Passover

Divine Gluten-Free Chocolate Cookies

by:
September 26, 2012
4.3
19 Ratings
Photo by James Ransom
  • Prep time 30 minutes
  • Cook time 15 minutes
  • Serves A crowd
Author Notes

This recipe is an adaptation of the one that I'm told originates with Homesick Texan, although I couldn't find it on her blog. (I did become excessively distracted by her other offerings, however, including desserts made with Dr. Pepper WEE OO!) Hers calls for pecans and chili powder, however, which I have eliminated, and upped the chocolate. I can promise you these will be eliminated within minutes so watch out. —Jestei

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • 2 1/2 cups powdered sugar
  • 1/2 cup unsweetened cocoa powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  • 1/4 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 3 egg whites
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 2 1/2 cups semisweet chocolate chips
Directions
  1. Preheat the oven to 350F and line baking sheet(s)with parchment paper
  2. In a bowl of standing mixer or large bowl with hand held mixer, mix powdered sugar, cocoa powder, cinnamon, and salt on low. Stir in the egg whites with a stand or hand mixer until the batter is well mixed. Stir in the vanilla extract and chocolate chips by hand. The batter will look weird. Don't worry about it.
  3. Using a small cookie scoop or spoon blob batter onto the baking trays, about an inch apart. They will spread a bit.
  4. Bake until the cookies are cracking on the surface, about 15 minutes.
  5. Let cool for ten minutes on the trays then carefully remove to cooling rack.
  6. These will keep in covered container for three days but you'll never keep them that long.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Margo Smith
    Margo Smith
  • Angie
    Angie
  • Madelien
    Madelien
  • Brenna Gordon
    Brenna Gordon
  • Kelly Sanchez
    Kelly Sanchez

77 Reviews

Rita H. December 15, 2022
Easy and delicious. I do them by hand. Takes 5 mins to get from start to oven. I skip cinnamon bc I like the chocolate/nut flavours. Even better when you replace half the chocolate chips with nuts (I love toasted hazelnuts). You can make these 4cm across for normal size cookies or 5-6 for lovely big ones.
 
Recyclegem December 7, 2022
These are great cookies! Always a hit when I take them to an event. And very easy to make. I sometimes add some almond flour to give a bit of protein. For Christmas I add some peppermint and they are amazing!
 
ubs2007 July 12, 2020
Absolutely scrumptious!!!! Only question: my cookies turned out really crunchy despite reducing bake time. Is there a way to make them more gooey rather than crunchy or is "crunchy" the texture it is meant to be? I don't want to play with the chef's perfection!!!!!
 
Margo S. January 16, 2020
Just made the cookies for a fundraising event. I took to heart the warning about the sweetness and followed the suggestion to cut the sugar (I used 2c ) and add more dark cocoa powder (used 3/4c). I also added 1/2 tsp expresso powder (great suggestion!). Someone on this thread used 2 Tbsp. almond butter and I added that too although the flavor didn't come through for me. The batter was delicious! Unfortunately, I used a store brand of bittersweet chocolate chips (O organic brand). They were an unappealing chalky color and had an off flavor - almost like plastic. The cookies turned out ok. Definitely a bittersweet chocolate flavor and not too sweet. I would opt for a better quality chocolate chip next time.
 
JZilch April 29, 2021
I took these three recommendations (1/2 cup less powdered sugar, add a 1/4 cup of cocoa powder and 1/2 teaspoon is espresso powder) and they turned out beautifully. I eat gluten and even I will devour these!!
I also made one last addition of some Maldon sea salt on top, it was the last perfect touch! Saving this one for more future use!
 
Faith April 18, 2019
I made these yesterday and MY WORD they're delish!! They're very simple to make and quick. They have this chewy chocolatey texture that is divine, if you're looking for a quick cookie to make even if you're not gluten free i recommend.
 
Angie November 8, 2018
I've been making this recipe for awhile now and have my coworkers and my mom making it as well now. It never fails that they're gone in just minutes and everyone loves them.
 
Madelien March 18, 2016
Just made them ... a test run for Passover (I know, confectioner's sugar is a no no, but we aren't very observant!) and followed recipe but used dark chocolate chips (what I had on hand). We are chocoholics, but thought they were too sweet. Like the texture though. May try again with a little expresso powder to cut the sweetness and maybe some finely diced nuts.
 
Brenna G. December 5, 2015
Oh my goodness - love these cookies! I have tried similar recipes before but this one is by far the best! I just made a batch and added some crushed candy canes as a little holiday twist! Delicious!
 
Barbara B. October 7, 2015
What can be substituted instead of almond flour - nut allergies in our family?
 
