in one. They run around $250 to $350, as he also custom paints some of them in red. New Vitamixes go for around $600 and are made of plastic. The old ones are all stainless steel and folks love them. :) Kathy

Default-small

12 months ago Sophia Henkel

We have an ice cream shop here in San Francisco, the original Swensen's before they became a chain. They make a version of chocolate ice cream called "Sticky Chewy Chocolate" it took me a couple bites to realize why the flavor was so familiar, it is the flavor of a tootsie roll, it is now one of our favorite flavors.

Stringio

about 1 year ago Amy Mancuso

Has anybody tried running the milk powder through a food processor to make it finer? That may cut down on the graininess.

Default-small

about 1 year ago titaemmie

I think the original recipe has lecithin in it.
Lecithin is used for treating memory disorders such as dementia and Alzheimer’s disease. It is also used for treating gallbladder disease, liver disease, certain types of depression, high cholesterol, anxiety, and a skin disease called eczema.

Some people apply lecithin to the skin as a moisturizer.

You will often see lecithin as a food additive. It is used to keep certain ingredients from separating out.

Stringio

about 1 year ago Amy Spaeth

Thank you so much for this recipe! My son cannot have food dyes, HFCS or any corn syrup so most candy is out:( We tried this tonight and he L-O-V-E-S it!!! When I first started mixing in the instant milk powder it was grainy like a few have commented, BUT I neaded it for a long time (which helped) and after letting it rest it got even better AND after wrapping and putting in the fridge, any bit of grainyness is gone. They turned out wonderful in my opinion! Oh, and I only had Ghirardelli Sweet Ground Chocolate and Cocoa, I was worried that it would be too sweet but it was perfect:)

Default-small

about 1 year ago JessBarton

These are delicious! But I'm wondering how would you make them into the vanilla Tootsie Rolls you see with the other fruit flavored ones? I can't find a recipe anywhere :/ Any suggestions?

008

over 1 year ago Joybee

Cool! I used to love tootsie rolls as a kid. I will have to try this sometime.

Default-small

over 1 year ago Shan2218

I made these tonight and I had the same problem as MonikaH. It was completely grainy even adding the dry milk slowly and letting it sit for a few hours. It was also still super sticky...decided not to give up and added a bit of flour (1/4 cup very slowly) and it still never firmed up enough to where it was workable. Tasted good :P But was a mess, not sure why. I'd like to try again if there are any tips or ideas. Thanks.

Stringio

over 1 year ago Nancy Lee Matthews Blondin

I read that there is a difference between powdered milk and instant dry milk. Some recipes call for powdered milk vs instant dry milk like this one calls for. The instant dry milk should dissolve better than the powdered milk variety so I wonder if that is the difference you are seeing?? Did you use instant dry milk or did you use powdered milk? I am going to make this today using the instant dry milk. Also I would think adding more powdered sugar is the answer to firming it up. Add a touch more salt if it seems to sweet. Or try putting it in the refrigerator as I have seen as a required step in several other recipes.

Stringio

over 1 year ago Nancy Lee Matthews Blondin

I tried this recipe using instant dry nonfat milk. It did get a little grainy, but the more I kneaded it the more the milk dissolved. I added powdered sugar to decrease the stickiness which worked fine. I also added a bit of extra salt to cut the added sweetness but it was probably unneccessary. It reminded me of making butter cream fondant and the texture and properties were similar. My kids enjoyed making these, but they both spit them out (ages 3 and 5.) They do have a bit of a dry milk aftertaste which may be the explanation. I think I might try to come up with a version using heavy cream instead of dried milk and increase the powdered sugar and decrease the honey to offset the difference. Overall this recipe was a fun project to do with young kids and probably an added plus that they didn't want to devour the entire batch. lol

Stringio

over 1 year ago Nancy Lee Matthews Blondin

I tried the heavy cream version and what I ended up with is the easiest no cook chocolate fudge recipe ever. But it wouldn't really qualify as a tootsie roll. After several hours, the original tootsie roll recipe flavors started to meld better and the graininess minimized and my 5 year old now loves them. The 3 year old spit out the fudge recipe as well, so her initial reaction is probably no reflection on this recipe. I would still recommend trying to make these. The most fun was wrapping them up in little squares of wax paper and twisting the ends like the real ones.

