All questions

A question about a recipe: Jim Lahey's No-Knead Pizza Dough + Margherita Pie

Food52_01-30-12-3449

I have a question about the recipe "Jim Lahey's No-Knead Pizza Dough + Margherita Pie" from Genius Recipes. Pizza crust not crisp before topping is done

asked by nutcakes 6 months ago
12 answers 1154 views
Default-small
added 6 months ago

I struggled with this dough. Last week I was using a very easy handling King Arthur recipe so trying to adjust. This was hard to stretch out and kept tearing. I squeezed the holes together and patted it out. The main thing is that the topping baked and was getting brown spots and the dough wasn't ready and crisp. It was thin and about the size indicated. I could see the flavor was good, but still dough underdone after 4 minutes. Any tips? I have the other 3 balls to use still. I use nonglazed ceramic tiles to bake it on.

Default-small
added 6 months ago

two tips, one I've tried and one that I just heard from a Italian pizza place. The first is to cook the dough for 4 min first, then take out of the oven, add toppings and put back in until done. The second tip is to throw some non-iodized salt onto the tile, then slide on the crust. (since I've not tried that, I'd be worried about the pizza being too salty)

Default-small
added 6 months ago

Are you cooking on a pizza stone? That helps out immensely because the stone can get much hotter than a regular pizza pan. I have a grill stone that I use, which allows me to crank up the flames on my grill and get the stone piping hot. Also, remember to go lighter on the toppings than you think. Especially the sauce and the cheese. I also throw corn meal on my stone instead of salt, this allows you to not worry about the saltiness levels.

Default-small
added 6 months ago

Yes, as I said, I'm cooking on unglazed tiles which is like what a pizza stone is made of. I do use cornmeal so the pizza slides off the peel onto the tiles.

I see Cynthia, about adding the topping later, maybe will try once more regular way, then that with the last ball.

Default-small
added 6 months ago

Thanks Cynthia, it worked out much better baking off the crust first. Thin and crisp and chewy this time and not undercooked. Still the dough is a pain in butt. I may try my easy dough but just small amount of yeast and overnight rise.

Default-small
Jim Lahey

Jim Lahey is known for his innovative no-knead bread recipe, popularized by the New York Times; he is the Founder/Owner of Sullivan Street Bakery, Chef/Partner of Co. Restaurant, and is the acclaimed cookbook author of "My Bread" and "My Pizza."

added 6 months ago

Sounds like your dough is either too stiff ( lacking water) and/or over fermented, which decreases the overall elasticity of the dough. What temperature did the pizza bake at? How did you measure your ingredients ? (volume or weight) I advise always weigh your ingredients using grams.

Sit2
added 6 months ago

Jim..Since you're here, and I hope you check back to this thread. Can you expand on what type of flour you use. I'm from the south and some of our flour is much softer than USDA. So you have a specific brand you recommend. The No-Kneed Bread recipe failed for me until I converted to using gold medal AP flour and adjusting for weight. 130g/cup for GM AP vs 125g/cup USDA.

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only
AntoniaJames

AntoniaJames is a trusted source on Bread/Baking.

added 6 months ago

I had this problem, especially with fresh toppings with high water content. I use a "screaming hot" pizza stone (pierino's description, bless him) and pre-bake without the toppings for about 3 minutes, docking beforehand and about 2 minutes in, knocking down any pita-like puffing. Worked like a charm. I use William Alexander's starter method and ratios from "52 Loaves," adding a touch of whole wheat and rye flours for more character. Excellent pizza, if I may say so. ;o)

Sit2
added 6 months ago

This is multi purpose. Get a spray bottle a fine mister bottle is best. But any dollar store spray bottle works.
Fill with 1/2 water and 1/2 olive oil. Shake and spray. on the pizza dough. The water and oil will help to give you a great crispy brown crust.
Don't bother with the pam or that 'misto' spray thing which always breaks after a few uses. Spray bottle and water and use it as spray oil. I've been using that for several months now and it's keeper for me. The added bonus is that my pizza crust is now nice and crispy brown. For the bottom of the crust...a very very hot stone..and let it rest on a wire rack to cool and crisp to avoid soggy bottom crust.

Default-small
added 6 months ago

How are you cooking the pizza? Are you doing it in your oven under the broiler? Just baking it in a hot oven? What rack are you using? How long are you preheating your stone/tile?

Bt-logo
added 6 months ago

You might try moving the tiles lower in the oven so that there's less heat on top of the pizza, and also be sure you are preheating the oven and tiles for long enough to get that searing hot temp. We recommend 500F. Regarding your dough, something that works well is shaping pizza dough on parchment. Using parchment can change your ease of pizza making dramatically. Less worry about sliding it onto the tiles, and it's especially helpful if your dough is having issues. Pull it out from under the pizza after 5 minutes.
http://brodandtaylor.com...

Default-small
added 6 months ago

Thanks all, and Jim I don't think I weighted it this time, I will try again-- thanks for the encouragement. The No Knead bread is no fail for me, so another huge fan here.

Yeah my stones are pretty far down. It is possible I didn't let the oven preheat for the extra time period enough past when the indicator showed it up to temp. I did do the broiler 10 min after that though.