Kelly S. July 15, 2015
Again, why have a choice to pin to Pinterest when none fit the parameters? It's very frustrating.
 
Evelyn J. March 10, 2015
Anyone know if I could sub out 1 cup of the powdered sugar for a cup of (or by weight???) a gluten free flour so they wouldn't be so sweet? Rice flour, almond flour, hazelnut flour?
 
Krystal March 10, 2015
I originally took out 1/4 c of powdered sugar and replaced it with the cocoa powder, I use Divinity or Dagoba cocoa powder, in addition to subtracting about a cup of chocolate chips for finely chopped pecans. So to be more direct, using a nut and/or playing with the recipe a bit should allow you to get a less sweet cookie. Also, if you hold a deeper appreciation for chocolate over sweet, consider using a bittersweet chocolate chip (85-90%) over the semi-sweet.
 
Evelyn J. March 10, 2015
Thanks Krystal! Hadn't thought of Cocoa powder! That sounds great! I like the addition of the pecans too! :)
 
Hgranger January 5, 2015
By weight, 10 oz powdered sugar, 1.5 oz cocoa powder, 15 oz chocolate chips
http://www.kingarthurflour.com/recipe/master-weight-chart.html
 
Lisa April 17, 2024
that link doesn't work
 
Hgranger April 17, 2024
www.kingarthurbaking.com/learn/ingredient-weight-chart
They changed their name since link was posted nine years ago!
 
barb48 December 14, 2014
Is it okay to make the "dough" and refrigerate a few days before baking?
 
Krystal March 10, 2015
I did this in complete reverse! haha

I baked the cookies and then let them cool completely. I then grabbed a few sandwich ziploc bags and 2 large gallon bags, I placed the cookies in the sandwich bags first, closed them and then placed them in the gallon bags before freezing them. I kept them that way for a week before the event. They thawed great and even tasted yummy semi-frozen. I'm not sure if that could be an alternative for you, but it's an idea! right? :)
 
Laura B. June 8, 2014
I made those today, and they reminded me of a much sweeter version of a brownie. They tasted good, but just too sweet for my taste, too rich.
 
cookiemo May 20, 2014
These cookies turned out well, just much too sweet for me. It seems like the batter is there just to hold a bunch of chocolate chips together. I'd rather eat less chocolate chips and a more substantial cookie.
 
Maggie May 5, 2014
Do you have modifications for high-altitude baking? Thanks!
 
Krystal March 10, 2015
http://www.kingarthurflour.com/recipe/high-altitude-baking.html

Betty Crocker also has a page, but King Arthur is my go to and hasn't failed me yet! ;)

Cheers!
 
Liz D. February 23, 2014
These cookies are absolutely awesome!
 
barb48 February 23, 2014
I just made these, subiing some white and butterscotch chips for one cup of the choc. chips. They came out great, but the choc smell in my house was overwhelming. And they expand really well, even using a regular teaspoon. Sending them to son's friend's house when he goes there tonight for dinner.
 
barb48 February 23, 2014
^^^^subbing
 
hotsauce January 21, 2014
These cookies are The New Truth and The New Light.
 
Kelcey January 8, 2014
Do you whip the egg whites and fold into the dry mixture? I need clarity on that step.

Thanks :)
 
Andrea D. January 8, 2014
rukahn

I am gluten and dairy free and I use the brand Enjoy Life Chocolate chips. These are perfect because they are made in a dedicated facility.
 
Jestei January 21, 2014
nope. just add them in.
 
rukahn January 8, 2014
I must eat gluten- and dairy-free, the latter meaning the chocolate must not be processed on equipment shared with milk lest there be traces of milk.(What a pain!)To avoid over-sweetness, does anyone know a truly dairy-free dark (bitter sweet) chocolate product [chips or otherwise]?
 
Andrea D. January 8, 2014
rukahn

I am gluten and dairy free and I use the brand Enjoy Life Chocolate chips. These are perfect because they are made in a dedicated facility
 
Liz D. February 23, 2014
Go for the kosher ones that are listed as nondairy. That way you can be absolutely certain there is no trace of milk. The kosher term for non dairy is "pareve". Scharfen-Berger with the symbol of the U surrounded by an O is non dairy as long as it does not have a letter D next to it. D stands for dairy. And it's great chocolate.
 
martina R. July 17, 2016
Just tried these chocolate cookies. I am allergic to gluten and dairy as well and I use this organic kosher chocolate https://www.santabarbarachocolate.com/ without allergens. I made no changes and the recipe is very easy to follow. And any special ingredients required which is good. The texture turns out between a cookie and fudge. Everyone likes them. Thank you for this great recipe.
 
emjayay December 30, 2013
Unless it's on the outside of a pretzel or something, using kosher or any other kind of bigger grained and more expensive salt makes no difference in any recipe.
 
