Make Ahead

Mill Creek Crab Cakes

by:
October  4, 2022
4.5
4 Ratings
  • Makes 4-5 crab cakes
Author Notes

Like a lot of kids who grew up around the Chesapeake Bay, my siblings and I used to catch crabs in the creek near our house, scooping them up with a net as they fed on barnacle-encrusted pilings. For me, there’s no better treat than blue crabs -- steamed, soft-shell, or in the crab cakes my mom makes. Like her, I’m a minimalist when it comes to these babies (and pretty much everything else..), using as few ingredients as possible to let the crabmeat shine. This is what I cook for friends when I can get my hands on Maryland crab, which sadly isn’t often enough, or just for me and my husband when we’re homesick for the bay. Ideally, you'd serve these with sliced homegrown tomatoes, Silver Queen corn-on-the-cob, and ice-cold Natty Bo. - Midge —Midge

Test Kitchen Notes

Midge describes her approach to these crisp beauties as "minimalist." In terms of ingredients, she's absolutely right. Their richness lies in their link to growing up near the spectacular Chesapeake Bay, and summer days spent catching crabs which her mother would turn into these cakes. Being geographically closer to the Left Coast, I used Dungeness Crab. Sweet crab, crisp crust, tart lemon, perfection! I ate a few of them just as is, right out of the pan, with a generous squeeze of lemon, and just for fun, stuffed a few more into a good bun along with some curls of red onion, then slathered on my sister's famous tartar sauce. It was right up there among the best dinners ever. These cakes are as perfect as a sweet, sunny, summer afternoon. - boulangere —boulangere

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • 1 pound jumbo lump or backfin blue crabmeat, preferably from Maryland (or “Maryland-style,” which I’m guessing is code for North Carolina)
  • 1 large egg
  • 1/4 cup panko or fresh breadcrumbs
  • 2 tablespoons mayonnaise, homemade is best but Hellman’s will do in a pinch
  • 1 tablespoon fresh flat-leaf parsley, chopped
  • 1 teaspoon Old Bay seasoning, more or less to taste
  • 1 teaspoon dry mustard
  • pinch sea salt
  • 1 tablespoon unsalted butter
  • 1 tablespoon canola oil
  • lemon wedges for serving
Directions
  1. Pick through crabmeat and discard any shells, careful not to break up those lovely clumps that you paid so dearly for.
  2. In a large bowl, beat egg. Fold in mayo, parsley, panko, mustard, Old Bay, and salt.
  3. GENTLY fold in crab --I use my hands-- keeping those lumps intact. The mixture will likely be loose, but that’s okay. Shape into four or five patties. Refrigerate for about 30 minutes or up to 24 hours.
  4. Heat butter and oil in a 12-inch skillet over medium-high heat until the butter stops foaming. Gently add the patties and sauté for about three minutes on each side or until they’re brown. I use two spatulas to flip them, but even if they fall apart, they still taste amazing. Serve with a squeeze of lemon.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Andrea D.
    Andrea D.
  • ReeceAmy
    ReeceAmy
  • boulangere
    boulangere
  • drbabs
    drbabs
  • wssmom
    wssmom
Midge

Recipe by: Midge

I’m a journalist who’s covered everything from illegal logging in Central America to merit pay for teachers, but these days I write mostly about travel. I’ve been lucky enough to find myself in some far-flung locales, where poking around markets and grocery stores is my favorite thing to do. Cooking, especially baking, is my way of winding down after a long day; there’s nothing like kneading bread dough to bring you back to earth.

56 Reviews

Andrea D. December 25, 2019
Didn't have access to fresh crab meat but the lump crab from the can did just as well. Delicious!
 
ReeceAmy June 9, 2014
Midge, I've made these twice - once with dungeness and once with blue crab. Holy cats! They are amazing - your minimalism pays off. Can't wait to make them AGAIN. thanks for this recipe.
 
Midge July 25, 2014
Thanks ReeceAmy! Time for me to make them again.
 
DebraCR May 21, 2013
I meant to add that I brush with butter and broil for a few minutes and bake to finish, it's so easy. Being a klutz, I tend to break them in a pan.
 
DebraCR May 19, 2013
Just like my recipe, but a friend taught me to use crushed Ritz crackers instead of bread or Panko and I am happy for the buttery flavor they add.
 
Midge May 20, 2013
I'll have to try that! Really crave these when the weather turns warm.
 
boulangere September 24, 2012
I remember these vividly!
 
David M. August 18, 2012
Thank you for this recipe. My wife was having cravings for crab cakes and I found this recipe with so many nice comments. We did substitute low fat mayo and I broiled instead of sautéing them. I know that they would have been better sautéed in butter, but they were still delicious. We ate them with a chilled dry rosé and an arugula balsamic salad. Fantastic.
 
