The Good Life, Gluten-Free

Converting a Recipe to Gluten-Free

By • June 24, 2013 • 16 Comments

112 Save

If you like it, save it!

Save and organize all of the stuff you love in one place.

Got it!

If you like something…

Click the heart, it's called favoriting. Favorite the stuff you like.

Got it!

Every week, Shauna Ahern of Gluten-Free Girl and the Chef -- and Gluten-Free Girl Everyday -- will be sharing smart tips and smarter recipes that will please even the most devout gluten-eaters among us. Come one, come all -- we're going flourless. 

Today: To adapt a recipe to be gluten-free, there's a little science and math involved, then you play with flavors, you follow your instincts -- and then you eat. Shauna shows us how while converting a Food52 favorite: Merrill's Crispy Oatmeal Chocolate Chip Cookies.

When you bake gluten-free, you can do two things. 

1) You can make up your own recipe from scratch, based on the ratios of fats to flours to liquids to eggs. (This pancake recipe came from ratios and playing with flavors.) 

2) Or, you can find a recipe you love that uses gluten flours and make it your own. 

Let's talk about how to make a recipe your own. 

Find a Great Recipe
The first choice is the most important one: find a good recipe. 

This one might be tough -- in the age of the internet, the first recipe that pops up from your search might not be a good one. It might be that the team that put it online did whatever necessary to make sure it shows up first in your search. Ever made a recipe online and blamed yourself when it turned out horribly? Don't. It might have been poorly written. 

I turn first to the sources I trust. Every baked good recipe by Dorie Greenspan, David Lebovitz, and Alice Medrich I have ever made has worked. Each of those folks -- as well as the dozens of other recipe writers I trust -- has done the work of baking, taking meticulous notes, and correcting mistakes so you don't have to make them. 

A good recipe is written well; it has to be more than just a series of ingredients and steps. You should be able to hear the recipe writer's voice in there, as though he or she is standing beside you, guiding you, standing back when you're doing fine but offering suggestions when something might feel confusing. If I read a recipe that tells me to bake the cookies for 15 minutes, but doesn't offer suggestions about the texture of the cookie or what it might look like to when it's done? I don't make it. 

Of course, you might want to make your grandmother's chicken pot pie or your uncle's famous snickerdoodles instead of turning to a cookbook. If it's written in shorthand, this is a great chance to have a family gathering and watch your grandmother make that pie with gluten. Write down everything you didn't know. Then go home and make it your own. 

Choose your recipe well and you're halfway there. 

140 grams, baby. 
I have written here before about the fact that many baked goods are equally good with gluten and without. It's really about getting the ratios right. Use too much of any flour and you're going to create an overly dense banana bread. 

So let's turn to the math. 

If you weigh out 1 cup of all-purpose flour, you will get…well, it will be different for every cup. Most recipe writers prefer you measure out a cup this way: aerate your flour by whisking it well, then spoon it into the measuring cup, and then carefully scrape off any excess flour with a knife. Or, if you bake anything like I used to bake, you probably just stuck that measuring cup into the bag of flour and scooped some out. The problem is that's a lot more flour than the recipe intended. 

A few years ago, when I started to bake by weight, I asked on Twitter for people to weigh out a cup of bleached white all-purpose flour, since that's the flour most baked goods use. The responses flooded in and they were all different -- I had answers from 4.2 ounces to 5.8. It all depends on how you measure your flour. 

But if you weigh your flours -- the way pastry chefs do -- every time you weigh out flour you will have the same amount. 140 grams will always equal 140 grams. And it turns out that most recipe writers I trust, including David Lebovitz, use 140 grams as a standard weight for 1 cup of white all-purpose flour. You might see 125 grams sometimes. Or 130. Find the one that works for you. But in our house, we use 140. 

So how do you convert a recipe from gluten flour to gluten-free? For every 1 cup of all-purpose flour you use in a recipe, use 140 grams of your favorite gluten-free flour blend. (Here is our all-purpose flour mix.) 

Most of the time, that's all you have to do. (Except with breads and pizza doughs -- but that's another story. Today, we're talking about the baked goods most home cooks are making, like cookies, quick breads, and pies.) 

Play with Flavors
If you want to convert a recipe, simply, you're mostly done now. You need the right amount of flour and you keep everything else in the recipe the same. But I can only rarely stop there. I like to play with flours and their different flavors when I'm converting a recipe. Most times, it makes the recipe better. Here are a few that are tried and true -- there's more to baking than math, of course. 

• If you're making cornbread, throw in some corn flour with your gluten-free all-purpose flour. 
• Making oatmeal cookies? Try some oat flour in the combination of flours. 
• Chocolate cake or brownies? Teff flour will intensify the taste of the chocolate. 

Trust Your Instincts
Once you convert the all-purpose flour to 140 grams of your flavorful gluten-free flours, then you play a little more. Does the dough feel a little dry? Try a splash of milk. Is it crumbling? Try an egg white or a whole egg. Is it missing some flavor? Try a pinch of salt. Or a little more cinnamon. And don't forget to take note of the changes for the next time you bake it. Make that recipe yours. 

It's not good enough for a recipe to be gluten-free. It has to be good. 

Go on, you can do it. 

Almond-Oatmeal Cookies with Dried Cherries

Makes about 18 cookies

You can't go wrong with recipes on Food52. These recipes are crowd-tested and come from the best home cooks I know. So, when I wanted to convert a recipe, I turned to Merrill's oatmeal chocolate chip cookies. Here's how I made them my own.

