Cookbooks

Piglet Community Picks

December 12, 2013

Welcome to the beginning of this year's Piglet! First up: Community Picks. 

The Piglet Tournament of Cookbooks is almost here! Because we don't want to mess with success, we'll be keeping the same format as last year -- inspired by Food52 community suggestions and by the bumper crop of cookbooks out this year, we will be featuring a Community Pick on each day of the Piglet. And since you're the wonderful community, we'll need your help in reviewing some of this year's most-loved cookbooks.

Shop the Story

Want to get involved? Call dibs on your favorite cookbook in the comments, below (we're looking for up to 5 testers per book, so don't worry if someone else already claimed yours). The rest is simple: Get the book, test a few recipes by cooking a meal or two, and send us your reviews by Monday, January 20th to [email protected].

Reviews should be under 500 words and explain what you liked about the book, why the recipes worked (or didn't), and what sets the cookbook apart from others. Most importantly, make it a great read. Just like we do for our contests, we'll pick the best community review for each book and feature it on the site. Now get cooking -- and be sure to tell us all about it! 

The Cowgirl Creamery Cookbook by Sue Conley and Peggy Smith



In The Charcuterie: The Fatted Calf's Guide to Making Sausage, Salumi, Pates, Roasts, Confits, and Other Meaty Goods 
by Taylor Boetticher and Toponia Miller



Mast Brothers Chocolate: A Family Cookbook by Rick Mast and Michael Mast 



Pok Pok: Food and Stories from the Streets, Homes, and Roadside Restaurants of Thailand
by Andy Ricker, with J.J. Goode



Coi: Stories and Recipes by Daniel Patterson



Modern Art Desserts: Recipes for Cakes, Cookies, Confections, and Frozen Treats Based on Iconic Works of Art
by Caitlin Freeman



Ivan Ramen: Love, Obsession, and Recipes from Tokyo's Most Unlikely Noodle Joint
by Ivan Orkin & Chris Ying



Sara Jenkins' New Italian Pantry by Sara Jenkins



Bakeless Sweets by Faith Durand 



Sorella: Recipes, Cocktails & True Stories from our New York Restaurant
by Emma Hearst & Sarah Krathen



Tartine Book No. 3: Modern Ancient Classic Whole by Chad Robertson



Homemade with Love: Simple Scratch Cooking from In Jennie's Kitchen by Jennifer Perillo  



Mastering the Art of Soviet Cooking: A Memoir of Food and Longing by Anya Von Bremzen



Le Pigeon: Cooking at the Dirty Bird 
by Gabriel Rucker, Meredith Erickson, Lauren Fortgang & Andrew Fortgang 

 

Manresa: An Edible Reflection
by David Kinch and Christine Muhlke  

 

GET THE LATEST

The Piglet—inspired by The Morning News' Tournament of Books—is where the 16 most notable cookbooks of the year face off in a NCAA-style bracketed tournament. Watch the action and weigh in on the results!

GET THE LATEST

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

  • Rob Lomax
    Rob Lomax
  • Pamela Trefler
    Pamela Trefler
  • Kenzi Wilbur
    Kenzi Wilbur
  • Allyce
    Allyce
  • Rose
    Rose
Recovering lawyer, food writer, pastry chef, and lover of food-related everything (namely: cheese, baked goods, and anything made by Mom)

110 Comments

Rob L. February 12, 2014
First year that I've heard of this and intrigued as to how we at home can play along? Are we meant to have bought all the recipe books before the beginning of the event? Can you pick any recipe to recreate or does everyone follow the same selection of recipes?
 
Pamela T. January 29, 2014
I sent my review in, on tie, why do I keep getting reminders????
 
Kenzi W. January 29, 2014
This is just another reminder -- send us your reviews to [email protected] if you haven't already!
 
Kenzi W. January 20, 2014
Hi all -- just a friendly reminder that your reviews are due today! If you haven't already, please email yours to [email protected]. Can't wait to read them all!
 
