The Piglet2014 / First Round, 2014

Vegetable Literacy vs. Saving the Season

Vegetable Literacy

Deborah Madison

Get the Book

Saving the Season

Kevin West

Get the Book

Judged by: Kat Kinsman

Kat Kinsman is the managing editor of CNN.com’s EPPY Award-winning food blog Eatocracy. She oversees CNN’s Matrimony beat and writes for CNN Living on numerous topics, especially mental health and being a ladyperson.

Before joining CNN in 2010, Kinsman served as the senior editor for AOL Food and Slashfood, worked as a copywriter at Tribal DDB, and spent 10 years as an art director and designer at publications such as Maxim, FHM, CitySearch, and others. She is a Kansas City Barbeque Society-certified BBQ judge, vice chair of the James Beard Journalism Committee and an avid member of the Southern Foodways Alliance. In 2013, she was nominated for a James Beard Broadcast Award, spoke at a wide variety of conferences, and joined the New York Times’ Kim Severson onstage at the Southern Foodways Alliance Symposium in a heated debate over Pie vs. Cake. (They tied.)

The Judgment

Calloo callay! Oh frabjous day! Somehow I managed to score two books that are both highly useful and relevant, and I might have to resort to the medium of interpretive dance to fully explain how rare that is.

Like many food editors, I live at the base of Cookbook Mountain -- a teetering pile of nearly every title that's published every season. While a certain -- unfortunately smallish -- percentage of them are interesting, the intersection of those and ones I'm actually likely to 1) take home and 2) sully in my kitchen is practically microscopic.

I collect cheffity-chef "this is my vision" manifestoes like they're going out of style (though they show no sign of it), but mainly for inspiration. I'm a dedicated home cook, to be sure, but it's not like I have room in my fridge for a hotel pan full of gellan gum and a gallon of duck web stock I was supposed to have made two weeks before. I -- and pretty much any other civilian cook I know -- ain't got time, let alone room, for that, unless it's for a big, special blowout feast.

Here's where Saving the Season and Vegetable Literacy swoop in to save the day. Vegetables and fruit happen. They occur in your home if you are trying to do that whole "not perishing of scurvy" thing, and you might as well have some fun with them. If you're anything like me (and Baal help you if you are), you grew up with an invariable rotation of frozen, canned, or occasionally fresh broccoli, carrots, green beans, corn, tomatoes, and the dreaded leaf spinach just kind of cut up and made hot, possibly tarted up with a pat of butter. Fruit was peeled and cut, or simply chomped, unless its destiny was as the filling of a baked good. Seasonality? BWAHAHAHA!

I made it to adulthood scurvy-free, but ignorant of the possibilities inherent in nature's bounty. In the last 10 years I've probably overcompensated for the lack by becoming one of those pedantic food freaks who grows her own heirloom salsify and epazote and put a provision for weird jarred experiments in her marriage vows (not actually kidding here), but who among us couldn't use a bit more know-how in the vegetable department?

Deborah Madison did a public service by writing Vegetable Literacy. It is, as the title implies, a primer for the crucial business of introducing fresh plant life into your body, and it does so in an incredibly practical, if fittingly academic way. Got a vegetable? Madison has an easy-to-execute method for dispatching it with minimal waste and agita. Every last one of the recipes I tried just worked. The Sautéed Rainbow Chard with the Stems worked. The Tuscan Kale with Anchovy-Garlic Dressing worked, too. 

That's not to say they were without fuss and flair -- slicing a pound of Brussels sprouts can prove either meditative or monotonous depending on the kind of day you're having -- but the outcome, especially in Slivered Brussels Sprouts Roasted with Shallots, is inevitably in the bag, and appetizing to boot. Techniques, such as broccoli stem dicing and chard leaf freezing are so simple and obvious as to instantly become canon, and may leave you fretting about all the potentially edible produce you've been tossing out all these years. (Sorry, nature.)

