Food History 101

"Eels Reversed," and Other Elaborate Medieval Fare

By • July 19, 2013 • 15 Comments

In Strange Food History, we're hitting the books -- to find you the strangest, quirkiest slices of our food heritage.

Today: Medieval food is probably not what you think it is -- it's even stranger. 

Barbara Kafka's Simplest Roast Chicken, from Food52

What comes to mind when you think about “medieval food”? Chances are, your brain creates a menu that’s a cross between what you ate at the Medieval Times Dinner and Tournament and what you learned about ye olde “Dark Ages” in seventh grade history (and maybe you’re also recalling something about the Bubonic Plague and the lack of plumbing). 

The idea that during the 1000 years that comprised the Middle Ages -- from the 5th to the 15th century -- Europeans subsisted on giant turkey legs, roast potatoes, and gruel alone is, however, one of the biggest misconceptions in all of food history. 

A Medley of Roasted Potatoes with Homemade Za'atar and Aleppo Pepper, from Food52

In reality (or what we know of it), medieval food was unbelievably elaborate, so much so that Paul Freedman, a professor of history at Yale and the editor of The History of Taste, claims that the only place it could possibly be recreated today is in the kitchens of modernist molecular gastronomy restaurants. 

Medieval food was in no ways simple or refined. The cuisine relied on intense combinations of sweet and sour, huge quantities of spice, heavy processing (so that no ingredient was identifiable or distinct), and trompe-l’oeil, a French term for optical illusion. Nothing was meant to taste as it looked. Meat was ground and shaped to look like apples, birds were disassembled, cooked, and put back together, and fish were prepared three ways and in three different colors. 

More: A menu for a medieval feast you'll actually want to eat.

 

Le Ménagier de Paris, known in English as The Good Wife’s Guide, is a medieval household book written by an anonymous older man as instructions to his 15-year-old wife. The book contains over 400 recipes (some of which come from Taillevant, chef to the King of France) that showcase just how different medieval European food is from contemporary cuisine.

One of the most intriguing recipes in The Good Wife’s Guide is for “eels reversed.” Eels are skinned and deboned, then sliced lengthwise and flattened into long rectangles. They are then filled with a mixture of meat and spices and sewn back together, inside out. The eel is then cooked, often in red wine, and served.  

So the next time you think the food at your neighbor's dinner party looks unappetizing, just be glad we aren't living in the 13th century. 

Photos by James Ransom, except eels by David Doubilet via National Geographic 

Jump to Comments (15)

Tags: strange food history, medieval, strange, meat, history, culture

Comments (15)

Default-small
Default-small
Default-small

12 months ago healthyservesone

If you get a chance, have a look at Heston Blumenthal's Medieval Feast episode of Heston's Feasts. Lamprey anyone? Yes, it takes a molecular gastronomy chef to recreate these dishes!

Default-small

about 1 year ago sfmiller

Interesting piece. It's worth noting that the sort of medieval cuisine described here would have been eaten only by a small minority of the population--the privileged classes, who could afford to raise or buy meat and purchase spices (outlandishly expensive in those days) and retain cooks and domestic servants to prepare elaborate dishes (you can bet the cookbook author's teenaged wife wasn't prepping those eels herself!) The display and consumption of food was a key marker of social class.

A typical peasant or urban worker ate mostly grains (baked into bread, cooked into porridge, or brewed into ale) and legumes, sometimes supplemented with cheese or eggs; very little meat or fish, and vegetables only in season.

12162013_1815

about 1 year ago Sophia Henkel

I agree, but I would also say that there are no low end cookbooks until Mrs. Beaton, and that was still middle class. Food for anyone under the wealthy and merchant classes are the only ones who would have been targeted, and it is not until after WWI that not having domestic help would have been an issue. The middle classes up until then almost always had some kind of domestic help. The idea of the nuclear family with the mom and female children were the only ones working on the domestic work is only since the mid 20th century. So, yes I guess it is a note, but it was just the way our society was, Instead of retail or service industries we had domestic help. Also you have to remember that the majority of even the wealthy classes were illiterate, so cooking was still a passed on and oral tradition.

