Milk/Cream

Cinnamon Rolls

June 20, 2021
4.5
35 Ratings
Photo by Erin McDowell
  • Prep time 12 hours 45 minutes
  • Cook time 30 minutes
  • Makes about 1 dozen fat rolls
Author Notes

Ooey-gooey and finger-lickin good. If you want someone to fall in love with you, make these cinnamon rolls and a really good cup of coffee on a Sunday morning. Then sit back and act like it was no big deal while they melt in front of you. —Erin Jeanne McDowell

Test Kitchen Notes

Note: The pan pictured above is the Staub 12.75 x 9" Cast-Iron Oval Baking Dish (https://food52.com/shop...). —The Editors —The Editors

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • For the dough:
  • 624 grams bread flour (4 1/2 cups)
  • 100 grams sugar (1/2 cup)
  • 10 grams instant dry yeast (1 tablespoon)
  • 15 grams kosher salt (1 tablespoon)
  • 244 grams eggs (cold from the refrigerator) (4 eggs plus 1 yolk)
  • 219 grams milk (cold from the refrigerator) (1 cup minus 2 tablespoons)
  • 255 grams soft unsalted butter, plus more for the pan (18 tablespoons)
  • For the filling:
  • 170 grams unsalted butter, melted (12 tablespoons)
  • 113 grams brown sugar (1/2 cup plus 1 tablespoons)
  • 50 grams granulated sugar (1/4 cup)
  • 1 1/2 tablespoons ground cinnamon
  • 1 pinch freshly grated nutmeg
  • 1 large egg, beaten with water, for brushing
  • For the icing:
  • 3 cups powdered sugar
  • 1/3 cup heavy cream, plus more as needed
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
Directions
  1. Make the dough the day before you want to make the cinnamon rolls. To make the dough, combine the bread flour, sugar, yeast, and salt in the bowl of an electric mixer fitted with the dough hook.
  2. Add the eggs and milk and mix on low speed until the mixture forms a ball around the hook, 4 minutes. Increase the speed to medium and mix until the dough is very smooth, 5 more minutes. (Note: If you are planning to make the cinnamon rolls on the same day, use room temperature eggs and warm milk.)
  3. Continue mixing the dough on medium speed and add the butter 1 tablespoon at a time, mixing well to incorporate after each addition. All of the butter should be added over 3 minutes of mixing.
  4. Transfer the dough to a large, oiled bowl and let rise, covered, for 1 to 1 1/2 hours. The dough is very enriched, so it may not expand much.
  5. While the dough rises, prepare the filling. In a medium bowl, combine the melted butter, brown sugar, granulated sugar, cinnamon, and nutmeg. Let the mixture firm up to a spreadable consistency at room temperature. Reserve at room temperature.
  6. Transfer the dough to a parchment-lined baking sheet and pat out into a rectangle with about 1-inch thickness. Cover directly with plastic wrap and refrigerate overnight. (Note: If you want to make the cinnamon rolls the same day, refrigerate the dough for 1 hour or freeze for 15 to 20 minutes at this point, then continue.)
  7. Preheat the oven to 375º F. Grease a large casserole or 9- x 13-inch baking dish generously with softened butter. We used this 12.75- x 9-inch Staub Oval Baking Dish: https://food52.com/shop/products/1787-staub-medium-cast-iron-oval-roasting-dishes.
  8. Lightly flour your work surface, then turn the dough out onto it. Remove the parchment from the dough, and flour the top surface of the dough. Roll the dough out into a rectangle about 1/2-inch thick.
  9. Dollop the prepared filling all over the dough, then use an offset spatula to spread the filling into an even layer. Try to spread the filling all the way to the edges of the dough so it is fully covered.
  10. Starting with the long side closest to you, begin to roll the dough into a tight spiral. Use your thumbs to prop the dough off the work surface and use your fingers to keep the roll tight while you work.
  11. Slice the finished roll into pieces 1 1/2-inch wide using a serrated knife. Arrange the rolls inside the prepared baking dish, leaving about 1/4 inch between each one. Cover the rolls loosely with plastic wrap or a clean kitchen towel and let rise in a warm place for about 30 minutes.
  12. Brush the top of the rolls with egg wash and bake until they are golden on the surface and the filling is bubbly, 25 to 30 minutes. While the rolls bake, combine the ingredients for the frosting in a medium bowl. Cover and reserve at room temperature.
  13. When the rolls are baked, let them cool for 10 to 15 minutes, then spread or drizzle the icing on top. Serve warm.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Pat
    Pat
  • debra
    debra
  • Smaug
    Smaug
  • Marina D Polak
    Marina D Polak
  • Katie Beach
    Katie Beach
I always have three kinds of hot sauce in my purse. I have a soft spot for making people their favorite dessert, especially if it's wrapped in a pastry crust. My newest cookbook, Savory Baking, came out in Fall of 2022 - is full of recipes to translate a love of baking into recipes for breakfast, dinner, and everything in between!

