Serves a Crowd

Tomato Rice (TamatarĀ Biryani)

October 27, 2021
4.4
15 Ratings
Photo by Bobbi Lin
  • Prep time 30 minutes
  • Cook time 45 minutes
  • Serves 6
Author Notes

We made this rice for Raghavan Iyerā€”Cookbook Author, Magazine Writer, Culinary Educatorā€”and I'm thanking him for writing this recipe. —pauljoseph

Test Kitchen Notes

We are simply in love with this savory tomato rice recipeā€”it's loaded with aromatics and layers of heat but so easily made for a simple side or lunch. Family and friends will love it and ask you for the recipe whenever you make it. With these precise instructions, the rice comes out perfectly cooked and soaked through with the flavorful tomato broth. Slow and steady wins here, especially cooking the rice over super-low heat at the very end. Featuring ghee, cloves, cardamom, cinnamon, ginger, garlic, and fresh chiles, this tomato rice dish is unforgettable, comforting, and warming. Throw in some chicken or ground beef and you've got yourself a delicious entrĆ©e. You can vary the spice with the type of chiles you choose (for example, Thai are much spicier than serrano), and whether you remove the seeds and heat-packed white ribs. Bear in mind that the spice will continue to build as you eat, and you can taste as you go. If you can't find whole mace, you can substitute 1/8 tsp ground mace or even skip it altogether and let the other spices carry the dish.

Yes, rinsing and soaking the rice seems time-consuming, but your patience will be rewarded and you'll end up with the best flavor and texture. All that's left to do is sautƩ the spices and aromatics, stir in the tomatoes, then let the rice simmer in all of that goodness. Your kitchen will smell delightful, and you'll forever love this combination of textures and ingredients.
—The Editors

What You'll Need
Watch This Recipe
Tomato Rice (TamatarĀ Biryani)
Ingredients
  • 1 cup white basmati rice
  • 2 tablespoons ghee or unsalted butter
  • 6 green or white cardamom pods
  • 2 (3-inch) cinnamon sticks
  • 2 blades mace
  • 1/4 teaspoon whole cloves
  • 1 small red onion, cut in half lengthwise and thinly sliced
  • 2 to 3 fresh green Thai, cayenne, or serrano chiles, to taste, stems removed, cut lengthwise into thin strips (do not remove the seeds)
  • 4 medium garlic cloves, thinly sliced
  • 1 teaspoon shredded fresh ginger
  • 1 (14.5-ounce) can diced tomatoes
  • 1 teaspoon coarse kosher or sea salt
  • 1/4 teaspoon ground turmeric
  • 1/4 cup finely chopped cilantro leaves and tender stems
Directions
  1. In a medium bowl, place the rice. Fill the bowl halfway with water to cover the rice. Gently rub the grains through your fingers, without breaking them, to wash off any dust or light foreign objects (like loose husks), which will float to the surface. The water will become cloudy. Drain and repeat this process three or four times, until the water remains relatively clear; drain again. Fill the bowl halfway with cold water and let it sit at room temperature for 20 to 30 minutes, until the kernels soften. Drain one more time.
  2. In a medium saucepan over medium-high heat, heat the ghee. Add the cardamom, cinnamon, mace, and cloves. Cook, stirring, for 15 to 30 seconds, until they sizzle, crackle, and smell aromatic. Add the onion and cook, stirring frequently, for 5 to 7 minutes, until light brown around the edges.
  3. Mix in the chiles, garlic, and ginger. Cook, stirring, for about 1 minute. (You don't want the garlic to brown because its nutlike crunch is important to the rice's texture.) Stir in the tomatoes, with their juices, and the salt and turmeric. Simmer, uncovered and stirring occasionally, for 5 to 7 minutes, until the tomatoes soften.
  4. Add the drained rice and toss gently to coat with the tomato sauce. Pour in 1Ā½ cups water and stir once to incorporate. Bring to a boil over medium-high heat. Cook for 5 to 8 minutes, until the water has evaporated from the surface and craters are starting to appear in the rice. Then (and not until then) stir once to bring the partially cooked layer from the bottom of the pan to the surface. Cover with a tight-fitting lid and reduce the heat to the lowest possible setting. Cook for 8 to 10 minutes (10 minutes for a gas burner). Turn off the heat and let the pan sit on that burner, undisturbed, for 10 minutes.
  5. Remove the lid, fluff the rice with a fork, and sprinkle with the cilantro. (Remove the cloves, cardamom pods, and cinnamon sticks before you serve, or just remind folks to eat around them.)
Contest Entries

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Dariusz
    Dariusz
  • Cindy Young
    Cindy Young
  • So sett
    So sett
  • Regine
    Regine
  • Cowpscowper
    Cowpscowper

131 Reviews

Nina February 25, 2024
Not very delicious. Too gummy
 
Dariusz January 7, 2024
This was waaay too spicy for me, it was burning my mouth. Should cut down on chiles and garlic.
 