Allyce January 15, 2014
Any other slots left? Thanks!
 
Kenzi W. January 15, 2014
Just for Coi!
 
Allyce January 15, 2014
Ill take Coi, Kenzi. Thanks!
 
Kenzi W. January 15, 2014
Great!
 
Rose January 14, 2014
Hello, are there any slots left to try recipes? I'd like to try the Sorella book or Homemade with Love...
 
Kenzi W. January 14, 2014
Hi there -- the only book available is Coi! These all went to fast! So sorry.
 
Rose January 14, 2014
I can do Coi, no problem! Thank you very much!
 
Kenzi W. January 14, 2014
Great! Looking forward to your review.
 
Matt M. January 13, 2014
Kenzi - I posted earlier and I just want to make sure that I am slotted in for Manresa and the Mast Brothers. Thanks!
 
Kenzi W. January 13, 2014
You are indeed!
 
Kenzi W. January 12, 2014
Update: The only books with slots left are Cowgirl Creamery, The Fatted Calf Cookbook, Coi, and The Art of Soviet Cooking. Thanks for your enthusiasm!
 
Alexandra H. January 12, 2014
Hi Kenzi, I posted earlier-- not sure if I'm down for 1 or 3 books... Just in case, and with surprise house guests this weekend, I'm hoping to keep Modern Art Desserts, and let others test Mast Chocolate or Cowgirl Creamery. Thanks!
 
Kenzi W. January 12, 2014
Thanks for letting me know! You're now marked down for just the one.
 
Leith D. January 11, 2014
I'll cook from Sorella, Homemade with Love, New Italian Pantry or whatever else is available....the Soviet book looks great too.
 
Carrie P. January 11, 2014
I'm up for trying Manresa or Homemade with Love if either are available!!
 
Sabrina January 10, 2014
I would love to do Sorella or New Italian pantry, if possible
 
Christina January 10, 2014
I would like to rwview Homemade with Love, but I just ordered from Amazon and it won't be delivered until 1/16. I'm not sure I can make the deadline, but I will try!
 
Ocean P. January 9, 2014
Are there any openings left?
 
Kenzi W. January 9, 2014
Yes! We'll be posting an update post tomorrow morning detailing them. Which book are you interested in?
 
marcandanna December 26, 2013
I'd love to do Sorella too if you still need someone!
 
Kenzi W. December 31, 2013
You've got it!
 
Kyla N. December 26, 2013
I'm interested in Ivan Raman if there are spots available.
 
Kenzi W. December 31, 2013
Sounds great.
 
Lisa December 26, 2013
I will take Sorella if there aren't enough reviewers for it yet.
 
Kenzi W. December 31, 2013
Thanks so much -- looking forward to your review.
 
Jenn December 17, 2013
I will take bakeless sweets.
 
Kenzi W. December 31, 2013
Lovely.
 
petitbleu December 17, 2013
Any spots left open for Mast Brothers cookbook? Would love to test that one!
 
Kenzi W. December 17, 2013
You're the last! Congrats.
 
Jenn December 17, 2013
I would love to do a review: Ivan Ramen or Bakeless Sweets.
 
Kenzi W. December 17, 2013
Both have spots! Do you have a preference?
 
Jenn December 17, 2013
Baseless Sweets would be my preference. Sorry for the double post.
 
Kenzi W. December 18, 2013
No problem! I've marked you down -- thanks!
 
maudia L. December 16, 2013
I am a librarian,do reviews for our newletter and buy for the cookbook section so of course I would love to do a review. Tartine, Sorella or New Italian Pantry, please!
 
Kenzi W. December 17, 2013
Tartine is full, but the others aren't! Which would you like?
 
Smelky December 16, 2013
I'd like to give Le Pigeon a go, if you still need reviewers!
 
Kenzi W. December 16, 2013
Great!
 
Jamie E. December 16, 2013
I would love to test drive Homemade with Love if you still need reviewers.
 