131 Reviews

TNBW January 16, 2024
Yum! Will bake again. First time making cinnamon rolls. I bake a lot, but I've so far avoided baked goods that require yeast. So I chose this recipe as a first and I loved how the rolls turned out. Airy, not dense. I had no issues with the measurements / conversions. It all made sense. I was worried b/c they didn't rise much, but the baker who submitted this recipe said that they wouldn't rise very much and I trusted her. They looked amazing and tasted great, nice texture. I am in Denver, at altitude, and without making any adjustments they turned out. Maybe I'm lucky. I will probably bake them for a little longer next time, but otherwise, they were very good. I will bake them again and again!
 
mckline7 January 15, 2024
The ONLY cinnamon roll recipe you need! The dough is so easy to work with once it's chilled, and it really doesn't need much rising time.
 
Delangre December 27, 2023
The best cinnamon rolls I have ever had and ever made and my new go-to brioche recipe. You're kitchen aid mixer will struggle with this, but it is worth it. I used half bread flour and half AP and it came out perfectly.
 
Pat March 6, 2023
I am not the most experienced baker. I do make yeast bread and scones well. I followed this recipe to the t. The rolls were far from fluffy. I'll try again someday. My husband liked them but he doesn't like fluffy.
 
debra March 10, 2022
These were the absolute best cinnamon rolls I have EVER made. I don't eat many cinnamon rolls because the dough is always so dense. However, the dough on these rolls were FABULOUS! And may I add VERY RICH! I used evaporated milk instead of whole milk because I ran out. I neglected to dilute it but I still loved the outcome. I needed to add a just a touch of flour but this recipe was flawless in my book.
 
Dicaron February 19, 2022
Best cinnamon buns ever!
Nobody explains the baking process better than Erin does. She even compares the failures so we can see exactly what is meant. Love the way she approaches recipes and have learned a lot.
 
Smaug January 27, 2022
In case you're not having your bowling team over for breakfast, this recipe is easily divided.
 
Smaug February 2, 2022
This comment was from an entirely different recipe, don't know how it got here. This is probably easy enough to divide if you can find the right size pan, but I haven't tried it.
 
cocoloco October 11, 2021
Dough is incredibly sticky, added a couple tbsp of flour and decided to just ~roll~ with it. Rise took abt 2 hours, just let it double in size. For the next day, make sure you put a lot of flour down before the filling part - it gets getting stickier and harder to work with as the butter melts and I couldn't cut them - had to bung it back in fridge for 2h.

Makes enough for two chunky caterpillars - I did cinnamon pecan + chocolate hazelnut. The buns are weightless and delicious, if rather buttery. Would recommend!
 
Marina D. June 15, 2021
Does anyone know why my rolls were swimming in butter/sugar syrup while baking? I was not able to bake properly because they were sitting in syrup
 
Katie B. December 24, 2020
Baked these this morning--holy moly, THE BEST cinnamon rolls, full stop. They have ruined us for all other cinnamon rolls, for all others are but pale immitations & just not worth the calories IMO.

A couple of notes:
1. I prepped everything 2 days ahead; rolled em up and set em in a greased pan, covered in plastic wrap & sat in the fridge for 2 days. No problems there, make em way ahead of time & have em on hand for whenever, they will do fine.

2. It's just me & husband in the house, so I halved the recipe. This yeilded 8 fat rolls, so I baked 4 this morning & I have 4 more chillin in the fridge for tomorrow morning (money in the bank, ya'll). 1/2 of the frosting amount is PLENTY, but do yrself a solid & use vanilla bean paste & a splash of KY bourbon.

3. I let my runny room temp filling sit in the freezer for about 15 min--you want a paste consistency so it isn't too oozy.

4. Speaking of the filling: sprinkle in some orange zest (and bourbon?). This recipe is a little fussy, and you are putting in some extra effort here, so why not really go for it, right?

5. I received an imaginary Paul Hollywood handshake for these rolls.
 
Kittie M. December 24, 2020
Katie, thanks for the tips! I too am cooking for 2 and love the idea of halving the recipe. Glad to know it was successful. Also, I just really got a kick from your comments. Made me smile! More bourbon? Of course! 😄
 
Joel R. October 18, 2020
I made these for my family on a Fall Break school break. These rolls are delicious! This was my third time making them and definitely the best attempt. I have only made them the same day. My electric LG oven has a "Proof" setting and I used it for the first rest (dough placed in buttered dutch oven with lid on for 1.5 hours). And, I also used the proof setting for last rest after the compiled rolls are placed into their baking dish. I also use 2.5 tbls of cinnamon when making the filling. Great recipe!
 
Cynthia S. October 10, 2020
Good stuff - been making it this way long before the appearance of this recipe since it’s really the same brioche-based recipe by renowned baker , Joanna Chang. For first class technique and recipes pick up one of her books.
 
Teresa September 27, 2020
Very disappointing. Too much butter in this recipe. The dough is so dense, I could barely get a rise. And what’s with the measurements? 1 cup minus 2 tablespoons? Really? As I ate one, I finally understand what Paul Hollywood means by “no lamination”. I’ll stick to Julia Child’s cinnamon roll recipe: works every time and well written.
 
