Make Ahead

Pierre Hermé & Dorie Greenspan's World Peace Cookies

June 22, 2021
4.7
75 Ratings
Photo by James Ransom
  • Prep time 3 hours 25 minutes
  • Cook time 24 minutes
  • Makes about 36 cookies
Author Notes

Of all the cookies you will bake and eat during the holidays (and beyond), this is the one people will remember. They're fine and sandy like a sablé, but with a friendly, soft chew, a bit like American chocolate chip. They're made up of well-salted, well-buttered cocoa dough, with generous pockets and wisps of chocolate feeding through. "I've seen World Peace Cookies made with peanut-butter chips, with cinnamon, with icing, and with gluten-free flours. I've seen them huge and small," Greenspan said. "I don't think you can do much to make them better and happily, there's little you can do to ruin them. Except overbake them." If in doubt, pull them out early -- they'll firm up as they cool. Adapted slightly from Baking: From My Home to Yours (Houghton Mifflin, 2006).

Helpful tools for this recipe:
- Five Two Ultimate Baking Tool Set
- Five Two Silicone Spoon Set
- Five Two Silicone Baking Mat

Genius Recipes

What You'll Need
Watch This Recipe
Pierre Hermé & Dorie Greenspan's World Peace Cookies
Ingredients
  • 1 1/4 cups (175 grams) all-purpose flour (see note)
  • 1/3 cup (30 grams) unsweetened cocoa powder (see note)
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1 stick plus 3 tablespoons (150 grams) unsalted butter, room temperature
  • 2/3 cup (120 grams) packed light brown sugar
  • 1/4 cup (50 grams) granulated sugar
  • 1/2 teaspoon fleur del sel or 1/4 teaspoon fine sea salt
  • 1 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  • 5 ounces (150 grams) bittersweet chocolate, chopped into chips (no pieces larger than 1/3 inch), or a generous 3/4 cup store-bought mini chocolate chips
Directions
  1. Note: If measuring by volume, it's important to measure the flour and cocoa lightly, as follows: stir flour briefly in the container or bag, spoon into the measuring cup until it's heaped above the rim, then level it with a straight-edged knife or spatula. If you dip the measuring cup into the container, you'll have more flour and cocoa and a drier, crumblier, more difficult dough.
  2. Sift the flour, cocoa and baking soda together.
  3. Working with a stand mixer, preferably fitted with a paddle attachment, or with a hand mixer in a large bowl, beat the butter on medium speed until soft and creamy. Add both sugars, the salt and vanilla extract and beat for 2 minutes more.
  4. Turn off the mixer. Pour in the dry ingredients, drape a kitchen towel over the stand mixer to protect yourself and your kitchen from flying flour and pulse the mixer at low speed about 5 times, a second or two each time. Take a peek — if there is still a lot of flour on the surface of the dough, pulse a couple of times more; if not, remove the towel. Continuing at low speed, mix for about 30 seconds more, just until the flour disappears into the dough — for the best texture, work the dough as little as possible once the flour is added, and don't be concerned if the dough looks a little crumbly. Toss in the chocolate pieces and mix only to incorporate.
  5. Turn the dough out onto a work surface, gather it together and divide it in half. Working with one half at a time, shape the dough into logs that are 1 1/2 inches in diameter. Wrap the logs in plastic wrap and refrigerate them for at least 3 hours. (The dough can be refrigerated for up to 3 days or frozen for up to 2 months. If you've frozen the dough, you needn't defrost it before baking — let it warm just enough so that you can slice the log into rounds and bake the cookies 1 minute longer.)
  6. Center a rack in the oven and preheat the oven to 325 °F. Line two baking sheets with parchment or silicone mats.
  7. Using a sharp thin knife, slice the logs into rounds that are 1/2 inch thick. (The rounds are likely to crack as you're cutting them — don't be concerned, just squeeze the bits back onto each cookie.) Arrange the rounds on the baking sheets, leaving about 1 inch between them.
  8. Bake the cookies one sheet at a time for 12 minutes — they won't look done, nor will they be firm, but that's just the way they should be. Transfer the baking sheet to a cooling rack and let the cookies rest until they are only just warm, at which point you can serve them or let them reach room temperature.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Sara Gillis
    Sara Gillis
  • patb
    patb
  • Trishington
    Trishington
  • Nicole Hurley
    Nicole Hurley
  • Dave Adams
    Dave Adams
Genius Recipes

Recipe by: Genius Recipes

175 Reviews

Marie B. April 16, 2024
Just made an account to leave a review. This is just the most wonderful cookie. Texture, taste, instructions…10/10, Dorie!
 
KekseBackenHeute January 6, 2024
This is such a great cookie recipe. I've baked these superb cookies multiple times since chancing upon Dorie Greenspan's YouTube video of her making these. Everyone comes back for more when I make them. And today, bereft of brown sugar, I used only granulated sugar and they turned out fine.
 
Gnana70 December 11, 2023
These are 2 of my very favorite cookies. And I believe that statement Annie Greenspan about world b peace if everyone eat one of these cookies we couldn't help but have world peace.
 
Gnana70 December 11, 2023
Pardon my mistake Dorie not Annie.
 
Lisa December 9, 2023
These are the best cookies I’ve ever made. Id strongly advise to watch the video and pay attention to the notes.
 
Jmk13 June 4, 2023
I’ve made these cookies about a dozen times and they are absolutely crowd pleasers. (Especially for chocolate lovers).
 
Ruth9407 March 14, 2023
These cookies are killer,
 
JustMegan December 27, 2022
I have been eying this recipe for YEARS, and have always put off making them. I decided to make them during the Advent season this year and they were an instant favorite by everyone. I actually had to make a second batch shortly after the first because they disappeared so quickly. These are truly the perfect chocolate cookie. Intensely chocolatey, but not too sweet or rich. Just a hint of salt in the dough and delightfully crumbly and tender in texture. They are also incredibly easy to whip up. I maybe spent all of 20 minutes between making and shaping the dough the first day and cutting them into slices on the second (I refrigerated my dough over night, to really let the flavors meld). These will forever be part of our yearly Christmas cookie baking from this year on, and although I usually have a rule that I only bake our Christmas cookie recipes during the holidays I can already tell that this recipe will be exempt.
 
anatyniak December 22, 2022
My dough came together very nicely. Beautiful cookie dough! I could see right away why the Sable cookie is named after Sand. The dough looked like moist sandcastle making sand before turning it out to bring together into logs. I didn't have any issues with my mix being too dry. I did it all by hand with a wooden spoon and spatula, weighed everything on a scale so measurements we're precise and even did 1 full batch plus a half batch all together at once. I ended up using gloved hands to finish off the dough in the bowl, it was easier than a spoon. I used Hersheys Special Dark cocoa which is a Dutch Process cocoa powder. The only things I can think of that are causing problems for others is using cup measurements and or the type of cocoa powder. Dorie says Dutch Process is best for this recipe. She also says to keep mixing until it comes together and that sometimes it takes longer for whatever reason. A tip to make slicing the cookies easier: try dipping your knife in very hot water and wiping it before slicing a few cookies and repeat. Sometimes it helps with getting a clean cut.
 