Kenzi W. December 16, 2013
Consider yourself the 5th and final tester for that book. Hooray!
 
Jamie E. December 16, 2013
Hooray indeed! Thanks, Kenzi!
 
Matt M. December 16, 2013
I would love to do Mast Brothers and Manresa. This is going to be awesome! Cannot wait to get in the kitchen with these two beautiful books.
 
Kenzi W. December 16, 2013
Great! Currently, these are the books that are full: The Art of Soviet Cooking, Pok Pok, Tartine 3, and Cowgirl Creamery.
 
KellyinToronto December 16, 2013
I would love to test drive Manresa - I'm hoping that Santa will leave it for me under the tree. I already own Ivan Ramen and I will be happy to submit my review for that one too!
 
Jacob K. December 15, 2013
I'm in for Mast Brothers Chocolate: A Family Cookbook. Looks like something I would have fun with.
 
Kenzi W. December 15, 2013
Thanks to those who have signed up as testers so far! Currently, Pok Pok is the only book with 5 testers -- the rest are fair game!
 
sel E. December 19, 2013
Hi Kenzi, re-reading the comments below, I've noticed that there are 6 of us who would love to test pok pok (instead of 5). Which one of us are in? Thanks.
 
Kenzi W. December 20, 2013
Yes -- you're right! The 6th snuck in on us; we miscounted initially, so we've decided to take 6 testers for Pok Pok. You're all in!
 
Martine R. December 15, 2013
Good Lord they all sound wonderful. Here is in preference order based on desire and experience.
Ivan ramen, popk pok, manresa, in the charcuterie, mastering the art.....
 
Kenzi W. December 15, 2013
Would you like to be a tester for Ivan ramen? Pok pok is now full!
 
I've noticed that Cypriot and Soviet food sometimes overlap - would LOVE to explore Mastering the Art of Soviet Cooking.
 
amyc December 15, 2013
Happy to do Tartine 3 and/or Le Pigeon.
 
Kenzi W. December 15, 2013
Let us know which and we'll mark you down!
 
amyc December 15, 2013
Tartine 3. I know that I already love the salted chocolate rye cookies!
 
Lisa S. December 15, 2013
New Italian Pantry would be my pick. I would enjoy cooking, eating, and reviewing from that cookbook.
 
edamame2003 December 15, 2013
I'd love to test from Manresa and Pok Pok!
 
Mihaela P. December 15, 2013
I would love to test Mastering the Art of Soviet Cooking - I am writing my dissertation on the literature of the period, so this could also count as research!
 
DeesJournal December 15, 2013
Sorella: Recipes, Cocktails & True Stories from our New York Restaurant please!
 
marcandanna December 15, 2013
The AOC Cookbook by Suzanne Goin would be my pick! :D
 
sxtwo December 15, 2013
I'd love to review and have an excuse to cook from HOMEMADE WITH LOVE!
 
dayna December 15, 2013
may i test 'in the charcuterie'?
 
Kenzi W. December 15, 2013
Of course!
 
Jamie E. December 15, 2013
I would love to test Ivan Ramen.
 
Alexandra H. December 15, 2013
If I must choose just one...
Modern Art Desserts
(then Mast, then Cowgirl)
Thanks!
 
Kenzi W. December 15, 2013
If you'd like all three -- they're yours!
 
Alexandra H. December 15, 2013
I'm in! Thanks!
 
Gret December 15, 2013
How do you pick the cookbooks? Wish you had picked "The Chew". It's a more complete cookbook, especially for families & everyday yummy cooking!
 
Kenzi W. December 15, 2013
We sit down as a panel and carefully consider all of the books of note published in 2013. Thanks for the suggestion!
 
Janay December 15, 2013
I'd love to test Pok Pok.
 