The recipes are divided into family groupings that may seem a bit oblique to begin with, but eventually make sense: carrot, mint, sunflower, knotweed, cabbage, nightshade. Goosefoot and amaranth, (former) lily, cucurbit, grass, legume, and morning glory. Yes, yes, kale gets its due, as does quinoa, sorrel, and all the other fashionable vegetables of our time as well as the greatest hits, but there's also a heavy emphasis on the outliers, like burdock, scorzonera, mandrake, einkorn, and a whole witches' brew of roots and herbs. If it's not in this book, it's not worth eating.

Vegetable Literacy is encyclopedic in its scope -- and sometimes in its tone. Where it's earned its MS in Vegetableology, Saving the Season opted for an MFA in Preservationism.

I didn't grow up with any expectation of pretty prose with my recipes, but I've come to thoroughly appreciate it. It's been a curious and often welcome development over the last while -- cookbooks that function as much as literature as they do instructive texts. It's the utility inverse of all those memoirs with a recipe often awkwardly gummed to the end of each chapter. Kevin West possesses a poet's mastery of language, and uses it to create vignettes that capture the essence of a fruit or vegetable's brief peak season as effectively as his recipes do.

And as with Madison's, the methods -- in this case for pickles, jams, condiments, and other season-prolonging staples -- work. They just do, time and time again, with little hoopla and ideal economy. A simple tip in a grenadine recipe kept my skin and walls un-stained, and while the output was an excellent standalone product (suitable for gift-giving, even), the portion that didn't fit neatly into a pint jar was easily slotted into the onion confiture recipe several pages forward.

But here's the neat trick: said confiture wasn't dependent upon the grenadine component (interdependency is a thing that drives me nuts about so many chef "vision" cookbooks), but rather offered it as an upgrade from a perfectly suitable Cassis. A plum liqueur makes use of apricot kernels left over from, jam, jelly, shrub, and cocktail making.

Those little harmonies loft this book from eccentric to essential, and from my kitchen to my nightstand.

In a different season, the wind may have blown in another direction, but right now, Saving the Season preserves my favor.

And the winner is…

Saving the Season

Saving the Season

Get the Book

Do you Agree?

78 Comments

Eliz. April 14, 2014
As only one of many who praised this review but would have selected VEGETABLE LITERACY for the Piglet, I would like to alert Food52 readers to an ekphrastic, lengthy and contextualizing review by Jane Kramer in this week's edition of THE NEW YORKER (04/14/14). While my love of eggplant knows few bounds (what a strange phrase, that), eggy eggplant dishes please me not, so I am hyper alert to the fact that the author tends to publish versions of the same eggplant custard dish in a succession of books. There's a little disconnect between exquisite photographs and recipes (e.g., a fennel dish with a bit of tomato paste looks so amazingly tomatoey, it made sense to add lots of slow-roasted tomatoes, instead, to duplicate photographer's vision). These are only quibbles. The book results from so, so much work, expertise and creativity that it is a real joy. Recipe for Steve Sardo's Rio Zape beans is simple and extraordinarily flavorful--truly one of the best things to do with dried legumes. The book is for someone who admires research, treasures reference books and is a produce geek.
 
Bevi March 21, 2014
I own both books, and wish they had not met head to head. Saving the Season is a wonderful book for the avid canner who appreciates variance and also a bed stand read. Vegetable Literacy is a classic in its own right; but an unfortunate aspect of Piglet surfaces in pairing disparate viewpoints on disparate topics.
 
TryItSheSaid March 21, 2014
Thoroughly entertaining, but I knew where she was going because of the "canning vows." I chose Madison. But every cook chooses according to where they are.
 
babyfork February 28, 2014
I own Saving the Season and have read it cover-to-cover which I don't do with all of my cookbooks. It's one of those cookbooks (like Smoke & Pickles) that is a joy to read as well as cook from. I am an avid canner and Saving the Season is one of my favorites out of my collection of preserving books. I'm cooking from it right now in fact...getting ready for our Marin County Fair in July! Currently working on West's curried cauliflower pickle and agrodolce onions. If you are into canning I wholeheartedly recommend his book.
 
