Summer is here and we're bringing back the soda fountain: give us your best egg creams, milk shakes, malteds, concretes, floats, frozen custards, sundaes, splits, Italian sodas, and any other quirky regional treats we've never heard of! Feel free to use store-bought seltzers and ice creams or get ambitious and make your own.
More about our contests»
Beauty School Knockout (Peppermint Hot Fudge Sundae)
photo 1 of 24
It's Christmastime! Just kidding. It's 100 degrees out. Good time to bust these out: peppermint extract, dark chocolate, brown sugar, cocoa powder, milk, egg, cream, sugar, salt, a starlight mint, and a Nabisco's Famous Chocolate Wafer.
photo 2 of 24
These mints are doomed. Doomed, I say!
photo 3 of 24
Amanda gets aggressive. The recipe calls for these mints to be chopped, but that wouldn't be nearly as much fun (or therapeutic), would it?
photo 4 of 24
photo 5 of 24
Might as well bash up those chocolate cookies now too.
photo 6 of 24
Ice cream fixins, and the recipe for guidance. Ironic that you have to cook stuff to make ice cream, but it's worth it.
photo 7 of 24
We fell in love with this pinky golden tone the milk took on as the starlight mints dissolved.
photo 8 of 24
As the minty milk heats, next door it's time to start beating egg yolks, sugar and salt till they're "very thick, pale and glossy," says Sydney.
photo 9 of 24
photo 10 of 24
Now we temper. A little hot milk gets whisked into the eggs to heat them gently ...
photo 11 of 24
... then the warmed eggs are whisked back into the hot milk. That's how you temper!
photo 12 of 24
Don't get cocky! If this gets up to a boil, it will curdle and you'll have to start over. Like we did.
photo 13 of 24
As the thick and creamy ice cream base sits cooling in its ice water bath, a dose of peppermint extract gets added.
photo 14 of 24
Nice and thick and no scrambled bits! Into the machine it goes.
photo 15 of 24
You're done churning when it looks (and tastes) like soft serve. Now you fold in those beaten up chocolate cookie bits, transfer to a new container and freeze through.
photo 16 of 24
Hot fudge time!
photo 17 of 24
Butter, cream, white and brown sugars, and corn syrup bubble away while cocoa powder awaits its cue.
photo 18 of 24
Final touch: some good dark chocolate.
photo 19 of 24
All whisked together, it's smooth and sinister and ready to pounce on some peppermint ice cream.
photo 20 of 24
Time to get dressed.
photo 21 of 24
We don't throw the term 'food porn' around here very often, but come on.