5 Ingredients or Fewer

Alexandra Stafford's No-Knead Peasant Bread

April  4, 2017
4.4
40 Ratings
Photo by James Ransom
  • Prep time 2 hours 45 minutes
  • Cook time 35 minutes
  • Makes two 14-ounce loaves
Author Notes

This is it: the bread recipe so simple and good, it will get you baking bread every week—even if you’ve never made a loaf in your life. It’s the comforting, no-knead peasant bread that’s ready in as little as 2 hours, unlike other no-knead breads that are ready ... tomorrow. Recipe adapted slightly from Genius Recipes

What You'll Need
Watch This Recipe
Alexandra Stafford's No-Knead Peasant Bread
Ingredients
  • 4 cups (512 grams) unbleached all-purpose flour
  • 2 teaspoons kosher salt
  • 2 teaspoons sugar
  • 2 1/4 teaspoons instant yeast
  • 2 cups (454 grams) lukewarm water, made by mixing 1/2 cup boiling water with 1 1/2 cups cold water
  • Softened unsalted butter, for greasing
Directions
  1. In a large bowl, whisk together the flour, salt, sugar, and instant yeast. Add the water. Using a rubber spatula, mix until the water is absorbed and the ingredients form a sticky dough ball. (If you need to use active dry yeast instead, proof it in the lukewarm water first for about 10 minutes, until foamy, before adding to the other ingredients.)
  2. Cover the bowl with a damp tea towel or plastic wrap and set aside in a warm spot to rise for 1 to 1 1/2 hours, until the dough has doubled in bulk. Note: Here's a trick for making the perfect warm spot for the dough to rise. Set the oven to 400° F and let it preheat for 1 minute, then shut it off. The temperature will be between 80° F and 100° F. you should be able to place your hands (carefully) on the oven grates without burning them.
  3. Set a rack in the middle of the oven and preheat it to 425° F. Grease two 1-quart oven-safe bowls, like Pyrex (see note below), with softened butter—be generous. Using two forks, deflate the dough by releasing it from the sides of the bowl and pulling it toward the center. Rotate the bowl quarter turns as you deflate, turning the mass into a rough ball.
  4. Using your two forks and working from the center out, separate the dough into two equal pieces. Use the forks to lift each half of the dough into a prepared bowl. If the dough is too wet to transfer with forks, lightly grease your hands with butter or oil, then transfer half to a bowl. (If your dough drops and breaks apart on the transfer, don't worry, just divvy the dough between the bowls and it will come back together as it rises.) Do not cover the bowls. Let the dough rise on the countertop near the oven (or another warm, draft-free spot) for 10 to 20 minutes, until the top of the dough just crowns the rims of the bowls.
  5. Transfer the bowls to the oven and bake for 15 minutes. Reduce the heat to 375° F and bake for 17 to 20 minutes more, until evenly golden all around. Remove the bowls from the oven and turn the loaves out onto cooling racks. If the loaves look pale, return them to their bowls and bake for 5 minutes longer. Let the loaves cool for 15 minutes before cutting.
  6. Note: If you don't have 2 one-quart bowls, you may use other vessels, though differences in pan sizes will affect the shape of the final loaves. This recipe can be adapted for 2 loaf pans (preferably 8.5 x 4.5-inch pans) by multiplying the quantities of ingredients by 1.5 (i.e. 6 cups/768g flour, 3 cups water, etc.).

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Stefanie Pont
    Stefanie Pont
  • Kasia Suzuki
    Kasia Suzuki
  • VictoriaOC
    VictoriaOC
  • Erin Axelrod
    Erin Axelrod
  • neonkitty
    neonkitty
Genius Recipes

Recipe by: Genius Recipes

411 Reviews

Dina February 26, 2024
Can I bake this in one Dutch oven and not divide it ? Or should I then do half a recipe ? Thanks
 
Anne G. February 27, 2024
When I bake this bread I just put it all in a Dutch oven and it comes out great.
 
freshbread February 27, 2024
Yes! Just as you wrote — you can bake this in a Dutch oven, in which case you wouldn't divide it; you'd make one large loaf. In fact, Alexandra suggests this as an option in her cookbook, "Bread Toast Crumbs," which takes this base recipe in a wide range of delightful directions.
 
gen1018 March 22, 2023
This is my first time ever baking my own bread. This bread is delicious, especially with a little butter on it. Will definitely make again, probably tomorrow !!
 
Carol G. October 16, 2022
The bread was okay, but I will probably not make it again. I much prefer Sally Lunn Bread which is also a no-knead bread and has a better crumb and is DELICIOUS and also makes great toast!
 
Picholine October 16, 2022
Sally Lund bread is not even the same type of bread! Has eggs and milk more like a brioche which is also a recipe from Alexandra’s cookbook .
No comparison in bread types. I make that too.
 
Carol G. October 16, 2022
I do realize that it is a different type of bread, but it is a no knead bread. I just think that for the time, Sally Lunn is a lot better. I've have been making it for 40 years. I just think that this bread didn't really have a lot of taste, that's all.
 
Picholine October 16, 2022
Can you post your recipe ! I’d like to try it!
 
Carol G. October 16, 2022
Certainly. 1 pkg active dry yeast, 1/4 cup warm water, 1/2 cup sugar, 2T lard, 2 eggs, 1 tsp table salt, 3 1/2 cup AP flour, 1 cup warm milk. Soften the yeast in the warm water for about 10 min. Cream the lard and the sugar - beat in the eggs and the salt. Stir in 1 1/2 cups flour and beat. Stir in the warm milk and yeast and mix well. Add the remaining 2 cups of flour and beat. Cover and let rise in a warm place for about 1 hour. Stir down the dough and spoon into a well greased 10" tube pan. Cover and let rise again for about 35 to 45 min .... until doubled. Bake in a preheated 325 degree oven for 10 min. Increase heat to 375 and bake for another 25 min. Cool slightly and remove from the pan. Enjoy!
 
Carol G. October 16, 2022
Just an additional note .... I also grease the pan in lard. I know, people think of lard and go .... OMG! But, lard is better for you than butter. It has less saturated fat than butter and coconut oil. And, it does make a difference in the taste I think. I keep it in the freezer.
 
Picholine October 27, 2022
Thank you for the recipe.
 
Debbie G. September 1, 2023
Can you make this in a bread machine?
 
brushjl September 8, 2022
Wow, a lot of reviews for pretty mediocre bread, if you count all the detailed instructions for microwaving water. The measurements were off - I had to add an extra cup of flour, the volume was wrong - it really only makes one loaf. And the cooking time also was off, I needed an extra 15-20 minutes, and though the bread was cooked, the top never browned. The result was decent, though the crumb was a bit gluey.
 
Picholine September 8, 2022
It makes two loaves if you follow directions. Takes exactly the time to cook as well. So sorry you must have done something wrong.
 
fgb May 26, 2022
easy and infinitely riffable bread base. Highly recommend !
 
Ellen L. April 25, 2022
We absolutely love this bread and how easy it is from start to finish. Initially I followed the recipe and made 2 smaller loaves. When I switched to a single loaf in a 4 qt dutch oven, we liked it even better. I have also made it with Everything But the Bagel seeds on top for variety. My only issue is removing it from the pot is not as easy as I would like.
 
physicist February 9, 2022
Too many recipes seem to assume a gas stove and oven.

In #2, getting a warm oven: "Set the oven to 400° F and let it preheat for 1 minute, then shut it off. The temperature will be between 80° F and 100° F." My electric oven gets to 135 in 1 minute because of the residual heat in the heating elements.

After setting the oven to 425 and starting the baking, "Reduce the heat to 375° F" and continue baking. My electric oven is very well insulated, and it takes a long time for it to lose heat. It won't get down to 375 in the remaining "17 to 20 minutes."
 
Rosalind P. February 9, 2022
The concerns you mention don't really have anything to do with the kind of fuel used to heat the oven. A good gas oven, well insulated, also retains heat. The point here is that no oven will cool to 375 degrees when the control is turned to 375. The heat drops gradually, and my oven doesn't fall to 375 until the baking time is almost over. It's that gradual drop that is built into the method. So go ahead and use the recipe. If you're still concerned you can leave the oven door open for a moment or two. But the method is more forgiving than you think. (And, believe it or not, there are now sites that tell you how to actually start this kind of bread in a cold oven with a cold container. A lot easier than juggling all that blazing hot stuff. Google to find them)
 
freshbread February 9, 2022
I have an electric oven, too. I’ve found that leaving the door open for a minute or two does the trick.
 
Suz February 2, 2022
Not really a review of the recipe, but I have trouble with high hydration breads - I always end up with crust surrounding a wad of glue. That’s what happened today with this one. Back to the old-fashioned kneaded bread for me!
 
Smaug February 2, 2022
Have you tried baguettes? They're good practice for dough handling and can be counted on to cook through.
 
Stefanie P. January 30, 2022
I’m following a diet with very specific carb/bread restrictions. This recipe converted beautifully to using spelt and sprouted whole wheat flours - just played with the water content a bit. Delicious!
 
Smaug January 31, 2022
Since the hydration level and use of all purpose flour (an ill defined commodity) are about all that separates this recipe from a million others, I think you can congratulate yourself on developing a new recipe.
 
TRH January 30, 2022
Works great! This was my first attempt at baking bread. The recipe is easy to follow and it tastes great! I’ve already made it twice and will show my daughter how to make it because she got one of the fist loaves and loved it!!
 
Arrxx April 19, 2021
The recipe calls for a Pyrex bowl but the video clearly uses a Dutch oven. I guess that's okay? Also - for 1 loaf - half the recipe?
 
jawerkowitch April 19, 2021
I made this yesterday, my very first time making bread! It was SO easy and came out looking great, and delicious!
Do we know how long this will keep for?
 
Urszula April 19, 2021
It doesn’t hold for long. We usually finish the first loaf on the baking day and I always keep the other one in a fridge, otherwise it will start going bad about on a third day, depending on the temp and humidity.
 
crusherjoe2000 March 7, 2022
The best way to prevent bread from going stale is by freezing it. Leaving bread in the fridge will prevent it from molding but will not stop it from going stale (in fact, bread will go stale faster in the fridge).
 
Smaug September 8, 2022
Refrigerating bread makes it go stale in a very special and unpleasant way; a classic no no. Most breads freeze pretty well.
 
Kasia S. April 14, 2021
I do not have an oven so I made it in a cast-iron Dutch Oven on the stove. It came out perfectly (only next time I will add a little bit more salt, perhaps). Also, I did not divide the bread into two but made it all at once, and had to flip it halfway through the baking. Nevertheless, it was super good and I will be making this bread most likely every week from now on. Thanks!
 
Jkk17 December 30, 2021
Try coving the loaf with olive oil for second rise. Loaf will brown
 
Vikki S. April 12, 2021
My dough came out too dry! I'm proceeding but I don't have the highest hopes. Sitting on my counter waiting for the 2nd rise. I'll wait as long as it take to double.
 
Patiotools August 16, 2020
Help! I cannot get a second rise! Any suggestions are welcome : )
First rise is good, but even if I shorten it, cannot get it to rise again. When i put in oven, it comes out flat or even sunken. Still tastes great but I'd like to get it to rise!
 
Ellen P. September 20, 2020
Same problem here - it worked when I first made it but note coming out flat and dense. It’s not rising after first rise at all
 
Pat J. January 31, 2021
Ellen, after experimenting I found a solution. I microwave water til boiling then leave it in the microwave to create steam, then place my dough in there for the second rise. It works!
 
Sarah K. February 24, 2021
I'm pretty sure microwaving water is dangerous. Something about uneven heating and superheated areas that can boil up dangerously. You may want to research!
 
Lori February 24, 2021
Never heard such a thing and I have been boiling water in microwaves for over 35 years. In fact, there are numerous food items that are brought to boiling in microwaves—rice comes to mind.
 
Sarah K. February 24, 2021
It is rare but not unheard of. And it happens only when you boil water alone (not with rice, for instance) and only if you use smooth-sided containers. "Microwaves are specifically designed to heat water molecules and to heat them very rapidly. This can end up heating the water faster than it can turn into vapor, causing it to become superheated. Bubbles of water vapor can then quickly form when the water is jostled as the cup is taken out of the microwave. This makes it boil up, seeming to “explode,” as all the vapor is suddenly released." That's from https://www.thekitchn.com/fact-or-fiction-exploding-wate-109388.
Also see this for more info, and many other articles from reputable sources online: https://www.stevespanglerscience.com/lab/experiments/exploding-water-in-the-microwave/
 
Lori February 24, 2021
Given the number of times I have boiled just water in the microwave over the years, I’m not going to worry about it. Maybe it is more of an issue of putting it in for too long. Kind of like putting in something that only needs to be heated for 15 seconds and accidentally heating for 15 minutes—you will end up with a fire m
 
Rosalind P. April 12, 2021
Sometimes -- and it really is only sometimes -- if you heat water in the microwave to a boiling point but the water isn't bubbling, if you then put something in the cup when you take it out -- like a spoon -- it can bubble vigorously (violently) for just a second. It's happened to me. I'm just careful now.
 
