Rogue Baking Tips with Alice Medrich

Measuring Flour Right: 3 Tips for Better Baked Goods

By • October 14, 2013 • 17 Comments

23 Save

If you like it, save it!

Save and organize all of the stuff you love in one place.

Got it!

If you like something…

Click the heart, it's called favoriting. Favorite the stuff you like.

Got it!

Every week, baking expert Alice Medrich will be going rogue on Food52 -- with shortcuts, hacks, and game-changing recipes.

Today: Knowing the right way to measure flour is harder than it looks.

How to Measure Flour on Food52

If your cakes are leaden and cookies doughy, your flour-measuring technique may need a makeover.

I wish I could simply say, "Get out your scale and weigh the flour!" But until the day comes when all recipes include weights, we are stuck with measuring cups. The problem is that we don’t all use them the exact same way.

The cook who dips the cup into the flour sack or canister and shakes it level can get over 6 ounces of flour into the cup, especially if the flour was compacted or the cook leveled the cup against the inside of the bag (you know who you are out there!). Another cook -- probably a baker -- who stirs the flour in the canister to loosen it slightly and then spoons it lightly into the cup and sweeps it level without shaking or tapping, gets only 4 1/4 to 4 1/2 ounces of flour in her cup. Those two people will produce two entirely different cakes using the very same recipe!

There is no single right answer to the dip-and-sweep versus lightly spoon methods because some of us do it one way and some the other. If you are working from a cookbook, you should check the front of the book to see if the author tells you how he or she measures flour and follow that method for the recipes in that book.

How to Measure Flour from Food52

Whether you dip-and-sweep or lightly spoon, here are my three rules to minimize the difference -- or make the issue moot:

1. Store flour in a canister and loosen it gently before you measure.

2. Never shake or tap the cup to settle the flour -- measuring is not a contest to see how much flour you can stuff into your cup -- just sweep it level with a straight edge.

3. If you are a budding or avid baker, get a scale and use it whenever you have recipe that includes weights, as all of our recipes will someday.

More: Make Alice's genius Best Cocoa Brownies. Go on.


Alice's new book Seriously Bitter Sweet is a complete revision of her IACP award-winning Bittersweet, updated for the 54%, 61%, and 72% (and beyond) bars available today. It's packed with tricks, techniques, and answers to every chocolate question, plus 150 seriously delicious recipes -- both savory and sweet.

 

Photo by James Ransom

Jump to Comments (17)

Tags: alice medrich, baking, flour, measuring flour, how-to and diy

Comments (17)

Default-small
Default-small
Default-small

4 months ago Max

Thanks for the information. My biggest problem, not having scales is that cup and tablespoon measurements vary which I never realised till I moved to a different country. Moving from Australia to N.Z., no problem but then to the U.K. and on to Sweden. I bake wherever I go and have, over time, managed to work out the different measurements, with very few failures (lucky me)! I also use many US recipes which also need to be converted. I love baking and my family and friends like to eat so win, win. I do plan to buy scales when I settle down but don't see the point yet as I leave everything behind when I move on.

Default-small

5 months ago Debwoudhuysen

No such implication. I am a long term admirer of the US and of American cooking and loved my time living and cooking in the US. That's why I follow so many US stes from the UK.

Birthdaygirlmick

5 months ago SuperWittySmitty

Until a few years ago, owning a digital scale seemed like a luxury, and not really necessary. Amazing how things have changed- they're inexpensive and very convenient to own. I use mine for portion control after the cooking is done, too.

Food52

7 months ago Manhattan Tart

I'm always a "spoon and level" kinda girl but recently tested the different weights, based on approach. You're right: holy cow, but there's a difference. I now spoon & level then mark on every recipe the weight so the next time I make that recipe I don't have to dirty as many dishes...

Alice.medrich.deborah.jones_-360x360

6 months ago Alice Medrich

Love it! This is exactly how one can slowly convert from volume to weights, even when the recipe doesn't include weights. Put down the weight of your volume measures, especially for your tried and true recipes. Once you have a weight for each ingredient (or even just the critical ones) you can tweak them as time passes...mark your changes etc. This is the way recipes get perfected and improved over time.