Sara G. December 16, 2022
These are amazing! I followed the recipe exactly as written, and sprinkled a tiny bit of sea salt on each just before baking. Note - I am confident there is no way you could get 36 cookies out of this recipe. I rolled and cut mine as written and got 26.
 
Pat C. September 12, 2022
The best chocolate cookies. I don’t use chocolate chips or nibs. I use chopped almonds. Salted ones are good too.
 
Erin C. March 17, 2022
Not that this recipe needs any more reviews, but I’m adding mine anyway ;)

I had a tin of Trader Joe’s peppermint bark leftover from Christmas that was sitting there, mocking me. The final 5ish ounces ended up chopped fine and subbed for the chocolate chips. A teaspoon of peppermint extract added with the vanilla echoed the delightful mint flavors in the bark.

My gluten free flour mix:
2 1/2 oz cassava flour
1 5/8 oz oat flour
1 1/4 oz arrowroot or tapioca starch
Rounded 1/8 tsp xanthum gum

Sprinkled with flakey grey sea salt and they were pure perfection!
 
Anonymous March 15, 2022
I made World Peace Cookies - it seemed like a good time in history to make them. 🇺🇦 They are absolutely delicious! It was a huge help to see DORIE make them in her video, especially how to use the parchment paper and a dough scraper to form that perfect roll - and using a ruler and knife to make perfectly consistent sized cookies! They turned out perfect!
 
arcane54 January 1, 2022
I know there’s now a WP Cookie 2.0 and I know that freeze-dried raspberry powder would probably make these over-the-moon delicious. But how can you improve on perfection? I’ll keep making these WP Cookies 1.0, measuring my dry ingredients by weight as suggested, and enjoying their chocolatey goodness.
 
patb December 21, 2021
Amazeballs! Easy, except for the sandy texture of the dough, but that's no biggie when you get results like these. No fancy ingredients means they're always a possibility and especially when you can store a log of dough in the fridge or freezer.
 
Michelle December 15, 2021
I made these to share at work and they were loved. Make sure to follow the instructions regarding taking them out while still soft even though they might not look done yet. Delicious!
 
MsJoanie December 13, 2021
I love this recipe and have made it successfully for many years running, but I have to say I NEVER get as many cookies as the recipe states. Clearly, my idea of a 1.5-inch roll is different from the actual measurement because I consistently get between 19-21 cookies per recipe. I've doubled the recipe with success as well and still got only 38 cookies when cut at 1/2 increments. My cookies look like the same diameter when finished as those in the video but maybe that's a trick of the camera? Anyway, just leaving this info for anyone else not getting 36 cookies per batch, or anyone preparing to make a large batch to give away.
 
Rita November 19, 2021
Love these cookies! It is easy to mix up a double batch so I have frozen logs at the ready as a treat fir my household or for a friend. They are consistently good. I first had them at an author event at my local library. Besides the pleasure of hearing Dorie in person, thanks to a generous committee, we all got to taste a few of the offerings from her Cookie cookbook. Delicious!
 
Wendy5998 November 18, 2021
Wow. wow. wow. These are wonderful cookies especially if you love chocolate.
 
Stacey November 17, 2021
Not only are they absolutely chocolatey, delicious and easy to put together, I totally love the idea of making the dough ahead of time and into turning it into 2 logs. Then I can take one out of the refrigerator and bake a batch right away and freeze the other log till a later time, which I have done. Thank you Dorie and Pierre!
 
Trishington September 30, 2021
I made these recently and they worked out splendidly. They not only looked exactly like the photos in Dorie's book and here online, but they tasted AMAZING!! I'm now about to attempt a gluten-free version. Wish me luck! As for those who've had a less-than fabulous outcome making these cookies, I believe that a major key to success is weighing your ingredients. I once read a product review article on Cooks Illustrated once that compared various brands of measuring cups (both dry and liquid volume) and was shocked to learn that a lot of top brands are way off! A kitchen scale is a baker's best friend. In fact, I won't buy a cookbook that doesn't include weight equivalents in the ingredient lists.
 
glorior September 29, 2021
I made an account just to leave this review.

These cookies are superb! I made a few modifications for my family's palette (less sugar - 90g brown sugar and 20g granulated sugar, mix of chocolate chips - 100g dark choc, 50g semi-sweet) and I baked them at 180deg for 12 mins. They turned out REALLY YUMMY. They're the soft type and a little bit between a cake and a cookie. Mind blown. Definitely making this again and again. Thanks for a great and easy to follow recipe!
 
Kevin S. June 22, 2021
These cookies are spectacular! I weighed all ingredients and had no trouble with the recipe. I did the second mix by hand (when adding dry ingredients to butter/sugar) instead of pulsing with the mixer and there was no dust...
 
tomny67 December 27, 2020
I think Dorie said these were her favorite cookies. I just made them for the first time and I concur. They are absolutely delicious. They’re extra-chocolatey and the texture is lovely. I followed Dorie’s instructions, sifting and measuring ingredients by weight... which I never do. I unintentionally left out the granulated sugar and I don’t regret my error. I honestly don’t think they need the extra sugar. This recipe is a keeper.
 
Rebecca December 20, 2020
These are the best cookies ever. Those of you who are having problems with too-crumbly dough are probably putting in too much flour. Weigh it out instead of scooping it, and you will likely have better results. I have been making these for years and the only problem is that they disappear to quickly!
 
Randie R. December 18, 2020
I’ve only made them once, but I had no trouble with the dough being crumbly. I don’t know that I did right, but I hope I can do it again next time. The only thing I can think of that might have helped me, is that I softened the butter in the microwave, because I decided to make the dough around 11 last night.
 