Rosalind P. April 12, 2021
Yup. Didn't see this response so I wrote something like it, but not as well as you explained it. :-)
 
Pat J. April 12, 2021
Hi Pat - I think I found a solution. (I tried the heated water in the microwave, it helped get a second rise but it deflated in the oven.) I read in a bread cookbook by america's test kitchen that no-knead breads really need a little folding between the first and second rise - i tried it and it worked for me - once, so far : ) Good luck!
 
Pat J. August 23, 2021
I will try that- thank you, going to make a loaf right now!
 
Catherine P. January 22, 2022
When heating water in microwave place a wooden popsicle stick or something similar (broken chopstick) in the container along with water.
 
Lynda June 1, 2020
Hello! I love making this bread. Has any one made this bread in a traditional loaf pan? If so, what changes are needed to the basic recipe?
 
Rosalind P. June 1, 2020
Not an expert but I believe that with this (and all the other artisanal no-knead) recipe/technique it isn't the shape of the pan but the capture of moisture that matters. I'm guessing that any proper-sized pan or bowl that can be pre-heated and is covered tightly will work.
 
Picholine June 1, 2020
Yes, I make it at least once a week in a bread pan that is a USA metal pan I bought on Amazon last year . It is for larger loaves and is a bit longer than the usual size loaf pan. Makes a perfect loaf for this recipe. Bakes in my convection about same as instructed in recipe.
 
Lynda June 1, 2020
Thank you so much for the feedback!
 
Lynda June 1, 2020
Thank you very much for the response.
 
freshbread June 1, 2020
Hi Lynda! Yes, step 6 above actually offers instructions on this, guiding in how to make this recipe in two 8.5x4-inch loaf pans -- there, the recipe says to multiply all amounts by 1.5. If instead you wanted to make just one loaf, which is how I like to do it, then you'd multiply all quantities by 0.75.
 
VictoriaOC May 24, 2020
I want to make a single loaf in a dutch oven. Video doesn't give a size, and one person said they've done it in a 2 qt. while someone else said they used a 5.5 qt. Anyone know?
 
freshbread May 24, 2020
I've done this -- it'll work! Just use the full 4-cup measurement for your one large loaf. It ends up being roughly the size of those Dutch oven breads from folks like Jim Lahey, Emilie Raffa, Ken Forkish.

In fact, in Alexandra Stafford's book, "Bread Toast Crumbs," she offers instructions on how to do this. Among these helpful notes, I find her parchment paper tip particularly smart, and now use it whenever making a Dutch oven bread:

"To give the Peasant Bread the Lahey treatment, while the dough is making its first rise (in a warm spot, but not your oven), preheat a Dutch oven for 45 minutes at 450F. Dust a clean surface with 1/4 cup (32g) flour. Turn the dough out onto the clean surface and shape the dough into a ball using the pinkie-edge of your hands to pinch the dough underneath, creating tension. Transfer the dough to a sheet of parchment paper – the use of parchment paper here is key, as it allows for a seamless transition from the counter to the preheated Dutch oven. After 20 minutes of resting on the counter, remove the Dutch oven from the oven, lower the Peasant Bread, parchment paper and all, into the pan, cover, and bake for 30 minutes. Uncover and bake for 15 minutes more."
 
VictoriaOC May 24, 2020
Thank you freshbread for all the info! Actually, I had read about the parchment paper method elsewhere and was definately going to go that route. Glad you confirmed it works great!

If this recipe works out for me, I'll probably get the book. But, for now, I still need some guidance on the size of the Dutch oven for this particular recipe. I want to end up with a nicely shaped loaf, not too flat and not too big for the pot. I have Dutch ovens that I think might work, but I'm not sure which one to use: 2 qt round, 2.75 qt. round, or a 3.75 oval. Please advise ... thank you so much!
 
Rosalind P. May 24, 2020
It can "work" in many sizes of vessel. I have used a medium size pyrex bowl, with a cover. I've used a 6 quart dutch oven. In that one, the bread was flatter than in a smaller baking vessel. I thought the a 4 quart dutch oven or the pyrex bowl gave the best shape, for me. But it was successful and delicious every time. And by the way, it can be started in a cold oven, eliminating that tricky part of getting the bread into the burning hot baking pot. Google no-knead bread, cold oven.
 
VictoriaOC May 24, 2020
Thank you, Rosalind, that helps, a lot! I'm going to try it in the 3.75 qt. oval and see how it goes ... wish me luck!
 
freshbread May 24, 2020
Good luck, indeed! With good results, I've used a 4-quart Staub Round Cocotte .
 
Picholine May 27, 2020
Use a larger than 2qt Dutch Oven. Works great!
 
VictoriaOC May 27, 2020
Thanks, again!
 
Amy February 25, 2021
Thank you, freshbread! I followed these instructions and used my Staub cocotte. It's beautiful! Hard to wait for it to cool.......... :)
 
Erin A. May 24, 2020
Has anyone made this bread recipe in a solar cooker? I use an All-American Sun Oven which typically gets up to 350-400 degrees. Just curious if I start with cooking this recipe at 350 and just cook it a bit longer will it turn out the same?
 
Erin A. May 24, 2020
Also, has anyone adapted this Recipe to use homemade sourdough starter instead of instant yeast?
 
Anita June 2, 2020
hi, curious if you ended up trying that and how it worked out? I'm thinking of giving it a shot and substituting by weight for water and flour (and crossing my fingers).
 
neonkitty May 10, 2020
Just did a 5 way Zoom call with busy mom's and taught them this super easy bread recipe that we will all continue to enjoy for ever and ever. The only tricky part was the end when we had to watch the oven as everyone's oven is different but getting to that 'golden point' was easy and we are now enjoying the best avocado / vegan butter/ hot honey toasts ever. Thank you!
 
Bobbie C. May 9, 2020
What size Staub is she using?
 
Yvonne P. May 8, 2020
The demonstration shows using a lid to bake but the directions do not say to cover the bowls before putting in the oven. Which direction should I follow?
 
Alex G. May 8, 2020
I’ve never used a lid to bake. It comes out beautifully. Happy baking!
 
Tamara K. May 8, 2020
This is the best recipe I've found yet! The buttered bowl makes for an amazingly crispy bottom crust, and the top is lightly perfect, and the bread is so soft. It was easy and quick to make, and my house smells amazing! Had some still warm with butter and raspberry preserves - omg! It will be good with OO, S&P, and rosemary; as grilled cheese; and just toasted. We'll be using this one again. Thank you!
 
joanie_moe May 8, 2020
Can I use my warming drawer to rise the dough? What temperature would I set the warming drawer to? I have never made bread, but sm going to try this tomorrow. Thanks!
 
Karen L. May 2, 2020
This recipe has become my go to bread recipe. I just finished my 3rd loaf and the smell of fresh baked bread is all over my kitchen. The scent of yeast stays with the bread after cooling. I have been making it in a 50 year old white corning ware casserole pan. It makes the perfect sized single loaf, easily sliced as it is more squarish. I think I will next try it in a Dutch oven (5.5 quart). Thank you so much for such an easy, amazing recipe.
 
Gabi C. April 27, 2020
I would love to make this recipe and would like to make it in my Dutch oven, however I only have a larger size Dutch, 5.5 quart. Otherwise I have a 12 cast iron pan with lid, could I use either one of these for this recipe?
 
Susanna April 27, 2020
I’ve used my Staub 5.5 quart for this bread and it works well. Just use the same recipe amounts but make one loaf, not two.
 
Gabi C. April 27, 2020
Great! I’ll give it a shot. Thank you Susanna!
 
Jessica April 27, 2020
You could use the “faux” focaccia version with your 12” cast iron.
 
Debbie April 10, 2020
This looks delicious, and I love the little round loaves. Where can I find the oven-safe 1 quart bowls?
 
bamcnamara April 10, 2020
Amazon :) They sell cute bowl covers too!!!
 
Debbie April 10, 2020
Thank you!
 
Micq September 20, 2020
I bought the basic Pyrex set at Macy’s this summer. All the Pyrex was on sale! I used the second to smallest bowl (didn’t have a measure on it) and the next size up, which is marked as 2.5 qt. I let it rise until the dome of the bread in the smaller bowl was just up to the rim. Both loaves turned out amazing!!
 
Debbie September 21, 2020
Thank you!
 
Lynn B. April 9, 2020
love this so easy has anyone tried adding jalapeno peppers and grated cheddar cheese to the mix
 
Stacey November 20, 2020
https://food52.com/blog/19411-once-you-ve-made-genius-peasant-bread-try-these-5-variations
 
Rachel November 22, 2020
I have as well as olives and a few other variations. All turned out delicious. I put the additional ingredients into the dry mix and let them rise with the dough.
 
Alex G. April 8, 2020
Has anyone made this bread using sourdough starter instead of yeast, which seems to be in short supply these days. This is an excellent recipe. The bread always comes out perfect.
 
Austincook April 8, 2020
I haven't tried this, but in a King Arthur Flour thread on whole wheat bread, a similar question was answered by a KAF baker with the suggestion that you can substitute 1 cup of fed starter for 1 cup AP flour and 1/2 cup water in that recipe. I've successfully used that ratio in other doughs, to enhance the flavor. However, you would have to dramatically alter the proofing time to make sourdough starter the only leavening agent. I'm not expert, but I'd guess it would take a 2-3 hours for the first rise, and probably overnight in the fridge for the second. Please let us know if you try this!
 
Alex G. April 8, 2020
Thanks. I will try and let you know. I have to grow my starter a bit first - just received yesterday.
 
Austincook April 15, 2020
In today's Washington Post food chat, a very similar question was answered with a link to a food blog entry that had a detailed explanation. I hope this helps.
http://www.wildyeastblog.com/going-wild/
 
Alex G. April 15, 2020
Thanks for that link. Great information!
 
cacapoopoo January 31, 2020
bad bread
 
Rosalind P. April 27, 2020
I didn't think "bad" so much as "meh!" BUT the tradeoff is how quickly it can be made. And in every way, better than super-market "bread". If you have time the many "no-knead" [i.e. wet dough] recipes give you superior loaves. But they need a lot of lead-time -- planning.
 
Suzy S. April 23, 2021
Since you give no details, I have no idea what you think makes it bad. (Or”meh.”) It is meant to be a plain white bread, so if you’re into sourdough or something you can whack someone over the head with, you may not be into this. But this is my favorite bread recipe, and makes a beautiful loaf every time. It helps to follow the recipe as written, and do make sure you use instant yeast.

I got the cookbook she wrote around this recipe, and it explains how to make different size loaves (among many other things). We are a 2-person household, so the loaves in the Pyrex bowls are perfect. I’ve also made it in loaf pans, though, and it was lovely.

The cookbooks has recipes using different flours, other seasonings, etc. LOTS of variations!


 
Suzanne T. November 29, 2019
Love this bread! Love putting garlic and herbs in it.
Has anyone tried a sweeter kind by adding cinnamon chips with cinnamon and more sugar? Would this bread work with that direction?
 
freshbread November 29, 2019
Yes, it will! In fact, Alexandra's book, where this base recipe appears, offers versions that include cinnamon swirl as well as a cinnamon-sugar monkey bread. Worth picking up at a bookstore or checking out from your library — it's a fantastic way to explore all that this one recipe can do!
 
Jane October 20, 2019
I left a review last November saying that my bread came out too salty. After learning that Morton salt is VERY salty I made it today with 1/2 the listed and it came out perfect.
The crust is very brown and I was worried, but inside is soft and pillowy. It is wonderful.
 
freshbread October 21, 2019
That's such good news, Jane! This recipe sure can bring a lot of joy; so glad you made a batch you loved.
 
Picholine October 23, 2019
I remember discussing before that it says kosher salt. That will not make it too salty. Most recipes especially baking are listed as kosher salt.
I love this bread recipe and the bread .I bought the book and have made most breads in the book . All delicious!
 
Jane October 23, 2019
I thought all kosher salt is the same too. But when I asked about this last year several readers said Morton is salter. I can only buy Morton’s here in Florida so I did a google search. I learned that it is salter. Who knew! Now I always use a bit less than a recipe calls for.
 
Josho November 6, 2019
The problem is that any given volume measurement of different brands of Kosher salt will have very different levels of saltiness. Because of the shape of the granules, Morton kosher salt (which is actually flaky) is much, much saltier than a similar volume measurement of Diamond Crystal kosher salt. So if you're measuring by spoonfuls, just recognize that a tablespoon of Morton kosher salt will make your bread (or whatever) much saltier than a tablespoon of Diamond Crystal.

The only way to get similar quantities of saltiness from different brands and types of salt is by WEIGHT (and most kitchen scales aren't sensitive enough to handle such small quantities). A given *weight* of salt will always provide the same level of saltiness no matter what the shape of the granules are or how the volume measurements conflict.
 
