A question about a recipe: Roasted Salmon with a Cheat's Vietnamese Caramel Sauce

I have a question about the recipe "Roasted Salmon with a Cheat's Vietnamese Caramel Sauce" from Kristin. Would a white butterfish work as well as salmon?

Ca1a6133 edf7 451a babf 6af99b0df6eb  open uri20140804 16599 iculf4
  • Posted by: Melissa
  • August 6, 2014


Greenstuff August 6, 2014
I think the most typical Vietnamese preparation would be with catfish, so Kristin's salmon was itself a culinary stretch.

(By the way--there are lots of different fish called butterfish. The one that Liza's Kitchen mentions is also as escolar or white tuna, and I suspect she guessed right that it was the one you meant. But that's the only one that bothers some digestive systems--I'd hate to sound an alarm on all the "butterfish.")
ChefJune August 6, 2014
The sauce might take over a milder flavored fish. That doesn't mean it wouldn't work, but it would be very different. Bluefish would be a more similar substitute--or tuna.
Liza's K. August 6, 2014
Hi Melissa! You could likely substitute butterfish, but remember that there are some health risks associated with butterfish (you aren't supposed to eat more than 6 oz at a time because you can get keriorrhea). Other white flaky fishes would work well also, like halibut, tilapia, or snapper.
Recommended by Food52