Make Ahead

Caramelized Butternut Squash Wedges With Sage-Hazelnut Pesto

by:
October 26, 2010
5
13 Ratings
Photo by James Ransom
  • Prep time 15 minutes
  • Cook time 30 minutes
  • Serves 4
Author Notes

Sage and butternut squash are a classic pairing. This is my riff on that pairing—a combination of squash wedges roasted at a very high heat topped with a hazelnut, sage, and ricotta salata pesto-ish topping. The idea to make a pesto using sage was inspired by the sage pesto in the Zuni Cafe Cookbook. The finished dish is great hot or at room temperature. —melissav

Test Kitchen Notes

Remember that potato chip commercial that goes: "Betcha can't eat just one?" Well, that's kind of how we felt, eating these squash wedges right out of the bowl. With our fingers. In a 500-degree oven, melissav's squash develops gorgeous bronzed edges and an almost candied interior. A hint of cayenne brings a subtle kick. The pesto, almost impossibly fragrant, is rich and subtle at the same time. It's garlicky without being overpowering, the toasted hazelnuts give it richness and depth, and the ricotta salata lends the otherwise earthy pesto a fresh salinity. We dare you to eat just one wedge. - A&M —The Editors

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • Sage, Hazelnut, Ricotta Salata Pesto
  • 1/4 cup sage, chopped
  • 4 tablespoons olive oil (up to 5 tablespoons)
  • 1 clove garlic, smashed
  • 1/3 cup hazelnuts, toasted
  • 1/4 cup
    2 tablespoons ricotta salata, crumbled or chopped until a medium fine crumble


  • 1 pinch salt
  • Butternut Squash
  • 2 butternut squashes [about 3.5 lbs total when unpeeled]
  • 2 tablespoons olive oil
  • 1 teaspoon granulated sugar
  • 1 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon cayenne, depending on taste (up to 1/2 teaspoon)
Directions
  1. Preheat the oven to 500 and place a rack in the lowest slot in the oven. Line a baking sheet with parchment.
  2. Peel the butternut squash, cut in half lengthwise and remove the seeds. Cut each squash half in half widthwise, right where the slender part curves out to the bulge. Cut each quarter into about 1 inch wedges (see picture) and place in a bowl.
  3. Toss squash with olive oil, sugar, salt, and cayenne. Place in a single layer on baking sheet.
  4. Roast for 10 to 15 minutes until caramelized. Remove from oven and flip over. Bake another 10 to 15 minutes until caramelized on the other side and cooked through. The pieces on the edges of the baking sheet will caramelize first so you want to move around during the baking time.
  5. While the squash is roasting, make the pesto: Warm 3 tablespoons olive oil, sage, and garlic in a small pan over very low heat just until the oil bubbles. Pour in a small bowl, reserving the garlic clove. Place the toasted hazelnuts in mini food processor along with the garlic clove and process until a fine crumble and add to the bowl (alternatively, you can do by hand or in a mortar and pestle). Add the cheese to the bowl along with 1 to 2 tablespoons more olive oil and stir until combined and salt to taste. This is not a traditional pesto -- more nutty than herby and not so much oil.
  6. Once the squash is roasted, place in a large bowl and toss with pesto to taste. Dig in.
Contest Entries

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Rachel Schienke Stevens
    Rachel Schienke Stevens
  • JodyO
    JodyO
  • RossB
    RossB
  • Andrew Augustin
    Andrew Augustin
  • Cheryl
    Cheryl

130 Reviews

Rachel S. December 16, 2023
I've had these on my radar for years and years now and finally made them this Thanksgiving. SO good; they were the best-received side of the night. Followed the recipe exactly. I did make them about a week later again using macadamia nuts and I personally preferred the hazelnuts, though some comments mentioned Brazil nuts being a solid option so I'll be trying that in the future. Either way, really incredible recipe.
 
brandonnyc November 20, 2022
Once incorporated into the Thanksgiving menu a decade ago, it hasn't budged: the mere suggestion of an alternative elicits panic, glowers and threats of divorce. Because of a hazelnut allergy in the family, I use Brazil nuts, with no sacrifice of deliciousness.
 