Picholine November 7, 2019
Interesting information, I guess one should pick the brand of kosher salt and adjust from there . I used kosher salt from the beginning following the recipe with no issues! Not rocket science!
 
bamcnamara October 11, 2019
I tried this today. My bread seems to be dense....it’s cool here in the northeast. My heat is not on. Maybe my first rise wasn’t enough? Second was definitely to the top of the bowls. I just got the book today. I’d like to try again for an office party next week 😊
 
idoc August 7, 2019
I have made other no knead bread recipes, but found this recipe to be the simplest one to use - the bread is easily prepared, with minimal hands on manipulation. I made the bread similar to that presented in the video, that is, one loaf of bread in an uncovered Dutch oven pot. I used softened butter to grease the pot and found that the finished loaf released readily without a problem. However, the bottom of the finished loaf gives off an oily residue on one's hands and on the kitchen counter; this is apparently from the butter that was used to grease the pot. Has anyone else experienced this same problem and what is a good solution to this problem.
 
Austincook August 8, 2019
My niece and I licked our fingers :-) But if it bothers you, perhaps you could just let it rest briefly on a paper towel.
 
Rita C. April 23, 2019
I made this bread and it was delicious! (I am a novice bread baker.) I also made it in the coquette as shown in the picture. I did not preheat it, and I did cover it, but it took a lot longer to bake to get any kind of color on the top...yet it was not overbaked. I will try it in a Pyrex bowl the next time and see how it turns out. However, I actually bought the coquette specifically for making bread. Does it always need to be preheated?
 
Rita C. April 23, 2019
Oops...I spelled cocotte incorrectly.
 
freshbread April 24, 2019
Do try the Pyrex bowl approach! The video is lovely, but seems to have introduced some confusion, as it could suggest that baking in a Dutch oven or cocotte is necessary. In fact, as written, the recipe specifies using a small (1-quart) mixing bowl, which does *not* need to be preheated. That's how I've made this recipe 99% of the time, and it comes out flawlessly -- with the nicely browned top you're seeking!
 
Carol C. October 16, 2020
Preheat your cocotte in a 500 degree oven for an hour
 
samanthaalison April 23, 2019
I make this all the time now. I can throw it together when I get home for work and have it ready before dinner. So easy and quite good!
 
Arrxx April 15, 2019
In the recipe it says "do not cover the bowl" (or Dutch oven?). But in the video it looks like it's covered. Do you bake covered or uncovered?
 
freshbread April 15, 2019
You can bake in a preheated Dutch oven, covered, to try and approximate the crusty texture of a hearth bread. But you can also bake it in a small Pyrex mixing bowl — in fact, that's how the recipe directs, and how I've made it most of the time, with excellent results!
 
Arrxx April 15, 2019
Thanks! Might try it both ways. What size is small Pyrex? I wonder if a souffle dish would work too. Straight sides.
 
Lisa B. April 15, 2019
I cook it in a cast iron pan, uncovered. It turns out perfect!
 
freshbread April 15, 2019
How cool! I'll have to try that...
 
freshbread April 15, 2019
My small Pyrex is 1-1/2 quart / 6 cups. I'll bet a soufflé dish would work though!
 
Picholine April 15, 2019
We make this bread now in a USA pan I bought on Amazon ,it’s 1 1/2 lb pan
Because we now like to make once a week and want to use as toast or sandwich. We find that it makes a perfect loaf and pops right out . Follow the same directions.
 
Arrxx April 15, 2019
Is it 8.5 x 4.5-Inch ?
 
Picholine April 15, 2019
10X5X 3
 
Chelsea April 15, 2019
I made this last night! It was wonderful I’ll be making another one tonight, I plan on adding some dried herbs. What do you usually bake this in though? I used a round baking dish and it came out delicious but I find it released ALOT of humidity. Is that normal? I was also baking chicken and veggies at the same time.. I don’t think that mattered or affected the quality just curious.
 
Karla April 7, 2019
I would like to bake this bread in my 2 quart enameled cast iron Dutch oven. I am planning on heating the Dutch oven for thirty minutes prior to placing the dough in it. Should I do the second rise in a bowl with parchment paper and then transfer to the heated Dutch oven to keep it from sticking? If so, would it be a good idea to cover part of the parchment paper with the unsalted butter? I’m a little nervous about it sticking without parchment.
 
Poppygold April 8, 2019
There is absolutely no need to heat the enameled cast iron Dutch oven.

Also zero need for parchment paper.

Just butter the Dutch oven well and it slides out perfectly every time.
 
ellemmbee November 24, 2019
I like using the parchment, esp if I choose to preheat the pan. You can use the parchment as a sling to transfer the dough. Either way works.
 
Theresa H. January 31, 2019
The video made this recipe seem simple. I found it to be way too many steps for this novice baker. I tried this it 2 times and both times had to throw it out!
 
freshbread January 31, 2019
Oh no! I'm so sorry to hear that, Theresa. When I first made this bread, I'd never made bread before - and it has come out nicely every time. It's been a joy to bake, and I'd hope you could share that, too!

Tell us what went wrong, and perhaps we can help?
 
Picholine February 1, 2019
Oh no! Don’t give up...I make once a week and the reason is how easy it is ...so here’s some tips : use instant yeast as directed , follow all measurements exactly, use kosher salt, I check temp of water to 105°
After I mix I cover with Saran Wrap , preheat the oven at 400 for ONE minute and turn it off. Place rising dough bowl in and raise till doubled
Then follow from there directions to raise again and bake..

 
Lindsay S. January 5, 2019
Tonight I made this and replaced some of the flour with 1 cup oat flour and half cup rye flour, and it was so delicious! such perfect flavor and texture. Next time I am going to try a full cup of the rye flour.
 
Austincook January 31, 2019
Lindsay, did you get around to trying the full cup of rye flour? And did you need to make any other changes to accomodate the whole grains? (more liquid, longer proofing time?...) I'm hoping to experiment this weekend!
 
Jennifer M. January 12, 2020
I replace 100 grams of flour with rolled oats, and it’s delicious. I like the texture better and the oats lend a little sweetness.
 
Lindsay S. April 10, 2020
I never make any other changes, just change the flours around, same amounts. This recipe is hard to mess up!
 
Mischelle C. November 20, 2018
Thank you so much for this recipe..turned out great and it's so easy!! Going to try other variations too!!
 
Suzanne T. November 8, 2018
Has any added in garlic and herbs to the dough? If so how did it turn out?
 
Carla November 8, 2018
I’ve added various herbs...Fresh if I have them, dried if I don’t...and granulated garlic or onion....it’s delicious! In the TBC cookbook there is a recipe for Apple, almond and thyme bread, which is amazing and only slightly more work than the basic loaves.
 
Carla November 8, 2018
Sorry...forgot about the roasted Garlic bread with herbs...rosemary and thyme..on page 49 of the TBC book... very good, a bit milder with roasted garlic vs the dry.
You really can’t go wrong regardless what you do! It’s ALL good!
 
Susanna November 8, 2018
Oh yes. I’ve tried a bunch of different herb combos, but my favorite is to make a mashup of the stuffing bread recipe on food52 (posie harwood, I think), and combine those herbs with this recipe. Works great and especially appropriate this time of year!
 
Libby January 28, 2019
What is the TBC book?
 
Poppy T. June 6, 2019
How much garlic and other herbs did you add?
 
Carla June 6, 2019
I use garlic powder a little more than 1/2 teaspoon..and a couple of big pinches of dry herbs...we like either rosemary or basil and oregano. In the summer when I have fresh herbs, I use that and at least double more than dry. I don’t really measure..but, I don’t go crazy either. I’m not sure it’s possible to mess this bread up.
 
Cynthia July 8, 2019
Bread Toast Crumb is Alexandra Stafford’s book, and it’s worth every penny. Once you’ve made the master recipe, her peasant bread, you have an endless amount of options. I’ve made the Peasant Bread, obviously, Anadama Bread, Oatmeal-Maple Bread, Gluten-Free Peasant Bread, Hamburger Buns, Buttermilk Pull-Apart Rolls, Focaccia, Soft Sandwich Bread, Peasant Pizza (three times), and the Dark Chocolate Bread. I even made Thyme Rolls, one of her online recipes. All were a great success, and easier than using a mix. I recommend the book highly!
 
Jane October 31, 2018
Mine never really browned. The texture was good, but WAY too salty.
I’ll try again, but only once,
I make 24 hr no knead bread successfully, so I was surprised that this recipe was less than perfect.





 
Picholine October 31, 2018
Did you use Kosher salt?
 
freshbread October 31, 2018
Hi Jane! Sorry to hear you had trouble with this one; it's been a super reliable recipe for many of us - and super satisfying, as well!

Like Picholine, I wonder about the salt you used. In her book, Alexandra encourages using Diamond Crystal kosher salt. Diamond Crystal is made in a way that creates pyramid-shaped grains, which means fewer fit into a teaspoon than the kosher salt crystals from Morton, which are pressed into flat shapes. And both of these are larger than fine-grained salt -- the standard table salt size. If you used fine-grained salt, or a brand of kosher salt other than Diamond Crystal, then that would definitely explain the saltiness.
 
Jane November 1, 2018
Yes I used kosher salt, Morton. This has to be the first time a brand of salt has been suggested. That’s just silly.
 
Jane November 1, 2018
I just googled kosher salt. I guess it’s not silly. Morton is twice as salty. I guess I learn something new every day.
 
Picholine November 1, 2018
Jane , I make this bread once a week and follow the directions carefully. Never had it too salty or not brown. Comes out perfectly every time. Hope you will try it again because it’s a great recipe!
 
barbra R. January 6, 2019
not enough cookbooks/recipe authors specify which salt they use. It makes a huge difference, and cooking with the right salt makes such a wonderful difference in the results. Happy seasoning!
 
Rosalind P. September 24, 2018
i try to refrigerate all my "artisan" breads before proofing and even afterwards (that is, twice). It takes longer but then again breaks the process down into managable time.
 
Elizabeth B. September 23, 2018
Has anyone ever put this dough in the refrigerator overnight after or before the first proofing?
 
Carla September 23, 2018
Yes...and it was still perfect...actually tastier due to the longer fermentation. I mixed, refrigerated, divided, let proof and baked. I don’t think you can do anything to mess up this bread. Easy process, delicious result every time.
 
Elizabeth B. September 24, 2018
I wound up proofing on the counter for 2 hours and then transferring to baking dish and refrigerating over night. I then popped it into the oven in the morning and it came out great. I used 2 cups white flour and 2 cups of whole wheat. It seems to make a denser bread but delicious.
 
Jill P. August 15, 2018
Is instant yeast the SAF yeast or red star quick rise instant yeast? Can it proof longer than the time suggested or will it be ruined?
 
Arrxx June 28, 2018
Could you half this recipe?
 
freshbread June 28, 2018
Yes! Though, as Alexandra notes in her book, when halving the recipe you should use slightly less than half the yeast — 1 teaspoon, rather than 1 1/8, which would be exactly half.
 
Arrxx June 28, 2018
Thanks for the response!
 
Carla June 28, 2018
Grams makes it so easy to divide...and one little bowl bakes so nice in a counter top oven. It’s just two of us and I always make just one loaf...it’s perfect!
 
IM June 22, 2018
Can you mix and cook in the same glass bowl?
 
Picholine June 22, 2018
Doesn’t sound like a good idea...the second rising is in a buttered vessel like a loaf pan or the pyrexbowls
I make this bread at least one x week .
 
Carla June 22, 2018
Nope, it will stick like toxic waste! You have to bake it in a buttered pan, bowl etc. don’t skip on the butter either! I have used lard...and that works too. I know...lard...
But you can’t make Cuban bread without it!
 
Deleted A. December 25, 2018
Oh yeah. NEVER forget to butter your pan or bowl. I forgot to butter my Pyrex loaf pan and totally destroyed a loaf trying to get it out of the pan. So I gave it to a friend and baked myself another one. LOLOL
 
Susanna May 22, 2018
The last time made this, I did a whole-wheat loaf and topped it with everything-bagel seasoning...it was great!
 
Austincook May 22, 2018
Wow! Susanna, I'd love to see your changes to the recipe! My family and I really like this bread, especially because it's so easy to make with kids. But for health reasons I'm trying hard to limit my family to 100% whole wheat. Even if you got a great bread with some white flour in it, I'd love to see the recipe! Thanks
 
vl N. December 5, 2018
I originally made the recipe exactly as instructed and it was delicious! I’m getting ready to make the same recipe but substituting the all purpose flour with 100% whole wheat flour, Susanna did you have to make any other changes to the original recipe?
 
Susanna December 5, 2018
I haven’t made it with wheat flour in a while, but I never used all whole wheat. More like half whole-wheat flour maximum.
 
Jean May 22, 2018
Would really appreciate knowing how much sodium is in this recipe... asking because I saw a recipe of peasant bread with over 2,000 mg of sodium... per serving... Thank you so much.
 