Krystal December 17, 2013
So... based on the "too sweet" comments (and chocolate loving family) I added ¼ more cocoa powder and ½tsp more vanilla, which made the batter very brownie like --which we loved. I also added cayenne powder & nuts.I added a few other things because I didn't have the full amount of chocolate chips.
Wonderful, wonderful, wonderful!
 
AnnaBell November 8, 2013
I made these with two big modifications and thought I'd post my results in case someone else is thinking along the same lines. I left out the chocolate chips, (didn't have any), and cut the sugar back to two cups since some reviews said they were very sweet. Well, turns out you really need the chips to hold everything together. The batter was very, very wet. I don't think another half cup of sugar would have made a huge difference, they definitely needed the bulk of the chips. Instead of trying to spoon out little cookies and making drippy mess, I poured the batter onto two silicone lined baking sheets and spread it into two giant cookies. They actually baked up a little better than I expected. They definitely need to cool before you try to remove them, and you don't want to under-bake them. Mine tasted of cornstarch, which I'm guessing is the "anti-caking agent" in my powdered sugar. I would suggest not using a brand that has cornstarch if you can help it - since there are so few ingredients, you really taste everything. Minus the cornstarch flavor, they were darn tasty, but very sweet, even with the reduction in sugar. I think beating the egg whites just a bit to give them some lift before incorporating the other ingredients would help if you are going to reduce the sugar and/or chocolate chips.

On a side note, I used one Silpat mat and one generic mat. I started one on the top rack and one on the rack right below; I switched and rotated them half-way through baking. The Silpat waaaaaay outperformed the generic mat. I've noticed slight differences before, but this little exercise convinced me the Silpat is worth every extra penny. The more you know...
 
chocolat January 14, 2014
idiots abound *sigh*
 
hotsauce January 21, 2014
Wow, what a rude and unnecessary comment.
 
Hilary G. November 3, 2013
Made them again with *mini chocolate chips*, about 1.5 cups. They worked exquisitely in the batter and you get some in every bite.
 
caroline September 23, 2013
I added almond butter-- just 2 tablespoons to the whole batch! Unbelievable!
 
Preena September 10, 2013
These look amazing! I would like to make them vegan - any suggestions?
 
Nancy M. August 30, 2013
Do you sift the powdered sugar before measuring?
 
Hilary G. August 9, 2013
These will be the next cookie I make! (Though I wish they could be the next thing I eat!)
 
cschaefer July 10, 2013
Just made this recipe last night. In addition to the one I am eating right now as I write this, I may have already eaten 6… I lost count. The texture & taste of these cookies came out more like a cross between cookie & fudge. A fookie, if you please. Nonetheless a yummy crusty gooeyness of a gluten-free fookie that I will be making again very soon.
 
sumi June 9, 2013
Can anyone tell me how many cookies this batter will make? It looks absolutely amazing!
 
graciousglutton June 9, 2013
I usually get about 3 dozen from the recipe.
 
em-i-lis April 9, 2013
these look delightfully like the chocolate chewies from whole foods, but better!
 
Emma L. March 23, 2013
I don't know how many cookies I got because I started eating them too quickly and couldn't stop.... Subbed out 1/2 cup chocolate chips for 3/4 cup dried cherries and loved the tartness/chewiness they added!
 
Brette W. March 18, 2013
These are the best cookies in the entire world. I made them 4 days in a row. Whoops.
 
GoCuse February 26, 2013
Great gluten free cookies without a list of specialty ingredients. I used Ghiradelli 60% bittersweet chocolate chips, a small #60 scoop and got 48 cookies from the batch. Very rich and will go over with the adults as well as the kids.
 
David W. December 17, 2012
These are fantastic! Many thanks! Thinking about trying a different flavor, perhaps vanilla and almonds or lemon. Would these work without the cocoa powder, or does that provide needed binding for the egg whites?
 
mschrank November 18, 2012
Wow. Delicately crispy on the top, chewy throughout. Just the right amount of sweetness with the semi-sweet chips. So decadent!
 
KKristen November 10, 2012
In love! I'm gluten and dairy-free, and it's hard to come by a good dessert recipe that doesn't require 12+ ingredients with various expensive flours. These cookies were perfect for my sweet-toothed, chocolate-loving self. Warning: They are fragile (crack easily) and stick easily to the sheet!
 
chopwood.ca October 25, 2012
Okay, it's probably because I keep testing the cookies I've just baked that I keep writing... But, any hints on making the cookies not stick so much to the parchment?? (Or is it because I haven't waited the FULL 10 minutes to have them cool on the tray before I give one a try?)
 
chopwood.ca October 25, 2012
Oh! I see in one of the comments someone used bittersweet choc chips....Sounds like a good idea.
 
chopwood.ca October 25, 2012
Mamazita these are sweet! I'm going to try them with unsweetened choc chips and see where we get from there.
 