Nicole H. December 13, 2020
So, I’ve made this cookie with equal parts success and (near) failures. I say “near” because it’s delicious (and SAVABLE) even when the dough resembles the dry sands of the Sharan desert. I found that my dough benefited from browning the butter ahead of time and letting it cool. The downside of this method is that there is some moisture lost in doing so. You may need to add a tablespoon of oil and/or alcohol (to NOT activate gluten) and to get the dough to hold together. I didn’t know that when I first tweaked the butter but was determined to salvage my crumbling mess. The answer is a biscuit cutter. Simply lay the cutter on your cookie sheet, fill with chocolate crumbles and press them down firmly with your fingers or the bottom of a glass. Carefully lift the cutter off and you’ll have perfect, solid shortbread cookies -THAT HOLD TOGETHER. Resist the urge to eat them straight out of the oven or they will fall apart. They absolutely must cool completely before you eat them. Hope that helps! Carry on, brave bakers!
 
plevee November 7, 2020
I have followed this recipe exactly, weighing and measuring everything. I used Gold medal regular AP flour and sifted it with the cocoa. I can barely get the flour to mix with the butter and sugar - it's not just crumbly - it's powdery I can't see this coming together. Is there anything I can add to make this work?
 
TeaForMe November 7, 2020
Try adding a bit of olive oil (a mild or buttery one). A mild olive oil will play well with the chocolate flavor and might help keep the dough to a manageable level of crumbly.
 
TashaLee August 30, 2020
I followed the recipe exactly and these came out very well. The dough is quite short and crumbly, which is the expected nature of this kind of dough. I found a sharp knife, and confident, careful slicing helped minimise crumbling slices. As some people have struggled with it: if you find that the crumbly dough log is too hard to work with, try shaping it into a disc before chilling and slicing it into wedges like a traditional shortbread.
 
Dawn A. August 22, 2020
I made them just as the recipe described and they turned out fantastic! I didn't have a bit of trouble with the dough. I used Ghirardelli cocoa powder, maybe that makes a difference?
 
tomny67 December 27, 2020
I used basic cocoa powder from Aldi and they came out perfectly. The key to success is to follow Dorie’s tips. Watch the video, read the recipe, and follow her directions. No need to brown the butter or add olive oil (as others have suggested). Listen to the pro and you’ll get the best results.
 
Dave A. July 15, 2020
There's a cleaner journey to this cookie! I've made this cookie a million times--my friends and family love it--but every time the "genius" trick of draping a towel over the stand mixer to cut down on mess still leaves me with coco and flour all over the underbelly of my mixer and dusting the countertop.

Ignore the towel trick and do this for no mess: pour in the dry ingredients, and before turning the machine back on, remove the flat beater and use it to manually cut the flour and coco into the creamed butter and sugars, like you're cutting butter into biscuits. I do this until there are no more big swaths of dry ingredients waiting to create a dust-up. Put the flat beater back on, and now you only need a couple quick pulses (without a towel draped over, you can see what's happening!) until the dough gets uniform and chunky.

Hope this helps anyone else who loves this cookie but can't stand an unnecessary mess!
 
linderseed May 31, 2020
Made! I used an updated recipe on Dorie's website with slightly different measurements than appear here. I also used European butter (Ferrarini from Costco). I didn't have any issue with them falling apart - perhaps because of the update or more fat in the butter. I found her tip of using the bench scraper and tugging the parchment paper to be so handy! Would definitely make them again.
 
Tara April 26, 2020
I am a caterer but admitting I’m not the best baker in the world but I do bake all the time. Was looking for a new Chocolate cookie. Followed this recipe exactly with super high quality ingredients. This recipe did not work. Dough was so crumbly that I could not roll it, form it or cut it. Chilled it for 4 hours. Seems like it is missing oil. Baked them anyway in crumbles and were a delicious deep chocolatey flavor but oh so dry. I will brown the butter next time and add oil and use a different recipe ;-)
 
Alexis March 29, 2020
Made these a few times, yet watching the video yesterday made a big difference in technique. My young grandchildren/assistant bakers watched with intense interest.. Covering the mixer with a towel after adding the flour/cocoa mixture was life changing! We used Barry cocoa and 86% chocolate and the cookies came together well after slicing. Little hands molded the the straggler pieces. We baked them right after dinner and had warm cookies and milk...huge hit with a new audience. Delicios!!!
 
AdventureGirl March 16, 2020
baked this dough this morning after assembling the dough two days ago. it was rolled in parchment and just left undisturbed in the frig. cut the dough directly from the frig, maybe should have left it sit for 10 minutes to soften a bit. it was a tad crumbly here and there, but was able to smooch the dough together as stated in the recipe. baked at exactly 12 minutes. cookies came out perfectly. huge hit.

wonder if we could omit the cocoa powder? any thoughts?
 
Sona J. March 22, 2020
If you omit the cocoa powder, the dough would lack acidity to react with the soda and would be way too moist. Cocoa is integral in this cookie.
 
anatyniak December 22, 2022
Dorie Greenspan also has a vanilla bean Sable cookie recipe which is basically the same as this one without chocolate.
 
Doğa February 28, 2020
This is the best cookies i've ever made for sure. I did this with exact measurement and it turned out perfectly. Thank you Dorie for this lovely cookies :)
 
Camille February 4, 2020
Just made these with very dark chocolate, browned butter, and a splash of orange flower water. Absolutely divine! If you brown your butter, you will lose some liquid through evaporation and may need to replace it with a few teaspoons of milk. This will bind the sandy clumps of dough together. Expect to be working with shortbread, not a gooey American cookie dough, and all will be well!
 
Camille February 4, 2020
Update: These cookies have driven a wedge between me, my family, and my roommates. Everyone sees me differently after I've baked a batch of these, and I'm worried that no one truly loves me for who I am, just what I can pull out of the oven. I think it was the browned butter that really did me in - its aroma lures everyone out into the kitchen to plead for more cookies.
 
jensiegelnyc April 15, 2020
that made me smile...can't wait to make these!
 
ELCookie January 3, 2020
My new favorite cookie. :)
 
Katherine M. November 7, 2019
This exact recipe was modified by Claire Saffitz in her Gourmet Bakes series on the Bon Appetite YouTube series for her Gourmet Oreo video, which is where I discovered it. I found that using her tip and browning the butter (bringing it down to room temp by putting in a Pyrex dish and storing in the fridge while prepping the rest of the ingredients) adds an amazing dimension of flavor. It also makes the dough a little earlier to work with, though I've made these many, many times with differing dough consistencies each time! Add some homemade Oreo filling between two and your life will be forever changed :)
 
Beth100 May 29, 2019
I always add a tablespoon of Scotch whiskey to help the crumbly dough come together better without activating the gluten. This works very well and adds an extra flavor dimension.
 
