Make Ahead

Corned Beef & Cabbage From Suzanne Goin

March 15, 2012
5
13 Ratings
Photo by James Ransom
  • Prep time 1 hour
  • Cook time 6 hours
  • Serves 6, with leftovers
Author Notes

This California twist on the corned beef and cabbage feast is untraditional in all the right places—and almost as easy as the old school dump-in-the-Crock-Pot approach, with a few brilliant tweaks. Goin divorces the vegetables from the meat so they're free to cook in their own time. In an exciting twist, she also throws the beef in the oven to brown and crisp up a bit at the end. Finally, she gives it just what any salty, long-cooked broth craves: a sauce that vibrates with life. Recipe adapted very slightly from Sunday Suppers at Lucques by Suzanne Goin with Teri Gelber (Knopf, 2005). —Genius Recipes

Test Kitchen Notes

"My family is very Irish and celebrates St. Patrick's Day ever year," says Assistant Lifestyle Editor Caroline Mullen. "My aunt used to make chicken nuggets for the kids because the menu at that function was awful. Boiled potatoes? No thanks. Irish corned beef and cabbage was the centerpiece, of course. But actually, now I love both!"

"Both the corned beef and the boiled potatoes?" I asked.

"No," she said, "the corned beef and the chicken nuggets."

What I love most about this Genius corned beef and cabbage recipe is that it really refreshes an old classic. And some, like Caroline, would argue that a dish this old needs it. Indeed, according to Smithsonian Magazine, Irish corned beef—a St. Patrick's Day mainstay—has been around since the 17th century, though there is an earlier reference to beef that's preserved (not necessarily with salt but with a byproduct of burnt seaweed called sea ash) in a 12th-century poem called Aislinge Meic Con Glinne:

Corned Beef, my son,
Whose mantle shines
Over a big tail.


This corned beef and cabbage finds new life in its method (each vegetable added at different intervals to ensure even cooking and zero mushage), as well as in the vibrant, vinegary parsley-mustard sauce, which Genius Recipes columnist Kristen Miglore relates to chimichurri or salsa verde. "It's so much more lively in flavor and texture than what you typically get for St. Patrick's Day," Kristen tells me, eight years after this recipe's publication date. "But it's still just as comforting." —Eric Kim

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • Corned beef and cabbage
  • 1 6-pound corned-beef brisket
  • 2 onions
  • 4 whole cloves
  • 2 bay leaves, preferably fresh
  • 1/2 bunch thyme
  • 2 chiles de arbol
  • 6 small carrots
  • 9 turnips the size of golf balls
  • 1 1/4 pounds yellow potatoes, peeled
  • 1 medium green cabbage (about 2 pounds)
  • Parsley-mustard sauce
  • 1/4 cup finely diced shallots, plus 2 tablespoons
  • 1/4 cup red wine vinegar
  • 3/4 cup chopped flat-leaf parsley
  • 1 tablespoon whole-grain mustard
  • 1/2 cup extra-virgin olive oil, plus 2 tablespoons
  • 1/2 lemon, for juicing
  • 1 pinch kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper
Directions
  1. Corned beef and cabbage
  2. Preheat the oven to 325°F.
  3. Place the corned beef in a large deep pot and cover with cold water by 6 inches. Bring to a boil over medium heat.
  4. Cut the onions in half lengthwise, peel them, and poke one clove into each half.
  5. When the water comes to a boil, turn off the heat and add the onions, bay leaves, thyme, and chiles. Cover the pot with aluminum foil and a tight-fitting lid.
  6. Cook the corned beef in the oven 4 to 4 1/2 hours, until it's fork-tender. (Carefully remove the foil and pierce the meat with a fork. If the fork doesn't penetrate easily, the corned beef is not ready.)
  7. While the beef is cooking, peel the carrots, leaving 1/2 inch of stem. Cut the carrots in half lengthwise. Trim the turnip tops, leaving 1/2 inch of stem attached. Cut the turnips in half through the stems. Cut the potatoes into 1-inch chunks. Remove any tough outer leaves from the cabbage and slice it in half through the core. Cut each cabbage half into three wedges, leaving the core intact to hold the leaves together.
  8. When it's done, remove the meat from the oven, let it cool a few minutes, and transfer it to a baking sheet.
  9. Turn the oven up to 375°F.
  10. Return the meat to the oven for about 15 minutes, until it browns and crisps on top. If it's not browning to your liking, you can pass it under the broiler. Let the corned beef rest 10 to 15 minutes before slicing it.
  11. Meanwhile, skim the fat from the broth. (There probably won't be very much.) Taste the broth. If it tastes good—not too salty but nicely seasoned and meaty—set half of the liquid aside in a medium saucepan. If the broth is salty, add a little water before setting half of it aside.
  12. Add water to the broth in the large corned-beef cooking pot until you have enough liquid to poach the vegetables. Bring to a boil over high heat, then turn the heat down to medium, and add the potatoes to the pot. Simmer 5 minutes and then add the cabbage, turnips, and carrots. (If your pot is not big enough, divide the broth into two pots, adding more water if needed.) Simmer over low heat 15 to 20 minutes, until the vegetables are very tender. Test each type of vegetable occasionally, and if one is ready before the others, use tongs or a slotted spoon to take the vegetables out of the broth.
  13. Taste the reserved broth and the vegetable-cooking broth. Combine them to your taste. If the vegetable broth tastes best, use it for the finished broth. If the vegetable broth is watery but has good flavor, add a little of it to the reserved broth, to your liking. Or, if you like the meat broth best, use it by itself.
  14. Place the cabbage on a large warm platter. Slice the corned beef against the grain into 1/4-inch-thick slices. Arrange the meat over the cabbage. Scatter the other vegetables over and around the platter. Pour over a good quantity of your chosen broth, and drizzle with the parsley-mustard sauce. Pass the extra broth and sauce at the table.
  1. Parsley-mustard sauce
  2. Place the shallots, vinegar, and 1/4 teaspoon salt in a small bowl, and let sit 5 minutes. Pound the parsley with a mortar and pestle and add it to the shallots. Whisk in the mustard and olive oil, and season with a squeeze of lemon juice, a pinch of pepper and a pinch more salt, if you like. Be careful not to overseason, since the corned beef may be on the salty side.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • janet Giles
    janet Giles
  • Mike Thierfelder
    Mike Thierfelder
  • Anny Mora
    Anny Mora
  • Analida Braeger
    Analida Braeger
  • golddeer
    golddeer
Genius Recipes