Cindy Y. April 27, 2022
I've made this Tomato Rice dish so many times and each time to raves from guests and family alike. Very easy prep and makes an awesome side dish with a protein or a delightfully light vegetarian entree served with some sauteed spinach and garlic. This recipe is definitely in our regular meal rotation!
 
arun October 14, 2021
nice one.
 
arun October 14, 2021
nice recipe..
 
arun October 14, 2021
wow...nice
 
arun October 14, 2021
wow!
 
arun October 14, 2021
nice
 
So S. March 20, 2021
Yummmyyyyy

I didn't see the description that said to ad 1/8th tsp of mace to replace the whole mace
so I googled it, which told me to sub 2 tsp ground instead. It was delicious in the end nonetheless.

I used canned crushed tomatoes as that's all I had, and I think the rice turned out a tad too liquidy, maybe will cut to 1.25 cups water if I use canned tomatoes next time
 
So S. March 20, 2021
Would also say that I having made the whole recipe and served it with nothing but 2 fried eggs on top, I don't feel it's a 6 person serving recipe unless you have a nice hearty main to go with it. I would say it could feed 3 people with an appropriate vegetable side or something

and 2.5 with nothing else
 
Kate B. June 4, 2019
I made it to the recipe only substituting dried instead of fresh mace which I've never seen in any speciality grocer. Delicious!!! My husband had seconds and thirds. The left overs will be superb as a side to tomorrow's fish
 
Regine September 11, 2018
Let me also add that for me this recipe, at least in my "rice lover" household, cannot be 6 servings but at the most 3. :D)
 
Regine September 11, 2018
I made this last night but used only dashes of (actually, several of each) powdered clove, cardamom and cinnamon because this is what I had on hand. My rice came out exactly like in the 2nd picture. It is quite tasty but I had to add a bit more salt to the liquids (which I tasted after I added the rice). It also took me 20 not 10 minutes on my gas oven (with the tight fitting lid) for the rice to be fully cooked. I do agree with Cowpscowper; raita would be good with this rice. Thanks for the recipe.
 
SoInconvenient June 28, 2018
We made this tonight and were so thrilled with the result. We didn't have any mace, so we subbed in a few dashes of nutmeg. We made a side of Nigel Slater's spinach with ginger, garlic and garam masala (whole recipe is in the title) and are so content and full and happy.
 
Brenda May 14, 2015
I cannot give enough praise to this recipe. It is so yummy...I made it last night and i am still thinking about it. I added broccoli to this dish, but would like to try adding tofu next time as well. :)
 
Cowpscowper April 14, 2015
This one's a keeper! I will continue to make this throughout my life: it's that tasty. Aromatic and flavorful. Spicy and sweet. I threw in some chicken. And made some raita on the side. Thanks for the wonderful recipe! :)
 
Bluejade November 24, 2014
This is pretty good. I used ground spices instead of the whole spices because I just don't buy them. I did not use the spicy peppers. I substituted with chopping up fresh red bell pepper and a small amount of red pepper flakes. That was fine for us. This recipe, as is, must be really hot. Altho the recipe is not tedious and it came together within according to the directions, it is not exactly simple. Worth trying.
 
sevenfaces September 6, 2014
This was great. I'm a big fan of spanish rice - rice cooked in tomatoes - so I knew I would like this too. I counted the number of cloves and cardamom pods I put in so I knew when I had picked them all out and could serve it at the table with confidence!
 
kimberly.godwin March 23, 2014
I made this last weekend. Quite good. I used 2 Serrano chilies, but think I should have used 3. (I like a bit more kick.) I even found mace! I did run out of turmeric so I had to do without. I will definitely make this again, and make sure I have turmeric on hand next go round.
 
Angel January 26, 2014
This was very good!! Will make again for sure. Thank you for sharing and congratulations on your achievement!
 