Naomi M. February 28, 2014
I enjoyed reading the review, although I disagreed with the decision. Probably because I have been a huge fan of Madison's cooking and cookbooks for a couple of decades. Her book is amazing in every way, but it is pretty daunting to be sure! I simply cannot wait to have her newest revision of The New Vegetarian Cooking for Everyone, which should be out soon. Her recipes are almost always perfect and totally amazing in flavor.
 
erinsk February 27, 2014
Having picked up both of these from the library in the last few months, I think Kinsman is spot on. Both look lovely, interesting, and useful. Both are on my list of "someday" cookbooks for sure.
 
The F. February 26, 2014
I disagree but enjoyed reading Kinsman comments.
 
Marian B. February 24, 2014
I want this judgment to win the Piglet.
 
Megan February 23, 2014
I do agree! Looks like a great book
 
holly February 23, 2014
Saving the Season sounds like a staple for having fresh, organic produce available year-round, which means blueberry pie in Fall and apple hand pies in Summer! Great elaboration, much enjoyed :)
 
Gristle &. February 21, 2014
I tend to add slowly to my cookbook collection, so it's a rare occurrence that I would have any of the "currently trending" Piglet candidates, but this time I already have both of these and can't imagine picking one over the other, they're both so so good and useful.
 
Ashley February 21, 2014
Enjoyed reading this review, both sound interesting.
 
sandriavdh February 20, 2014
Very interesting review. I am tempted to add both books to my collection. I need some inspiration to add more veggies to my life. Thanks for a great review.
 
cookinginvictoria February 20, 2014
This review was an absolute pleasure to read. It is one of my favorite Piglet reviews this year -- well written, articulate, and entertaining to boot. And I have to say that I was persuaded even though I am a HUGE Deborah Madison fan. Vegetable Literacy was already on my wish list of cookbooks to own. But as a cook who has only recently embraced canning, preserving and pickling, Saving the Season sounds like a fabulous, must have book too. (I really appreciate reading the thoughtful comments below of those Food52ers who have cooked from Saving the Season.) I may have to add both books to my own full to overflowing "Cookbook Mountain." :)
 
creamtea February 20, 2014
Great review, so well written!
 
Lauren's P. February 20, 2014
When it comes to eating your vegetables, all are winners. Great review, and will add both to my library.
 
biomouse February 20, 2014
:)
 
Rita D. February 20, 2014
What an entertaining, fun review . . . even the reference to Baal was great since I am singing Mendolssohn's great opera Elijah . . . "hear our cry O Baal" this summer with my chorus. And I did grow up " with an invariable rotation of frozen, canned, or occasionally fresh broccoli, carrots, green (and wax) beans, corn, tomatoes. I have never owned just a vegetable cookbook and am curious to find some intriguing recipes so I might vote for Vegetable Literacy. But Kevin West's writing sounds interesting too so I might want both books.
 
MyLime February 20, 2014
Color me surprised! But now I know to check out Saving the Season!
 
Dr R. February 20, 2014
I lean more towards Vegetable Literacy.
 
ATG117 February 19, 2014
Piglet is so spot on this year. I would have voted for Vegetable Literacy, but thoroughly enjoyed the review.
 
Blackbird F. February 19, 2014
I have to vote for Vegetable Literacy, if only for it's practical applications and gorgeous photography/styling...
 
MplsCitified February 19, 2014
What a great review. So funny and so concise.
 
Tamara B. February 19, 2014
I think I would agree with the winner but both books would be a welcome addition to my collection.
 
Jeannie V. February 19, 2014
I own and LOVE Vegetable Literacy.
 
aargle February 19, 2014
I loved this review! So witty and eloquent. I would buy Vegetable Literacy over Saving the Season but happy that the underdog (only my opinion) won.
 
Joan O. February 19, 2014
My daughter works at the library and recently borrowed Vegetable Literacy and I flipped through it while at her house the other day and was very impressed. It is now on my wish list and after reading this review I know I'm going to have to check out Saving the Season to see if it too deserves a place on my wish list as I enjoyed this reveiw.
 
BakerK February 19, 2014
I hae had a lot of success with Vegetable Literacy--loads of delicious and unique recipes. I'll have to check out Saving the Season as well, as I've been wanting to start preserving more seasonal items. Great review.
 
Hui February 19, 2014
Saving the Season sounds like a really good book! now I am tempted to get it if I don't win it!
 