Recipe by: Genius Recipes

60 Reviews

janet G. March 18, 2024
This was the best corned beef and cabbage I’ve ever made. Due to the countless warnings about smells and such, I cooked each of the vegetables separately to the dentist that I wished in the stock created from the corn beef. It turns out fabulously with need of little salt and the sauce… Partially mustard… Looking for other uses for that as it is amazing.
 
Mike T. March 19, 2023
This didn't work out well for me. The meat was actually the star and was nice, but everything else was not great. Boiled everything was the problem I think. Cabbage turned out fishy, and as I learned later after a few Googles, after the 5th minute of boiling cabbage, you start doubling the hydrogen sulfide within (rotten egg smell). The instructions were very vague, the methods were pretty crude and as for boiled turnips, I'm just not sure how that could ever be pleasant.

I decided next year to spend less time (than 4hrs in the kitchen) on something that would be 100 times more well received like scratch pho. Not Irish, but much more satisfying. YMMV.
 
Sarah March 15, 2020
So good. Thank you for the delicious recipe!
 
jkeller1800 March 12, 2020
This will be my 3rd year making this recipe. Never disappoints!
 
Anny M. March 3, 2020
its absolutley delicious.
www.annyspecial.com
 
Anny M. March 3, 2020
https://www.annyspecial.com
 
Analida B. March 10, 2018
I can't wait to try this for Saint Patrick's Day! Here is another favorite of my family for Guinness beef stew: https://ethnicspoon.com/guinness-stew/
 
Laura March 25, 2017
Made this for company tonight and it was a huge hit! Love the tang in the cabbage from the pepper. Delicious!
 
Liz March 18, 2017
The recipe says to cover the beef with water by 6 inches. This cannot be. Please advise if this is a misprint.
 
Liz March 18, 2017
The recipe says to cover the beef with water by 6 inches. This cannot be. Please advise if this is a misprint.
 
Weasel8 March 19, 2017
I've made this several times and did cover the meat with that much water.
 
Liz March 19, 2017
What is the reasoning behind that much water, what's with all that broth, and doesn't it water the flavor of the meat and seasoning?
 
Liz March 19, 2017
What is the reasoning behind that much water, what's with all that broth, and doesn't it water the flavor of the meat and seasoning?
 
Liz March 19, 2017
What is the reasoning behind that much water, what's with all that broth, and doesn't it water the flavor of the meat and seasoning?
 
jackie January 30, 2017
Could someone tell me if the chiles de arbol should be purchased as fresh or dried? Thanks!
 