Smaug January 27, 2022
Would 7/8 of a cup or 7 ounces be easier? Most people don't have a 7/8 cup measure so will probably do it by measuring a cup and subtracting an ounce (two tablespoons).
 
JamieATL June 21, 2020
Divine! Lots of steps but straight forward and easy to follow. We did double the vanilla in the icing, and since I have a convection oven we baked at 350 for 20 minutes. They are light, buttery and perfect.
 
NXL April 26, 2020
This dough is rich and buttery and a lot of fun to work with, although it is very soft and delicate to roll. It stuck to the paper during the overnight stay, so next time I'd put it directly onto an oiled pan. The filling is good, but not quite cinnamony for me, so I'd probably bump that up a little or ass more nutmeg. Altogether a good recipe and fun baking project.
 
Jenna April 5, 2020
Hi everyone, for the past month I have been baking various cinnamon bun recipes, like the many "Cinnabon Copy Cat" recipes and others that claim to be "the best." They are actually very similar in composition, with about 4 (to 4.5) cups of flour (bread or all-purpose), milk, 2-4 eggs, 1-2 packets of yeast, and so on. They also share the same process of production. The recipe at hand IS, IMHO "The Best"! It has more egg and MUCH more butter, that is incorporated late in the mixing/kneading process. There is also a two-step treatment of the dough after the first rise, in which you press it into a cookie sheet, chill, and then roll-out the chilled dough--which works beautifully. (The dough is especially easy to handle.) Once baked, these buns have a chewy, pillow-y, melting quality in the mouth that is just heaven and quite unlike any others. Really, they make all the other "best" buns seem like wheat bread and they easily take the bun up a notch from the Cinnabon buns at the mall. So, many thanks to Erin for this splendid recipe!
 
Smaug January 27, 2022
This type of enriched dough is pretty common (with variations on how enrichhed) and can be used for any number of purposes; they do generally handle much better cold.
 
Kittie M. January 1, 2020
I've made these 3 times. Each time, I used a different butter and I found the butter really makes a difference in how the dough handles and in the consistency of the filling. However, each time the filling has been runnier than I would think it should be, and when I roll up the dough, the filling squeezes out. Anyone else have this problem? How did you solve? Refrigerate the filling?
 
P S. January 2, 2020
The butter in the filling is too warm when you begin to roll them up. spread the filling and take your time getting it even across the dough and up to the edges. the butter will stiffen the filling as it cools so taking time and not rushing is key. i use the generic unsalted butter from walmart for all my baking with excellent results.
 
Kittie M. January 2, 2020
I make the filling the day before I bake the rolls and it sits out at room temperature, per the instructions in the recipe. It just never stiffens up as much as I'd think it should.
 
P S. January 2, 2020
I would chill it for just a couple minutes in the fridge. just be careful that it doesn't firm up too much on you. assuming you are using a basic stainless mixing bowl give it 60 to 90 seconds in the freezer, stir it up good and gauge the consistency. you need to be able to spread it. the other option is to spread it an put it in the fridge for a couple minutes before you roll it up. if your fridge is like mine there isn't always enough room. if the weather permits (cold and dry) put it outside. the filling should set up with out impacting the dough and your ability to roll it up...
 
Kittie M. January 3, 2020
My thought, too, to refrigerate it for a bit to thicken. Thanks!
 
frizz January 1, 2020
I made these today by hand with amazing success! I was tempted to add more flour but didn't based on the comments below. I kept adding butter to the dough as directed, and it all came together! Trust the recipe -- after the dough came out of the fridge, it was perfect.

The butter from the dish oozed onto the floor of my oven, so I might cut back on it a little for next time. That was the only adjustment I'd make. I love the texture, flavor, and wow factor.

Overall - huge success. I'll definitely make again!
 
P S. November 10, 2019
Good recipe. Just did a test run before the holidays. The key is to follow the steps and give yourself time the day before when making the dough. i used regular flour with no issues. may dial back the butter in the dough, cut the recipe in half and allow the dough to proof a little longer. im a sticky bun person but will break this recipe out Thanksgiving weekend. Overall I would go for it if your on the fence trying it.
 
Kittie M. November 9, 2019
I made these this morning for my husband's birthday breakfast. Definitely a winner! I, too, have searched for years for a roll recipe that would turn out this good. Like others, I wondered if my KitchenAid was up to the task, but it held out! Only flaw was I forgot to put on the egg wash! There it was on the counter as I pulled the rolls out of the oven! :-) Nothing was particularly difficult to do. The rolls were huge! I really did not have 1/4 inch of space between them in my 13x9 dish. Maybe they rose more than normal? Anyway, next time I will divide the dough and make two pans of smaller rolls. Has anyone else done this? If you did, how long did you bake them?
 