Sauertea December 15, 2013
I would do Tartine 3
 
Alexandra H. December 15, 2013
I'll happily test:
Cowgirl Creamery
Mast Brothers
Modern Art Desserts
 
bantae December 15, 2013
Pol Pok and Le Pigeon please
 
Johannah December 15, 2013
I'd love to test Modern Art Desserts!
 
Laura December 13, 2013
Would love to test Tartine 3 please. Thanks.
 
luvcookbooks December 13, 2013
New Italian Pantry please
 
sel E. December 13, 2013
Would love to test Pok Pok. Thanks
 
Annie B. December 13, 2013
I meant, Soviet Cooking for me, please!
 
Annie B. December 13, 2013
so iet cooking for me! please!
 
hardlikearmour December 13, 2013
Glad to see a couple of Portland cook books in the mix! I had a blast testing last year.
 
SuzanneS December 13, 2013
Would love to do Soviet Cooking, please!
 
Kenzi W. December 13, 2013
Everyone who has commented so far is signed up for their book! Thanks all.
 
boulangere December 13, 2013
I would like to test Tartine 3.
 
Megan December 13, 2013
I would like to test Cowgirl Creamery Cooks. I love the Piglet!
 
Pamela T. December 13, 2013
I would like to test the Pok Pok cookbook, I own it and love it!
 
Belle A. December 12, 2013
We'd love to test Mastering the Art of Soviet Cooking. The cuisine is different from what we normally cook, so a great way to step out of our comfort zone. Thanks for the opportunity!
 
mjsauer89 December 12, 2013
I'd love to test New Italian Pantry.
 
Molly B. December 12, 2013
I would love to test tartine!
 
StaceyMoreno December 12, 2013
I would love to check out Tartine or Bakeless Sweets!
 
Kenzi W. December 12, 2013
Great! Just let us know which and we'll put you down for one.
 
StaceyMoreno December 12, 2013
How about Tartine. Thanks!
 
aargersi December 12, 2013
I will test Ivan Ramen, K?
 
Kenzi W. December 12, 2013
Perfect.
 
aargersi December 12, 2013
is Sara Jenkins in iBook only?
 
Kenzi W. December 12, 2013
Yes, that's right!
 
healthierkitchen December 13, 2013
unfortunately, I don't have an ipad! Love Sara Jenkins recipes!
 
Kenzi W. December 12, 2013
Thanks all! Keep 'em coming!
 
snowcitygirl December 12, 2013
I would absolutely love to test the Modern Art Desserts cookbook by Caitlin Freeman. It combines two of my biggest loves: food and art!
 
Chef T. December 12, 2013
Would love to test the Mast Brothers cookbook
 
Melissa December 12, 2013
Dined at Pok Pok for the first time this year and it was fabulous. I would love to test (and taste) some of Andy Ricker's recipes.
 
dymnyno December 12, 2013
I would love to test The Cowgirl Creamery cookbook. I am a huge fan and have been "testing" their products from their beginnings years ago.
 
Kenzi W. December 12, 2013
All of these are noted! Thanks so much.
 
Bevi December 12, 2013
I would love to test Homemade with Love, by Jennie Perillo.
 
Betsy December 12, 2013
I, too, would love to review Cowgirl Creamery Cooks. I've been meaning to get a copy since the Cowgirls spent a week on Food52!
 
wkend.baker December 12, 2013
I would love to test out Bakeless Sweets by Faith Durand. Being that I'm oven-less (have been for a few months) and want to cut down on sugar (major sweet tooth), Bakeless Sweets is the perfect solution for my problems :)
 
Karie M. December 12, 2013
I would LOVE to try out Cowgirl Creamery Cooks!
 
cookinginvictoria December 12, 2013
So excited that it's almost Piglet time! And I am thrilled that there will be Community Picks again. I would love to test Homemade With Love.
 
beetsandbluecheese.com December 12, 2013
Jennifer Perillo sounds like a girl after my own heart. I'd be happy to review Homemade with Love: Simple Scratch Cooking from In Jennie's Kitchen.