Gina B. January 15, 2019
These were divine. Texture was perfect and not too crumbly to roll up. I read the various comments about sweetness and cut the sugar by 50%, which was not sweet enough for my taste. Will remake with 1/2 c of brown sugar/2 Tb white. These are simple and delicious.
 
jessicam December 19, 2018
This is a bad cookie dough recipe. I rarely write reviews but I want to save others the frustration of making these. The dough is so dry that even after chilling for 24 hours (and following the directions to the tee) I was unable to cut the dough. It just fell apart. I had to add a whole egg as a binder and was able to form rough cookies.

The taste is good, however. It is kind of a sandy brownie cookie. But overall I do NOT recommend this recipe.
 
EO April 16, 2019
Sorry you had such a bad experience. I have made these for years and now they are expected of me when I'm invited to Easter and Xmas dinners because they are so loved. Perhaps you just don't like the texture --and a very sharp knife is an asset. They can be crumbly but you can patch it together. My dough is never exactly the same, no matter how many times I've made them. But they are always always delicious.
 
jlriddell December 13, 2018
I have been making these for 3 years running. For some reason, this time, the dough was super crumbly, to the point they were not holding together when slicing. Squishing the dough back together really doesn’t work since it does not make a nice-looking cookie. Maybe butter was too cold? I see someone else here is substituting some olive oil, which I will try. Re: sweetness, I routinely cut sugar in cookie recipes by 1/3 or sometimes more and have always been happy with the result!
 
Lisa November 27, 2018
I LOVE this cookie. I sub coconut sugar for the brown sugar and use a 80-88% dark chocolate bar so they are never too sweet. I make several several batches at a time to keep on hand and slice/bake right from the freezer. A holiday favorite, for sure! Thanks for the recipe.
 
FoodIsLove November 28, 2018
Curious if the coconut sugar changes the texture? I love the idea that they would be a little less sweet.
 
Lisa November 28, 2018
I don't notice any difference. I still add the granulated sugar (organic) and cream everything very well. Coconut sugar seems a little harder to blend
 
Elyse M. December 3, 2018
Just made these, they are delicious. I also subbed for coconut sugar and they turned out great. Thanks for the tip!
 
Elaine J. November 17, 2018
Way too crumbly!! I have them wrapped in plastic wrap. I used Valrhona cocoa powder and bittersweet chocolate so my dough is delicious and not too sweet. I do think the batter needs more butter or olive oil and/or an egg!
 
Kristen M. November 19, 2018
Elaine, the dough can be crumbly sometimes, but that's probably okay! When you slice it, don't hesitate to squish any crumbly bits that fall off back onto the slices. If it's still not holding together at all, you could try beating in a little more liquid in the form of softened butter, beaten egg, or even water briefly, just until it holds together, but I'd recommend trying to bake a few off first to see if you like them as-is. Good luck!
 
Catherine R. February 9, 2018
I really liked this recipe in general, particularly since the dough freezes well, but, like some commenters on here, I also felt like they were a tad sweet. So, I made the following changes: subbed the 3 tablespoons butter with 1/4 cup extra virgin olive oil, used bittersweet chocolate chips (72% cacao) in lieu of the chopped semisweet chocolate, and topped the cookies with Maldon flaked sea salt before popping them in the oven. Very pleased with the results - they are rich and slightly fruity from the olive oil and darker chocolate and definitely not as sweet as the original recipe. I really do appreciate that this recipe is versatile and encourage everyone making it to play around with it. I imagine this would also be lovely with some grated orange zest or pomegranate seeds in the dough.
 
Funwithme December 20, 2017
Just made these, way too sweet for my taste!!
 
jakestavis December 15, 2017
had the same problem as a lot of others, weighed my ingredients and dough was still extremely crumbly. they kind of look like clumps of dirt. taste much better though.
 
Nancy M. December 9, 2017
These are amazing. I have made them several times and they are always a hit. I am commenting here only to mention the aroma. If you put a few of these on a plate the people around the table will be drawn to them like bees to a flower.
 
Jazzy B. November 3, 2017
They were extremely delicious! Thank you for a great recipe :)
 
Sheila L. February 12, 2017
I have to say that I've tried this recipe two times unsuccessfully. They melted in the oven and turned into a crepe.
I'm crazy about cookies and I knew something was missing in the recipe and that I could fix it. Comparing with other perfect recipe that I use for years, I added 1/4 more of flour and 1 medium egg. Voila!! They came out perfectly after 13 min at 325 F in the oven. Soft and chewy in the middle and the borders crunchy! And the best: you don't need to freeze the dough for 24, 48 hours or a week... Just 1 hour in your fridge and they will be perfect.
 
Sheila L. February 12, 2017
1/4 cup more.
 
Liz L. December 9, 2017
Thank you!
 
Renee B. December 15, 2017
I wish I'd added these. Mine cooked up fine and held their shape but lack substance when you bite into them. It's almost as though they aren't cooked enough (they were and our oven temp is dead on). They're also a bit too sweet for me. I so wanted to love them as cookies. That said, they are fantastic broken over vanilla ice cream or frozen custard.
 
karencooks January 2, 2017
After having this cookie on my "to bake list" for years, I finally made them this Christmas. Why did I wait so long? They are easy, very delicious and freeze well! They are now one of my husband's favorites (and mine).
 
Catherine December 29, 2016
How are these "World Peace " cookies. They don't even call for fair trade chocolate.
 
Leanna H. March 1, 2020
The original recipe for these cookies was given to Dorie by her friend, Pierre Hermé, a wonderful Parisian pastry chef. In the cookies’ first incarnation, they were called Sablés Chocolats, or chocolate shortbread. In their second, the one in which chopped chocolate was added to the sweet/salty dough, they were dubbed Sables Korova and were served at the Paris restaurant of the same name. Finally, a neighbor of hers gave them the name they truly deserve: World Peace Cookies. He was convinced that if everyone in the world could have these cookies, there would be planetary peace. I hope he’s right. What I know for sure is that everyone who has these cookies smiles and smiles are pretty powerful.
 
allison969 December 17, 2016
This has become my "go to" cookie for almost every occasion. My initial attempt, the dough was like sand -- barely held together, as I see others also experienced. I made the following slight tweaks and they've come out great every time since. Also, weighing, rather than measuring ingredients has given me much more consistent results.
170 grams flour, 30 grams cocoa (I use dutch processed), 155 grams of butter, 130 grams brown sugar, 1-1/4 tsp vanilla extract

 
Anny99 December 18, 2016
Allison, thanks for the measurements. I have also had some mixed results, although these cookies are definitely a favorite. Did I miss the tweaks you've figured out? I don't see them in your note. Thanks!
 