Joel R. January 24, 2020
My daughter and I made smaller rolls. We divided the rolled dough into 16 rolls and placed in two baking dishes for the same time and temp. The rolls were not tall (we didn’t do the final dough rest with the rolls in the pans before baking). I’d recommend trying smaller rolls.
 
Kittie M. November 9, 2019
Made these this morning for my husband's birthday breakfast. Definitely a winner! I, too, have struggled to find a recipe that would turn out good and this one definitely does. Like others, I wondered if my KitchenAid would meet the task, but it held out! I didn't find anything particularly hard to do, but I forgot the egg wash! :) There it was on the counter as I pulled the rolls out of the oven! The rolls were huge and I really didn't have enough space in my 13x9 dish for a 1/4 inch space between them. Maybe my dough rose more than usual. Anyway, may divide the dough next time and make two pans of smaller rolls. Has anyone else done this? If you did, how long did you bake them?
 
ccarpe01 October 29, 2019
Absolutely delicious!!
 
Laura October 21, 2019
Please give the measurements of the rectangle. Guessing 18" x ?
 
Kelly G. September 15, 2019
Really wish there dimensions for the rolled-out rectangle. One of the comments estimated the width, but that wasn’t all that helpful. Any suggestions?
 
Eden L. September 5, 2019
Great recipe! The ol' kitchenaid was struggling but it pulled through and these cinnamon buns are ohhhh soo fluffy! I switched out the bread flour for all purpose because I was going to use it within a few hours. I used room temperature eggs and warmed the milk to 85F for prime yeast development. Instead of mixing it all at once, I let the dry yeast wake up in the milk for ten minutes until mixing it into the dry ingredients. To quick proof, I set the oven to 170F (the lowest it will go) and then let it cool down a little bit before placing the dough in seran wrapped bowls into the oven. I punched the dough down twice -- it was magnificent.
I also added a few tablespoons of flour into the filling mixture and found that it didn't leak out like that. It was beautiful!
It baked up magnificently!
 
Alex January 29, 2019
These were wonderful and so indulgent! I made them for my daughter’s Christmas birthday breakfast. I’ve tried different recipes the last four years, but won’t need to test any others, these are the winner! The dough is wet and sticky, but after a night in the fridge it’s so easy to work with. I thought we would prefer a cream cheese icing, but decided to make the icing as written and we loved it. Thanks Erin!
 
Paula B. November 15, 2018
Best Cinnamon Rolls I've made but I've only really tried like 3 recipes, however, I'm sure I"ll be returning to this recipe. The dough was nice - springy and moist. The icing got compliments from my husband who thought it was nice and soft but not runny once they cooled. Apparently the wrong kind of icing can be too messy to enjoy. Great flavor. My only hiccup was that I measured everything and still ended up with a sticky dough but I just mixed and added 1-2 tbsp at a time until the dough formed a ball. I was worried that it would make my bread dry and heavy but it didn't. I also forgot about my dough baby and let it rise for like 3 hrs instead of the 1 1/2hrs suggested - flavor was not affected.
 
P S. November 10, 2019
i had the same result and likely should have used more flour.
 
debra October 12, 2018
Thank you! I made these for my birthday. They are wonderful! First time ever making these. I was always a bit intimidated. Now I am a pro!
 
Darling H. January 13, 2018
The dough almost broke my brand new kitchen aid stand mixer- it kept dislodging the bowl there was so much of it. So to get the butter incorporated I divided the dough in two parts and mixed one at a time. Also couldn’t use a speed higher than 2 with
It dislodging the bowl. After all that it’s finally in the fridge waiting for tomorrow’s bake!
 
ashleyamore December 25, 2017
Made this by hand - with high altitude adjustments from https://www.kingarthurflour.com/learn/high-altitude-baking.html and they were perfect. I'll be making this on the reg now, with some various different flavor profiles in addition to baking the recipe as is.
 
Joel R. January 24, 2020
I’m interested to hear your adjusts to this recipe that you enjoy.
 
Molly M. December 15, 2017
If I want to make the dough the day before, after which step should I stop and refrigerate?
 
Molly M. December 15, 2017
nevermind! missed it the first time
 
moo November 25, 2017
Of all the cinnamon roll recipes I've tried over the years, nay decades, this is the best! Of course I should have expected it to be a great recipe--the dough has over a stick of butter and four eggs! It was sticky but with using bread flour, not unmanageable,
 
Olivia H. September 2, 2017
I had such high hopes for this recipe since there are so many great reviews but sadly, it was a disaster. I followed directions EXACTLY but I ended up with a sticky, wet dough (even after putting it in the fridge overnight). I went to roll it up after spreading the filling and it just became this pool of dough. I couldn't salvage it even a little bit. It's a huge dissapointment when you waste so many ingredients on such a recipe. I'm surprised no one else ran into this as I'm not a beginner baker. Oh well.
 
Joel R. January 24, 2020
Interesting. I made this today. The dough was sticky. However, after pulling it from the freezer to roll out on my floured counter I had no problems.
 
Martine P. May 18, 2020
Sometimes its just the flour you use, did you use a bread flour?
 