Ham July 20, 2013
This turned out fantastic. I made it with three serrano chiles and fearfully removed about 3/4 of the seeds. Not necessary! The heat was extremely mild, so next time I will keep the seeds in at least two of the chiles. I also threw 1/4 cup of peas in just after the "crater" step which I thought worked well. I will absolutely make this again.
 
za'atar July 8, 2013
This dish has such wonderful flavor. I needed to use up some Thai jasmine rice and didn't have any basmati on hand, so my end result was a little gloppy, but we still loved it. Looking forward to making it again soon with the proper rice.
 
rupal November 14, 2013
za'atar, incase you dont have basmati rice or you unsure about the right amount of water to put in for boiling rice so that it doesnt get mushy, you can first boil rice separately in a pan in good amount of water n once you feel the rice is cooked just fine you can remove from the stove and can drain excess water using a sieve...hope that helps :)
 
rupal November 14, 2013
and later u can mix this rice with the rest of the cooked ingredients and can let it warm of couple of mins on the stove.
 
HaLi H. May 15, 2013
I made this before and we loved it! If I want to double the recipe, do I need to add 2 cans of tomatoes?
 
piacere March 29, 2013
Fantastic aroma filled our home when this was cooking. Great fun to try the new rise rinsing and soaking techinique too. Wonderful flavors and rice texture in the finished dish. The only drawback was needing to eat around the spices. Cinammon sticks could be easily removed. The cardamom pods virtually disintegrated and so did the mace blades so no worries there either. Avoiding the cloves was a bit trickier. :-)
 
ami@naivecookcooks March 2, 2013
i just made it and it reminds me of home cooked food in India!
 
Jann August 28, 2012
Made this for my cooking club and Indian Night and it was very good. My husband loved it the next night with black beans! Really tasty recipe. Thank you.
 
dymnyno August 27, 2012
It's great to see this recipe featured! I can hardly wait for my trip to India this December.
 
pauljoseph August 27, 2012
Please don't forget to visit us when you are in Kerala,India
 
pauljoseph August 27, 2012
Please don't forget to visit us when you are in Kerala,India
 
pauljoseph August 27, 2012
Please don't forget to visit us when you are in Kerala,India
 
Z June 29, 2020
@pauljoseph did you mean to brown the garlic instead of do not brown?
 
ubs2007 January 13, 2012
Incredible! "Wow...this is amazing" said my 4 yr old. I'm Indian so I've always been skeptical about Indian recipes. This recipe was scrumptious, authentic (at least the way my Kashmiri mother use to make it). Thank you very much for the meticulously detailed, delicous recipe...may be one day I'll enhance my repertoire of northern Indian dishes:)
 
pauljoseph January 17, 2012
Thank you for your comment
 
pauljoseph January 17, 2012
Thank you for your comment
 
JSaez October 11, 2011
Wow! Fabulous. I made this recipe today and it was so good. I even used brown rice instead and still amazing. Thank you!
 
JSaez October 11, 2011
Wow! Fabulous. I made this recipe today and it was so good. I even used brown rice instead and still amazing. Thank you!
 
pauljoseph January 3, 2012
Thank you
 
aargersi September 18, 2011
We had this for dinner again last night. It really is the best rice I have ever eaten!!!
 
pauljoseph September 18, 2011
thank you aargersi
 
ashleychasesdinner September 15, 2011
This is right up my alley. I adore rice and all the wonderful spices used in this recipe. I can't wait to try!
 
pauljoseph September 16, 2011
thank you for your comment
 
pauljoseph September 16, 2011
thank you
 
Donald S. August 11, 2011
Just discovered this site today and I'm so happy! new recipes ! I'll try this recipe and thank you so much!
 
pauljoseph August 11, 2011
Donald Short Thank you any more Indian recipe please ask
 
nogaga July 7, 2011
I just discovered this! How wonderful! Definitely my next rice dish :)
 
pauljoseph July 7, 2011
Thank you nogaga
 
mangoes2020 July 7, 2011
In order to succeed this recipe you have to use Diamond Pearl Basmati Rice. This is a Pure Indian Basmati rice. If you want more informations go on the website http://www.sonaimpex.net or send a mail at [email protected]
 
pauljoseph July 7, 2011
You can use Kohinoor Basmati Rice http://www.kohinoorfoods.in/products.html
 
innoabrd July 7, 2011
actually, this recipe doesn't need any SPAM to be good. it stands on its own merits. Please don't spam here, mangoes2020. It's rude.
 
pauljoseph July 7, 2011
innoabrd Thank you I never thought mangoes2020 comment is SPAM I cant delete my link above you can use ANY Bamathy no problem i HOPE FOOD52 WILL DEFLATE BOTH LINK SORRY AGAIN
 