Therese December 8, 2016
Absolutely delicious but my dough was crumbly when I cut it. I was able to pinch the dough together but the cookies were lop sided. However, they were fantastic!
 
k November 27, 2016
I am making 6 dozen of these for a cookie exchange in a few weeks. I have a question: I have a new gas range with convection; has anyone used convection to bake these cookies, and if so, what was your experience?
 
Bea November 13, 2018
There's no difference that I can tell , I baked them the exact same. Most people say bake at a lower temp but I don't . They were done in about the same time, actually 11 minutes for mine.
 
Raquel November 16, 2016
Good god, these cookies are perfect.
 
Anny99 November 10, 2016
I've been making these cookies for years -- ever since getting Dorie's amazing cookbook, Baking. Absolute family favorite.
 
Terri S. November 2, 2016
Delicious cookies. I followed exactly, except the part about putting a towel over the mixer...I just mixed by hand until dry ingredients were just incorporated. No problem with being too sticky, etc. I rolled them into logs after dropping the dough onto a piece of plastic wrap and using the plastic wrap to help roll the logs. No problem there either. Sliced perfectly, no crumbling. 12 minutes was perfect. I am going to try these GF and possibly slice a tad bit thicker next time. Thank you for sharing this recipe.
 
suziqcu October 8, 2016
Measured by weight, sifted dry ingredients just because, and had to use about one fourth vegan "butter" as I was low on Irish butter I had. The cookies were fantastic! I am freezing some of the dough for later.
 
Idalu February 12, 2016
Lovely cookies though just a bit too buttery. I didn't have any problems with the dough crumbling. I used a good Danish brand butter (Lurpak) and some good quality latin american dark chocolate (70%) that I chopped. Instead of draping the bowl in a towel after adding the dry ingredient, i mixed slowly with a spatula and then pulsed a few times on low speed. Freezed the dough for 24 hrs and baked for 12 mins. They are good and I'll make them again.
 
JOEY January 24, 2016
Measured all ingredients by weight; baked on parchment-lined cookie sheets for exactly 12 minutes; let cool as directed. These are the best chocolate cookies ever!!
 
DAVID December 27, 2015
These were great. Everybody loved them. Thank you for sharing.
 
Michelle December 25, 2015
This is great, not too sweet! And someone even called it "the best chocolate cookie I've ever had". For anyone who had trouble with this recipe, make sure to carefully measure all ingredients. Including the butter, according to the package each stick of my butter should have weighed 113.4g but it actually weighed 126g. You won't regret making this!
 
Lindsay F. December 19, 2015
I'm a pretty experienced cook and I carefully weighed all the dry ingredients using my old, but trusty food scale, but my "dough" was beyond dry and crumbly - in fact it was impossible to form it into anything! I finally added a bunch of melted butter, rolled the logs and they're in the fridge now to be baked tomorrow. I mean chocolate and butter - how bad can they be, but I'd like to try these again - following the recipe. The ratio of dry ingredients to the butter seems to err heavily on the dry side? Anyone else run into the same issue??
 
CarlaCooks December 19, 2015
I just made this using the weighted ingredients and I had no problem with them. Did you weight out your butter as well as the dry ingredients? Sorry to hear they didn't work... these really are tasty cookies.
 
Lindsay F. December 19, 2015
I didn't weigh the butter but according to the weight on each stick, 11 tablespoons should have weighed exactly 150 grams. Clearly I messed up the dry ingredient weights somehow.
 
Janet December 23, 2015
I weighed everything and had the same experience. I thought the dough was dry but went ahead anyway. What a disaster. Too sweet, and the density of the chocolate was overpowering. I have half the logs in the freezer and I guess they can't be salvaged at this point. An expensive disappointment.
 
Tracy September 4, 2016
I had the same problem and I weighed all of the ingredients. I will bake them later today.
 
Sheila L. December 2, 2015
This recipe has no eggs or I missed something? Just to be sure.
 
Emily L. December 2, 2015
you're not missing anything, no eggs is correct!
 
Courtney C. August 12, 2015
These are delicious and easy. Perfect when you need a chocolatey-salty treat.
 
Kara May 14, 2015
I've made these a few times now and frankly, they are AMAZING. The first time i followed the recipe exactly as described and they turned out perfect. Second time i unfortunately ran out of plain flour (only had about 100grams!) and substituted the final 20grams with self-raising. They still turned out fantastic; fantastic enough to have a friend declare her praise very loudly. A+ totally one of my go to recipes now!
 
liz O. April 11, 2015
I made these "exactly" as the recipe states "except" when I didn't. Holy moly is right!
 
Alaina C. April 11, 2015
I made these according to recipe, except substituting coconut sugar in for both sugars and using tapioca flour instead of all-purpose to make them gluten-free. They turned out exceptionally good, having a thin, delicate, crackly crust on top. All this despite accidentally adding 40% extra butter and having to do some math to bring the other ingredients into proportion. It's a winnah!
 
Steven W. October 6, 2015
why bother commenting? you didn't even make these cookies.
 
Gift October 8, 2015
I love what you did. We need to be creative and allow recipes to suit our lifestyles.
 
Tracy September 4, 2016
Sounds delicious!! I must try this gf version .
 
Emily L. April 10, 2015
has anyone else had problems with these spreading out into huge flat pancakes? the first time I made these they were perfect, and I have been cursed ever since. I follow the recipe exactly!
 
Michelle M. June 17, 2015
Mine spread out when i baked on Silpats!
 
Emily L. June 17, 2015
I hadn't even thought of that, thank you!! Will be trying them again on parchment paper..
 
Robin March 20, 2015
Help!! I must have mixed my dough too it was to moist and sticky. Is that what I did wrong. I managed somehow to get it into a sticky mess of a log and they are in the fridge so hoping they will bake okay. I bake a lot so j really don't know what I did wrong. Any suggestions or comments I would appreciate.
 
dianeshuggins November 9, 2015
I use the waxed paper to help shape them into logs, touching the dough very little.
 
Emily L. December 2, 2015
I like to stick the lump of dough in plastic wrap and roll it in the plastic wrap! Mess free :)
 
Eve L. March 16, 2015
These cookies are fabulous. Ice been wanting to make these for awhile but was kind of annoyed by the preciousness of the recipe instructions. I mean, the thing with the towel and 5 pulses? But I followed all the rules and the turned out great. And then I made them again without all the extra fancy steps and you know what? They turned out great again. I even used chocolate chips that I gave a rough chop, not fancy dark chocolate. They were still fantastic. As my husband says, they're a keeper.
 