Nancy June 2, 2017
This is a lovely recipe! Looks so easy and therefore encouraging. Success on first try. Adapted to non-dairy (because of what I had in pantry) and they worked beautifully...just use oil at 80% volume of butter (because butter is only about 80% fat) and some soy, seed or coconut milk in the dough. Looking forward to making it with butter next time.
 
xinekim January 22, 2017
Can you bake this on a sheet pan instead of a baking dish? And would it be prudent to double the recipe?
 
jjw January 22, 2017
xinekim, Maybe on a lipped sheet pan? But they'd spread and be pretty flat-ish, I'd imagine. More like a danish? And I don't think my mixer could handle a double batch...hope you have a strong one! Good luck :•]
 
Audrey R. January 19, 2017
I made these cinnamon rolls twice over the holidays - for Christmas and again for New Year's Day. They are the most delicious things I've ever made. I have passed this recipe onto two of my friends who were also blown away by how good they are!
 
Änneken December 25, 2016
A total showstopper!!! That was the first time I made cinnamon rolls at home and oh boy, I am a glad I used this recipe. Erin McDowell, I commend you! Hands down the most luxurious cinnamon rolls I have ever tasted in my life. I didn't use any mixer, made it entirely by hand (I FaceTimed with family while working in 18 tbsp of butter individually...). Also, in terms of the frosting, I only had 1.5 cups of icing sugar and no heavy cream at home (replaced it with a couple of tablespoons of milk) and it all worked beautifully.
 
peggy M. December 21, 2016
Wonderful! Yes, the dough does seem sticky at first but it works out in the long run. I am always pleased to see measurements by weight when baking, saves me figuring them out. (I don't really think it's a political thing:))
 
Elaina B. December 20, 2016
HI! I don't have an electric mixer, I'm wondering if I can hand mix and have the same result?
 
Sharon G. December 20, 2016
Hi!
I made it all by hand and they turned out fantastic!

 
Sya December 20, 2016
Hi! Can you hand knead the dough instead?
 
Sharon G. December 20, 2016
I hand kneaded the dough and they turned out great!
 
Sya December 21, 2016
Thank you, love!
 
jjw December 19, 2016
Hi Briana, I've frozen them a week ahead to have for Christmas morning, so I think you'd be ok to refrigerate? I went through all the steps, even brushing with egg, then popped them in the freezer. I pulled them out about 45 minutes before baking, put them in the buttered pan to bake, and they were as wonderful as usual. Good luck!
 
Briana December 19, 2016
Thanks, jjw!
 
Briana December 19, 2016
I want to make these on Christmas morning but will have to prepare the dough on the 23rd. Does anyone have experience refrigerating two days before baking?
 
Casey May 1, 2016
13 year old made these this weekend. We kept them in the fridge overnight. Hands down, best cinnamon rolls I've ever tasted. Great, detailed instructions and great recipe. We did change the frosting because we like the cream cheese frosting. Thank you for a great recipe!
 
Annika S. April 30, 2016
I don't have a dough hook for my mixer. Can I do the kneading by hand? First attempt at making cinnamon rolls!
 
Jess S. February 29, 2016
Hi there, can bake this in a casserole similar to the one in the image? Say a 29cm oval cast iron casserole from Le Creuset?
 
Monica8866 November 22, 2015
I have been on a cinnamon roll quest lately, making various recipes and enjoying them all. Oh my goodness, though, these are the best! Call off the dogs, the search is over! No need to try another recipe! Thanks so much for sharing these!
 
Fara November 18, 2015
Excellent recipe. The dough was a bit sticky after mixing but I decide to just roll with it, they turned out fantastic. Thank you!
 
buzzWOOF November 16, 2015
I made these this past weekend. As I was mixing the dough in the stand mixer, it never really formed a ball around the hook, as the instructions said it would. Because of this, and because the dough seemed overly sticky to me, I mixed in extra flour -- almost a whole cup extra! After spreading onto a sheet pan and cooling in the fridge for nearly 24 hours, I realized that, as the softened butter in the batter cooled, it helped the dough firm up tremendously. I probably didn't need all of that extra flour at all. The dough was incredibly easy to work with and probably even TOO stiff/floury. They still turned out delicious, albeit a tiny bit dry. Next time I'll try them exactly according to the instructions. I imagine they'll be truly perfect!
 
Jennifer October 18, 2015
My husband AND kids loved these rolls. Yes, I freaked out when the dough was sticky, but added more sprinkled flour on my work space as I rolled it out (then I worried that it wouldn't be sticky enough to seal the roll). Turned out just right and an instant hit!!! I'm wondering if the extra yolk was truly for the dough or meant for the egg wash.
 
Janet October 4, 2015
I don't have a stand mixer and I'm fairly new to baking. How would one proceed without it?
 