Susanna May 22, 2018
Well let’s see...kosher salt has 1800 mg of sodium per teaspoon and there are two tsp in this recipe, which means that two loaves contain approximately 3600 mg total. Of course you can use less salt if you want, but it will affect the taste—the loaves may taste bland or flat.
 
Picholine May 21, 2018
Is there any problem with covering the the loaf while rising?
I cover it for a portion of rising near stove and it seems to rise faster . Then uncover before it crowns the top of the pan. I have the cookbook and I would recommend as I have made many of the recipes and they are all terrific!
 
yvette May 1, 2018
We LOVED this bread! I've made it twice in the last week. I put a handful sunflower seeds and pepitas on top - it was awesome. It's an amazing "base" bread for so many things. I'm going to try mixing cheese in there next time... YUM. THANK YOU!!!
 
claireinaustin April 8, 2018
I am confused about this because the video shows a different process than what is described in the recipe. In the video the dough is not divided into 2 parts, and is instead placed all into one pot with a lid, rather than a bowl. Please advise. Thank you .
 
Poppygold April 8, 2018
It can be made in 2 loaves or in a staub cast iron dutch oven...found here:
https://food52.com/shop/products/1784-staub-round-cocotte
Or any appropriate sized loaf pan that is ovenproof.
 
claireinaustin April 8, 2018
one pot with the lid on? or off? video shows on, but directions specifically say bake without a lid.
 
Poppygold April 8, 2018
Off and do not skimp on the butter when greasing the pan!
 
Dawn S. July 13, 2018
I'd reeeaaally want to make this and I have a Dutch oven but not pyrex bowls and I'm still SOOO scared of yeast so I have more questions! If using the dutch oven, should I not separate and instead put the entirety into the one dutch oven? If so, should I lengthen the cooking time?? If so, what am I looking for to know it's finished?? A brown crust? Should I poke it with a skewer? Thank you thank you for any/all answers!
 
Debbie August 23, 2018
Try this YouTube channel out! All your worries about yeast will fade away. He has a lot of variations of techniques and uses different kinds of containers. My favorite is the Poor Man’s Dutch Oven. https://www.youtube.com/user/artisanbreadwithstev
 
Robin J. March 29, 2020
I think in the video when the lid is placed on the dutch oven it's prior to the second rise. I believe using the lid at this stage is replacing covering the loaf with a towel or plastic wrap. When I've baked loaves in a dutch oven, I've baked them covered for half the time (for good rise), then uncovered for the second half of bake time, for them to brown properly.
 
Anne G. April 7, 2018
I have made this bread several times using different types of flour and has turned out perfect every time. I don't believe this recipe can fail.
 
mdmize March 29, 2018
I'd like to make hamburger buns, this recipe work? straight forward, just as is?
 
freshbread March 29, 2018
Actually, Alexandra has a recipe for a hamburger bun version in her book! (Bread Toast Crumbs) Since it's not included online, I won't post it here—but be sure to pick it up at your local bookstore or library: the book offers all sorts of tips, in addition to lots and lots of recipes, that are super useful.
 
Picholine March 30, 2018
The book Bread Toast Crumbs is worth every penny you pay for it !
 
Urszula March 27, 2018
I discovered Alexandra's peasant bread recipe a year ago. Since then, I make two loaves of this delicious and simple bread EVERY week. Sometimes twice.
 
Susanna March 18, 2018
I posted about this bread around the holidays because my dough wouldn't rise and I was despairing. I finally did get some SAF yeast (had to order online) and since then I have made it several times, with variations, and it comes out great. However, today I made a loaf and halved the recipe (as a single person I don’t always need/want two loaves), and although the dough did rise some, it wasn’t as much as I wanted or expected. If one halves this recipe, should the quantity of yeast stay the same as in the original recipe? Just wondering if that’s might have been the problem. Thanks for any insights...(FYI I used 1 1/4 tsp yeast).
 
jy2nd March 18, 2018
I always halve the recipe as it’s just me eating it. I use a generous 1/2 of the yeast specified and it has always gone well. Was your kitchen maybe cooler than usual?
 
freshbread March 18, 2018
Hi Susanna - So good to hear that you've had success since the holidays!

As it happens, I always halve the recipe. And, like you, initially I figured that 1-1/8 tsp would be the way to go. But in Alexandra's book, she addresses this question -- and says that a half recipe (that is, one loaf) requires just 1 tsp. That's what I've done every time since perhaps my first loaf, and I haven't had a fail yet. (I should add, though, that Alexandra offers various ways of tweaking the recipe, including using less yeast for longer rises -- if, say, you're seeking a sour flavor -- and she says this works. So, even if you were to use too little yeast, it should just need extra time.)

I wonder if some of your rise challenges come from altitude, or yeast that has spent time exposed to air?
 
Poppygold March 18, 2018
It does halves well but I always make the full recipe as it freezes well too -- that is, if it lasts that long with friends and family eating it all the time!
 
Picholine February 26, 2018
There is a recipe for Oatmeal-Maple Bread in the book. Not sure it is ok to post it though .
 
Cindy B. February 23, 2018
Have made this bread many times, and it always comes out perfect! Was wanting to try adding oatmeal, but not sure how much or what other changes in the recipe I would have to make in order to add the oatmeal. Anyone ever try adding oatmeal to this recipe?
 
Picholine February 23, 2018
I have the book and I will,check and come back if recipe,with oatmeal is in there
 
JaneMiami February 28, 2018
I have added Chia seeds, oatmeal, sunflower seeds.. any crunchy items really. Just weigh flour plus seeds/oatmeal so that it equals 18 ounces.
 
JaneMiami February 28, 2018
Flours= 16 oz(6oz whole wheat 10oz white) + 2 oz crunchy items.
 
CA February 22, 2018
I just made this bread using my Staub cocotte. It turned out perfectly delicious. Any tips on how to store the remains so the crust stays crisp? Thanks for a great recipe and all the helpful comments!
 
Poppygold February 22, 2018
Well, paper wrap works well...but usually this bread not around for long ;)
 
CA February 22, 2018
Thanks for the tip, Poppygold. My husband and I finished off half the loaf at dinner! Yikes!
 
Victoria H. February 19, 2018
I've made this bread a few times and it always pleases. My favourite part is the forks! With a bit of practice I've found the using two forks is the easiest way to handle the high hydration doughs I mostly use for my breads. Feels weird at first, but once you get the hang of it, it's a game changer. Take a look at a video of the forks in action: https://youtu.be/OvRAT-9zs1Q?t=31
 
jy2nd February 17, 2018
Decided to make a bread towith my batch of chili. Added a scant 1/4 C cornmeal, replaced all of the cold water with beer (a plain lager), added about 3oz shredded cheddar, I had to add a little water to get. the right consistency. It came out well. This is a very versatile recipe.
 
Picholine January 15, 2018
Where can I find the video that shows this bread baked in a Staub pan?
Thanks
 
Poppygold January 15, 2018
https://food52.com/shop/products/1784-staub-round-cocotte?utm_term=11335078&utm_source=Sailthru&utm_medium=email&utm_campaign=20171127_bfcm_mondaypm_buyer
 
olivia.k January 2, 2018
I’ve ordered some sprouted grain flour for the next bake. Will I need to do anything differently or can I treat it just like the bread flour. I might do 50/50 at first.
(Oh yeah. I used bread flour instead of all-purpose.)
 
freshbread January 2, 2018
It's definitely worth tracking down Alexandra's book at your library or local bookstore. I was happy to find it at my library, and then to find that her explanation of the process -- complete with FAQs, troubleshooting, and fail-safe formulas for making the sort of tweaks you describe -- illuminates the big picture of this recipe's flexibility.

Your 50-50 bread-whole wheat plan should work! But Alexandra's detailed description of how to make all sorts of tweaks with confidence will ensure that you make every loaf well.
 
olivia.k January 2, 2018
I made my first loaves last week after ordering some 1-qt bowls. This was my first bread baked from scratch and they came out perfect! Next, I added bran: took a cue from the quinoa loaf variation and dumped in a half cup of wheat bran and just a tiny bit more water.
Still delicious!
 
Anne S. January 1, 2018
I had seen this recipe a while back, but hadn't tried it until I hurt my hand and couldn't knead anything of my usual selections. So...what can I say? AMAZING! I use it all the time now and am very grateful!
 
Rosalind P. December 30, 2017
This is my third comment, but I hope this one is useful: because my schedule was getting outof hand, and the timing of the bread wasn't going to work, I decided to refrigerate the dough after the first rise and the separation. I've done this with many other breads and have always found that the slow, cold rise makes them even more delicious. Just remove the bowl(s) when you start to preheat the oven, and bake as directed. You can even leave one loaf for later baking. Makes this recipe even more convenient!
 
Renée R. December 30, 2017
Nothing earth shattering to add here. Simply want to say I've made this numerous times since last April and it always turns out perfectly. I make it exactly as written, except I don't use forks to separate it. I use a silicone dough scraper and plop it in the bowls. I purchased one quart clear Pyrex bowls for this recipe and found the size to be very handy for a multitude of uses. I bake all my bread and this recipe is in regular rotation. Love it!
 
Julie W. December 29, 2017
Just made this bread for the first time and wow! I've never baked bread from scratch, followed the instructions, and got two delicious loaves of bread. Thank you for sharing your recipe!
 
Julie W. December 29, 2017
Just made this bread for the first time and wow! I've never baked bread from scratch, followed the instructions, and got two delicious loaves of bread. Thank you for sharing your recipe!
 
Suzanne T. December 29, 2017
Love this bread!!! Makes really good grilled cheese the next day!
Has anyone tried making it with wheat flour?
 
Picholine December 28, 2017
Saw this come in to my email as I’m on this thread as I’ve posted several times before! Made the bread so many times and just so happens I made tonight . Here’s what I do with the bread dough : I rise the second time in a two quart Pyrex bowl a bit longer than it says and wow! I get a perfect bread! We had it tonight and that’s what I do every time I make it !
 
willa December 28, 2017
My breads are in the oven! The last time I attempted bread from scratch was around 10 years ago. It was pretty awful. I'm so excited for the results from this recipe though! The hardest and most fun part was trying to split the loaves evenly. One loaf is a hilarious monstrosity. I'm baking them in circular 4-cup Pyrex food storage containers, and they still rose beautifully. I've been reading all the comments and I really appreciate all troubleshooting responses from Alexandra and the fans of this bread. Thank you for caring about our breads! <3
 
Poppygold December 27, 2017
I have now made this bread at least 10 times -- it came in very handy for holiday gifting. I have added saffron, nuts, olives [heavily blotted], sesame seeds, and more. It is very forgiving when made in a Staub cocotte 4 quart. After the first rise, just tilt the bowl and edge it out using a bigger serving fork. I do not use instant yeast [just do not have it around] but do follow her proofing directions and it is perfect every time but be sure to butter pan liberally as this cannot be emphasized enough.
 
Pamela J. January 14, 2018
Hi, Poppygold. Did you bake as one loaf? I find the video not terribly helpful in terms of matching it to these written directions. Did you have to allow more time for rising? More time for baking? Thanks in advance for any advice!
 
Poppygold January 14, 2018
Hi Pamela,
I bake as one loaf with no added time on rising -- though note that it will not get to top of 4 quart Staub, I just let it double and then just bake until golden.
Good Baking!

 
Rosalind P. December 27, 2017
Meant to add this: I swapped out one-quarter of the white flour for whole wheat, and using a King Arthur Flour trick, used about 2 tablespoons of orange juice (reducing the water by 2 tablespoons). They recommend it when using whole wheat flour because it takes away some of the natural bitterness of whole wheat. Not absolutely necessary but makes for an even better bread.
 
Rosalind P. December 27, 2017
This is a little complicated but it will help you handle the very soft, runny, sticky dough (more batter than dough, really). I conquered my fear of this kind of dough from the techniques in Artisan Bread in Five Minutes a Day, What I did was divide the dough immediately after mixing, into two bowls just for the first rise. It is far easier to divide it in this stage! Use a scale if you're uncertain about getting it into equal parts. Then after each half rose in its own bowl, I just folded it inward with a fork, as in the instructions, and then poured/scraped it into its final baking bowl, using a rubber spatula.. More bowls, yes, but it eliminates the tricky dividing of a very wet dough, and getting half of it out into the baking bowl.
 
Alex G. December 25, 2017
This bread is so delicious and easy to make! I will be using this recipe often, experimenting with additions ... and sending your cookbook to my brother. Thank you so much for sharing!
 
Susanna December 23, 2017
I am so frustrated! Admittedly I’m not a baker, but I tried to make this today as a trial run for the holidays. I measured everything EXACTLY on a food scale, but the dough didn’t rise more than 10% (I used the oven trick). I really can’t see that I did anything wrong. So was it ineffective yeast? Or should I just give up on ever trying to bake bread?
 
freshbread December 24, 2017
Susanna, I’m so sorry to hear this! But I’m sure you have bread-making days ahead.