Two T. February 12, 2015
Maybe I'm weird but I liked these best baked 14 min! Delicious.
 
EmilyC January 18, 2015
I'm kicking myself for having waited so long to try these. They're perfect!
 
Danielle December 26, 2014
These were fantastic! I made them for Christmas exactly as described above, without a kitchen scale-- however I did accidentally throw in an extra T of butter, but I think it ended up helping and making the dough more workable!

I loved them so much that I decided to make a second batch with a variation. I kept my extra T of butter, added 1/2 tsp of cayenne to the sifted dry ingredients, and topped each cookie with a piece of Falksalt's smoked flake salt before baking. The end result was amazing-- multiple guests at my Christmas party asked if they could take some home. Highly recommend this version if you like heat!! The smoked salt was fantastic, but I think any flake salt would do.
 
betty888 December 22, 2014
Update: I made these again for my family, this time gluten free. I used Bob's Red Mill Gluten Free 1-to-1 Baking Flour, and they turned out surprisingly well - very similar to the real deal. I just replaced the flour with the GF four.
 
FoodIsLove December 20, 2014
I just finished making my second batch of these. They are awesome. I did make mine larger...rolled the dough to 2" size and baked them for 15 minutes to compensate for the larger cookie. They are wonderful. I know others are having problems with these being crumbly, I did not experience that. What I always do when I make logs of dough is to form them into a rough shape and then slam them on the counter a few times to compact the dough, then do the final forming. It does seem to help.
 
Sara P. December 16, 2014
I made these yesterday and let me tell you, they are fantastic. I baked mine for 13 minutes, not 12 (my oven can be wonky), and was very careful when measuring my dry ingredients. I also decided to see what would happen if I added a little vanilla fleur du sel as a finisher and let me tell you, it's amazing!! You can make vanilla fleur du sel by just adding a vanilla bean to your salt. Overall, really fantastic cookie with rich chocolate flavor and lovely texture.
 
betty888 December 10, 2014
I will start by saying that I am not a huge chocolate-lover. I know, shoot me. I do enjoy it now and again, but when I have a sugar craving, I would grab a blondie over a brownie. That said, I was looking for a cookie that didn't contain nuts, made it tonight. Holy moley - it is delicious. I followed the recipe to the letter, except I chilled the dough for 2 hours instead of 3. I didn't have any issues with crumbling dough, and I kept an eagle eye on them after I put them in the oven. No problems at all. They are seriously good - something about the sandiness that reminds me of fudge. Just wonderful.
 
visionsofsophia December 23, 2015
Carla - I was your Secret Santa and I loved them so much that this Christmas I recreated them, candy canes and all!
 
CarlaCooks December 9, 2014
I made these as part of my Food52 Secret Santa gift. I added 1 crushed candy cane and replaced the vanilla extract with mint extract. After making the dough, I froze half of it in a log and kept the 2nd log in the fridge. After 2 days I baked the 2nd log. After 8 minutes in the oven I rotated the pan, then took them out at 12 minutes. They are perfect!
 
Ann-Marie D. November 28, 2014
I made this recipe when I saw it somewhere else (different name, same recipe by Dorie and Pierre Hermes), and just made it again this morning. People die when they try them, literally so good. Am going to make it for a (late) Thanksgiving dessert table! Highly recommend!
 
Lilismom October 11, 2014
I'v made them several times as directed. Yes, it's crumbly but if you put the dough onto Saran Wrap or the like and roll it sushi style it's easier to roll the log. The cookies are divine.
 
evl August 6, 2014
I found the dough too crumbly to work with the first time I made these. The next time, I let the dough sit at room temperature for about 15 minutes before slicing and the problem was solved.
 
Andre A. June 7, 2014
AN OBSERVATION to this remarkable recipe:

The first I made these cookies, I didn't believe they were done because they were really not firm at all. So I left them for a little longer in the oven, and they got slightly toasted below.

I just made them again now, paying more attention. Maybe because of reason inherent to my oven, the cookies are indeed not done after 12 min. And since they do not look ready when they are done, I was left without a parameter to know when to take them out of the oven. The method I adopted was, then, the following:

While still in the oven, spike them with a fork to check. Sometime they will get to a point when they are beginning to feel sandy. Note the feeling of this texture, then wait a little (just a little), take them out and observe. Even if they are not firm inside the oven (and they should not be firm indeed), they should crystallize and by firm after just a few minutes at room temperature. If they remain soft after a few minutes, put them back in the oven and bake for a while longer. Repeat the process above, now knowing that the point of the texture should be firmer then before, when you check with the fork.

I did this after leaving a batch for quite a long time out of the oven before realizing the cookies were indeed raw. I baked them again, and they are perfect.
 
Hernan C. May 7, 2014
I have never ever changed or questioned any recipe from dorie - follow instructions and all is well- never problems or surprises- she explains it all very well
 
Wendy D. April 29, 2014
Why "world peace"?
 
cschaefer March 3, 2014
Perfect. Mine came out exactly as you described with a sandy, soft chew. Cookie perfection in it's entirety and now an added favorite in my cookie repertoire. Thank you for sharing!
 
lisa M. February 19, 2014
I made these gluten free - used 1 cup rice flour based gluten free flour blend, 1/4 cup teff flour, 1/2 tsp. xantham gum. They turned out great! I did forger the baking soda though - the cookies spread quite, but were delicate and just a little crisp. Perfect with a drizzle of milk chocolate swirled on top - I think they would make lovely ice cream sandwich cookies this way too. So my "world peace" cookies ended up being renamed "happy accident" cookies!
 
Wendy February 13, 2014
This is by far the most frustratingly crumbly cookie dough I've ever worked with. That being said, the dough produces some of the most delicious cookies I've ever tasted! I discovered that it helps if I shape the dough into patties and place them directly onto the cookie sheet, then cover, and THEN refrigerate for the required time. That makes it much easier than having to deal with trying to slice a crumbly log of dough after refrigeration. Hope that tip helps other people, because the finished product is certainly worth the work!
 
Anita February 14, 2014
Hi Wendy! I was very worried about how crumbly these cookies were going to be from reading other comments so I added 2 tablespoons of canola oil to my dough and it was not very crumbly. I hope that helps!!
 
Wendy February 20, 2014
Hi Annie,
Did adding the oil affect the shortbread-like texture of the cookies at all? That's one of the things I like about them - I love the idea of making the dough easier to work with, but would prefer them not to be greasier as a result. Thank you for the tip!
 
