Monica's Sour Cream and Chive Mashed Potatoes

By • September 21, 2011 • 17 Comments



Author Notes: This recipe is from my late mother-in-law Monica. I’ve never had mashed potatoes that even come close to how delicious these are. With both cream cheese and sour cream, they’re the perfect balance of creamy and tangy, with the chives at the end tempering the richness.

Monica was a great cook without realizing she was one. She had a handful of dishes that she proudly served at holidays, family gatherings and bridge parties, and this dish were one of them. My husband and his two sisters requested these potatoes for every birthday dinner (with a big grilled steak, being the born-and-bred Nebraskans they are), and the first time I tasted them, I completely understood why.

Here are a few important tips that I picked up from Monica during the countless times I watched her make them. (1) Generously salt your cooking water. Yes, you can and should add salt to taste at the end, but you need to season the potatoes well while they’re cooking. (2) Put away your fancy potato ricer or food mill when making these. Use your trusty hand mixer, or if you must, your standing one. (3) Keep tasting and seasoning as you go -- and keep tinkering ‘til you get it right. (4) Don’t even think about leaving the chives out. The chives are so important that on several Thanksgivings, my husband and I have gone on a wild goose chase trying to hunt them down.

When I asked my husband if I could share his mom’s recipe, his response was, “Is the world ready for that much sour cream and cream cheese in the same bowl?” I suspect the answer to that question is Yes.
EmilyC

Food52 Review: Okay. I love mashed potatoes, but I never knew what that truly meant until I tasted this absolutely addictive spin on the dish. I ended up eating an entire bowl for dinner with nothing else, because they were that good. I've never seen nor heard of cream cheese in mashed potatoes and it's one of those “aha” moments. Seriously, why haven't I been doing this all along? It adds a richness and creaminess that is really, really good. It's easy to see why this is on EmilyC's Thanksgiving table every year. The chives are also a refreshing addition and help cut the rich potatoes. I will make this again and again. figgypudding

Serves 8

  • 5 lb potatoes, peeled and cut into large chunks (Monica always used red potatoes, but yukon gold also work)
  • 8 oz cream cheese, cut into large pieces (at room temperature)
  • 1 cup sour cream (at room temperature)
  • 4 T butter (at room temperature)
  • kosher salt + freshly ground pepper to taste
  • 1/4 cup finely chopped chives
  1. In a large pot, cover potatoes with cold water and season generously with salt. Bring to a boil, then lower heat to maintain a simmer. Cook until the potatoes are tender, about 20 minutes. Drain, and either return to the same pan, or place in a large bowl for combining with other ingredients.
  2. While potatoes are still hot, start mixing in the remaining ingredients using a hand mixer with beater attachments. Add the cream cheese first (a few pieces at a time) and mix until thoroughly combined. It's important to start with the cream cheese because it's the ingredient that benefits the most from the hot potatoes when mixing. Next, add the sour cream, then the butter, mixing thoroughly after each addition. Continue mixing until the potatoes are smooth, creamy, and lump-free. You may want to stop a few times and clean the sides and bottom of your mixing bowl with a spatula. Season to taste with kosher salt and freshly ground black pepper.
  3. A few notes: I like to add the cream cheese, sour cream, and butter at room temperature to make the mixing easier, but Monica always used them straight from the fridge. If you want, you can start with lesser (say 3/4) amounts of the cream cheese, sour cream and butter and then tinker with the quantities to taste at the end, but 9 out of 10 times I've done this, I've ended up adding the full amounts. Trust me, these potatoes are worth the indulgence.
  4. Mix in chives. Serve and savor every bite.
Jump to Comments (17)

Tags: best mashed potatoes, chives, cream cheese, holiday side dish, sour cream

Comments (17) Questions (0)

Default-small
Default-small
Open-uri20140816-14542-1rtgnoj

12 days ago ColleenRodden

I am making this for a Birthday dinner tonight. Have to double the recipe. I will let you know how they turn out. I am excited.

Img_7818

12 days ago EmilyC

Really hope you like them! My husband requests these for his birthday. And happy b'day to you.

Stringio

8 months ago glenfrank

Awesome! Making this tonight along with the steak...

Img_7818

8 months ago EmilyC

Great -- hope it's a hit!

Cumberland_pass_atv_trip_-_july_20__2013_019

9 months ago JanetFL

These are definitely my kind of mashed potatoes! Butter, cream cheese and sour cream - yum!

Img_7818

8 months ago EmilyC

Thanks Janet! It seems like overkill with all three but it's not!

Dscn3274

9 months ago inpatskitchen

Congrats on the CP Emily! I make almost the exact recipe and what's really great about it is than you can make it the day before and and re warm in a crockpot the day of!

Img_7818

9 months ago EmilyC

Thanks IPK! I've never used the crockpot trick but my sister-in-law just told me about it. Glad to know it works well! By the way, these potatoes are amazing as the base for the Genius potato cake recipe posted a few weeks ago! http://food52.com/blog...

Dscn3274

9 months ago inpatskitchen

Thanks for the tip! If we have any leftover after Christmas, I will definitely make them.

Photo_(14)

9 months ago foxeslovelemons

Haha YES. The world is ready for this recipe! I did sour cream and chive mashed for Thanksgiving, but now I wish I would have put some cream cheese in there too! Congrats on the CP.

Img_7818

9 months ago EmilyC

Thanks Lori! And definitely try the cream cheese -- you may never go back! : )

Default-small

9 months ago LLStone

EmilyC, I had a recipe for this many years ago that I've lost. It was much like this, but substituted mayo for butter (in roughly the same quantities) and it could be frozen forever. You just had to thaw a day before then bake. I always wondered about butter instead of mayo, and am curious if you've ever frozen this? I assumed maybe the sour cream made it more freeze-friendly.... I agree, this is a killer potato.

Img_7818

9 months ago EmilyC

I'll ask my husband if his mom ever froze these potatoes. We've never tried, mostly because any leftovers disappear quickly. I've always been surprised how well these reheat in the microwave, straight from the fridge! By the way, I see you're from Evansville. I grew up about an hour NW, on the Illinois side, and Evansville is where we'd go for bigger shopping trips, etc. It's a good part of the world.

Img_7818

9 months ago EmilyC

My sister-in-law and brother confirmed on Thanksgiving that their mom used to freeze these potatoes with good results!

Img_7818

9 months ago EmilyC

Oops, typing too fast, meant to say my sister-in-law and husband!

3-bizcard

almost 3 years ago sdebrango

Suzanne is a trusted source on General Cooking.

YUM! Love these mashed potatoes.

Img_7818

almost 3 years ago EmilyC

They're worth every single calorie! We have them every Thanksgiving, and it's the dish we most look forward to!