What kind of yeast did you use? Alexandra encourages instant yeast, sometimes sold as “rapid rise.” That’s what I’ve used, and never a problem—with a dozen loaves. I have found active dry yeast to be unreliable.
 
Carla December 24, 2017
Susanna, don’t give up! Fresh bread is right, active dry yeast can be hit or miss. I started using SAF red instant yeast years ago and haven’t had a failure. For sweet dough..SAF gold. Also be sure your liquid temp is not too hot..that will kill yeast. My mom’s care giver tried to make this bread and got no rise...she’d used the boiling water and warm Two water..too hot!! Just use water from your tap...and it should be pleasantly warm on your inner wrist..like for a baby bottle! I proof in giant zip lock bags...even a sheet pan fits and the temp is always perfect. Good luck and keep baking!!
 
Susanna December 24, 2017
Thanks to both of you for the advice and encouragement. Re water temperature, I used the boiling/cold water method and it definitely wasn’t too warm, maybe not warm enough? The yeast is Red Star quick rise/instant yeast, in a jar. It’s the only one they had at my Whole Foods.

I’ll definitely try again. I’m just not accustomed to having complete cooking failures!
 
freshbread December 24, 2017
You’re on top of the details, so of course this would irk!

It sounds as if your yeast was newly purchased, so its age probably isn’t the issue. Another tip from Alexandra—which you’ve probably followed—is her clever suggestion to use your oven, turning it on for just a couple of minutes before rising, to create a perfect environment for proofing. I do this every time, and tightly cover my bowls in plastic wrap.

Maybe just give it another try? Or, replace the yeast, just in case it’s a bad batch?
 
Carla December 24, 2017
Susanna, Please do give it another go...I bet next time will be brilliant! You’ll be hooked. To make you feel better....if a baking project is going to go wrong for me...it’s when I’ve promised to do it for someone else and have no time to do it over! Just happened last week! ☹️ Happy Holidays!!
 
Alexandra S. December 25, 2017
Carla and freshbread, thank you so much for all of your troubleshooting and encouraging words to Susanna! Susanna, sorry for the trouble. It does sound as though you are doing everything right. I have used that same jar of red star instant yeast when I am out of SAF, and it works great. Regarding the oven trick, you did just turn it on for a minute and then turn it off, right? It wasn't too hot, was it? You should be able to hold your hands to the oven grates without burning them. One final thought: colder temperatures do make the rise happen more slowly, so if you have the time to let the dough rise longer, maybe that's all it needs — more time. Happy holidays!
 
Susanna December 27, 2017
Thanks, Alexandra, freshbread, and Carla. I’m going to try again today or tomorrow, but I will definitely test the yeast first before adding the flour. Happy early new year!
 
Poppygold December 4, 2017
I have made several times now with multiple variations: saffron and dried orange, olive and rosemary, and want to try roasted red pepper and mexican oregano next...works well in the Staub 4 quart [no lid on] and I adjusted for high altitude -- about 1/8c less flour...
 
Carla December 4, 2017
Must try the saffron...have a stash in the freezer. Your variations sound amazing! Where are you? I’m in Denver and always have to add more liquid when I bake bread. No real issues other than dry and stuff proofs quicker. Now cakes, candy, jam....tricky. Do share tips!!
 
Poppygold December 27, 2017
You can use the Hungarian High Altitude flour as well and my secret weapon in cakes is sour cream!
 
Carla December 4, 2017
Made the basic recipe...bought the book (which I recommend).....really boosts baking confidence! Just made two lovely loaves...50% buttermilk, 25% white whole wheat flour, dry oregano and basil....OMG...delicious. I’m Sorry I took both loaves to my daughter. Have to make more for us. Such a wonderful forgiving recipe! If liquid isn’t not too hot..you really can’t mess it up!
 
Alexandra S. December 25, 2017
So happy to hear this, Carla!
 
Lisa B. December 4, 2017
Just made this and it is excellent. A real treat.
 
Poppygold November 26, 2017
I see someone has posted about the video using a Staub for this bread and I want to get the same information as to what size Staub was used -- I am assuming a 4 quart would be fine with lid off during the last 15 minutes or so to brown it up [?], temperature used and time to bake...thanks so much.
 
Kristen M. November 27, 2017
Hi Poppygold, yes it was the 4-quart size, and according to the team who shot the video, the recipe worked as written in the French oven (other than not dividing the dough in two). If it's not golden enough, just leave it in the oven for a few minutes longer, as mentioned in step 5.
 
Pamela J. January 14, 2018
Do you need more time to allow for rising? More time for baking? I am confused since the recipe as written makes two loaves but the video shows all the dough going into one Staub pot (4 qt).
 
Kathy November 26, 2017
How is it that I do not own a 1 quart bowl???? What will happen if I substitute 1 1/2 quart? Will it bake properly? I like the idea of 2 small loaves.
 
Jane B. November 26, 2017
I use a 1.5 qt bowl every time (actually 2) quite successfully. It takes a little longer for the second rise. It was the only size I had on the pyrex bowls and couldn't find more at the tag sales. I'm just going to make some now!
 
Kathy November 26, 2017
Thank you! I have 2 of the 1 1/2 quart. Go figure! I think I am also going to make some right now!
 
HEATHER B. November 25, 2017
I saw a video of this recipe being baked in the Staub Cocotte--can you advise which size Staub was being used and what the baking time is (as all the dough is cooked at once). thanks
 
Kristen M. November 27, 2017
Hi Heather, it was the 4-quart Staub cocotte, and according to the team who shot the video, the recipe worked as written (other than not dividing the dough in two). If it's not golden enough, just leave it in the oven for a few minutes longer, as mentioned in step 5.
 
Tamara November 13, 2017
Just out of the oven. So easy - I halved it and it is a perfect size for our house. Looking forward to playing with additions.
 
Margaret November 3, 2017
I should add: the color of the bread is not as golden as in the photo, and the crumb in the photo looked a little drier.
 
Margaret November 3, 2017
HELP! I've made this great bread three times, and each time it came out undercooked, i,e,, too moist in the middle. Wonderful aroma, taste, and crust, but too wet. I am not at all a baker. Can anyone tell me how to fix this problem? (I followed the recipe closely.)
 
HopeD November 3, 2017
You might try just baking it for longer. Mine has been taking 10 extra minutes to finish baking.
 
Alexandra S. December 25, 2017
Margaret, I think baking it longer will do the trick. HopeD is right — try for 10 or 15 minutes longer. It's forgiving!
 
muggs45 October 18, 2017
Has anyone tried this recipe in a SLOW COOKER.....or ...RICE COOKER?
..........no oven....... want to try!
 
Picholine October 16, 2017
Have been baking this bread for a while ,love it and I earlier commented on a variation I used with Molasses,cinnamon and nuts. I can no longer find that variation. Where are the articles on adaptations? Thank you!
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
Hi! I think you're thinking about this one: https://food52.com/blog/19411-once-you-ve-made-genius-peasant-bread-try-these-5-variations
So happy you like this one.
 
Picholine October 17, 2017
Thanks so much! My adaptation made last night: 3 C unbleached C whole wheat, 2T Molasses ,1 T honey(instead of sugar) 1T cinnamon. 1cup chopped pecans , 1/2 C raisins, 2 T flax seed. Toasted this am with cinnamon butter ! Yum! Dumped whole dough bowl into a long tin bread pan!
 
Alexandra S. October 17, 2017
YUM!! That sounds amazing. Perfect for this time of year, perfect toast. I feel like it would be good on a cheese plate, too. Love the long bread tin!
 
Picholine October 17, 2017
Great idea re cheese plate ! I also want to put some pepitas and sunflower seeds in the mix next time! Thank you for this terrific bread recipe I have been using for a while!
 
Alexandra S. October 17, 2017
Oh yes: pepitas + sunflower seeds are so good. I'm so, so happy you like the bread!
 
jy2nd October 15, 2017
I used bread flour, which I thought gave it a little stronger structure.
 
betsy October 15, 2017
this looks wonderful, and i can't wait to try! can i make it with bread flour, which i have at home? or does it only work with regular flour?
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
Yes! Absolutely, bread flour is fine. I suggest all-purpose mostly because that's what people have on hand.
 
Tony M. October 13, 2017
I am not a good baker and have never made a successful yeast bread, so I was skeptical about this recipe. I just made it and have literally eaten half of one loaf by myself. It is FANTASTIC and ridiculously easy to make. Thank you, thank you, thank you Alexandra! I'm hoping to experiment with the dough and make small rolls, but will definitely add this to my list of regular recipes.
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
I'm so happy to hear this, tmac!! And sorry for the delay here ... somehow I don't get email alerts for this thread (just a glitch!), so I'm catching up now.
 
Susan October 11, 2017
In Serbia, and other Balkan countries, they make a simple peasant bread called Pogaca (various spellings). It is a flattened, but not flat like pita, round loaf and my mother made it often. She did knead the bread but rose it only once on the baking sheet. This dough is perfect for Pogaca. Instead of dividing into bowls after the first rise, simply tip out onto a parchment lined or well buttered sheet pan. It will flatten as is rises the second time. My mother always pierced the bread several times with a fork and sprinkled with a little coarse salt before putting in the oven, and I do this too. I bake at the higher temperature for about 25 minutes. I find this Pogaca superior to the one I grew up with. Sorry, Mum.
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
This sounds fantastic, Susan!! I cannot wait to try it. Fun!! So, higher than 425? Like 450 for 25 minutes?
 
Austincook September 19, 2017
Sorry to re-post but I'm looking for a GF bread I can feed a real Celiac sufferer next week. Can this recipe work with GF flour that works "measure for measure" with AP? Thanks
 
Austincook October 11, 2017
Answering my own question - the GF experiment was not a success. The bread tasted fine but didn't rise nearly as much as AP wheat flour, and had a dense, closed crumb. I won't make it again.
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
So bummed to just be seeing this!! I would love you to try the GF peasant bread variation of it: https://feedmephoebe.com/best-gluten-free-bread-recipe/ Also here is a quick 1-minute video that sums up the process: https://vimeo.com/223239748 I am partial to Cup4Cup gluten-free flour, but I have to admit I have not experimented with a ton of brands. Tip for this recipe. Mix the liquids separately from the dry (as instructed) but slowly add the wet to the dry — you may not need all of the wet ingredients. All gf flours absorb liquid differently, and sometimes with this recipe if you add all of the wet to the dry, it will be too soupy. So add some wet, stir, add some more, etc, until the consistency looks like the photo/video in the links I sent. Let me know if you have any other questions!
 
Austincook October 18, 2017
Thanks so much for the reply and links. I will be seeing my celiac-suffering friend next month and will try this then. 1 more question: this friend usually joins my family for Thanksgiving, as does my vegan brother & SIL. I try to make the whole menu (except the Turkey :-)) both vegan and gluten free. Is there an egg substitute that would work in the GF version? Or am I really asking too much (won't be surprised if the answer is yes). Thanks again. This kind of feedback is what makes Food52 so special.
 
Alexandra S. October 20, 2017
You're amazing! How nice to be so accommodating on a holiday not typically friendly for vegans and celiacs. I can't say what to do for sure bc I haven't experimented enough with these sorts of substitutions, but I have heard great things about doing the flax "egg" or chia "egg". Look at the comments on this thread, and I think you will find something: https://glutenfreegirl.com/2011/05/baking-without-eggs/
 
Pisanella September 12, 2017
I really like this recipe but I've been back several times to uncheck the send me emails about new comments ! I have to uncheck the box. Again. And. Again! Just saying!!!
 
HopeD September 12, 2017
Would this work in a single cast-iron Dutch oven, rather than diving into two small bowls?
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
Yes, but you have to be sure to really grease whatever vessel you are using very well. You're talking about a non-preheated Dutch oven, correct?
 
Austincook August 28, 2017
I helped a 7 year old make this bread over the weekend and it was just as easy and delicious as described. 2 loaves disappeared in one (large) family meal! One question, though. Has anyone tried this with gluten-free flour? I usually use the King Arthur mix. Thanks!
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
So happy to hear this Austincook! So sorry again for the delay :(
 
Austincook December 24, 2017
I thought you'd appreciate knowing that the 7 year old (now 8 year old) is proudly making this bread by herself for her family's Christmas dinner.
 
Alexandra S. December 25, 2017
Nothing could make me happier!! Merry Christmas Austincook!!
 
Jani August 17, 2017
i've made the spread several times and it always comes out great. I have a question of how long do you think it will last on the counter? I made one and I want to give it to my friend but I won't see her till tomorrow do you think it'll last three days and still be good ? thx!
 