WileyP October 20, 2012
Okay, Jestei - That'll be enough of *that*! I made a batch of these cookies for a "do" here in the canyon this evening. Then a few neighbors dropped in for a little Saturday morning java and jaw-jackin', and poof, they were gone! Just put a new batch in the oven and will not volunteer any samples to visitors!

These are just marvelous little cookies - A nice bit of crunch on the outside and all that gooey goodness inside. And probably the most intense chocolate flavor I've ever tasted n a cookie. I got 36 cookies using a 1 1/3 tablespoon scoop. They puffed up nicely, even at my 8,000 foot elevation.

Thanks for this great recipe, Jestei!
 
patb October 16, 2012
To. Die. For. And far to easy to mix up. I had to make do with half a batch as my husband had eaten most of the chocolate I planned on using. Many moans from the fam for producing such a small number of so fabulous a cookie. Was told by everyone to make then again ASAP and to do the full recipe.
 
Jestei October 16, 2012
wait was that the end of that? or did you make your husband take out the garbage and also rake the yard after that crime???
 
patb October 17, 2012
He did rake the leaves without being asked. And said he'd replace the chocolate. Getting more today and will immediately make the full batch. Scary part of that recipe - it's so simple and quick with minimal ingredients I have it memorized already. Means never having to say you're sorry......we have no cookies.
 
shoestringmama October 16, 2012
WOW - death by chocolate came to mind when I read the recipe so of course I saved it, printed it, and can't wait to try it! Thank you for sharing!
 
susanrtw October 15, 2012
This seems like a lot of sugar. Can you use a sugar substitute, and which one would you recomend ?
 
Jestei October 15, 2012
i suspect the cookies would not hold together well without this amount of sugar. i know of no substitute but other users on the site may.
 
cfelten October 14, 2012
I got 36 cookies. Though cinnamon is not a flavor I love with chocolate, I included it, then also included a generous 1/2 tsp espresso powder. I also added more salt because the batter was a little too sweet for me. Lastly, I used bittersweet chocolate and, doubtfully, shoved the first pan into the oven. 25 minutes later, I gotta say, pretty darn good. I think the office crowd will love them. A little cayenne would not be misplaced in this recipe. But, really, shouldn't these be renamed Chocolate Coma Cookies?
 
micki October 14, 2012
2.5 cups. Is that 2 1/2 cups?
 
Jestei October 14, 2012
yes
 
pvanhagenlcsw October 10, 2012
Luckily one cookie broke slight;y as I removd them from the baking sheet so I got the first taste. These are incredibly delicious; chewy.moist. I was skeptical when I reviewed the recipe but relied on faith and goodness prevailed. Thanks for this recipe.
 
Jestei October 11, 2012
love broken and ugly cookies, don't you? i know it's a weird recipe as read but it does work. glad you enjoyed them as much as i do.
 
MaryDD October 10, 2012
I have 2 inlaws that have Celiac and am always on the look out for desserts that don't call for buying expensive subsitute ingredients... These are perfect! Thank you.
 
Jestei October 11, 2012
i hope they like them!
 
graciousglutton October 10, 2012
Is an electric mixer necessary, or can I just mix everything by hand?
 
Jestei October 10, 2012
I think you can but you'll find it pretty tiring as confection sugar is heavy to work with.
 
Dana M. October 8, 2012
Jonathan, will you let me know what your yield was? I like this recipe but wish we were told how many cookies you get. I have a healthy food blog and want to figure out all the nutritional values but quantity means a lot... thanks for your help! Did they turn out?
 
Jonathan O. October 9, 2012
They turned out great! The cast and crew really liked them. For this recipe, I used a standard flatware spoon to blob the batter, and I ended up with somewhere in the range of 38-40 cookies. I was in a hurry, so I didn't count them all.
 
Jestei October 9, 2012
glad you liked them here is the full story: http://www.food52.com/blog/4615_jennys_glutenfree_chocolate_cookies
 
Jonathan O. October 8, 2012
I'd like to say thank you in advance for this perfectly timed recipe. I'm a director for a festival of student written, directed, and acted One Act Plays, and I wanted to bring something for technical rehearsal tonight, but I knew some of the cast were gluten-intolerant.
I'm going to prepare these cookies this afternoon, and hopefully they'll be a hit.