Anita February 20, 2014
Hi Wendy! I've actually never made them without the oil. :-/ However, they have not turned out too greasy! I think even just 1 tablespoons of canola oil would help. Also, whenever I have made them all the kiddos, husband, and neighbors gobble them up instantly (I'm constantly saying, "Just WAIT for them to cool!!!") so I do not know how texture has been affected. Sorry about that!!! I hope the next time you bake these you have more fun in the process of making them, but you are right - they turn out delicious!!!
 
Barbara January 7, 2014
Loved the cookies. I printed the recipe when it was first posted and it was missing the white sugar in the printed version. I wondered when making them why it said, add both sugars. Before baking I came back to the digital version and added the sugar (after everything was blended). They turned out perfectly and are my favorite chocolate cookie ever. Thanks.
 
Crystal A. January 5, 2014
Great recipe! My new favorite cookie for grown-ups. I imagine it would be great while sipping a some small batch bourbon. My two-year-old didn't enjoy it as much, more for mom!. I used a salted caramel chocolate bar chopped into bits and only half the salt.
 
Mary S. January 5, 2014
No egg in this recipe? Perhaps that is why cookies are crumbly. Has anyone tried adding an egg?
 
Steven W. October 6, 2015
I believe that would change them from a shortbread type cookie to a cake like cookie...
 
Kaydee January 3, 2014
I just made these cookies. They tasted delicious, but they did not look like that at all. I'm not sure what happened to it, but my dough was super creamy and sticky. And after putting them in the oven, they turned out to be flat, crispy pancakes. I don't know how I manage to mess up a super easy recipe. help?
 
TriSarahTops February 13, 2014
I had the same thing happen the first time I made these (using volume measurements). The second time I made them I used the weight measurements and they turned out perfectly. I highly recommend using the weight measurements.
 
CookOak January 1, 2014
So sad...what a big disappointment! I followed your measuring instructions with the flour and cocoa (lightly packed) and my cookies came out thin, crunchy, and very oily. Looks like too much butter to flour/cocoa to me. The flavor was good but no delicious crumbly, sandy consistency. On the positive side, they hardly crumbled and sliced very easily (maybe that should have been my first clue?). Also, I baked the second sheet for only 11 minutes so they definitely weren't over-baked.
 
Erica December 27, 2013
Wow wow wow!! I froze a double batch of batter (4 logs) a week ago just prior to leaving town for the holidays. I literally just returned from my trip - and the first thing I did was bake these cookies (they've been on my mind all week). Oh my goodness - these are AMAZING!! I just baked one batch - I added a minute to the cooking time. They came out great. I still have 3 frozen logs and I'm already making plans to bake and send my next fresh batch to my cookie-loving sister in Philly. I'm pretty sure I'll be keeping a ready-to bake batch in the freezer at all times. SO Easy. SO Good. !!
 
CurioCook December 23, 2013
Just made these for Christmas Eve (I'm in NZ so it's already the Eve here!) - freezing the dough over night helped a lot with the crumbling - there was a bit of crumbling but minimal. Definitely wouldn't get 36 cookies at 1/2" cut, but perhaps my log was too big? I got 24 big, delicious cookies though.
 
Joy B. December 20, 2013
I followed the directions carefully, took all your suggestions about measuring (thanks, K!), and played some festive music. These came together seamlessly and without issue- what a genius recipe. Shipping these off to Grandma, who's always been an advocate of World Peace.
 
Lynn M. December 16, 2013
Crumbly problem solved! I made my first batch, and they were sad. Consolation: the crumbs will be delicious over ice cream (or in coffee). A mini-muffin pan solves all problems. Those that slice nicely, great! The crumblies have a mold to smoosh them into. Bake for the same 12 minutes, cool and pop out.
 
TeaForMe December 15, 2013
These are divine! A few changes I made based on everyone's dough experiences: the use of dark brown sugar instead of light and 3 tablespoons of good extra virgin olive oil in place of the 3 tablespoons of butter. My dough stayed together just fine after mixing. Refrigerated overnight.
My dough cut very well and was easily smooshable; cutting cleanly through mini chips isn't easy!
This is my new favorite chocolate cookie:)
 
georgina December 15, 2013
Ugh, a total waste of ingredients! The "dough" did not come together even after tightly wrapping in plastic wrap AND tin foil, and refrigerating overnight. What a disappointing recipe :(
 
Kristen M. December 20, 2013
Georgina, I'm sorry to hear this. I've updated the recipe with clearer volume measuring instructions and metric weight measurements too, so hopefully results will be more consistent, if you want to try again.
 
Rhonda December 14, 2013
Hi Kristen, I was asking about the granulated sugar measurement because one of the posts said 1/2 cup. Thanks for your help. Rhonda
 
chiefkief December 14, 2013
Hi Kristen! You mention making a "slight adaption" from the original recipe. May I ask what that is? Thanks!
 
Kristen M. December 14, 2013
Chiefkief, good question -- that's the default credit that I give, because I often add tips/clarifications from my own experience. But in this case, Dorie's instructions are so thorough, I added nothing (except the gram measurements from an earlier version of this recipe).
 
Kristen M. December 20, 2013
Now I've updated even more in the recipe to help clarify the measurements, just for the record!
 
Nancy H. December 14, 2013
ok, best cookies of the season (yet!). these are wonderful - turned out exactly as described. Made the 'logs' a little smaller and so cookies are small (so can eat more, of course). Taking to a friend's house tonight. Keeper recipe. Thanks for posting!
 
Rhonda December 14, 2013
I googled the 50 gram conversion of the granulated sugar so just about 1/4 cup. Should have done this before asking the question. Can't wait to try!
Happy Cooking! Rhonda
 
Kristen M. December 14, 2013
Thanks Rhonda, and no worries -- it should say 1/4 cup above, to the left of the 50 gram measurement. Does it not show up for you?
 
Louise December 14, 2013
Have just made these for our neighborhood cookie exchange party tonight and will have to make another batch as theyve already been demolished by the family! I made the dough yesterday, rolled it and popped in the fridge. The first one i took off the baking tray fell apart but i just left them to cool for a few minutes as the recipe stated (read that bit after!) and they slid off perfectly. Thesse will be my go too chocolate cookie now! Honestly didnt use any fancy ingredients, cocoa powder from trader joes and everything else from the local grocery store and a 50 year old stove and they are perfect - thanks for sharing the recipe! and about to go start batch number 2 and hope they last until this evening!!
 