Jani August 17, 2017
this bread -not spread! lol
 
cookinginvictoria August 17, 2017
We make this bread a lot, and have found that about 4-5 days is the shelf life on the counter. Is it hot and humid where you are? If so, I would consider freezing it. It freezes very well. :)
 
Jani August 17, 2017
thank you, cookinginvictoria! It is hot and humid, but the kitchen isn't too hot. I will freeze it , thanks. 👍🏼
 
Margaret August 18, 2017
"This spread" looks like a voice-typing error, from "this bread."
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
Thanks for chiming in CookingVictoria! I store bread in my bread box for 3 to 4 days. If I think it's going to be any longer, I'll freeze it. Also, a brief heating at 350 revives the bread very well.
 
jy2nd August 13, 2017
I had the same problem in the beginning, but found that if I sprayed the bowl with pan spray - over the butter - the bread came out fine. And I still got the buttery crust.
 
SusanK August 12, 2017
I have purchased bread toast crumbs and have made the bread 4 or 5 times. The first time it came out great but ever since it is sticking badly to one or both bowls. I use room temperature unsalted butter. Lots of it. I run a knife around the sides but it is sticking to the bottom of the bowl. Any advice. Sometimes with cakes you leave them in the pans awhile. I am considering trying that. Fwiw, I am making the rosemary version with the semolina flour but I also had sticking with the olive bread.
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
SusanK — so sorry for the delay here! Just seeing this. Sorry to hear about the sticking, too. I'm not sure how to advise, because room temp butter does the trick. I do find that this time of year, when the butter isn't as soft at room temperature, it takes more. Or it needs to be softened in the microwave or oven, to really make sure it gets to that super soft stage. I also find that if the bowls are at all wet, it makes spreading a nightmare. Hope you've been able to find a solution!
 
MargieShanghai July 20, 2017
Hi! I'm an Aussie living in Shanghai and bread here is super expensive and not that wonderful. I found this awesome recipe last week and decided to give it a go. I made one loaf and 12 small rolls in muffin tins and they turned out so well! I'm looking forward to experimenting with herbs and cheese next!
Thanks so much for this easy, delicious recipe!
 
Alexandra S. July 20, 2017
So happy to hear this Margie!
 
Joshua July 14, 2017
Hi! I'm planning to make this for the first time this weekend, and I was curious if you had any tricks for making this bread seeded (as in seeds on the crust, not throughout the dough). Thanks in advance!
 
freshbread July 14, 2017
Doable, if tricky, in terms of presentation. One to two tablespoons would fit well on the top of each loaf.

The tricky thing is that the flattest part of the loaf ends up being the top -- the part that crowns above the bowl. The rounded part, which strikes me as preferable for featuring the seeds, is the part inside the bowl. But I suppose you could try sprinkling the buttered bowl with seeds before adding the dough... perhaps they'd adhere when you later take the loaf out?
 
Carla July 14, 2017
An egg wash works great...just mix an egg with a little water and a pinch of salt...everything will stick to that!! Makes the crust real shinny too!
 
Joshua July 14, 2017
I was thinking about that, but I do have the concern that the seeds won't come with the loaf. Thinking I may pop it out of the oven after it bakes, take it out of the bowl, flip it, hit it with a really thin egg wash and add the seeds, and bake for an extra few minutes to bake them on as well as to crisp up the crust.

Thanks!
 
freshbread July 14, 2017
Makes great sense - let us know how it works out!
 
Joshua July 16, 2017
I ultimately made two batches - the first in a bowl as per the recipe, which I did not seed, because when I took it out of the oven in anticipation of seeding it and putting it back in, it was perfectly golden and I didn't want to cook it any more! The second batch I ended up doing in a loaf pan, so I did the egg white & water wash plus seeds before it went in as you would with any loaf of bread. Both came out delicious though!
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
So happy to hear this, Joshua and so sorry for the delay. I love adding seeds to the dough — I often add 1/4 cup each of sesame, pumpkin, and sunflower — but quinoa (1/2 cup) and flax (1/4 cup) is another favorite. See this Food52 post on variations: https://food52.com/blog/19411-once-you-ve-made-genius-peasant-bread-try-these-5-variations
Also, one photo at the bottom of this post: http://alexandracooks.com/2017/06/12/new-toast-bookplates-toaster-notecards/
Also, if you want seeds on the exterior, I made a seedy sandwich bread by simply brushing the loaves with water and rolling them in a sheet pan covered with seeds: http://alexandracooks.com/2017/02/24/seedy-sandwich-bread-sprouted-wheat/
 
freshbread June 29, 2017
I made (half) the recipe exactly as written and it was a total success! Alexandra's oven proofing trick is super clever, and the wonderfully subtle, comforting touch of sweetness in the loaf is spot on. The loaf looked great, too.

I'm eager to try the anadama variety, and perhaps work into the classic recipe some rye flour I have on-hand—though likely no more than 20% of the total flour. Has anyone tried using a bit of rye?

Another thought: how about rubbing the bowl with salted, rather than unsalted, butter?

This recipe is such a wonderful gift. Thank you, Alexandra!
 
freshbread July 5, 2017
P.S. I made this again today, substituting 25% of the AP flour for whole wheat flour, and adding 2 tablespoons of millet. Still delicious! Maybe even more so. I was pleased to see that neither the millet nor the heavier flour weighed down the dough; the rising time was the same.

And to answer my question from earlier, I rubbed the bowl with salted, rather than unsalted, butter -- and it didn't taste salty. It didn't taste noticeably different at all, though, so it doesn't appear to make a difference which kind of butter you use for the bowl.

Next up: trying out rye flour! And maybe toasting the millet first to make it crunchier.

But again, seriously: what a wonderful recipe...
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
FreshBread— so happy to hear all of this and so sorry for the delay here! Yes to adding rye. I do 1 cup rye, 3 cups all-purpose, and with that variation I add some caraway seeds, too, which I know isn't everyone's favorite, so it certainly can be omitted. Glad to hear you are having success with the variations! I love using salted butter on the exterior (I love salt) but I typically use unsalted bc some people are sensitive.
 
Annada R. June 16, 2017
Hey Alexandra, I made this bread yesterday. Turned out awesome! Thank you!
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
So happy to hear this, Annada!
 
Sharon M. June 14, 2017
Brava!
I just bought Alexandra's cookbook (first ckbk in years, as I have too many!)--it's a beauty and I've post-it'ed several recipes to try, including gluten-free for my sister.
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
Oh, Sharon, this makes me so happy. Thanks so much!
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
Oh, Sharon, this makes me so happy. Thanks so much!
 
Tara June 14, 2017
I never comment, but had to for this: This has become my go-to recipe, with a tweak. My husband and I used to have a splurge lunch at Bouley in NYC whenever we were in town. We loved their bread service, and 2 breads in particular (the Sour Cherry and the Black Current and Anise). I was so sad when they closed, but with this recipe as a base, I've managed to replicate the flavors of my 2 favorite Bouley breads. Now I add 1 tsp of anise seeds to the dough at the beginning, and then add a big handful of dried tart cherries (Montmorency from Trader Joes) to the dough at the stage where you separate it in half and put it in the buttered bowls for the 2nd rise. I like it best toasted (or warm from the oven) with butter and the tiniest bit of sugar sprinkled on top. With tea, it's nirvana. In just a couple of months, I've become famous for this Anise and Tart Cherry bread! People RAVE. I've made it for neighbors who came from Iran, and the Grandmother in their family doesn't eat any American bread because she can't find any she likes, despite trying tons, and she *loved* this bread and begged for the recipe. I've made it for sick friends, for no-reason gifts dropped off to someone's porch, for family, etc, and universally people have acted like it contains some kind of black magic and I must be some kind of Bread Witch :D Of course, I do tell them how easy it is, but no one believes it.
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
Tara, I am so happy to hear all of this!! So sorry for the delay here. I absolutely love the sound of your anise and tart cherry bread and cannot wait to try it! Headed to TJ's in the morning!
 
Sharon M. May 28, 2017
Just made mascarpone (went Food 52 nuts last weekend) and next time will use the whey--thanks for the tip!
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
Nice!
 
Stefanie P. May 28, 2017
Made the loaves with the whey I had left over from making ricotta - lovely flavor and I think it rose a little higher. Also makes terrific dried breadcrumbs. Take the stale bread and dry out in a warm oven and then take it for a spin in the food processor - nothing goes to waste!
 
Alexandra S. October 16, 2017
So happy to hear this, Stefanie. I love the flavor of whey bread, too! Happy you're making crumbs with it, too — such a great feeling not letting anything go to waste.
 
jy2nd May 25, 2017
I should add that I turned the loaves out of their bowls at the end of the 35 min baking time and put them back in for another 10 min. Better, but still not golden. . . .
 
jy2nd May 25, 2017
I keep making this because it's a lovely and quick loaf of bread. I solved my sticking problem by adding pan spray on top of the butter. Today I added 2T of a buttermilk sourdough starter - just for tang, and made a sesame-semolina variation. (Think next time I'll up the semolina to 1/3 or 1/2 of the total flour). In both loaves I have a lovely top crust, the bottom is golden, but the sides are nothing like the lovely golden brown crust that the recipe pics show. Any tips?
 
Alexandra S. October 17, 2017
Hi jy2nd! Sorry for the delay here. I'm so interested in your buttermilk sourdough starter...can you elaborate?

Glad you've solved your sticking issues and are getting there with the golden exterior. Questions: does your oven typically run cool? I ask because I was baking phyllo hors d'oeuvre at a friend's house this weekend, and it took about 2x as long to get the golden hue I was used to getting in my oven. My suggestion is to experiment with different shelves in your oven. Some people get better results (more even browning) when they bake on the lowest rack, some get better results with the higher rack. Also, are you using clear pyrex (or other) bowls? I find the clear to be really nice because I can tell when the loaf is golden all around, at which point I take it out.
 
jy2nd October 17, 2017
I use the French Buttermilk Starter from Beth Hensperger’s The Bread Lover’s Bred Machine cookbook. It always works, only takes a couple of days to mature (especially if your buttermilk is a bit “old”) and is easy to keep going. Now that the weather is cooling off it’s time to bake bread again and time to make up a new batch. I often add a little to breads that aren’t meant to be “sourdough” - it adds a little tang and keeping tang. My oven is convection and typically runs a bit hot. I baked on a low rack, just above a pizza stone. I wasn’t sure about putting the pyrex bowl on the stone, but, now that I think about it, that may work. The bowls are clear.
 
jy2nd October 17, 2017
Oops, meant Bread Machine cookbook, and that the starter adds keeping time.
 
Alexandra S. October 17, 2017
Awesome, thanks so much for sharing! I'm excited to try the buttermilk starter.
I don't know how to advise re placing bowls on stone or not — I would hate them to shatter on you, though I've never had a bad experience. Does your oven have to be on convection or can you switch it to standard bake? Part of me wonders if you removed your pizza stone, if you might get better air circulation around the bowls?
 
aaCooks May 21, 2017
I made the dough and put the whole portion into a loaf pan so had a great loaf of bread for kids lunches!!
 
Alexandra S. May 22, 2017
So happy to hear this, aaCooks!
 
Sharon M. May 21, 2017
bought 1 qt bowls from Amazon Prime--nice gifts + recipes for my daughters-in-law and brides-to-be...
 
Alexandra S. May 22, 2017
So great! I love doing this, too, Sharon.
 
Sharon M. May 21, 2017
Just made two loaves--I'm not only converted, but will be a preacher with The Recipe...my husband even had a slice of the crust with his swordfish salad for lunch--irresistible right out of the oven (with a 15 min rest, of course)...Thanks!
 
Alexandra S. May 22, 2017
Yes! So happy to hear this!! (Waiting the 15 minutes is the hardest part :))
 
Virginia May 20, 2017
What a great recipe! I followed the instructions as written using active yeast (not instant), except for using olive oil instead of butter. My loaves stuck to the bottom of the bowls and I could not get them out cleanly, but the bread was delicious! My cooking time also took longer - about 30 min after the temp reduction. I left one loaf plain and put rosemary and smoked sea salt on top of the other. Thinking this could be a great focaccia base as well.
 
Alexandra S. May 22, 2017
Hi Virginia,
Sorry to hear about the sticking! I've never had success with olive oil with the bowls either unfortunately, but yes, this makes great focaccia! I pour 3 tablespoons olive oil over a 9x13-inch rimmed sheet pan, dump the entire amount of dough over top, let it sit for 20 minutes, then stretch it out. Season with salt (smoked sea salt sounds amazing!), rosemary, or however you wish.
 
Mary-Gay May 17, 2017
After realizing that my freezer's Sister Schubert Parker House roll inventory was down to nil, I opted to try your recipe when my math determined that treking to the grocery during rush hour would actually take longer to culminate in a baked bread product than making my own. The five of my kids who showed up for dinner on time pulled a full-on piranha attack, and the two loaves were gone before the butter made it on the table. Thanks for another great addition to my keeper file!
 
Alexandra S. May 22, 2017
Love the image of the piranha attach on the bread Mary-Gay!! So fun. Thanks for writing in.
 