Panfusine June 23, 2011
just made this for dinner (substituting crushed tomatoes instead of diced ones..) delightful treat, Makes me want to quote a sanskrit blessing 'Anna daata sukhi bhava' (May the person who provides you food, live well & prosper!)
 
pauljoseph June 25, 2011
'Anna daata sukhi bhava' Sanskrit thank you for your comment Panfusine please call us when you are in India
 
76sarah May 1, 2011
Made this with brown rice and baked it--fabulous!
 
pauljoseph May 1, 2011
76sarah Thank you any more Indian recipe please ask
 
AntoniaJames April 15, 2011
I made this the other night and it is sensational. And it's so easy. Without question, this is one of my favorite recipes, ever, on food52. Thank you, pauljoseph! ;o)
 
pauljoseph April 15, 2011
thanks a million AntoniaJames you relay encouraging me to add more recipes
 
AntoniaJames April 7, 2011
I plan to make this, at long last, tomorrow evening. I don't have any whole blades of mace, but I do have some mace (from India), that is in small broken pieces. How much should I use? I assume I should pound them with a mortar and pestle . . . .I am so looking forward to this. Thank you. ;o)
 
innoabrd April 7, 2011
Mace is the lacy covering around a nutmeg, to give you an idea of scale. So a blade, by my reckoning and roughly speaking, is about an inch long by 1/4". Definitely just use them whole rather than ground. That's one of the distinguishing characteristics of South Indian cooking, IMO. The whole spice gives you a much different result than the ground and fried spice used in north India.
 
pauljoseph April 7, 2011
Thank you AntoniaJames do exactly what step 2 says use whole mace

Yes innoabrd is correct a blade, of mace is , is about an inch long by 1/4".
 
TheWimpyVegetarian March 3, 2011
I made this for dinner last night it was just perfect!!! Thanks so much for a GREAT recipe!!
 
pauljoseph March 3, 2011
ChezSuzanne thank you
 
aargersi February 18, 2011
We made this again last night and all 6 of us LOVED IT!
 
pauljoseph February 18, 2011
Thank you aargersi
 
SallyCan February 3, 2011
I'm so glad to see this as a Wildcard Winner! Well deserved!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
thank you sally
 
MyCommunalTable February 3, 2011
Congrats on the Wildcard win. You deserve it. I always enjoy seeing what you put on this site. Thank you.
 
deensiebat February 3, 2011
Made this last night! I tried it with brown basmati, and tweaked the time and water to accommodate but didn't get it quite right (my constant peeking probably didn't help things either). But even with a slightly soppy result from my mistakes, the flavor was still lovely. I'll be making it again!
 
pauljoseph February 3, 2011
next time try with white Pakistani or Indian basmati rice
 
edamame2003 February 3, 2011
oh, yum! this looks delicious--i like the tomato and peppers! saucy and spicy--i wish i'd seen this before trying to figure out my mom's Thai Biryani! great recipe--congratulations to you!
 
pauljoseph February 3, 2011
THANK YOU
 
monkeymom February 3, 2011
So happy to see this picked! Congratulations pauljoseph!
 
pauljoseph February 2, 2011
thank you a million to Amanda and Merrill and all Food52 members that all of you are one of our (me and our family and friends ) favorite and its the best food blog
 
AntoniaJames February 2, 2011
This is on the menu this week at our house, for sure. I am so looking forward to making -- and eating -- it!! Congratulations, pauljoseph on this well-deserved honor. ;o)
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you AntoniaJames
 
drbabs February 2, 2011
OK, pauljoseph, you inspired me. I am making this right now. Had to made a few minor substitutions based on what I had in the house, but it smells SO good. And I am turning it into a one-dish meal by laying some fish filets that I had planned to cook tonight over the rice for the final steaming. (I did open the pan to turn them over.) Wonderful. Not anything I would have ever made without your inspiration. Thank you! And thanks A&M for this discovery.
 
drbabs February 2, 2011
Oh, I almost forgot! Here's the other great thing about this recipe: I'm a clean as you go kind of girl, the dinner is finishing on the stove, and except for that, my kitchen is clean! Hooray! No big after-dinner clean-up!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you drbabs next time have with lime pickle
 
testkitchenette February 2, 2011
I will be making this this weekend...thanks for contributing such tasty recipes!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you testkitchenette
 
TheWimpyVegetarian February 2, 2011
This looks wonderful pauljoseph!!! I think I'll make it this weekend! Congrats for the great win!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you ChezSuzanne
 