JodyO February 3, 2022
Absolutely delicious! Thank you! I didn't have hazelnuts, so substituted with Pecans and it was still delicious.
 
RossB January 8, 2020
It was a hit! I looked like a genius! Modifications I made: uncharacteristically, I used pre cut chunks of butternut squash; toasted raw hazelnuts in microwave so I didn’t burn ANY; used more garlic; used fresh and dried sage. Last night I went to make this and didn’t have the squash I thought, so I used (pressure cooked) Jerusalem artichokes, then briefly broiled. It’s also a terrific combination.
 
Lisasaintlouis October 5, 2018
Can someone clarify the ingredient list for the pesto? My monitor shows that after the hazelnuts I need 1/4 cup of something that does not appear. Next is listed 2 tablespoons of ricotta salata. Is that meant to be 1/4 cup + 2 tablespoons of the cheese or am I missing an ingredient?
 
jungli_beleza October 5, 2018
1/3 cup Hazelnuts, toasted
1/4 cup ricotta salata, 2 tbsps. Of which should be medium fine crumbles (to be used as a finishing topping with the pesto).
 
Andrew A. November 14, 2017
Has anyone tried this with cubed butternut squash? I'm feeding 12 and think it would be much easier to cube and roast. Thoughts?
 
Cheryl November 14, 2017
I haven't tried that way (but think I will the next time). love this and made this several times and the slices are awkward to eat. Plus if it was cubed, the pesto and cheese could be more evenly distributed. Just make sure the cubes don't get overdone.
 
Andrew A. November 14, 2017
I think I'll try it that way - I'll let you know how it turns out!
 
Ann.T November 27, 2016
Every Thanksgiving, I like to try a new side dish out along with the usual dishes. Everyone loved this, and voted it into regular rotation!

I did as others did and adjusted per what I had on hand (walnuts and feta instead of hazelnuts and ricotta salata).

I bet this will also be a huge hit at the holiday potluck, as it can be served at room temp.
 
Cheryl February 12, 2016
Oh my that was wonderful! Used feta in a very small crumble.
 
cindy November 22, 2015
Hi I am going to make this for my side to bring to my in laws. There are quite a few of us, and even in their large kitchen it gets pretty crowded. Could you give me suggestions for preparing this ahead of time and re heating it when it's dinner time. Thanks so much! Cindy
 
Susan November 3, 2015
This was on our thanksgiving menu last year and it was well enjoyed. I was thinking of making it again this year. This time for my husband's family. The only issue is that there are two people in his family with tree nut allergy. Any suggestions for subbing the hazelnuts? I was considering pepitas or sunflower seeds. Thoughts?
 
epicharis October 12, 2015
This was incredible. I made a double batch of the pesto because I figured it would be tempting and sure enough, my boyfriend and I are spreading it on toast. The squash is just perfect. Thank you for this!
 
Samantha A. December 3, 2014
Soooo good. We made this for Thanksgiving and it turned out amazing. It was the most popular dish on the table. Thank you!
 
Sharon F. November 15, 2014
Very yummy. Just made it for dinner tonight. The ricotta salata was not necessary and next time (if I don't have any on hand) I might just leave it out. I thought it would melt with the warm oil or the hot butternut squash, but it stayed intact.
 
Marie November 15, 2014
Sure looks great! I usually cube the butternut squash and bake it (paprika and olive oil) Another wonderful way to eat this yummy squash!!
 
Kira F. November 4, 2014
This was unbelievably good!! I didn't have hazelnuts so used cashews - still great. I had to search 4 grocery stores for Ricotta Salata but was pleasantly surprised to learn it's not that expensive of a cheese. Now I just need to figure out how to use the rest of it. :-P
 
DellaConsuela October 24, 2014
I can't believe how good this is! got some butternut squash in my CSA box and was looking for something new. I used pecans instead of hazelnuts (I live in the south and they're always on hand). Fabulous! would definitely make for company
 
Callie H. October 6, 2014
This was AMAZING! I ended up just finely chopping the garlic and putting that in the olive oil with sage, let that cook a few minutes and then pour that over the nuts and added cheese. I was without a food processor and I really liked the nutty taste this provided it was really great.
 
jungli_beleza July 18, 2014
yes! made for a party; everyone consumed to the last tiny bit!
 
