$8 Flat Rate Shipping Express Shipping Available Wedding Registry Manage Your Registry
Original & Vanilla Bean Goat's Milk Caramel Sauce (2-Pack)
Photography by James Ransom.

A tangy, sweet sauce.


Original & Vanilla Bean Goat's Milk Caramel Sauce (2-Pack)

$30 (Was )  + $ shipping surcharge
Please enter a quantity larger than 0.
Add to Basket Sorry, this item is currently out of stock.
Expected back in stock .
Notify me when it's back. Submit
Thanks! We'll email you when it's available again.
11 + Save

Fat Toad Farm's unique goat's milk caramel sauces combine rich, sweet caramel with the subtle tang of goat's milk for a creamy, not-too-sweet dessert sauce unlike anything we've tasted. We love it with ice cream, fruit, and cheeses -- and to be honest, straight from the jar. This silky caramel is actually a traditionally Mexican preparation called cajeta, and Fat Toad Farm makes our favorite version.

The set includes one jar of original caramel sauce and one jar of vanilla bean caramel sauce. Each jar is housed in a hand-stamped burlap gift bag tied with a wooden spoon (for expedited eating, of course).  

  • Made in: Brookfield, VT
  • Made of: Goat's milk, pure cane sugar, and baking soda (vanilla bean version also includes organic French bourbon vanilla beans)
  • Size: 8 ounce jars

Sourced from: Fat Toad Farm

365 day shelf-life. Refrigerate after opening.

Standard Shipping: Ships out within 2 business days.

Additional Shipping Information: Cannot be shipped to U.S. Territories or P.O.Box/APO/FPO/DPO addresses.

Our Return Policy

All the seaweed you need to try
The Unsung Ingredient of the Sea

All the seaweed you need to try

A mermaid salad.

Nothing like your cafeteria kind, we promise

Great sticks.


Amanda & Merrill are going head-to-head & need your help

The Food52 Cookie Truck!

Proper copper.