Monica8866 November 23, 2015
Hi Janet, I just made this recipe, and I would not attempt it as a newish baker without a stand mixer and dough hook. Maybe Santa could bring you one. You will use it a lot! :-)
 
Janet June 2, 2017
Hi Monica8866, sorry it's taken so long to reply. You were right. It didn't turn out well at all by hand. :(
 
Valerie September 13, 2015
My dough came out incredibly sticky/gooey and very difficult to manage. Does anyone know what could have went wrong (I used a digital scale for all my measurements)?
 
Cassie W. September 13, 2015
I had this issue, as well. It took me 4-5 tries making this and figuring out the best way to work with this type of dough. The most important thing I can recommend is to make the dough a day in advance. After you make the dough, let it rise until double in size, then put it into the fridge (do not punch down). I've found that this dough stops risin as soon as it goes in the fridge. The next day, lightly flour your bench and roll the dough out like normal. It will feel like sugar cookie dough. After you form and pan your rolls, let them proof 2-2.5 hrs (the cold dough takes longer to rise), then bake like normal. They'll be perfect!
 
Cassie W. June 27, 2015
Y'all, calm the hell down... these are cinnamon rolls, for goodness sake! And damn good cinnamon rolls, if I may say so. (If you're in a tissy about the measurements, try using common sense.) I'm a bakery owner, and I've been on the hunt for softer, more tender cinnamon rolls. These are ethereal! Mine did not come out cakey, like some comments mentioned. They were soft, stretchy, and delicious! Definitely a keeper! My staff devoured the whole first batch!
 
alexia S. June 22, 2015
These rolls are amazing! I made them for my husband and dad for Father's Day -- because who can resist sweets for your sweets? -- and cannot wait for an excuse to make again. My first time making a brioche-type dough and who cares about the measurements? They were PERFECT.
 
Tracie June 21, 2015
I made these this morning and they were divine. Moist and gooey - a huge hit! Thank you!
 
Chloe S. June 21, 2015
Just made these for my dad for Father's Day. Cinnamon rolls are his favorite and I have never made them from scratch. These turned out soo good! I made the dough the night before (I went ahead and rolled and cut the dough too) then I put them in the fridge already in the skillet ready to be cooked in the morning. In the bottom of the skillet I coated it with butter and left over filling. Instead of the icing in the recipe I did a cream cheese frosting (just our preference) it was 8 oz cream cheese 8 tbsp butter 1 cup confectioners sugar and vanilla to taste. I'm not sure how to store the leftovers though. Do I cover and put in the fridge? Or cover and leave at room temp?
 
Sharon G. May 23, 2015
This was one of the best recipes I've ever used. I made some slight adjustments here and there with the sizing of the rolls and such so that they only baked for about 20 minutes before being perfect. Great recipe!! Very pleased!
 
vanessa May 10, 2015
I make cinnamon rolls all the time and decided to try this new recipe. I just made them, and am not very happy. They are extremely cakey and not much like the cinnamon rolls my family likes. Pretty disappointed.
 
LaKady May 2, 2015
Made these cinnamon rolls today and followed the recipe to a T, weighing out all the ingredients and baking the rolls in a cast iron skillet. I rarely comment on recipes but this time I was too bummed out not to. I am an experienced baker and I like to use only the best ingredients for recipes. These cinnamon rolls sounded and looked very promising...that is, until I took the first bite. It was just not worth all the hype. They were soft, cakey, and just not the perfect texture that I was hoping for. My husband liked them but I don't think he loved them. It was special because I stayed up prepping the dough and got up early to bake the rolls as a surprise for him. Too bad, I was really hoping for more than just a "good" recipe. Thank you for sharing.
 
Linda C. May 1, 2015
Honestly! Is there no civility anymore? Measurements in volume isn't necessarily a European versus American thing anymore. I've always heard that professional chefs use a scale to weigh their dry ingredients as it was more precise than ounces and cups. Let's all thank Erin for sharing a wonderful recipe and remember that the internet is our friend, if we choose to investigate and learn.
 
Valeria April 29, 2015
Jimmy, you obviously DO have a problem with this recipe otherwise you wouldn't have had to ask your phone to translate it for you.
 
Jimmy L. April 29, 2015
I always have a problem with measurements in recipes. I live in Europe and we don't use American measurements. All those cups and ounces are pretty annoying, but converting is just a few seconds job by the phone so why not?
 
Jimmy L. April 29, 2015
I have no problem with weight of volume, seriously can't people just ask (literally) their phone to convert for them if they need it?

For me I just raise my phone and say ok google how many grams are 9 ounces, then it's already there, those with iphone could ask siri too...

By the way I'm having the dough in my fridge now, can't wait to bake them tomorrow morning!
 
Skilletlicker April 29, 2015
I could ask my phone, I guess, or go online and convert for TEN INGREDIENTS individually - like I do when I'm in Europe and I'm trying to follow a recipe from, say, an Elizabeth David cookbook. It's a pain in the ass but I expect to do it in countries where the metric system is standard. On my home turf I'm not into it. I'll just go out and buy cinnamon rolls and I won't expect the bakery to accept Euros instead of dollars.
 
