Wildcard Winner

New England Lobster Rolls with Lemon Chive Mayonnaise

By • August 19, 2013 • 18 Comments

102 Save

If you like it, save it!

Save and organize all of the stuff you love in one place.

Got it!

If you like something…

Click the heart, it's called favoriting. Favorite the stuff you like.

Got it!

Every Monday and Wednesday, we'll announce a new Wildcard winner: a recipe that may not have been entered in (or won) a contest, but a recipe that we've tested and loved.

Today: No need to travel to New England for its quintessential summer food.

New England Lobster Rolls

WHO: Sonali aka The Foodie Physician  is a culinary school grad and emergency medicine physician in New York City.

WHAT: A classic New England seafood shack lobster roll, made in your own kitchen.

HOW: Make a lemony, herby mayonnaise, then fold it into diced lobster and celery. Spoon it into lettuce-lined, buttery, toasty buns. Garnish with more mayo, if desired.

WHY WE LOVE IT: We love that Sonali tackles the quintessential New England summer food -- that, now, can be enjoyed far outside the northeast. The homemade mayo is a great touch -- but, in a pinch, good-quality store-bought mayo can be used in its place.

New England Lobster Rolls with Lemon Chive Mayonnaise by Sonali aka The Foodie Physician 

Serves 4

Lobster Rolls

2 cups cooked, diced lobster meat
1/4 cup homemade lemon chive mayonnaise (or other good quality mayonnaise)
3 tablespoons finely chopped celery
Kosher salt and black pepper
4 top split hot dog buns
3 tablespoons unsalted butter, melted
3 leaves Boston lettuce, sliced

Lemon Chive Mayonnaise

1 room temperature egg yolk
1 teaspoon dijon mustard
1 1/2 teaspoon fresh lemon juice
1/8 teaspoon kosher salt
6 ounces canola or other neutral-flavored oil
2 ounces extra virgin olive oil
1 tablespoon water (optional)
2 teaspoons chopped chives

See the full recipe (and save and print it) here.

Photo by James Ransom


Tags: wildcard, wildcard winner, lobster, lobster rolls, lobster roll, sandwich, summer, new england

💬 View Comments ()

Comments (18)


over 1 year ago Karen Branham

I'm definitely going to try this getting a lobster in Anchorage Alaska should not be too hard right...congratulations on your win


over 1 year ago DeGustibus_Dan

Two comments....first, if you don't have real hot dog buns, make your own by slicing off the sides of those hot dog rolls they sell in the rest of the country. It's a good substitute but a substitute none-the-less. Second, no self-respecting or otherwise New Englander would add anything in the mayo for a lobster roll except mayo ingredients, say oil, eggs, salt, maybe a bit of lemon, if you're from the Cain's Mayonaise camp (from whence I spring). Anything other than lobster, not too finely chopped, mayonaise, maybe some celery diced, salt and pepper (of course, we are not Barbarians), is unnecessary. The lobster carries the roll. Don't get nerved up about the sides, cut them off with a serrated-edge knife. Leave the chives for a baked potato.


over 1 year ago Sonali aka the Foodie Physician

Thanks for all of the comments! I believe I used the Pepperidge Farm top split buns but they are not the traditional New England style buns with the flat sides that toast up so well. Those are really hard to find. Regarding the lemon juice, most store-bought mayo (like Hellman's) has lemon juice in it already. I like putting a good amount of lemon juice in my homemade mayo because I think it pairs nicely with the lobster. I know that people feel strongly about their lobster rolls, I hope you try my version! :)


over 1 year ago Cest La Vie

I'm originally from The State Of Maine, and have truly enjoyed many of the succulent symbiosis of flavors, which are embodied in the tastings of the best seafood's The State Of Maine has to offer. Nothing can compare to those flavor profile, and I feel so very fortunate to have been brought up with that ability in my life, too! What recipe's that I have been fortunate to gather during that period, too! M-M So Very Tasty, too!!


over 1 year ago threefresheggs

A proper NE clam-shack-lobster-roll is usually served on a buttered, griddled hotdog roll. I have always thought the point was to add as little bulk as possible, and no flavor beyond butter. Also, while this recipe is excellent, and I love the sound of the lemon chive mayo, I have to say, a dyed-in-the-wool New Englander who has vacationed on the Maine coast her entire life, I have never once had a lobster roll north of New York City that has lemon in it (I wouldn't put it past Connecticut though). The infamous Red Hook Lobster Pound Makes the same mistake. Totally regrettable.


over 1 year ago Vivienne

If you can get to a Wegman's, they carry top split "New England" style buns. Pepperidge Farms also makes them but they are not distributed nationally.


over 1 year ago tenuta melagrana

The key to the lobster roll is the bun. How do we get those iconic buns outside of New England?


over 1 year ago CookOnTheFly

You make your own, like I do. King Arthur Flour sells a NE hotdog bun pan. Their recipe is excellent.


over 1 year ago Muse

Oh my goodness these look delicious, wish I were having them for lunch right now. Congratulations on your Wildcard win! Peace, Light and Love.


over 1 year ago Sonali aka the Foodie Physician

I just saw that my recipe was chosen as a Wildcard winner and it made my day! Thanks so much Food52!


over 1 year ago lastnightsdinner

Congrats!! These sound amazing!


over 1 year ago Sonali aka the Foodie Physician

Thanks! Hope you're doing well!


over 1 year ago fiveandspice

Emily is a trusted source on Scandinavian Cuisine.

Oh how I wish I were eating this tonight! Congrats.


over 1 year ago Sonali aka the Foodie Physician

Thanks so much!


over 1 year ago QueenSashy

QueenSashy is a trusted home cook.

... joining Kukla! I just saw this dish and cannot stop thinking about anything else. Congrats!


over 1 year ago Sonali aka the Foodie Physician

Thank you! I hope you try the recipe!


over 1 year ago Kukla

Congratulations Sonali aka the Foodie Physician!! I cannot believe that such simple yet delicious recipe did not have even one comment for more than two and a half years. Thanks to Food52 for acknowledging this recipe and the WildCard Win!


over 1 year ago Sonali aka the Foodie Physician

Thanks, Kukla! I love lobster rolls and it's exciting to see my recipe recognized!