The sweet spot.
Caramels made the old-fashioned way with locally sourced butter, milk, and cream? Count us in. Everything here was slow-cooked to perfection in a bona fide copper kettle, then lovingly packaged with a refurbished vintage cutting and wrapping machine (yep). Wondering about gluten, nuts, soy, or artificial flavors? You won’t find any of that here.
Snag a set for the candy lover in your life (and we won’t tell if you keep it for yourself):
- Salted Caramel Sampler: 2 pillow boxes each of Black Lava Sea Salt, Cape Cod Sea Salt, and Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt.
- Caffeinated Caramel Sampler: 2 pillow boxes each of Deep Chocolate, Dark Roasted Mocha, and Café Noir
- Taste of the Northeast Gift Set: Cape Cod Sea Salt & Tapped Maple.
- Traditional Favorites Gift Set: Classic Vanilla & Deep Chocolate.
- Unexpected Flavors Gift Set: Black Lava Sea Salt & Single Malt Scotch .
- Party Box: A medley of four different flavors: Classic Vanilla, Black Lava Sea Salt, Deep Chocolate, or Tapped Maple - in a small or large size (depending on how long you want the party to last).
- Variety Box: For the true caramel connoisseur. This set has around four pieces each of nine different flavors: Dark Roasted Mocha, Ginger Fusion, Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt, Single Malt Scotch, Black Lava Sea Salt, Tapped Maple, Cape Cod Sea Salt, Classic Vanilla, and Deep Chocolate.
Photography by Julia Gartland
Details & Materials +-
Hyde Park, Massachusetts
Each caramel starts with a base of: Fresh milk, fresh cream, cane sugar, inverted cane sugar, tapioca syrup, butter (cream, salt), and molasses.
Flavors have the following mix-ins
Cape Cod Sea Salt: Sea salt, vanilla extract.
Tapped Maple: Pure maple syrup, vanilla extract.
Classic Vanilla: Salt, vanilla extract.
Deep Chocolate: Salt, vanilla extract, chocolate liquor (Dutch-processed).
Black Lava Sea Salt: Salt, vanilla extract, Hawaiian black sea salt (sea salt, activated charcoal).
Single-malt Scotch: Salt, single malt Scotch. Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt: Truffle sea salt (sea salt, truffle mushroom), fresh rosemary.
Dark Roasted Mocha: Salt, vanilla extract, chocolate liquor (Dutch-processed), fresh ground coffee bean.
Ginger Fusion: Salt, fresh ginger.
Sampler Set: Each set contains a case of six sampler pouches (two of each flavor). Each case measures: 4.25" W x 9.60" L x 2.10" H; 8.4oz. Each pouch contains approximately 5 pieces of caramel. Approximately 30 pieces per case.
Gift Set: Each set contains two packages of caramel (one of each flavor). Each package measures: 2.50" D x 6.75" H; 5.5oz. Contains 17-20 pieces of caramel per package.
Small Party Box: 5.50" W x 5.65" L x 2.75" H; 12oz. Contains approximately 40 pieces (10 of each flavor).
Large Party Box: 8.50" W x 8.50" L x 3.00" H; 23oz. Contains approximately 80 pieces (20 of each flavor).
Variety Box: Box measures 5.50" W x 5.66" L x 2.75" H; 10.5 oz. Each box contains 36 pieces (approximately four of each flavor).
Care & Notes +-
Store in a cool, dry place. Do not refrigerate or let your caramel reach temperatures higher than 70°F.
Shipping & Returns +-
View our Return Policy.
Meet the Maker
Our Tips & Stories
How we'd use this beauty in our own homes.
A&M show us just how fun making caramel can be -- don't miss their step-by-step tutorial.
Merrill shows us how to make maple candy.
No ghosts or ghouls, just dessert!
A Similar Style
Elsewhere on Food52
Today’s Top Story55 Impossibly Easy, Slightly Lazy, 100% Reliable Summer Dinner Recipes
So Hot Right Now
Kitchen HacksThe Secret to Keeping Lemons Fresher, Longer