160 grams almond flour 
20 grams coconut flour
1 teaspoon baking soda
1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
1 teaspoon cinnamon
1/4 teaspoon nutmeg
1/8 teaspoon ground cloves
180 grams unsalted butter, at room temperature
200 grams (1 cup) brown sugar
150 grams (1/2 cup) white sugar (we prefer the taste of the unbleached sugar)
1 large egg, at room temperature
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
250 grams (2 1/2 cups) certified gluten-free oats
250 grams dried cherries (make sure they're gluten-free) 

 

See the full recipe (and save and print it) here.

 

Photos by Shauna Ahern

Jump to Comments (16)

Tags: the good life gluten-free, gluten free, gluten, glutenfreegirl, adapting, recipe, oatmeal cookies, special diets

Comments (16)

Default-small
Default-small
Default-small

1 day ago Debby Graham

I love my cranberry bread recipe but want to convert it to gluten free so I can give it to someone who can't have gluten. I bought Pillsbury Gluten Free multi-purpose gluten free flour blend (rice flour, potato starch, pea fiber, tapioca starch and xanthan gum). Will this work as a substitute? Will I have to adjust or eliminate BP or BS?

Default-small

4 months ago Denise Pudelski

Hi, I made an apple cake using a pre mixed gluten free flour. It called for 2 eggs, I used 3, but it still didn't hold together well. It's not all falling apart, but it's not the way it should be. I did use the xanathan gum also. Any suggestions. Thanks, Denise

Default-small

about 1 year ago Madeline

am trying to make gf-grain free pizza but i just dont know where to start with the flour, i have Bobs red mill Quinoa flour and i have coconut flour ? so where do i start to make the crust?

Default-small

over 1 year ago elmleaves

Can I use vegetable oil instead of the butter to make cookies or biscuits, cause I got high cholesterol?

Default-small

over 1 year ago Sophia

Thank you very much for the advice. This helps me a lot. I also look forward to trying your oatmeal almond cherry cookie recipe!

Default-small

over 1 year ago dt

Thank you thank you thank you!! This post is exactly what I have been needing to expand my repertoire of GF cooking. Simple at it's core, but just a tad bid more info to help me "tweak" as needed. I'm inspired. (P.S. I love it all the more that it has no xanthan gum in it. I prefer cooking without it if I can get by without -- though with some recipes, I add an extra egg white.)

Default-small

over 1 year ago GoodFoodie

While I love Shauna's work (and her new cookbook), I think people new to gluten free baking need- need something to 'glue' it all together. For example, I recently made Wild Rice Cookies that literally fell to bits because there wasn't anything like xantham gum included in the ingredients to hold it together. Be aware folks!

Shauna_and_danny_ahern_-_photo_credit_sarah_bunch

over 1 year ago glutenfreegirl

Shauna James Ahern is cooking up a good life, gluten-free. Her most recent book, Gluten-free Girl and the Chef was named one of the best Cookbooks of 2010 by the New York Times.

I have found that we don't need xanthan gum or any other binder if the ratio of flours to fats to liquids to eggs is accurate. In fact, in this recipe, the coconut flour works as a hydrocolloid, absorbing some of the liquids and holding the cookies together. So remember -- it's about the recipe!

Default-small

over 1 year ago GoodFoodie

Hmmm interesting science at work. Is there any way tell beforehand - such as the inclusion of coconut flour - whether the ingredients will hold together or not without those additions = to ID a 'good' recipe?

Open-uri20130827-25091-162nu7q

over 1 year ago Atlanta

I wouldn't mind trying these cookies--Shauna, how could I adapt your recipe so as to include guar or xanthan gum so that I don't end up with GoodFoodie's experience! Thank you so much! :)

Shauna_and_danny_ahern_-_photo_credit_sarah_bunch

over 1 year ago glutenfreegirl

Shauna James Ahern is cooking up a good life, gluten-free. Her most recent book, Gluten-free Girl and the Chef was named one of the best Cookbooks of 2010 by the New York Times.

You don't need xanthan or guar gum in these cookies. I took those photos. These are the cookies from the recipe.

Open-uri20130827-25091-162nu7q

over 1 year ago Atlanta

"This one might be tough -- in the age of the internet, the first recipe that pops up from your search might not be a good one. It might be that the team that put it online did whatever necessary to make sure it shows up first in your search. Ever made a recipe online and blamed yourself when it turned out horribly? Don't. It might have been poorly written."

It's not tough at all. Use Allrecipes.com. They have tens of thousands of recipes and a large GF section. Each recipe is reviewed by those who have already made it (removing further guesswork), sometimes by hundreds of users. Great resource.

Me

over 1 year ago Kenzi Wilbur

Kenzi is the Managing Editor of Food52.

I think what Shauna is saying is just that there are plenty of not-so-great resources along with the great ones. It's just a warning to read and select carefully!

Default-small

over 1 year ago trifle-n

I second the Allrecipes's gluten free section. I go by recipes that have many reviews that are well-written. Sure, in this day and age, people will sometimes puff reviews with fake feedback, but if a recipe has 30 reviews where it seems the majority actually MADE the recipe, I'll take a chance on it. GF flours cost too much money to waste them on a bad recipe!

Default-small

over 1 year ago The Principal Cook

Now I feel that my worlds are truly aligning! Shauna Ahern is one of my wife's heroes as an example of how to thrive and continue to eat well and enjoy fine food in spite of having celiac disease. And as I am the chief cook and bottle-washer in our house, "The Gluten-Free Girl and the Chef" gets lots of work in our kitchen! I'm glad to see her on Food52.

Me

over 1 year ago Kenzi Wilbur

Kenzi is the Managing Editor of Food52.

So happy to read this. We're glad to have her too!