I would venture to say most or our human culture that were record is not of the working classes, or urban workers. It is well know that fast food has been the main staple of the majority of humans living in large populations. Ancient Romans, Chinese, or as I said large dense populations did not have kitchens in the home, most food was bought prepared or brought to the home of the average family or worker, not prepared in the home. Even here in San Francisco's China Town, there are residents who had the food delivered prepared by local restaurants and then was consumed in the living quarters. and that was well into the 20th century.

Default-small

about 1 year ago wjd

fyi: i'm assuming you realize that turkey legs cdn't actually have constituted part of the european medieval diet, since they're native to the americas, and had to await european "explorers" to carry them back on their homebound trips; the first old-world turkey mention is from 1529.

Chris_in_oslo

about 1 year ago Greenstuff

Chris is a trusted source on General Cooking

The potatoes too, of course, but I think she's referring to oddly American venues like this one http://www.medievaltimes...

Dsc09796

about 1 year ago Sarah Jampel

Sarah is Food52's assistant editor.

Right! Turkeys did not come to Europe until after the Columbian Exchange. I was referring to Renaissance Fairs, Medieval Times events, and food like this: http://thepioneerwoman...

Default-small

about 1 year ago Muddyfeet

Interesting article and comments. I like eating eel but not looking at them. So I for one, thank you for the picture of cute little glass eels. I wonder how turning the skin in as mentioned in the recipe benefited the dish. The fat I guess? Or maybe the tight skin held the filling together?

Dsc09796

about 1 year ago Sarah Jampel

Sarah is Food52's assistant editor.

Thanks, Muddyfeet! I am not certain how turning the eel inside out benefited the dish except that it probably cooked the "meat" of the eel more thoroughly (and made it possible to stew it in different flavored and spiced liquids, too).

I am definitely more a fan of those cute little glass eels than the ugly big guys. I chose the photo accordingly. I also did not want to scare off readers!

Chris_in_oslo

about 1 year ago Greenstuff

Chris is a trusted source on General Cooking

Actually, eel skin is much too tough to eat, it's more appropriately made into belts and wallets. I think if you look, the glossary for the book says that the reversed eel is skinned and deboned before being turned inside out, essentially butterflied. Interestingly the glossary also goes on to say that the reversed eel is cooked in red wine, a preparation that remains popular in Europe to this day. (Page 344, sarah, thanks to amazon preview.)

Chris_in_oslo

about 1 year ago Greenstuff

Chris is a trusted source on General Cooking

And one more comment, just so you all know I'm obsessed in all directions. That is one great photograph by David Doubilet, one of the best-known photographers of marine animals of all time. The picture is of young eels at a stage when they are clear rather than pigmented. European and East Coast American eels are both born in the middle of the Atlantic, then migrate to one or the other coasts at this young age. They live in estuaries and upriver waters for many years before making the long swim back to spawn. The little "glass eels" in the photo would be far to small to turn inside out and stuff. Most states have outlawed fishing for them anyway.

Dsc09796

about 1 year ago Sarah Jampel

Sarah is Food52's assistant editor.

Thank you for your comments! I didn't want to scare off readers with a photograph of a full-blown eel, which is why I chose the cuter ones. I hadn't heard of David Doubilet before writing this post, but now I'm anxious to check out his other photographs!

Chris_in_oslo

about 1 year ago Greenstuff

Chris is a trusted source on General Cooking

While I wait for The Good Wife's Guide to show up, I pulled the other book sarah jampel mentions, Paul Freedman's Food: The History of Taste, off my shelf. I had forgotten what a beautiful book it is, richly illustrated and packed with history. There's a chapter on the birth of Medieval Islamic cuisine as well as one on Europe in the Middle Ages. 2007, University of California Press, I highly recommend it.

12162013_1815

about 1 year ago Sophia Henkel

I have this book noted on one of my lists of antique cooks books, I have always been interested in ancient foods, and found the book and its history compelling. Though I though his wife was younger, I remember reading 13 not 15, which was not uncommon then. I used to frequent a site that is no longer up and wanted to try out all the all recipes, called foody.com, they had ancient roman recipes, up to Mrs, Beeton. There were a great many regency ones I wanted to try, I wish I had copied and saved them, since the site is not gone. :(

Me

about 1 year ago Kenzi Wilbur

Kenzi is the Managing Editor of Food52.

This is a fantastic article.

Chris_in_oslo

about 1 year ago Greenstuff

Chris is a trusted source on General Cooking

Eel is delicious! Just ordered the book.