less than a minute ago


Marian Bull favorited


Porcelain Enamelware Cups


Porcelain Enamelware Cups


Sankaku Japanese Bandana


Slab Galette with Swiss Chard and Gruyère


My Basket ()

All questions

Got sand dabs from the farmer's market but they smell very fishy...ok to eat?

I got some sand dabs from a fish monger at a farmer's market yesterday -- when they defrosted, they smelled quite fishy even through the pastic bag. I've always heard that fresh fish shouldn't smell fishy. Are sand dabs particularly fishy-smelling fish, or did I get a less than fresh bag? Are they ok to eat?

asked by clintonhillbilly over 3 years ago
7 answers 2020 views
added over 3 years ago

I am not familiar with sand dabs, but if something didn't smell right to me, I wouldn't eat it. Especially fish!


Cynthia is a trusted source on Bread/Baking.

added over 3 years ago

"Fresh" fish should never smell "fishy". Sounds more like cat food.


Sam is a trusted home cook.

added over 3 years ago

I had to look that up. They look like a flounder or flat fish. Still slimy or fishy smelling fish should be tossed.

At first I thought it was something Florence Henderson would have picked up from the former mayor of NYC.


June is a trusted source on General Cooking.

added over 3 years ago

I don't think I'd eat them, but I do think I would be sure to tell the fishmonger next time I went to the market that his sand dabs were off.


Chris is a trusted source on General Cooking

added over 3 years ago

For all of you you haven't had the pleasure of eating them: sanddabs are small flounder that are generally sold on the bone. They are easy to pan fry and are a California favorite. There's just no excuse for them to be anything but very fresh. Honestly, I've never seen them frozen and would recommend them if they were. Sorry clintonhillbilly, I hate it when I buy fish that's not good.

added over 3 years ago

Take them back! The fish store that I go to never has a fishy smell, as all their fish is very fresh. You might want to find another fish store!

added over 3 years ago

Please let the fish monger know. In my experience vendors would much rather have you complain to them so they can do something about it - like refund or exchange. They want to deliver quality and if there is a problem want to fix it! And I concur with everyone else - smells bad, don't eat it.