Stringio

over 1 year ago Brandee Kestermont

Did you ever figure out what the problem was?

Default-small

over 1 year ago MonikaH

Ok...I did something wrong! The mixture became very grainy after I added the instant dry nonfat milk! Help!

Default-small

over 1 year ago MonikaH

Hi Heather,
I was planning to make these for Christmas gifts. How far ahead can I make them? What is their shelf life? Thank-you!
MonikaH

Default-small

over 1 year ago Kaycita

I made 2 batches of this tonight for Halloween. Awesome. I tried using the knife and it was kind of a pain because it kept getting sticky even though I kept using butter. SO... I just pulled off bits of dough and rolled little logs. Worked great. This would be a perfect recipe for kids to do on their own that way. Thanks so very much!

Default-small

over 1 year ago leighbe

Love tootsie rolls!! Can't wait to give this a try.

Bss-sun-150

over 1 year ago softenbrownsugar

I absolutely love Tootsie Rolls. It hadn't even occurred to me to make my own. This sounds like such a fun and easy recipe, but I'm so surprised to see people posting about orange flavoured Tootsie Rolls. It's all a matter of taste, but for me, it's always been the regular chocolate flavour. Thanks for the recipe, Heather!

Default-small

over 1 year ago Katie Potato

Ordinary chocolate tootsie rolls have fruit flavoring. It says so right on their webpage. So people are just trying to get a more authentic recipe~

Bss-sun-150

over 1 year ago softenbrownsugar

How interesting. I've never even tasted the 'subtle, fruit-flavored undertone'. I guess after eating them for over 55 years, I've become immune to the subtleties. :o)

Profile_low_res

over 1 year ago Heather Baird

Hi haapi,
You can use 1/8 to 1/4 teaspoon of orange essence. I recommend kneading it into the dough a couple of drops at time until the desired flavor is achieved. I did not add it to this recipe because of personal preference.

Default-small

over 1 year ago haapi

Shouldn't there be orange essence in here? Can you recommend an amount?

Profile_low_res

over 1 year ago Heather Baird

BTVSgal - I haven't substituted cacao powder for cocoa powder before. I think it would be fine as long as it's properly stored in the refrigerator.

Default-small

over 1 year ago BTVSgal

Can you use Cacao powder instead of the cocoa powder?

Default-small

over 1 year ago Ahuang

Thank you so much Heather! That makes all the world of difference. I will now be able to make some tonight. YAY! :)

Profile_low_res

over 1 year ago Heather Baird

Ahuang,
It's also called "icing sugar" or "confectioners' sugar". Does that help any?

Terya - I used natural cocoa powder.

Default-small

over 1 year ago terya

Is that dutch processed cocoa or natural?

Default-small

over 1 year ago Ahuang

Hi, this looks like an amazing recipe, one which I would love to try. I just had one question - I live in Australia and haven't heard of powdered sugar before. Could you tell me what our equivalent might be? Thank you.

Profile_low_res

over 1 year ago Heather Baird

Hi Kate,
The first thing that comes to mind is an organic non-dairy coffee creamer. I've never used one in this recipe, but I'll certainly be trying it out in some test batches . Thanks for your question! I'll update this thread with my results.

Default-small

over 1 year ago Kate Criswell

What do you think those of us dairy free folks could replace the milk powder with?

Default-small

over 1 year ago Katie Potato

It's not a Tootsie roll without orange flavor. The official explanation is a "subtle, fruit-flavored undertone" but I"m pretty sure it's orange.

Mcs

over 1 year ago mcs3000

i must try this. cool!

Button-butteryumcopy

over 1 year ago ButterYum

Looks wonderful - we love Tootsie Rolls... the girls and I will have fun making a homemade version. Thanks for sharing the recipe.

3-bizcard

over 1 year ago sdebrango

Suzanne is a trusted source on General Cooking.

Love this, tootsie rolls were always one of my favorites and making them yourself sounds like fun and so delicious. I like that they are softer, I remember loosing a filling once from a tootsie roll.