Midge August 19, 2012
So glad you liked them! My mom broils them occasionally too, it's a great healthier option. Love your accompaniments.
 
David M. August 18, 2012
Thank you for this recipe. My wife was having cravings for crab cakes and I found this recipe with so many nice comments. We did substitute low fat mayo and I broiled instead of sautéing them. I know that they would have been better sautéed in butter, but they were still delicious. We ate them with a chilled dry rosé and an arugula balsamic salad. Fantastic.
 
David M. August 18, 2012
Thank you for this recipe. My wife was having cravings for crab cakes and I found this recipe with so many nice comments. We did substitute low fat mayo and I broiled instead of sautéing them. I know that they would have been better sautéed in butter, but they were still delicious. We ate them with a chilled dry rosé and an arugula balsamic salad. Fantastic.
 
David M. August 18, 2012
Thank you for this recipe. My wife was having cravings for crab cakes and I found this recipe with so many nice comments. We did substitute low fat mayo and I broiled instead of sautéing them. I know that they would have been better sautéed in butter, but they were still delicious. We ate them with a chilled dry rosé and an arugula balsamic salad. Fantastic.
 
David M. August 18, 2012
Thank you for this recipe. My wife was having cravings for crab cakes and I found this recipe with so many nice comments. We did substitute low fat mayo and I broiled instead of sautéing them. I know that they would have been better sautéed in butter, but they were still delicious. We ate them with a chilled dry rosé and an arugula balsamic salad. Fantastic.
 
brender June 5, 2012
Finally a real "Maryland" crabcake recipe. I have some in the freezer and will definitely use your recipe. My neighbor used to bring fresh crabs up from the Chester River and we'd pig out!
 
drbabs July 25, 2011
Midge, I made these tonight and they were wonderful. I only had about 1/2 hour to chill them, so I made the cakes and put them on a tray in the freezer for about 1/2 hour before frying them. They were excellent, and only one fell apart. Thank you so much for a great recipe.
 
Midge July 26, 2011
I'm so thrilled you liked them drbabs! Thanks so much for trying the recipe.
 
boulangere May 12, 2011
Congratulations on your EP! Richly deserved.
 
Midge May 12, 2011
Thanks again for trying them and for your awesome review boulangere!
 
wssmom May 12, 2011
The Spouse insisted on making these last night and we LOVED them!
 
Midge May 12, 2011
Wow, I'm so pleased! Thanks so much for letting me know.
 
boulangere May 10, 2011
Midge, I swear you could make these with crab-flavored cat food and the result would be divine. I had them last night, and used Dungeness since I'm closer to the Left Coast. The first few I ate straight out of the skillet, generously spritzed with fresh lemon. They were pretty heavenly. The last few I stuffed into a good sandwich roll along with some curls of red onion and slathered them with my sister's famous tartar sauce, which I just happened to have on hand. Now that was heaven. No wonder you chose this as that for which you most want to be remembered. I will certainly remember you for these. Thank you so much.
 
Midge May 11, 2011
Wow boulangere, you've no idea how thrilled I am that you liked them. Thanks so much for testing them and for your kind remarks!
 
boulangere May 11, 2011
You misunderstand; I LOVE them.
 
Midge May 12, 2011
:)
 
boulangere May 5, 2011
I'm the luckiest person alive today because I get to test these!
 
Midge May 5, 2011
You're sweet boulangere, I'm honored that you chose them. Wish I had time to test a recipe this weekend. Your lovely cake is on my list!
 
Midge May 5, 2011
Hope its works with dungeness if you go that route. My west coast brother has even made them with the crab that come in those tins (from the Philippines?) out of desperation and has reported decent results.
 
I love, love crab cakes, and these sound wonderful. I guess I'd have to use dungeness crab, too, since I now live on the west coast. Thanks for the definition of Natty Bo -- was wondering about that, too!
 
Midge May 1, 2011
Thank you civ!
 
fiveandspice April 29, 2011
Thanks for sharing this lovely recipe and memory with us, Midge. I loooooove crab cakes, and these sound so good!
 
Midge April 29, 2011
thank you fiveandspice!
 
gingerroot April 29, 2011
These sound wonderful, Midge! Thanks for a lovely memory and recipe.
 
Midge April 29, 2011
thanks gingerroot!!
 
healthierkitchen April 28, 2011
I'm not a Marylander but I live in MD now and there is nothing like a good crab cake like this one! Better than Cantler's by far!
 
Midge April 28, 2011
Thanks healthierkitchen! Funny, I just had a Cantler's crab cake last time I was down there!