Rhonda December 14, 2013
Does the recipe call for 1/4 cup or 1/2 cup of sugar?
Thanks,
Rhonda
 
Polly V. December 14, 2013
How many cookies does the recipe make? Going to try them on my family for Christmas Eve dessert.
 
Kristen M. December 14, 2013
It should make about 36 cookies -- hope you like them.
 
MsJoanie December 17, 2013
I followed the directions and rolled mine to 1 1/2" diameter and cut at 1/2" intervals and didn't get nearly 36 cookies. I only got 24. Not that I'm complaining. They're wonderful (I froze my dough overnight to avoid the crumbling issues people mentioned), but people shouldn't expect 36 cookies at those measurements...
 
Stephanie.a December 13, 2013
There's something wrong with this recipe! I made two batches of these, and both fell apart. The second time I even tried to use warmer butter and refrigerate longer, but the result was the same--the dough just collapsed into pieces at the touch of the knife. I managed to salvage the cookies by smashing all the crumbs into mounds, and once they baked and cooled they stayed together. But they looked crumby, in every way. One small change I made to the recipe that I liked: I used half chocolate chips and half Andes peppermint chips. The peppermint made the cookies look and taste a bit more festive. Still, I probably won't make these again.
 
Kristen M. December 13, 2013
Stephanie, I'm sorry to hear about the trouble. See my responses below about tips for next time, if you do try them again.
 
durun99 December 13, 2013
Haven't tried them yet but have read the comments and a little research turned up a later comment by Dorie Greenspan that she's had issues with crumbling on occasion, too, and that using Dutch-processed cocoa may help. http://doriegreenspan.com/print/2009/02/tuesdays-with-dorie-world-peace-cookies.html
On the issue of weights vs. volume, I never understand why a baker wouldn't provide both. Having too much or too little flour based on measuring method could well explain the crumbling issues as well.
 
Kristen M. December 13, 2013
Thank you for mentioning this durun99 -- we used natural cocoa powder each time we tested this, but it would be worth experimenting. I just found the measurements in grams from Paris Sweets and added those to the recipe.
 
durun99 December 15, 2013
Thanks for tracking down the gram weights, so much easier than measuring. I actually made these before I saw that you had added the weights and used just about the same amounts (a little less flour and brown sugar) and had no problems whatsoever with crumbling. I refrigerated for 24 hours and used a serrated knife to cut them. I also used full-fat, Dutch-processed Valrhona cocoa. The cookies were amazing, rave reviews from everyone in the family. Thanks for finding these.
 
durun99 December 16, 2013
The recipe in Paris Sweets actually calls for 120 grams of brown sugar: http://www.epicurious.com/recipes/food/views/Korova-Cookies-355952
 
Kristen M. December 16, 2013
Thanks for this -- good to know. I was pulling from here: http://doriegreenspan.com/2009/02/world-peace-cookies-metric-measures-and-variations.html Guess I'll need to try both soon. Let us know about your results if you do try them.
 
durun99 December 16, 2013
I made them yesterday figuring 2/3 cup times 200 grams for a cup of brown sugar, which came to 133 grams (much closer to 120 than 180), and they were sensational. The post you pulled from also cites to Paris Sweets, but you can look at the book itself using "search inside" on Amazon and it definitely says 120 grams. I'm sure they'd be good with more sugar, too, but we loved them with the amount I used.
 
Kristen M. December 20, 2013
Thanks so much for your help -- I just tested them again with the 120 gram brown sugar measurement and they worked great, so I've updated the recipe.
 
durun99 December 21, 2013
Hmmm, I need an excuse to do some more "testing" myself these cookies are so good.
 
Edda December 12, 2013
I love anything chocolate and chocolate cookies is my biggest weakness. I followed the recipe word by word except that I allowed my log to refrigerate overnite. The cookies turned out thin and crunchy. Far from chewy. As a matter a fact, the cookie crumbles at first bite. Can't figure out what when wrong. Any suggestions?
 
Kristen M. December 13, 2013
It sounds like you might have overbaked them -- they should still be fairly pudgy and soft when you take them out, and they'll firm up as they cool.
 
Cristina December 12, 2013
Can you provide the ingredients list by weight? I seem to better with weights vs. volume. Thanks in advance!
 
Kristen M. December 13, 2013
I just found weight measurements from Paris Sweets -- let us know if you try it!
 
Meags December 11, 2013
Just made an attempt at these and the dough is hardly doughy! The roll wont keep its form even after refrigerating and it just crumbles apart. Am I missing something or did I just manage to make the antithesis to World Peace Cookies? :(
 
Kristen M. December 11, 2013
Oh no! Ours was also crumbly, but here are a few tips: twisting the ends of the plastic wrap to tighten the log, refrigerating for the full time in a cold part of the fridge, and slicing with a serrated knife all helped. Can you smoosh it back together?
 
inés December 12, 2013
Mine did the exact same thing. I tried two batches and the dough looks like crumbs. So, in the spirit of world peace, I'm going to sprinkle this cookie dough on top of brownie batter and hope for the best.
 
Margaret O. December 12, 2013
I would guess the water content in both the sugars and the butter could be different and result in a "too crumbly" dough if dry. a few sprinkles of water with the vanilla before rolling up might be worth a try.
 
Lauren W. December 12, 2013
I followed the advice to tightly twist the ends of the plastic wrap, which seemed to help, but also mistakenly added an extra tablespoon of butter. Didn't seem to change the texture and could have helped a bit with the crumbling. I also refrigerated overnight.
 
Kristen M. December 13, 2013
I'm so sorry to hear this -- I dug up weight measurements in grams from Paris Sweets and added those to the recipe, so hopefully those will help. Check out durun9's comment above about trying with Dutch process cocoa -- although we used natural without issue.

One more flour-measuring trick that might help -- we use this method: stir flour briefly in the container or bag, spoon into the measuring cup until it's heaped above the rim, then level it with a straight-edged knife or spatula. If you dip the measuring cup into the container, you'll have more flour and a drier dough.
 
Rumbum December 11, 2013
Sorry K, didn't see your reply! (I'm getting old...)
 
Kristen M. December 13, 2013
No worries -- sorry I didn't see yours till now too!
 
Rumbum December 11, 2013
The original recipe as it appears in Paris Sweets has 1/4 C sugar as an ingredient
 
Kristen M. December 11, 2013
It does here too!
 
Loo December 11, 2013
The recipe only has brown sugar listed but in the method it says to combine BOTH sugars. I think that you're missing something!
 
Kristen M. December 11, 2013
Thank you! 1/4 cup granulated sugar -- it should be there now.