Josie M. March 22, 2014
So, so delicious! We'll definitely be making this many more times! (I used feta in place off the ricotta).
 
ksschapp January 4, 2014
Made this for Thanksgiving and even my picky eaters loved it. Looking forward to finding other uses for the pesto.
 
erica December 17, 2013
Just made this and loved it! Beautiful too!
 
gotham G. June 1, 2013
Absolutely delicious! I made this as a side dish for a small dinner party at my house and we all literally fought over the last serving. Thank you for sharing this yummy recipe!
 
ChefFace January 23, 2013
yummm, made this for a large crowd, rave reviews, thank you!
 
Lori L. January 21, 2013
Congrats on this! http://www.purewow.com/entry_detail/recipe/4483/Butternut-squash-from-a-crowd-sourced-cookbook.htm
 
Chef T. November 29, 2012
This was excellent... loved the pesto!
 
Trillinchick December 26, 2011
I am confused about the garlic in the ingredients and recipe. It calls for 1 clove of garlic. It says to mix the garlic with olive oil and sage, and to reserve 1 clove of garlic? I don't understand - 1 clove or 2? I went to the question section first but none them appeared to have been answered. Help us out, please!
Thank you.
 
melissav December 26, 2011
After you warm the garlic with the sage and oil, you put the sage and oil in a bowl. You reserve the garlic clove because you add it to the processor with the nuts. I hope this helps.
 
melissav December 26, 2011
You warm the garlic clove with the sage and oil. Once warmed, you put the sage and oil in a bowl. You reserve the garlic clove after it is warmed because you will be adding it to the processor with the nuts in the next step. Hope this helps.
 
EmilyC November 27, 2011
I made this for Thanksgiving, and my husband declared it the star of the meal! I'm kicking myself for waiting so long to try it! What a fabulous combination of flavors and textures...I'll be making this again and again.
 
fearlessem October 24, 2011
So glad this got re-highlighted on the site. I made it last year, it was super awesome, and then I promptly forgot about it. Can't wait to make it again!
 
Miamac October 20, 2011
I made this last winter and it was so amazingly good that my sister still mentions it. It's all we ate for dinner that night. Now that Thanksgiving approaches, it's at the top of my list! so good and so easy!
 
Atlanticgull October 15, 2011
Wow. Wow. Wow.

This just earned a much desired spot on a very competitive T-day table. You are a genius.
 
Atlanticgull October 15, 2011
Wow. Wow. Wow.

This just earned a much desired spot on a very competitive T-day table. You are a genius.
 
mtrelaun October 6, 2011
Did you know that this recipe makes the most delicious soup ever? Last night I puréed the roasted squash with chicken stock, and it was fab.
 
melissav October 12, 2011
Great idea. Did you top it with some of the pesto or blend the pesto into the soup?
 
melissav October 12, 2011
Great idea. Did you puree the pesto with the soup or use it as a topping? I'm going to give this idea a whirl . . .
 
mtrelaun October 19, 2011
@melissav, I've made it into soup twice. The first time, I topped it with the pesto. The second time, I didn't have the ingredients for the pesto so I put a blob of Greek yoghurt and some bacon crumbles on top. Fab both times!
 
liz.wellbelovedstone October 6, 2011
LOVED this dish! Served it over a garlic couscous. Will be making it again very soon! Thank you for posting this (I got it from Whole Foods' page yesterday).
 
arielleclementine September 14, 2011
what a wonderful recipe! this is probably the most delicious butternut squash i've ever had. thanks so much for sharing :)
 
parker May 15, 2011
I have an obsession for butternut squash ravioli, but I'm usually disappointed by its blandness. So I did an "inside out" version, dumping this whole dish into a big bowl of linguini. Big flavour at last - worked great!
 
dymnyno March 24, 2011
If you baked it at lower heat as I did for my Spicy Butternut Salad it would caramelize better and not burn (as it appears from your picture yours did). I have been making my version a year before the contest and it is perfect every time! It looks like Sara Schatz styled yours after my photo.
 