StevenJC123 May 8, 2017
Hi Alexandra, thanks for sharing this recipe with the community. I've never baked bread before but looking forward to giving this a go this weekend! Is it possible to substitute the butter for a vegan-friendly ingredient?
 
Alexandra S. May 10, 2017
Yes! Gena Hamshaw, who is an amazing vegan blogger and contributor here and author/nutritionist (she's so many things!), uses softened vegan buttery sticks: http://www.thefullhelping.com/six-tasty-vegan-toast-ideas/
 
FS May 4, 2017
How about using a 2 quart Pyrex pan instead of two? I just happen to have the one pan ...
 
Alexandra S. May 6, 2017
Yes! Just bake it for 10 to 15 minutes longer. You can also, after 30 minutes of baking or so, turn it out of its bowl, and let it bake directly on the rack or on a sheet pan for 10 to 15 minutes.
 
FS May 6, 2017
Thanks for the tip! I tried it and it came out great! This bread will become a regular guest in my oven, I think! :)
 
Alexandra S. May 6, 2017
woohoo!
 
Jani H. May 3, 2017
I made this yesterday and it was so good, both loaves are gone, and we're only 2 people. I have never made bread before though, and I have a silly question...i used the quick rise yeast in the packet...and just add it to the dry ingredients, right? You don't mix water or anything to it first, right? Thanks! I passed it on to 3 friends already❣️
 
Alexandra S. May 6, 2017
Yes, exactly! With the quick-rise yeast, you just stir it right into the flour. Yay! So happy to hear this.
 
Jani H. May 7, 2017
Thank you! I've made it twice already, and everyone LOVES it. 👍🏼
 
Alexandra S. May 7, 2017
Woohoo!
 
Yaco R. May 2, 2017
Absolutely in love with this recipe. I followed the recipe with whole wheat instead and mistakenly lowered the temp to 350 as I put in the bread. The result was good though, though the inside was a bit undercooked. I fried each slice on a bit of olive oil and it was glorious on its own or with cream cheese and marmalade.

I'm now experimenting with variations, and got a ton of flour to keep on baking.

It's exciting to see how bread can vary with a few tweaks, and how quick and adaptable the recipe is. The 1st experiment, today, is 50% whole wheat, 50% AP white, extra sea salt, sugar (I ran out of honey), some butter, an egg, and oats that I'd left soaking in milk overnight. It has a really tender inside and a pleasantly crunchy, crumbly crust.

Thank you Alexandra + Foood52 for sharing.
 
Alexandra S. May 6, 2017
Yaco Roca, I'm so happy to hear you're liking the recipe and are having success/fun with variations. Your combination of soaked oats, butter, egg, and sugar sounds so good! Thanks for sharing.
 
Margaret May 1, 2017
This sounds like a wonderful recipe. I'm not a baker and am searching for an uncomplicated bread recipe I can make often. I'.m just wondering how long the bread would last. Should I perhaps cut it in half and make just one loaf?? Thanks for any suggestions.
 
Alexandra S. May 1, 2017
You can definitely halve the recipe, but know that it freezes beautifully, too, either in sliced form or whole or in chunks. Happy baking!
 
jy2nd May 1, 2017
Well I made the pepper, jack and scallion bread from Alexandra's book -- sort of. I didn't have a pepper in the house and so used pepper jack cheese. As a single household I scaled the recipe in half. The first loaf had the amount of cheese specified as well as the amount of yeast. It barely rose, although the crust was lovely. So I made another loaf, this time scaling back the chess to 1/3 the amount specified for a full batch, rather than 1/2, and by increasing the yeast by 1/4t to 1.5t. This time it worked beautifully -- delicious bread with a lovely crust. I followed Alexandra's suggestion and put the loaf back in the oven for 10 min after taking it out of the bow. That gave me a really crackling crust. I also changed the recipe a bit by using bread flour rather than AP. And my earlier sticking problem was solved by putting some pan spray on top of the butter. The loaf popped right out and I still got a crust with a buttery flavor. I'll be trying more variations.
 
Alexandra S. May 1, 2017
Glad you've been able to make adjustments to make this one work! I love the crust and color of the breads with cheese — they're so beautifully golden. Glad the spray helped with the release! Thanks for writing in.
 
Lindsay S. May 1, 2017
I loved the texture and how easy and fast this recipe is! Can you tell me why mine has a strong yeast smell / taste? Almost soapy. I'm new to bread making and this keeps happening. Is it because I had to wait a couple hours and put it in fridge after it had already risen a bit? Im determined to figure this out. Thanks for sharing such a perfect recipe, I'll use it often!
 
Alexandra S. May 1, 2017
Hi Lindsay! I'm not sure. Can you tell me a little more about your timeline? How long are you letting it rise before you put it in the fridge? And then how long is it in the fridge before you take it out and bake it? Let me know!
 
Lindsay S. May 2, 2017
Thanks! I had already put it in the warmed oven for maybe 10 -20 minutes and it had started to rise a bit, then I put it in the fridge and boy it did rise a ton, for 4 hours I think?
 
Alexandra S. May 2, 2017
Sure thing! I can't say for sure, but next time I would suggest sticking the bowl in the fridge right away if you plan on refrigerating. Or if it's risen a bit before you stick it in the fridge, deflate it with your forks, cover it, stick it in the fridge. If you give it another go, report back!
 
Carla May 1, 2017
Had to try this..as I love high hydrated dough. The bread was delicious and by scaling the recipe in half, it was perfect for two! Alas, I did not have 1 quart oven proof bowls...so, a quick trip to Goodwill was the answer. I found two little Anchor Hocking clear bowls for only 10 cents each!!! In fact, all clear kitchen items were 10 cents on Sunday!!! I swear, the bargain bowls made the bread taste better!!!! Lovely recipe..and the cinnamon with raisins is equally wonderful. Thanks much.
 
Alexandra S. May 1, 2017
Amazing!! What a find?! I have no doubt those bargain bowls made the bread better :) :) :)
 
Pisanella April 30, 2017
I used wholemeal flour and there was very little rise. I'm used to pouffy dough, and although this seemed light, it didn't rise much at all. I have baked 2 delicious-looking bricks!
 
Alexandra S. April 30, 2017
Bummer! Wholemeal is the same as whole wheat, yes? Whole wheat flour will definitely make for a denser loaf. I recommend starting with half whole wheat flour, and then adjusting proportions from there.
 
Pisanella May 1, 2017
Well, although they LOOK like bricks, they taste absolutely delicious. The crumb is light and the crust is moist and buttery. I sliced the loaf lengthways and stuffed it with mozzarella, tomatoes, olive oil and some little gherkins. Wonderful!
 
Alexandra S. May 1, 2017
Oh yum, so great to hear this!
 
cookinalong April 29, 2017
I haven't made this yet, but I will. It is nearly identical to a recipe in Beard on Bread called Myrtle Allen's Brown bread which I've been making for years and years. It calls for 3 3/4 c. whole wheat flour, molasses instead of sugar, requires no kneading and only needs to rise once. All the other ingredients are the same and it's absolutely fool proof. It was the first loaf of bread I ever made and I still make it a few times a month. Looking forward to trying this variation.
 
Nancy April 30, 2017
Agree. That Myrtle Allen btead recipe is a classic.
 
Alexandra S. April 30, 2017
Sounds delicious! How's it baked? 2 cups water? I'd love to try it!
 
Katie April 29, 2017
can I ask why there is sugar in this recipe? I have never put sugar in any bread before (and here in France there is normally not sugar in bread!)
 
Smaug April 29, 2017
I seldom do either- a lot of bakers feel it feeds the yeast more efficiently than flour; in this sort of quantity it should all be consumed before the bread is done; you shouldn't be able to taste it.
 
Alexandra S. April 30, 2017
You can bake it without the sugar. When I first was making my mother's bread, I always used active-dry yeast, which often calls for a little bit of sugar to help activate the yeast. When I switched to using instant yeast, I kept the sugar out of habit. The sugar might help the rises go a teensy bit faster, but you can definitely leave it out.
 
Greg O. April 29, 2017
Why would one select 400 degrees and preheat for only a minute? It doesn't matter what temperature is selected; what matters is that the oven is on for only a minute, no?
 
Alexandra S. April 29, 2017
It's true—it's just to give people an idea, because over the years people have asked: what temperature? Any temp is fine. And yes, your oven should be about 100 degrees after the minute of preheating.
 
BaliThai April 28, 2017
Has anyone tried the initial rise in the refrigerator? I realize the beauty of this recipe is that you can make the bread in an afternoon - but was curious if anyone tried an overnight rise in the refrigerator and if that improved the taste of the bread? I was thinking about trying that after getting the kids to bed some night!
 
Alexandra S. April 29, 2017
Yes! You can do the first rise in the fridge. I do this a lot when I need to make bread, but don't get around to it till after dinner, and I don't feel like staying up to finish the process. Just follow the recipe exactly as written but place the bowl in the fridge. In the morning or the next day, you'll see that the dough has risen somewhat. You can either let it rise further at room temperature, or you can divide it immediately and place it in the buttered bowls. Keep in mind the second rise will take much, much longer—maybe as long as two hours. Just be patient, and when you see the dough crown the rims of the bowls, it's ready for the oven.
 
BaliThai May 1, 2017
Thank you! I'll give that a try next time! I did make it this past weekend with the Kalamata olive variation (and added a 1/2 c up Parmesan to it) and subbed a cup of buttermilk for 1 cup of the water. It was fabulous!
 
Alexandra S. May 1, 2017
Yum! That sounds so good :)
 
Jane B. April 28, 2017
Made this bread today. Beautiful crumb. Only had one bowl so upped the quantities and used two 8x4 pyrex loaf style dishes. My neighbour took one to the country for toast tomorrow.......I had toasted blt tonight and it was delicious. Used bread flour because I was low on ap.
 
Alexandra S. April 29, 2017
Nice! So happy to hear all of this Jane. A BLT on this bread is about my favorite thing to eat.
 
Anne B. April 28, 2017
Would it work in stainless steel bowls?
 
Alexandra S. April 29, 2017
Hey Anne! Any oven-safe vessel will work. Just be sure to grease it well. What size are the stainless steel bowls you are using?
 
Debra M. April 26, 2017
Can I use King Arthur Bread Flour?
 
Alexandra S. April 27, 2017
Yes!
 
aaCooks April 26, 2017
How do you adapt this if you are using a sourdough starter?
 
Alexandra S. April 27, 2017
aaCooks — I don't have much experience using sourdough starters, but I think you would have to do something like this: whisk 1/4 cup of your starter with the 2 cups of water (or maybe use 1 3/4 cups water to compensate for the starter being wet.) Add the 4 cups flour and the 2 teaspoons salt and stir to form a sticky mass. You'll probably need to let it sit covered with a damp towel at room temperature for 8 to 10 hours or until it doubles. Then deflate the dough/divide it into 2 halves, and place each in the buttered bowls. Let it rise again until it crowns the rim of the bowl — this may take an hour or so (I have no idea truthfully!). Then bake it the same: 425 for 15 minutes; 375 for 17 minutes.
 
aaCooks April 27, 2017
Great! I will try that and let you know!
 
Alexandra S. April 27, 2017
Awesome! I just took my starter out of the fridge and am going to try to make it work in this recipe. Will report back in a few days. Fingers crossed!
 
Alexandra S. April 28, 2017
Doing this now. I wouldn't suggest cutting back the water after all. I did this: 50 g starter, 2 cups (430 g) lukewarm water, 2 tsp. kosher salt (10 g) , 4 cups (512 g) all-purpose flour. Forgot the sugar! Don't think it's necessary for these long rises anyway. Will report back tomorrow — I'll either bake this late tonight or tomorrow morning.
 
Alexandra S. April 29, 2017
OK, so this is fun! I ended up making 3 batches, two when the starter was right out of the fridge, and one after I fed it, and it rose till it doubled. I think the measurements above are good — no need to reduce the liquid; 2 cups is great (though it may weigh more than 430 g, which is fine). The first rise took all day, and by the time I got around to deflating it, I was too tired to stay up to bake it off, so I divided it, placed the portions in buttered pyrex bowls, and stuck them in the fridge. In the morning I took them out, and let them rise for about 2 hours before baking them off. The third batch rose all night, and in the morning I divided it into bowls and let it rise for an hour or so before baking it off—interestingly, the dough didn't look as though it was doing much, but in the oven it puffed way up. Hope this helps! I really like the bread. It's not super sour tasting, which I like, but it has some nice subtle sour notes.
 
NancyFromKona April 30, 2017
That is a lot of bread Alexandra! An appeal of this recipe is the ease of prep so can I make a suggestion using our sourdough pets that is easy? King Arthur Flour points out that each cup of unfed starter = 1/2 cup water + 1/2 cup flour so to use it in your mom's recipe we use your measured flour minus 1/2 cup, your measured water minus 1/2 cup and your measured yeast so that the quick rise remains. Instead of your trick of adding boiling water to cold water, I'll just measure out 1 1/2 cups of water and microwave until hot because the starter is cold from the fridge. I'd use this to avoid throwing out starter and to add tang to your easy recipe. And if not enough tang then titrate with citric acid. You can use the trick of unfed starter in any recipe that has water and flour and knowing this has encouraged me to keep that starter going. I usually use the unfed starter for our now weekly pizza but after I find some Pyrex bowls I need to make this recipe esp the cheese and cayenne modification to which I'll probably add chopped basil. Thanks so much, love your blog too!
 