Jenali February 19, 2014
This was such a wonderfully written review that highlighted the strengths of both books. I want (actually need) to own both after reading this review!
 
Teruska February 19, 2014
This had to have been one tough choice!
 
CaseyAnne February 19, 2014
I just started trying canning and preserving, this looks like a great book to try!
 
jamcook February 19, 2014
I always love to find a new preserving book, but am a also an owner of many Deborah Madison books.. This must have been a difficult choice. Both sound terrific .
 
Sauertea February 19, 2014
I have love Saving the Season. I have been fortunate enough to take classes from Kevin West. It is amazing when the poetic and practical come together so seamlessly. The Boysenberry jam recipe produced the best jam I have ever made. So good that I could not bring myself to share it outside of the family, this year I am making at least two flats. His apricot jam recipe is masterful and his Seville orange marmalade recipe is foolproof. He takes one beyond the basics of the Ball Canning Book and manages to delight both the palate and the soul!
 
topdawg11 February 19, 2014
Hard to argue when the winner ended up on her nightstand.
 
Hannah R. February 19, 2014
I have to root for Vegetable Literacy here- it is a the vegetable encyclopedia that cooks need- it is the gastronomic and modern equivalent of Webster's dictionary.
 
jess M. February 19, 2014
These seem like great complements to each other!
 
Claire February 19, 2014
Glad to see the more accessible one winning! Was just put on a sugar-restricted diet due to a recent diagnosis, so vegetable dishes that "just work" will be my saving grace!
 
Erika February 19, 2014
My favorite review that I've read yet! Your review was so fun, I just want to go out and buy both of them.
 
LittleFrier February 19, 2014
This is great.
 
Kala February 19, 2014
My goal for 2014 is learning the art of food preservation. Will have to check this book out.
 
sherry M. February 19, 2014
I own Vegetable Literacy already, and have learned a lot about veggies...I am also new to fermenting, and believe in the health benenfits completely. Would love to add Saving the Season to my kitchen~
 
Fresh T. February 19, 2014
I didn't agree with this review. I checked Saving the Season out of the library and I'm very happy I did because I didn't want to buy it after reading it. It read long and tedious to me and the recipes weren't anything special. I much prefer Deborah Madison's book, although I do wish there were more pictures.
 
Victoria February 19, 2014
Yum! I'l have to get my hands on a copy of that!
 
NellieMc February 19, 2014
So glad to see two cookbooks that add something to food knowledge, rather than just regurgitate.
 
Miss H. February 19, 2014
I haven't read either books. But I love vegetables and am new to canning!! I love pickles!
 
EmFraiche February 19, 2014
They both sound wonderful! Will definitely have to check out Saving the Season. Thanks!
 
Sheila E. February 19, 2014
I love this review, the writing was delicious. I want both books, winning Saving The Season would mean more cash for enlarging my garden this summer. I'm new to growing food, and since I'm expanding this year I totally need some plans for preservation.
 
Amanda M. February 19, 2014
I knew nothing of eating seasonally into I became a vegan. Love Kat's smart, witty, on-point review of two cookbooks that are delightfully, and deliciously, on trend!
 
jenna_lee February 19, 2014
To echo earlier sentiments, GREAT review! Best so far this year, humor, detailed analysis, thoughtful judgment... While I was pulling for Vegetable Literacy (maybe it can make a reappearance as a wildcard??), I have been wanting to try canning and preserving for awhile now. Looks like Saving the Season may be just the book to kickstart it for me particularly based on others' comments as well.
 
Bevi February 19, 2014
I am a bit partial since I count myself as "a preservationist". Lovely review, and fun to read.
 
Katie February 19, 2014
I too grew up with frozen to microwaved green beans, but now spend my nights deciding how best to fit 5+ fresh vegetables into every meal. thanks for the delicious review! can't wait to start saving the season!
 
Jennelle S. February 19, 2014
Saving the Season sounds great.
 
rosalind5 February 19, 2014
Best review yet!
 
Donna February 19, 2014
Great review! I already have a few books by Deborah Madison. Would love to get my hands on Saving the Season. Thanks for the opportunity!
 