tburns01 January 18, 2011
I made this last night with some Butternut squash from our CSA and it was FABULOUS!! It was one of the best squash recipes I have ever tried. I will definitely make it again as we have an over abundance of butternut squash in our root cellar.
 
healthierkitchen January 17, 2011
I made this a while back and loved it and just made it again this past weekend for a dinner party and I just wanted to mention again how delicious this combination is. The flavors really balance each other. Really delicious!
 
safenervine January 8, 2011
This was a spectacular holiday treat! Thanks for the recipe.
 
Erin K. January 2, 2011
This recipe caught my eye and I could not wait to try it. I made it without the pesto and added it to my beef stew. Absolutely fabulous!
 
MadeInMaine December 12, 2010
It's crunch time now, and I'm making this for a shindig on Tuesday night. Is there any special trick to toasting the hazelnuts? Temperature? Time? Thanks and holiday wishes to all!
 
melissav December 12, 2010
You can toast them a number of different ways - You can put a small fry pan over low heat and dump in the nuts and stir them from time to time until they start to smell and look toasty. You can also do the same in the oven or toaster over at 325. I'd check on them after 3-5 minutes.
 
avimom December 10, 2010
Made it for a Hanukkah party last weekend. Could not find hazelnuts or ricotta salata and substituted filberts and gorgonzola. Was delish, although I'm sure the original is better. Was the perfect dish to bring and serve at room temperature. The touch of cayenne was brilliant.
 
Mprize December 8, 2010
Without any hyperbole, I must say that this is one of the most delicious things I have ever eaten. Very simple as well and you really can do it with a mortar and pestle, which makes it nice and chunky. Only think I didn't get quite right was that my bnut squash didn't hold its nice moon shapes....although I may have overcrowded the baking sheets a bit. Thanks so much for such a GREAT recipe!
 
Bevi December 2, 2010
I made this as well. The touch of cayenne pepper gave a wonderful afterheat, and the pesto was so good that I am thinking of trying it on pasta, and using it to flavor a quiche.
 
castironmaiden December 2, 2010
I made this for Thanksgiving and it was divine! The sage pulled it together beautifully with the rest of the meal.
 
ehrrin November 26, 2010
I made this for Thanksgiving, and it was the hit of the table! So delicious. Unfortunately all the leftovers got snapped up before I had a chance to set some aside. I'll be making this again soon.
 
enbe November 26, 2010
We couldn't find ricotta salata so subbed it for cotija, which I think worked well.
Made a double recipe for ~16 people for a side and we had MORE than enough. Then again it was one of 10 sides. This was delicious and really did travel well (my cake on the other hand, not so much).
Thanks!
 
AnnP November 25, 2010
This was fantastic!!! Made it last night and ignored everything else on my plate. Only problem, my family didn't eat it - squash phobia - so I will need a new family.
 
MadeInMaine November 22, 2010
Does this really serve only FOUR people as a side dish? Seems to me that 3 1/2 pounds of squash would be enough for at least double that. I'm planning to make this and take it to a potluck for 20 people, where it will be one among three or four other side dishes, so I'm guessing that each person will take one or two pieces.... Any idea as to quantities? Should I double the recipe? Triple it? HELP!
 
melissav November 22, 2010
My husband and I can finish off one butternut squash by ourselves but we typically eat it as the sole side to a light dinner (like a piece of fish). At a potluck with 3-4 other side dishes, you can probably figure on four or five people per squash since as you mention each person will only take a slice or two. I think if you double it, you will have more than enough.
 
MadeInMaine November 22, 2010
Thanks so much! I'm looking forward to making this... and tasting it! :))
 
pieceocake November 22, 2010
Would I be amiss if I roasted the squash with eggplant, sweet potatoes, and red bell peppers? I think all of them would benefit from a little toss in the Sage Pesto. Call me a renegade, but I am going to try it!
 
melissav December 12, 2010
Sounds great to me. Hope it turned out well.
 
hardlikearmour November 21, 2010
My husband said this was the best butternut squash EVER. Thanks for a delicious recipe.
 
healthierkitchen November 16, 2010
Made this last night - seriously delicious! I don't usually like ricotta salata, I think because I've bought the harder kind in the past. This time I had a soft one and the pesto was terrific. Thanks.
 
ehrrin November 16, 2010
Totally making this for Thanksgiving dinner. Cannot wait to try it (and impress the family!).
 