Alexandra S. April 30, 2017
Nancy, this is so smart!! Thank you. I love this, I'm going to try tomorrow—I shared many of those sourdough loaves with family this weekend :).

So, is this what I should try?

1 cup unfed starter
1.5 cups water
3.5 cups flour
2 tsp. salt
2 tsp yeast

I love this because I do always feel a little bad tossing the starter for feedings. Thanks so much for this!! And thanks for the kind words re the blog, too :) Means a lot.
 
NancyFromKona April 30, 2017
You got it! And I just got back with 1 quart Pyrex bowls and you know what that means...bread! When you have a spare moment, try King Arthur's search plugging in 'unfed starter' and you will never throw starter away again. Their caramelized onion biscuits, their pizza dough, they even use it in cakes and it all makes one feel so thrifty!
 
Alexandra S. May 1, 2017
Oh, I love this! I definitely will. Thanks so much for all of your tips Nancy! I'm mixing up my unfed starter peasant bread now. Will report back!
 
Alexandra S. May 1, 2017
This worked like a charm—thank you!! Now, I'll never worry about throwing away starter. The bread had a subtle sour taste, which I really liked. And the texture was nearly identical. Rise times the same, too. Thanks!
 
Maame A. April 26, 2017
Does anyone know where the 1 quart bowls used in the pictures above are from? They're so pretty and I want them. I am excited to try the recipe in them!
 
Alexandra S. April 27, 2017
Hi! You can find them on Ebay and second-hand shops. On Ebay, search: Pyrex 441 — those are the smallest of the Cinderella nesting set. They are 1.5 pints. Sometimes you have to buy the whole 4-bowl set; sometimes you can find them separately. Another great option is the Pyrex 322 (1 qt). You can find those both vintage and new.
 
Maureen April 28, 2017
I bought a 4 bowl set on Amazon.
 
Maureen April 28, 2017
Ooops...Just looked and I actually ordered them from Walmart. 4 1 qt bowls for $26. Sorry for the error...I rarely order anything from Walmart but couldn't find them elsewhere.
 
Alexandra S. April 29, 2017
That's a great price! They've gone up on Amazon. I order them from Shop World Kitchen, but I order a ton (22) at a time, to get free shipping. It comes out to about $4.80/bowl, but they're fun to have on hand to give for gifts.
 
Tasneem April 25, 2017
Can I substitute honey for sugar, and wholewheat with all-purpose?
Thank you.
 
Alexandra S. April 27, 2017
Yes! You may want to dissolve the honey into the warm water to help it incorporate more evenly. And with whole wheat flour, I recommend starting with 1 to 2 cups to start—using 100% whole wheat flour will make for a very dense loaf, which some people like, but I think it's helpful to see what the loaves look like/taste like with a small amount of whole wheat flour first. Hope this makes sense.
 
Steph G. April 19, 2017
Alexandra, you are one of my most trusted recipe sources. Everything I've ever made from you has been a hit and soon on regular rotation. I don't know why I delayed trying this bread, but yesterday I had a major carb craving and went for it.
I didn't have enough yeast (and only active dry); once I measured a full teaspoon, I saw that the remaining 1 1/14 tsp wasn't there and just dumped the remainder into the proofing cup in frustration. I had just run out of sugar and used brown sugar. And I only had a 1 qt bowl and a 1.5 qt bowl, so I used them.
Despite all of these mistakes/errors/failures to plan, both loaves were INCREDIBLE. Like other commenters, we promptly ate one with butter. Thank you for another winner - can't wait to get your book!
 
Alexandra S. April 27, 2017
Steph G, first, SO sorry for the delay here!! Somehow I didn't see these comments till now :( Anyway, thank you for your kind words — I'm so happy to hear you've had success with the recipes.

And i'm SO happy to hear that despite not having the ideal amounts/varieties/size of the yeast/sugar/bowls, it still turned out well! It really is a very forgiving and adaptable recipe. And commercial yeast these days is very reliable/consistent/powerful, so we probably could get away with cutting the yeast back in lots of recipes.

Anyway, yay!! Thank you once again for your kind words. So happy to hear all of this!!
 
anita F. April 11, 2017
Just read the recipe in its entirety....note to self...always read full recipe! my question about alternate cooking dish has been answered!
 
Alexandra S. April 16, 2017
Great! Sorry just seeing this!
 
Alexis April 10, 2017
I've always said I have a fear of yeast, but this recipe couldn't be easier. I made the bread in pyrex glass bowls and they turned out perfectly! The bread is just great! Thanks for a super easy, full proof recipe!
 
Alexandra S. April 11, 2017
So happy to hear this, Alexis!
 
Cel W. April 10, 2017
Made the bread this weekend and it turned out perfectly! I used a pyrex and corning ware pots with no sticking at all using just Pam. It's so easy and everyone loved it, I will put it into rotation and next time try the other versions.
 
Alexandra S. April 10, 2017
So happy to hear this, Cel! Great to hear that Pam worked, too!
 
Jessica April 8, 2017
I love to make this recipe as a faux-caccia! I line the bottom of a 8x13 Pyrex with parchment, then olive oil. Spread in the dough and sprinkle with salt and rosemary. So good! So quickly gone.
 
Valerie April 8, 2017
That is such a great idea! Must try.
 
Alexandra S. April 8, 2017
So happy to hear this, Jessica!
 
Hafsa S. April 7, 2017
I absolutely love love love this bread! We always end up eating one loaf right then and there with some home made honey butter. Thank you so much!
 
Alexandra S. April 8, 2017
So happy to hear this!
 
Rachel April 6, 2017
Would this work in deep aluminum tins that I can use when travelling and staying in a rental apartment?
 
Alexandra S. April 7, 2017
Rachel — what size are the tins? You can bake the bread in anything oven-safe really, just be sure to grease them really well. Also, know that if the tins are really deep, it might look as though the dough isn't rising compared to the photos you see here, and the final shape may not look quite the same, but it will still work.
 
Valerie April 6, 2017
Spent all day looking forward to making this later, and the homemade-bread-midweek situation, and it did not disappoint. Easy to follow, I used dry yeast and proofed as instructed. Baked the loaves in two medium porcelain bowls which worked brilliantly. Delicious results, warm bread and butter for supper. Thanks for the recipe!
 
Alexandra S. April 6, 2017
So happy to hear this!
 
cookinginvictoria April 6, 2017
I made this bread yesterday, and my family (we are big bread lovers) devoured the first loaf and gave it rave reviews. I followed the recipe exactly, and it worked like a charm. Bread dough was a good consistency, rising times were spot on, and baked bread released from the bowls very easily. (I used 1 Pyrex bowl and 1 1-quart souffle dish.) I really liked the tender crumb and the delectable, buttery crust. (I was very generous with the amount of butter I used.) What I found to be truly genius (and hopefully life-changing about this recipe) is that there is no advance planning required -- I can decide on a whim to make homemade bread in the middle of the afternoon and pull it out of the oven in time for dinner. Looking forward to making some of the variations and checking out Alexandra's new book!
 
Alexandra S. April 6, 2017
So great to hear all of this CookinginVictoria — nice work on using the souffle dish, too, and glad to hear you had no issues sticking.
 
jy2nd April 6, 2017
Just made the bread. It is certainly easy and quick. But I ran into two problems -- I had trouble getting the bread to release from the bowl, even though I greased heavily with butter. i had to pry it out an that sort of deformed the side/bottom. the other problem is that this is a very soft loaf -- it feels like I can squish it with my bare hands. Is that correct? I'm used to making bread with very sturdy crusts -- any way to make this "sturdier" without changing the crumb? My other thought is to add a little mayo (real) in for part of the liquid, for a little tang. What do you think?
 
Alexandra S. April 6, 2017
Hi jy2nd — sorry to hear about the sticking. One thing I have noticed is that it helps to have the butter very soft. I find in the winter, even if I am generous with the butter, if it's still kind of waxy as opposed to soft, it doesn't work as well — does that make sense?

Mayo constantly surprises me, so if you give it a go, please report back!

One thought re crusts: If you store the baked bread at room temperature unsliced — not in a bag or anything, just out on the counter — the crust firms up a bit, and the crumb still remains soft. You can also, after the bread has finished baking, return it to the oven out of its bowl and heat it directly on the oven racks for 5 to 10 minutes more, which firms up the crust as well.
 
Judith April 5, 2017
Made it today. Turned out just fine, tasted good. It is a good bread for toasting, breakfast, etc.. And for all those who never had a real country bread. As of me, I'll stay with the original no kneed bread, that is more versatile, can be made with seeds, cheese, olives, or just plain. I bake once a week and that last us, works with just about everything.
 
cookinginvictoria April 6, 2017
Judith, did you see these variations? You can add seeds, cheese, herbs, etc. to Alexandra's recipe. https://food52.com/blog/19411-once-you-ve-made-genius-peasant-bread-try-these-5-variations
 
Alexandra S. April 6, 2017
Thanks for passing on the link, CookingVictoria!
 
Maureen April 5, 2017
A few weeks ago I ordered the bowls from Amazon (best deal was a set of 4) but haven't had a chance to make this yet. Excited to see it posted here so I don't have to search thru my desktop bookmarks to find it.Can't wait to hear how it works for all.
 
cookinginvictoria April 5, 2017
Making this right now. Dough is in the oven for the first rise. Fingers crossed!
 
Swetha C. April 5, 2017
Would this recipe work the same if I substituted whole wheat flour for the all purpose flour? Thank you!
 
Alexandra S. April 5, 2017
Hi Swetha, yes! I would suggest substituting half to start — using all whole wheat flour will make for a denser loaf. Once you make it using half whole wheat, then try with 3 cups whole wheat flour, then try with 4 cups — I think it helps to increase gradually so you can find what ratio you like best.
 
Smaug April 5, 2017
You could use regular yeast without proofing in a dough this wet. If you're going to use the oven for rising, it doesn't matter what temp. you set it to if you're only going to 100 degrees- you can probably skip the preheating if you have a pilot light. Just a note- traditional methods of making bread, including proofing and kneading, still only involve about 10 minutes of actual work- it's really not a big deal.
 
BakerMary April 5, 2017
Took my oven 5 min. to get to 75. It's cold here!
 
BakerMary April 5, 2017
It's not going well here. 10 min. rise and up over the top,of the pan, so I scooped some out and put in overn. Eek.
 
Kristen M. April 5, 2017
Do you mean for the second rise in the pans, in step 4? Up over the top of the pan a bit is okay (scroll through the photos above to see how high mine were—a little more than crowning, I'd say). And if it's feeling too high next time, you can punch/scrape it down with forks and let it rise again to a more appropriate height. Alexandra Stafford's book has loads of trouble-shooting advice for every possible scenario, and I tried to include the most useful bits here, but missed this one. Keep us posted!
 
BakerMary April 5, 2017
Went up, over and onto the counter. Scooped a cup+ of dough out and went on.
 
BakerMary April 5, 2017
My dough was WAY wetter. Batter-like.
 
Kristen M. April 5, 2017
Oh my—how's it behaving in the oven? And at which stage was the dough batter-like? In the trouble-shooting section of the book, Ali mentions that if the dough is pourable, try adding about 1/4 cup flour (next time). This might be due to humid weather (the flour won't absorb as much of the liquid), and if you live in a particularly humid place, you might have better luck reducing the liquid by 2 to 4 tablespoons. By your description, it sounds like it might have over-risen, in which case punching down will help.
 
Alexandra S. April 5, 2017
Hi BakerMary,

What size bowl are you using? It sounds as though, as Kristen suggests, that it may have over-risen. Do you use a scale when you measure flour?
 
BakerMary April 5, 2017
Scaled it up as directed for a loaf pan. Yes, I use a scale for meas. flour. Thanks.
 
Alexandra S. April 5, 2017
Ok, and one more question: Are you in a hot/humid climate right now? I do find that in the summer the second rises happen incredibly quickly.
 
BakerMary April 5, 2017
Nope. Just had a too wet batter, didn't add more flour as noted by Kristen above. Oh well. May try again another time. Thanks for your kind assistance.
 
Alexandra S. April 5, 2017
Sure thing! Keep us posted!
 
delbor April 8, 2017
4 cups of flour is typically 20 oz, and 2 cups water is 16 oz, so this is at 80% hydration and would certainly be pushing "batter" consistency. Conventional bread dough is more like 60 to 70% hydration.
So it will not look or feel like what you might be expecting. Presumably that is how it gets by without kneading, and without a long fermentation.