A question about a recipe: Scottish Oat Cakes

I have a question about the recipe "Scottish Oat Cakes" from Syronai. Can butter be used in place of the shortening?

23b88974 7a89 4ef5 a567 d442bb75da04  avatar
Pine Nut Oat Cakes
Recipe question for: Pine Nut Oat Cakes


beyondcelery December 21, 2011
@nutcakes: Without having my mom's original recipe in front of me, I can tell you to sub oat bran for the rice bran and regular all-purpose flour for the sweet rice and amaranth. Add the water slowly, since you may need more or less than the gluten-free recipe calls for. (I think my mom actually added MORE water to hers than I do, but I'm not sure--it's been 10 years or so.) That should work pretty well for you!
beyondcelery December 21, 2011
Butter absolutely works in this recipe! It will make the dough a little wetter, as Amanda notes. I just put less hot water into the dough to start out and inch it up from there. It isn't usually a huge difference in liquid. The butter also changes the flavor and texture slightly--it makes the oatcakes richer and a little closer to shortbread.
nutcakes December 21, 2011
It would be great to know how to make these without going gluten free. I was going to whip up a batch, but I don't have those specialty ingredients. I have oats, almond flour and regular rice flour, though.
Amanda H. December 20, 2011
This is from a previous hotline question -- thought it was helpful so I'm just pasting it here: "Butter contains 14-19% water. Shortening is 100% fat." If you use butter, you may want to use less -- keep in mind, it also may add more moisture to your dough.
Recommended by Food52