Sadassa_Ulna February 2, 2011
Congratulations, this sounds great, thank you for contributing so many great recipes!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Sadassa_Ulna for you kind comment
 
nannydeb February 2, 2011
Congratulations!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you
 
hardlikearmour February 2, 2011
Hooray, pauljoseph! This sounds delicious.
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you hardlikearmour
 
fortheloveofyum February 2, 2011
I was just looking at this recipe a few days ago and thought it looked fabulous, I'm really glad pauljoseph got the wildcard win! Many Congrats! :)
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
fortheloveofyum thank you
 
onetribegourmet February 2, 2011
Congrats Paul! My mouth is watering thinking just thinking about this Byriani!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you
 
healthierkitchen February 2, 2011
Look forward to trying this soon! I just got Raghavan Iyer's Betty Crocker cookbook!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
healthierkitchen Lots of relay good Indian recipes in that book one of our favorite author also try to buy Maya Kaimals Savoring the Spice Cost of India lots of Kerala recipes
 
mrslarkin February 2, 2011
Congratulations, pauljoseph! Can't wait to make this dish!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
mrslarkin thank you
 
WinnieAb February 2, 2011
Yay PaulJoseph! So happy this is a wildcard win!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you WinnieAb
 
TiggyBee February 2, 2011
How wonderful pauljoseph!!! Congratulations on your beautiful rice!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Thank you
 
Bevi February 2, 2011
Congrats to you!!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
Bevi thank you
 
lastnightsdinner February 2, 2011
So wonderful - congrats to pauljoseph!
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
lastnightsdinner thank you
 
gingerroot February 2, 2011
Congrats pauljoseph! I am so thrilled for you - a well deserved wild card win! I will make this again soon.
 
pauljoseph February 5, 2011
gingerroot thank you have with lime pickle
 
drbabs February 2, 2011
Congratulations, pauljoseph!
 
pauljoseph February 3, 2011
Thank you drbas
 
aargersi February 2, 2011
Hurrah! This rice is SO good, great wildcard choice! Congratulations!!!
 
pauljoseph February 3, 2011
Thank you
 
innoabrd February 2, 2011
Bravo! Will look forward to trying it.
 
pauljoseph February 3, 2011
Please try and send me a picture
 
Kitchen B. February 2, 2011
PaulJoseph - I am a HAPPY Woman to see you hounoured. Fantastic. Congratulations - Woow.
 
pauljoseph February 3, 2011
Yes Kitchen Butterfly as a man I am very proud of that
 
Midge February 2, 2011
Congrats pauljoseph! This looks so delicious.
 
pauljoseph February 3, 2011
MIdge thank you
 
Sagegreen February 2, 2011
Congrats on the wildcard win, pauljoseph! So happy for you.
 
pauljoseph February 3, 2011
Thank you sagegreen
 
SallyCan November 4, 2010
I made this and it is so fragrant and lovely. If you don't like too much heat, you could seed the peppers...
 
pauljoseph November 5, 2010
Yes that helps
 
gingerroot November 3, 2010
This looks delicious - and I bet it smells wonderful as it is cooking (fragrant rice, cardamom, cinnamon, cloves, ginger, garlic, chili - YUM!). I am saving this and will try it soon.
 
pauljoseph November 3, 2010
Thank you
 
gingerroot November 4, 2010
I made this tonight for my family and it was delicious. To add some protein, I did brown some ground beef separately with onion and garlic and combined it with the finished rice. Everyone enjoyed it, even my three year old son (who usually does not like tomatoes). Thank you for a fantastic recipe! We will be making this again soon.
 
pauljoseph November 4, 2010
Thank you I also want try with ground beef
 
aargersi November 3, 2010
Pauljoseph - I made this for dinner last night and it is EXCELLENT - all of the seasonings are present but no one thing overpowers the other. I followed the directions precisely and it came out perfect - we ate as much as we could last night and divided up the leftovers for our lunches today. Excellent recipe!!
 
pauljoseph November 3, 2010
Thank you aargersi As somebody trying our recipe, this kind of commend ( very rare) really encourage me to post real genuine try out (at least 5 time recipes) with real picture thank you again
 
pauljoseph November 3, 2010
Thank you all for you commend
 
aargersi November 2, 2010
I am making this! Sounds SO good and we just happen to have everything in the pantry!
 
mrslarkin November 2, 2010
this sounds wonderful, pauljoseph! Thank you.
 
Sagegreen November 2, 2010
What a great rice recipe! Thank you.