Kristen M. January 30, 2017
I think Suzanne Goin uses dried—and if you scroll through the photos, that's what we used too! (It's certainly easier to find.)
 
frank November 16, 2016
so with a commercial Cryovac corned beef, do you soak first to remove some of the salt?
 
golddeer March 18, 2015
I made this for a St. Patrick's Day dinner party yesterday. The corned beef and parsley sauce were delish but the boiled veggies were kinda lackluster - next time I will roast the veggies or make some other side dish.
 
dianerlee March 17, 2015
Yikes! Thank you, Emily! I bought beef brisket instead of corn beef brisket! I was so disappointed because I've had this before and it was truly delicious!
 
em-i-lis March 17, 2015
oh no! yes, beef brisket is not pre-seasoned. "corned", historically speaking, means salted, so if you buy a corned beef, you can assume added salt whereas with other beefs, you cannot.
 
dianerlee March 17, 2015
I don't understand how this could be salty when the recipe doesn't call for any salt? I just made this and the meat and veggies have no flavor?
 
em-i-lis March 17, 2015
REALLY??? Did you buy corned beef?? It's usually loaded with salt and seasonings. What a disappointment for you! Mine was perfect for the third year in a row. Aah!
 
SuSu March 17, 2015
This is my third year serving this yummy, traditional St Paddy’s Day dinner and as in past years, to many compliments. I wouldn’t dare change a thing ... although, I like gingerroot’s idea of cooking the meat a day ahead. And most def agree, the Parsley-Mustard sauce is a winner.
 
gingerroot March 16, 2015
This will be my fourth year making corned beef for St. Patrick's day this way - Suzanne Goin's Parsley-Mustard sauce really breathes new life into the dish! I've also always cooked the meat a day ahead without a hitch. Then, I can just finish the meat in the oven and cook the vegetables right before eating.
 
Lynn W. March 12, 2015
This was delicious! Very easy preparation and wonderful vibrant favors. Definitely will make again. Thanks!
 
Owing to my failure to make Irish soda bread earlier in the day, I was forced to use my one oven for baking and to forego the browning step for the meat. It was still great. I did double the carrots as they are my favorite part of the meal and I came very close to skipping the sauce as it didn't seem appropriate for a traditional corned beef dinner. Thank god I didn't!! I'm telling you that that sauce is absolutely unbelievable - packed with layers of flavor and easy to make. When there is silence at the dinner table you know you've got a winner and we were like a group of monastic monks who had taken a vow never to speak again. The sauce is also terrific on all manner of vegetables and chicken. I also used it on a hamburger (nothing wrong there) and if I could I swear I would put in on my morning cereal. A seriously delicious recipe (meat, vegetables, sauce).
 
Megan March 17, 2014
This is fantastic! I really liked the touch of browning the meat at the end -- created some nice crispy bits while still having a tender piece of corned beef.
 
Sauertea March 16, 2014
Amazing! Simply amazing! I have searched for years for a good recipe for corned beef and cabbage! I have finally found it!!!
 
ABG March 15, 2014
Made it and it was outstanding! Got rave reviews from all my dinner guests.
 
ktmckinsey April 5, 2013
I made this for St Patrick's Day. Wow! The spicy mustard really made the meal special. I didn't even use high-grade whole grain mustard (store brand all the way) and it was spectacular. I'll be making this again soon.
 
ktmckinsey April 5, 2013
Meant to say "parsley mustard" instead of spicy mustard.
 
Michael B. March 23, 2013
My son was enjoying it and was about to ask for a little mustard when he spotted the Parsley Mustard Sauce. He was blown away by it... elevated the meal. Alone with some Irish Soda Bread and a pint of Guinness-- not a bad St Patty's Day!
 
mbj913 March 18, 2013
the parsley mustard sauce makes this.
 
annasmithclark March 18, 2013
Delicious - the parsley sause was perfect. We added a beet horseradish.
Mmmm! SO good!
 
em-i-lis March 17, 2013
Delish!
 
stu4don March 17, 2013
I did this last year and it was absolutely perfect. Couldn't find a 6 lb corned beef so I bought two 3.5 lb-ers one is 'eye of the round' the other flat cut. Should I cook them separately or can put them both in the same pot and how long? Thanks!
 
Kristen M. March 17, 2013
You'd just want to make sure that the simmering water could get to all the brisket -- if they were stacked tightly, the mid-section might not get cooked as thoroughly. I think you could space them out in the pot by nestling the onion in between. If so, the cooking time shouldn't change much -- might be a little shorter if the pieces are skinny. Hope it's as good as last year's!
 
edelpiano March 17, 2013
OMG!!! this was wonderful. I have a wood fired oven in our yard and this is where I prepared this wonderful corn beef! It was truly amazing and we especially loved the parsley mustard sauce what a great addition!!!!!
 
Nancy W. March 17, 2013
I make a paste of brown sugar, yellow mustard and cracked black pepper and spread this on the corned beef before baking it. Gives it the same brightness as the parsley sauce.
 