Default-small

12 months ago Chris Cook

It would be nice if Food52 would at least start including weights in their recipes as well as volumes. I don't really understand the logic behind "we move slowly here."

Default-small

5 months ago fionula

I am definitely in this camp. And I too started the conversion by finding out what 'my' cup of flour weighs. Also very glad to see Alice Medrich as a contributor.

Prospect

3 months ago Jewels Vern

Just because something is a good idea, that doesn't mean everybody should convert. For instance, artists do not fare well with metric measurements; it changes their perceptions of ratios. Nobody understands why, but the differences are there. People use whatever measures they find convenient. Bead necklaces are sold all over the world with diameter specified in mm and length specified in inches. Nobody even blinks at a listing like "8 mm x 18 in". Another problem is that a lot of people never owned a scale and don't intend to buy one. They will eat hamburger and mixed veggies every day rather than knuckle under to some new fad. From my own experience, the changeover is annoying. I bought a scale several years ago but it is just today that I found out what a cup of flour is supposed to weigh, and it is still not certain.

Default-small

3 months ago fionula

what would it hurt to have both ? no one is proselytizing.

Default-small

12 months ago Jennifer P

Alice - I have been a fan of yours since Cocolat in Berkley!! So glad to see you will be a regular contributor.

Alice.medrich.deborah.jones_-360x360

12 months ago Alice Medrich

I completely agree. Weighing is the best and metric is best of all. But we move slowly here. My upcoming books are all metric as well as cups and spoons! Thanks for your comment.

New_years_kitchen_hlc_only

12 months ago AntoniaJames

AntoniaJames is a trusted source on Bread/Baking.

I started using a scale for breadmaking quite some time ago. I use my own wild yeast levain, and the author of the book I used to capture and develop my starter (William Alexander, "52 Loaves") provides recipes only in weight, so it sort of became a habit. It's so much easier than volume measuring.

Now, my question for you: I almost always convert volume-based recipes by using the nutrition information from the side of the bags/boxes/jars of ingredients, which in the U.S. always include grams as well as well as volume, except certain liquids, which provide metric volumes. (It's particularly helpful for messy ingredients, such as peanut butter! One really appreciates the advantages of not having to wash a measuring cup and spatula covered with peanut butter.) I realize that the correlation between how a recipe was actually measured in volume when tested by the author, and the weight/volume ratios stated by the manufacturer, may not always be accurate. In general though, I've found this method to work just fine for pie crusts, quick breads, cookies, brownies and yeast breads. Do you think this practice is too risky for cakes and the like? It worked for -- and in fact, improved -- my mother's old-school sour cream pound cake. I'm wondering, however, about other more delicate cakes, where not getting it "right" might make more of a difference. What do you think? As always, thank you so much. ;o)

Default-small

12 months ago Debwoudhuysen

Should also have said I love your books, especially Chewy, Gooey etc. Your lemon thin biscuits (as we call cookies) have become a much admired staple.

Default-small

12 months ago Debwoudhuysen

I know this is a very European point (as a UK admirer and user of this site) but I really don't understand why you don't just weigh things - then you can be as accurate as possible.

Gator_cake

12 months ago hardlikearmour

hardlikearmour is a trusted home cook.

Probably for the same reason we don't switch to the metric system ;-)

Default-small

12 months ago Debwoudhuysen

Not sure I follow this - you can weigh in pounds and ounces too (as I often do being old enough to have learned to cook in imperial).

Birthdaygirlmick

5 months ago SuperWittySmitty

The implication being that Americans are so behinds when it comes to weighing and measuring, as evidenced by our insistence on retaining this old-fashioned system. I use both in my kitchen- my Grandma from germany didn't know from grams or ounces- she used measuring cups and teaspoons, and she didn't talk down like a snob to those who did things in another way.