ChefJune February 19, 2014
Thank you, Kat Kinsman, for making my morning. What a pleasure to read such deliciously chosen words! I'm rather new to pickling and preserving, so I guess I'd better add Saving the Season to my library. Sounds like some inspired recipes for preservation of summer stuff.
 
Kristina T. February 19, 2014
Lovely review! Saving the Season has me completely intrigued! Must get my hands on a copy ASAP! :-)
 
Brigit T. February 19, 2014
Deborah Madison books are always on my wish list and I don't have Vegetable Literacy, but your review makes me wish for "Saving the Season'
 
Stephanie J. February 19, 2014
Your reviews are wonderful reading! I am now intrigued by Kevin West's book. I already own Vegetable Literacy and couldn't agree with your review more. Deborah Madison is veritable vegetable inspiration! Thanks for the great reviews!
 
aixpat February 19, 2014
My favorite Piglet entry yet! Since I too need a provision for weird jarred experiments, Saving the Season sounds like something I'll have to check out!
 
kate H. February 19, 2014
I have gifted Vegetable Literacy many times this year-so I am thinking I must want a copy for myself!
 
Stesha February 19, 2014
agree with you completely! Kevin West's book is that rare thing in preserving cookbooks--beautiful, compelling and completely useful! I've made tons of stuff from it already (just completed the vin de pamplemousse) and can't wait for the spring/summer to get canning again!
 
penelopemacaroni February 19, 2014
love vegetable literacy!
 
aargersi February 19, 2014
The review is a great read and makes me want BOTH books! Cookbook Mountain!!!
 
KarenL February 19, 2014
yummy review on two yummy books. i am in a quandry about which to read first.....i better check them both out. thank you for showing them in such nice inspiring light. Karen
 
tyrannyofcake February 19, 2014
I adore Vegetable Literacy for its beautiful images, earnest-sounding, if a bit encyclopedic text, and for its treatment of damn-near everything you might ever pluck out of the dirt and consider munching on. But, this review has me coveting a copy of Saving the Season as well. I'm intrigued by Kinsman's comments on the interrelationships between recipes, and I might just have to know more!
 
biomouse February 19, 2014
I have so enjoyed your reviews and plan to grab a copy of both of those lovely books as soon as I can :)
 
Shalini February 19, 2014
Marvellous prose. Thanks!
 
Inko February 19, 2014
I have Vegetable Literacy and love it. I like the way she explains how the different families of vegetables inform the ways to cook and eat them. Now I am eager to check out the other cookbook.
 
Tiffany February 19, 2014
As a vegetable gardener I'm intrigued by both reviews. I've been looking for a book like Saving the Season because at the end of the season, I end up with so much excess that I could use a couple more preserving methods. It's definitely going on my wishlist.
 
aacers February 19, 2014
Another wonderful review. Piglet is really bringing it this year! I want both of these,
 
Cynthia G. February 19, 2014
Best review yet. I'm more tempted by Vegetable Literacy from just this review, but I'll take a look at both!
 
kgmom February 19, 2014
I NEED THIS BOOK!! Saving the season looks amazing, I must have it.
 
drbabs February 19, 2014
I really loved this review. Thank you.
 
AntoniaJames February 19, 2014
What a beautifully written, thoughtful review. I agree with the judgment, too! I've worked extensively with both books since early last summer. I would have chosen "Saving the Season" for many of the same reasons articulated by the judge. To my mind, it's one of the best of its kind, ever (and I study, and use each year, every book on preserves that I can get my hands on, as the scores of jars of preserves on my garage shelves will attest). Ms. Madison is one of my top 5 favorite cookbook authors, ever, but I am pleased that Mr. West is receiving the accolades here. His writing is a joy to read (so interesting, too!), but more important, his recipes produce great results. I hope he's working on another book now. ;o)
 
healthierkitchen February 19, 2014
Yes, great reviews this year!! A pleasure to read.
 
JadeTree February 19, 2014
Fabulous review! Thoroughly enjoyed the energy, enthusiasm and details. Wonderful tournament this year! Must clearly get both books.
 
LLStone February 19, 2014
Another very fine review - the reviews this year are just excellent.