Kay J. March 16, 2013
My plan this year is similar. I have been boiling and then roasting for a number of years and it finally occurred to me that I will roast the veggies along with the corned beef. I'm planning to lay everything out on a roasting sheet, quarted cabbage, nice slender carrots, split leeks, small halved potatoes and the boiled meet at 415 degrees for about 15 minutes. Then horseradish sauce and mustard sauce on the side. And soda bread.
 
em-i-lis March 16, 2013
is this best made the day it's to be served, or can i make a day early?
 
Kristen M. March 16, 2013
A day ahead would be great -- I'd cook the vegetables on the day of or reheat them gently do they don't fall apart. Hope you like it!
 
em-i-lis March 16, 2013
fantastic! thanks kristen!
 
Midge March 12, 2013
Made this last year for St. Patrick's Day and I'll never make it another way. Delicious.
 
likokai March 16, 2013
Me, too! I am so excited to be able to make this again! This is my St. Patrick's Day menu-thanks so much!
 
loubaby March 12, 2013
I am so glad you tried this..I have this cookbook and haven't tried this yet...now I will for sure this year....thanks so much...
 
Renee B. February 13, 2013
Is there a fresh herb you recommend other than parsley that goes nicely with the mustard and other flavors? I have a very deep aversion to it... I've read somewhere that certain people have a quirk in their DNA that makes cilantro unpalatable to them and I'm wondering if there aren't people with quirky DNA that makes them unable to enjoy parsley.
 
Kristen M. February 13, 2013
You could try some tarragon or dill, maybe with some chives, or maybe bulked up with a green like arugula, depending on which flavors you like best. (To taste, of course!)
 
Renee B. February 13, 2013
I like tarragon! It's a nice, bright herb. Thanks!
 
fhp March 12, 2013
I love "green sauces" and this recipe is a nice take on the classic Italian bollito with its salsa verde and "mustard" . I have an abundance of chervil in my garden so I tried a mix of chervil and mint and the result was astonishing and dare I say very green.
 
GSmodden April 10, 2012
I was sick over the weekend, but I still wanted to make something special for Easter Sunday and this looked not that work intensive. The meat was beyond tender. The veges provided a good accompaniment to the meat. The sauce added a tangy kick. But for a sick gal, the broth felt soothing on my scratchy throat. Sipping it I felt warm all over. It was so comforting that I saved some of the broth to use for a soup later. Just what I needed. Thanks for this great recipe.
 
superlotto March 29, 2012
I am thinking this might be a good street food. What if you were to make won ton taco shells, chopped cabbage that was blanched added chopped corned beef and topped with a horseradish chipotle cream sauce. Any ideas to improve this?
 
loubaby March 12, 2013
only some chopped onions to go along with it...sounds tasty indeed
 
annalea March 18, 2012
Genius indeed! I made this with a piece of beef that was just under 4 pounds and adjusted the cooking time accordingly (for this weight, it was in the oven for about 2.5 hours). This turned out to be an excellent meal. The parsley sauce is like icing on a delicious cake. The acid really helps balance the rich meat. I'll make this again and again. I might not even wait until next St. Patrick's Day!
 
blazesch1 March 18, 2012
It's great !
 
Ghazzzit March 18, 2012
/Agree with CSAchick - the oven then brown method was fantastic! The component I loved most though was the Parsley-Mustard Sauce - so incredible I've been going back and back again to find more to drizzle (slather) it on! I added the juice of a full lemon for some extra acid and am in love. Thank you so much for sharing this! Made it a memorable Irish celebration and feast.
 
CSAchick March 18, 2012
Made this last night - amazing! Combined it with my Irish-Jewish grandmother's recipe - so kept the parsnip, sugar, carrots in the cooking broth and omitted the chiles. Make corned beef and cabbage often since I love it so much - but cooking it in the oven, rather than on the stove - and then browning it at the end - made it the best corned beef I have EVER cooked. And the sauce was to die for!
 
1172 C. March 18, 2012
Thank you, this was the best St Paddy's Dinner I have ever made!
 
Msl0101 March 18, 2012
I also used my pressure cooker to make this recipe which cut the cooking time to only one third of the time listed. This recipe is outstanding. The broth needed some seasoning adjustment before adding the vegetables, but this was nothing but fabulous deliciousness eating. The idea to crisp up the beef in the oven is genious, and the "chimichurri-like" sauce on top of everything was just the perfect compliment to an already delicious dish.
 
JoyP March 17, 2012
Thanks for sharing this wonderful recipe. I have fallen in love with my pressure cooker and used it to make the corned beef. It was perfect. I then followed the rest of the recipe and it turned out great. I especially love the sauce!