McCrea's Candies

McCrea's Candies Handcrafted Caramels

$30$60
McCrea's Candies

McCrea's Candies Handcrafted Caramels

$30$60
3.7 Stars / 6 Reviews
Free Standard Shipping on Orders $149+

The sweet spot.

Caramels made the old-fashioned way, with the best locally sourced butter, milk, and cream? Count us in. Everything here was slow-cooked to perfection in a bona fide copper kettle just the way it used to be made, then lovingly packaged with a refurbished vintage cutting and wrapping machine (yep). Wondering about gluten, nuts, soy, or artificial flavors? You won’t find any of that here. Snag a set for the candy lover in your life (but, psst, we won’t tell if you keep it for yourself, either).

Free Standard Shipping on Orders $149+
and Easy-Breezy Returns

Get a load of these sweet sets...

  • Spring Sampler: This seasonal box includes two fan-favorites: Deep Chocolate Caramel and Classic Vanilla. (The small has 20 of each flavor, while the large has 50 of each.)
  • Salted Caramel Sampler: 2 pillow boxes each of Black Lava Sea Salt, Cape Cod Sea Salt, and Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt.
  • Caffeinated Caramel Sampler: 2 pillow boxes each of Deep Chocolate, Dark Roasted Mocha, and Café Noir.
  • Taste of the Northeast Gift Set: 1 tube each of Cape Cod Sea Salt and Tapped Maple.
  • Traditional Favorites Gift Set: 1 tube each of Classic Vanilla and Deep Chocolate.
  • Unexpected Flavors Gift Set: 1 tube each of Black Lava Sea Salt and Single Malt Scotch.
  • Party Box: A medley of four different flavors—Classic Vanilla, Black Lava Sea Salt, Deep Chocolate, or Tapped Maple—in a small or large size (depending on how long you want the party to last).
  • Variety Set: For the true caramel connoisseur, this box has about 4 pieces each of 9 different flavors: Dark Roasted Mocha, Ginger Fusion, Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt, Single Malt Scotch, Black Lava Sea Salt, Tapped Maple, Cape Cod Sea Salt, Classic Vanilla, and Deep Chocolate.

The sweet spot.

Caramels made the old-fashioned way, with the best locally sourced butter, milk, and cream? Count us in. Everything here was slow-cooked to perfection in a bona fide copper kettle just the way it used to be made, then lovingly packaged with a refurbished vintage cutting and wrapping machine (yep). Wondering about gluten, nuts, soy, or artificial flavors? You won’t find any of that here. Snag a set for the candy lover in your life (but, psst, we won’t tell if you keep it for yourself, either).

Free Standard Shipping on Orders $149+
and Easy-Breezy Returns

Get a load of these sweet sets...

  • Spring Sampler: This seasonal box includes two fan-favorites: Deep Chocolate Caramel and Classic Vanilla. (The small has 20 of each flavor, while the large has 50 of each.)
  • Salted Caramel Sampler: 2 pillow boxes each of Black Lava Sea Salt, Cape Cod Sea Salt, and Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt.
  • Caffeinated Caramel Sampler: 2 pillow boxes each of Deep Chocolate, Dark Roasted Mocha, and Café Noir.
  • Taste of the Northeast Gift Set: 1 tube each of Cape Cod Sea Salt and Tapped Maple.
  • Traditional Favorites Gift Set: 1 tube each of Classic Vanilla and Deep Chocolate.
  • Unexpected Flavors Gift Set: 1 tube each of Black Lava Sea Salt and Single Malt Scotch.
  • Party Box: A medley of four different flavors—Classic Vanilla, Black Lava Sea Salt, Deep Chocolate, or Tapped Maple—in a small or large size (depending on how long you want the party to last).
  • Variety Set: For the true caramel connoisseur, this box has about 4 pieces each of 9 different flavors: Dark Roasted Mocha, Ginger Fusion, Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt, Single Malt Scotch, Black Lava Sea Salt, Tapped Maple, Cape Cod Sea Salt, Classic Vanilla, and Deep Chocolate.

Meet the Maker

McCrea's Candies

Hyde Park, Massachusetts
Kate and Jason McCrea fell in love while working as researchers on the Arctic Tundra, and after double layoffs, they began to cook up sweet treats for their neighbors and friends. The raves came rolling in, and before long, they were whipping up batch after batch in copper kettles, then feeding it all through a restored, early twentieth-century cutting and wrapping machine. They’re on a mission to make the world’s best caramel (and with those fresh-as-can-be ingredients, they just might have done it).
View Full Profile

Reviews for
McCrea's Candies Handcrafted Caramels
3.67 Stars / 6 Reviews

All reviews come from Verified Purchases
5.0 Stars
Simply delicious
This box is perfect for gifting, but I kept it for myself. ("Need to, ahem, check the quality before I gift these...") Super tasty caramels, each about two bites worth; they are not tiny. You can tell the flavors are all natural, and they really are distinctive. My fave is the single malt scotch (boozy, followed by the rosemary truffle (can taste each element clearly). Will definitely buy again...and keep for myself again.
Verified Purchase
Submitted on: 11/14/2021 Reviewed by: PerryDog Option: Variety Set
5.0 Stars
So delicious
These are an absolute guilty pleasure!! We are hooked! I ended up buying them at Christmas and then followed up by buying them for my kids birthdays as well because everyone loved them so much.
Verified Purchase
Submitted on: 9/11/2021 Reviewed by: Megmac Option: Variety Set
1.0 Star
terrible taste
I recommend that you don't every buy VERY EXPENSIVE candy in cute little boxes, not worth your time, money or frustration!
Verified Purchase
Submitted on: 7/11/2021 Reviewed by: Scotty H. Option: Sampler Set, Salted Caramels (Set of 6)