Julie B. May 23, 2015
Skilletlicker Did you know the U.S. is the only country in the world that DOESN'T use metric so I guess the author didn't think it would be necessary to write a separate recipe for just one country.
 
Skilletlicker May 25, 2015
Yes, I'm aware of that. I'm also aware that 99% of recipes available on this site are choose standard measurements over metric b/c this is an American site and, except for the measurements, the instructions and all other pertinent information is delivered in English - so if the author "didn't feel it would be necessary to write a separate recipe for just one country," then by your logic, she's prioritizing the UK, South Africa, and Australia since, as far as I know, this recipe is not available in French, Hungarian, or Vietnamese. If you had read my comment above you would know that I expect metric measurements when I'm away from my home turf. But since Food 52 is a site founded by American women and I would guess a majority of visitors or subscribers to the site are American, an expectation of standard measurement is not exactly asking for the moon. I don't have the time or the inclination to convert 10 ingredients to metric. This isn't the only cinnamon rolls recipe on this site or several other recipe sites I frequent. Incidentally, I have actually LIVED in Paris, Rome, and London which is why I referenced Elizabeth David. Read carefully before you bite.
 
Julie May 26, 2015
Point 1) There are far more than 3 countries in the world that speak English and English is used as the universal language around the world. Point 2) Not sure why you assume most people using this site are Americans. Seemed to be many from other countries. Point 3) It's rather presumptuous to think the US is the highest user here. This is what bothers most other countries around the world about the States is their arrogance that they are most important and should be catered to more than anyone else. Your first comment reeked of this attitude and why I commented on it. And good for you having lived in other countries but that has nothing to do with this article. You may think the US is most important but there are a lot of other people out here who would beg to differ with you. A little humility would help.
 
Amanda R. December 18, 2016
When baking, you should always use weight... which is typically metric... I never use cups or teaspoons etc. always grams, oz or lbs. the only way to bake, honestly.
 
Christina April 28, 2015
I am making these rolls now to bake in the morning. Is the dough supposed to be super sticky? Difficult to handle.
 
jjw April 29, 2015
Mine was stickier than I thought it should be, so I added additional flour with no ill effects. Good luck!
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi everyone, thanks for all your comments. Most of my recipes include both weight and volume measurements, but this recipe was missing volume - I've added it in now for those without scales. Thanks!
 
Steph A. April 30, 2015
Thanks a million!
 
Valeria April 27, 2015
sorry, I meant ounces, and why are SAE and metric measures intermingled?
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi Valeria, I've included both weight and volume measurements for the recipe now. Thanks!
 
Valeria April 27, 2015
And also, since when are eggs measured in grams!
 
Valeria April 27, 2015
I agree with the condescending weight measurements, clearly these cinnamon buns are too sophisticated for the average American. Maybe Michelle Obama's chef can make them for her.
 
Skilletlicker April 27, 2015
By the time I finished reading the text I was super-excited to make this recipe - and then I got to the measurements - I don't know if NOT including volume measurements for the enthusiastic American home kitchen amateur is an innocent oversight or a condescending (and infuriating) slight but either way I guess I'm not making these cinnamon rolls.
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi Skilletlicker, I've provided volume measurements now along with the weight. Hope these find their way into your oven!
 
Skilletlicker April 28, 2015
Thank you SO much! I really can't wait to make these now! Especially since the rolled dough can be frozen.
 
jjw April 27, 2015
I made these today. Yes, it was a bother having to convert so many of the measurements (and I often rounded up or rounded down for convenience sake), AND my poor mixer and dough hook were wildly uncooperative... BUT they were amazing and worth every moment spent. My family is already begging me to make more. The one issue I had with the final buns was that the two very center buns (I laid them out 4x3 in a dark metal rectangular pan) were woefully underdone -- but any more baking would have made the corner buns OVERdone. This weekend, when I make them again, I will either use a larger pan so that they spread more and have a greater chance to cook through, lower the oven temperature so they cook more evenly through the middle, or bake them in 2 pans with six in each (no middles). Yes, I'm making them again this weekend, they were THAT good.
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi JJW, so glad you loved these. I've included volume measurements now too, so hopefully your converting days are over!
 
A. April 26, 2015
This recipe looks like one I used to have years ago, but lost. Glad to find it again! However, the mish-mash of grams, ounces, cups make the author of this recipe look like a fool. Since I have a scale, I don't mind using gram measurements. Or even ounces, or volume measures. But I've never seen a recipe that used ALL of them at once! Does the author think this adds a "cool factor" to her recipe???
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi A - The recipe includes both weight and volume throughout now. Thanks very much!
 
Rae S. April 26, 2015
I agree with the other comments about grams, ounces, etc....if you are going to publish a recipe please give us the measurements in English which is the standard home kitchen practice here in the USA...staff needs to be a little more diligent. I would guess the majority of us on this site are NOT professional chefs. I would love to try this recipe but when it is easier to follow.
 