Jennifer A. November 14, 2010
Thank you! I just made this as a little appetizer for dinner and it is so amazing.
 
Laura M. November 14, 2010
I plan on making this-- it looks amazing! Unfortunately I don't have access to ricotta salata. Would there be another cheese that'd work well in its place?
 
hardlikearmour November 14, 2010
Another recipe I've seen that uses ricotta salata suggests either French feta, pecorino romano, or cotija. For this recipe i think the pecorino would be too hard, but the cotija or feta would work well.
 
Oui, C. November 11, 2010
Congratulations! This is a fabulous looking dish, I plan on making it for a dinner party this weekend. - S
 
melissav November 10, 2010
Thank you everyone. So glad everyone is enjoying this recipe. By the way, we had some of the pesto on some thick cut pork chops last night and it was muy bueno!
 
Sagegreen November 10, 2010
Love your recipe. Congrats on the win!
 
Kelsey B. November 10, 2010
Great recipe, congrats!
 
Lizthechef November 10, 2010
Best congratulations for a well-deserved winner!!
 
LazizaBites November 10, 2010
Congrats! it's a wonderful recipe!
 
cheese1227 November 10, 2010
Fabulous recipe. Congrats.
 
gingerroot November 10, 2010
Congrats melissav!! I can't wait to make this.
 
Lori L. November 10, 2010
Congratulations! It's really delicious!
 
mrslarkin November 10, 2010
congrats on the win, melissav!!
 
ABCDELICIOUS November 10, 2010
i tried this the other night and it was spectacular. i ended up substituting fresh roasted chestnuts for the hazelnuts and was over the moon with the results. i plan on using the pesto with homemade butternut squash ravioli as a first course for thanksgiving.
 
lapadia November 10, 2010
Congratulations! I have this recipe on my "to make" list...
 
drbabs November 10, 2010
Congratulations!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Jennine November 8, 2010
This was great! Made it tonight for dinner and I will definitely be making it again soon. I didn't have ricotta salata so I used goat cheese instead. Congrats on being a finalist! Well deserved.
 
Jesslovestocook November 8, 2010
This dish is superb. It's like nothing I have ever had before and I mean that in the best sort of way. Two lovely people you & I both know (think Fairway) made this as a side dish when they hosted my husband and I for dinner this past weekend. I was impressed by how something as plain as butternush squash could be transformed into such devine yumminess. I loved it so much I was talking about it the next day. Kudos to you for coming up with a great recipe!
 
melissav November 22, 2010
Thanks for your kind words and glad you enjoyed dinner with Adam and Leslie.
 
jwlucas November 7, 2010
Wow, this sounds so good. I think this will be part of our Thanksgiving feast.
 
Elycooks November 7, 2010
Oh my, this is divine! Has anyone tried freezing the pesto? What do you think, good idea or not?
 
melissav November 7, 2010
So glad you liked it. I haven't tried freezing the pesto so I am not sure how it would hold up; perhaps it would be best if you freezed it without cheese? Let me know how it turns out if you freeze it.
 
maryvelasquez November 7, 2010
What a wonderful dish! I love the flavor combination. And I can attest to the fact that the pesto is very good with fish, too.
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thank you. I am planning on whipping up another batch to tomorrow to serve with some pork chops.
 