Chocolate B. April 26, 2015
The US is almost the only country in the world which still uses volume measurements for baking, a wildly inaccurate way to measure. A cup of flour from from one source is generally not the same as a cup of flour from another source. It is the World Wide Web, many of us are not cooking in the US. We are grateful when we can actually use baking recipes from Food52 which are comprehensible globally rather than just in the US.

 
Marie April 27, 2015
I agree with Rae. I'll wait until this recipe is available in a format I can follow.
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi Marie, the recipe now has volume measurements along with weight. Thanks!
 
medic1963 May 13, 2023
Baking is a science and it has nothing to do with where you live in the world. Weighing is the most accurate way to get the results you want from a recipe. Making a stew or cooking a chicken is where you can add or subtract ingredients as you see fit but baking is where you need accuracy. My $10 scale is a staple for me when baking, it gives me a guaranteed result every time. Embrace the scale, you will be surprised how much easier it makes your life whether you are baking bread, cookies or cakes. And p.s. most scales weigh in both imperial and metric to eliminate any confusion. Happy baking.
 
jpriddy April 26, 2015
Also, the instructions say to roll from the long side, but the more detailed instructions show it being rolled from a narrow end. The emphasis in the latter is to get the thickness correct, and the instructions above are clear only about thickness. But then we have 12, 1.5" rolls. That suggest a wide side of 18". It would be helpful to simply say that. https://food52.com/blog/12757-your-guide-to-the-best-cinnamon-rolls-of-your-life?utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_term=Sunday%20Email%20Send&utm_campaign=20150426_SundayDigest
 
jpriddy April 26, 2015
I'm sure this is a great recipe, but grams, teaspoons, cups, and ounces all together?
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi jpriddy - the recipe now includes volume measurements for convenience and ease! Thanks!
 
Meg April 26, 2015
Can cinnamon rolls be frozen for easier prep? Freeze the dough separate from other ingredients? Or combine and freeze all? Thanks
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
You can freeze the rolled cinnamon rolls. It's best to thaw them fully before baking! Thanks!
 
Lindsay April 25, 2015
What kind of baking dish are you using? I've been looking for one like that
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
This is a Staub brand casserole. We love it!
 
Tracey March 6, 2018
Is that the 4qt oval dish? Could I bake it in a 13" round staub or would that be too big? It is a 4.5 qt
 
laumasan April 25, 2015
Ahh!!!+This+is+so+good+recipe!+Came+out+beautiful,+with+rich+taste.+Everyone+at+my+home+loved+it.
+I+don`t+care+so+much+about+measurements+as+here+in+Europe+I+always+need+to+recalculate+all+recipes+which+are+given+in+volume+ingredients+as+well+those+that+are+given+in+ounces,+pounds+and+gallons.+And+when+there+comes+in+a+measurement+like+"a+stick+of+butter"+(?!?!?)...+:)+But+you+know..+that+just+let+you+know+more+about+the+world,+it`s+differences.
 
KathyTS April 21, 2015
Not everyone has a scale. Please include volume measurements.
 
Aaron April 21, 2015
These cinnamon rolls are exceptionally rich. I suspect that the odd measurements are due to the recipe's having been scaled down from a commercial recipe. If you prefer a more traditional recipe with more traditional measurements, no scale required, consider the Grandma Bercher's recipe, https://food52.com/recipes/24943-grandma-bercher-s-cinnamon-rolls .
 
jpriddy April 26, 2015
But the Bercher recipe is not at all like the one above—probably half the eggs and a quarter of the butter.
 
Aaron April 27, 2015
Right. It's a more traditional recipe, not exceptionally rich like this one.
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi Kathy TS - the recipe includes volume measurements as well now. Thanks!
 
Cindy April 20, 2015
Admittedly we're the only country that doesn't use the metric system, but I have enuf to do keeping up with world events to bother about these conversions. I mean really?? The staff here needs to take that into consideration. I'm tired of this.
 
Erin J. April 28, 2015
Hi Cindy, the recipe now includes volume measurements as well as weight. Thanks!
 
Norm V. April 18, 2015
As my training was in chemistry, the units used are unclear. Switch from ounces to grams, are ounces weight or volume, are they SAE ounces or Imperial? I have assumed that all measures are weights but recipe should be explicit about this. Assuming is not good practice. Accuracy of measurement is another bug of mine - the recipe puts ounces to 1/100 of an ounce which is 0.28 gm. but grams are quoted as units, no decimals.
I realize some of this is standard kitchen practice but . . .
thanks.
 
Aaron April 21, 2015
I went with the assumption, particularly with some of the odd numbers, that everything was measured by mass, and was successful with that assumption.
 
Norm V. April 21, 2015
Thanks Aaron - and agree with your assumption about starting as a commercial recipe.
 
Shay April 17, 2015
Looks+lovely!+Is+there+any+way+a+recipe+can+be+provided+in+cups+for+those+of+us+who+don't+own+scales...??
 
Marie April 17, 2015
Can you just say how many eggs, instead of ounces???
 
[email protected] April 17, 2015
Hi Marie, based on average large egg weights, this would be about 4 eggs!