Flavor D. November 6, 2010
I Love the addition of the ricotta salata. Butternut squash is a fall favorite in my kitchen, and it can only get better with this awesome recipe. Way to go melissav!!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thank you!
 
karen S. November 5, 2010
OMG... This was incredible! I made this tonight and it was fabulous. Everyone was eating the crumbs and went home with the receipe. I gave you all the credit!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Hi Karen - so glad you tried it and it was a hit!
 
npsyched November 5, 2010
What a delicious picture to wake up to:o)...Yummy!!
 
ctgal November 5, 2010
Question: Although I still have sage growing in my herb box outside, I'm not a big fan of it. Do you think another herb would work as well. I know sage goes w/ butternut sq., but... Marjoram? I still have that and garlic chives growing. Any suggestions anyone?
 
melissav November 7, 2010
I haven't tried it without any other herbs but I am sure it would work with any other hearty herb that pairs well with butternut squash. If you try a different herb, please do let me know how it turns out.
 
monkeymom November 5, 2010
congrats melissav! You are studly!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thanks Monkey Mom! You're pretty studly yourself! Your eggplant is due for another appearance on our table soon.
 
Lori L. November 4, 2010
This sounds really awesome. My mouth watered reading the description. I wish I had a wood-burning oven to try it in.
 
melissav November 7, 2010
A wood burning stove would awesome with this. Wish I had one too. . .
 
gingerroot November 4, 2010
This looks amazing. I've had spiced butternut wedges before and bet with your pesto this is out of this world. Congrats on being a finalist!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thank you!
 
allie November 4, 2010
What a great recipe -- squash wedges are such a great idea (I do cubes but hate how they disappear into nothing...) & pesto looks wonderful...
 
melissav November 7, 2010
I agree with the cubes. . . it is a fine line between perfect and too mushy. Hope you try it.
 
dymnyno November 4, 2010
I am looking forward to trying your version...my salad started with the same ingredients; sliced butternut, olive oil, sugar and cayenne. Our cooking times are very different. I am going to try your hot and quick cooking time versus my slower carmelizing of the squash.
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thank you Mary. Your salad looks beautiful.
 
Midge November 4, 2010
Definitely a contender for my Thanksgiving menu. Way to go melissav.
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thank you.
 
TheThinChef November 4, 2010
YUM, this sounds really wonderful. Congrats on being a finalist!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thanks!
 
EmilyNunn November 4, 2010
I'm with Tom: so exactly the way I want to eat Butternut squash!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Let me know how you like it if you give it a whirl.
 
cookinginvictoria November 4, 2010
Congrats on being a finalist. I love hazelnuts, and the idea of a pesto made with them sounds seriously yummy. Hope to try this dish soon.
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thank you for your comments and I hope you try it.
 
nutritioulicious November 4, 2010
This recipe looks great! I'm definitely going to try it out. Congrats on being a finalist!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thank you.
 
Annelle November 4, 2010
Sounds absolutely wonderful! Vegetable or hot appetizer! Can't wait.
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Let me know how it turns out if you try it.
 
Sagegreen November 4, 2010
Congrats on being a finalist! So many amazing recipes last week to sort through, this must have been really interesting for the editors. Love the pesto twist.
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Hope you try it, Sagegreen. I always find your recipes very interesting and creative!
 
Bevi November 4, 2010
This looks like it can easily be doubled. I like that at room temperature it's still really good. This will free up some oven space on the Bird Day!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
It absolutely can be doubled, tripled, or even halved.
 
mrslarkin November 4, 2010
Wow, this looks really good! It's gonna be a tasty Thanksgiving. Congrats on the EP and on being a finalist. The pesto would be great over pasta, too, I think!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
I agree, great idea.
 
drbabs November 4, 2010
Congratulations! I'm so happy for you!
 
melissav November 7, 2010
Thank you!
 
cheese1227 November 4, 2010
Oh my, my! In the jockeying for oven time on Thanksgiving, I am not sure I can a 500 degree oven in place for this. How does it do if I caramelize the squash before hand and reheat it in a more moderate oven just before service?
 
melissav November 4, 2010
I think it would be fine. I actually really liked it at room temp as well.
 
thirschfeld November 4, 2010
I had a sneaking suspicion this one would be in the finals. In fact I already made it and love it and give it a vote of approval fo sho. I like the pesto a lot.
 
melissav November 4, 2010
Thanks, Tom. That means a lot coming from you! The pesto is good, isn't it? We ate the leftover on top of some fish the next night and really enjoyed it and, in the interest of full disclosure, I actually ate a lot of it right out of the bowl!