Dad's Favorite Seafood Stew

By • October 16, 2011 • 112 Comments

1,326 Save

If you like it, save it!

Save and organize all of the stuff you love in one place.

Got it!

If you like something…

Click the heart, it's called favoriting. Favorite the stuff you like.

Got it!


Author Notes: Our family was in the retail fish and seafood business for almost 80 years and during the course of time hundreds of seafood recipes were collected, tested and developed. Dad came up with this one years ago and it's been a family favorite for those of us who love the fruits of the sea. An impressive, but easy, company dish for four to six....Serve it up with crusty bread !inpatskitchen

Food52 Review: WHO: inpatskitchen is an avid FOOD52-er and food blogger -- with fish and seafood retail in her blood.
WHAT: A bright, pure seafood stew that comes together in just 20 minutes.
HOW: Simmer tomatoes, stock, and wine, add seafood, simmer some more, and garnish. (That's it!)
WHY WE LOVE IT: This stew tastes of the sea -- if the sea was delicately perfumed with tomatoes, aromatics, and herbs. Plus, the broth was so good that we drank it on it's own.
The Editors

Serves 4 to 6

  • 1/3 cup extra virgin olive oil
  • 4 crushed garlic cloves
  • 6 peeled and seeded roma tomatoes cut into thin strips
  • 1 cup homemade fish stock, purchased seafood stock or clam juice
  • 1/2 cup dry white wine
  • 1 pound skinned saltwater fish filets(snapper, sole, halibut, cod) cut into 2 inch chunks
  • 16 large peeled and deveined raw shrimp
  • 16 sea scallops
  • 1/2 cup finely shredded fresh basil leaves
  • 1/2 cup chopped flat leaf parsley
  1. Heat the oil in a 4 to 6 quart dutch oven or sauce pot. Add the crushed garlic and saute on very low heat for about two minutes or until the garlic is fragrant but not browned.
  2. Add the tomatoes, stock and wine and simmer for about 10 minutes. (At this point you can cool and refrigerate this if you want to prep a day ahead - just reheat before adding the seafood)
  3. Add the fish and seafood and simmer for about 5 minutes until just done (Don't over cook!). Stir in the parsley and basil and serve immediately ( with that crusty bread!!)
  • This recipe is a Wildcard Contest Winner!
Jump to Comments (112)

Tags: fish, scallops, shirmp

Comments (112) Questions (1)

Default-small
Default-small
Default-small

6 days ago Janice Robinson

I have gathered all the ingredients for this recipe and will be making a special dinner. I am not an experienced cook. My question is will there be enough broth with only a cup of clam juice and a 1/2 c of wine? Thank you. Janice

Dscn3274

6 days ago inpatskitchen

The seafood will give off some liquid but if you're concerned, instead of fresh tomatoes (since they're not in season around here) use a 15 ounce can of really good Roma tomatoes like San Marzano and their juice. I find this works best in winter. Hope you enjoy!

Default-small

19 days ago Soleil

Here in Dubai, we have the day off tomorrow with it being our UAE National Day. This soup is on the menu for tomorrow, however, I will be adding some scallops and kalamari to this beautiful recipe! I cannot wait! Sahteeen!

Dscn3274

19 days ago inpatskitchen

Sounds great! Enjoy your Holiday!

Stringio

about 1 month ago Lynn Frost

What coud I substitute for the clam juice(but still will add flavor) as I have a severe allergy

Dscn3274

about 1 month ago inpatskitchen

You might try a shrimp broth or a fish broth. Chicken broth could sub but won't give you as much seafood flavor.

Default-small

about 1 month ago PlainCheesecake

Made this dish last night and it was such a hit at the table. As per some of the comments, I used canned San Marzano tomatoes, just cod, added in sliced baby Dutch Gold potatoes (I'd soaked them earlier to remove some of the starch), and a pinch of crushed red pepper. The broth IS the best part. It's incredibly adaptable and looking forward to making it again.

Dscn3274

about 1 month ago inpatskitchen

Totally agree with you about the broth! Thanks so much!!

Open-uri20141101-1058-17onqfz

about 1 month ago Spencer Dylan Smith

I have been making this for years. An addition I have added is that I make a sauce of mayo, rice wine vinegar, and cayenne. You whisk them all together and refrigerate for an hour or so. Drizzle this on top of the soup and then the parsley on top of that. It adds a good acidic zing and a little spicy kick.

Dscn3274

about 1 month ago inpatskitchen

Sounds wonderful!!

Open-uri20131006-11355-1o9e909

2 months ago Romney Lewis

This has been my go to recipe for quite a while. Just thought I would stop by to say thanks.

Dscn3274

2 months ago inpatskitchen

Thanks so much Romney! Thrilled it's your "go to"

Default-small

3 months ago Susan

My 14 year old daughter asked for seafood soup, so going to try this tonight!! So excited. Adding little neck clams & mussels instead of scallops, along with cod & shrimp. Will have to go with canned tomatoes and I just used up all my fresh garden heirloom tomatoes. Also adding fresh corn on cob, 2-3 inch size pieces as its still available here in Iowa. Also fresh thyme instead of basil because she loves that flavor. Also will make stock from the shrimp shells. Thanks-so glad I found this site. I love that its your dad's favorite and that I can modify to fit our needs!

Dscn3274

3 months ago inpatskitchen

Your version sounds wonderful Susan and good canned tomatoes work perfectly! Thanks for trying this and welcome to Food52!!

Default-small

3 months ago Debbie

Hi! Okay this was delicious! it made a lot too- granted I added more stock and the liquid I steamed the muscles in- just amazingly yummy. Even heard "best soup I've ever had"(it looked like more like a soup than a stew when all was said and done) which is quite a statement in a house that doesn't typically eat a lot of seafood. My question is- how long can this be in the fridge though? I don't know the rules since I don't cook seafood often :)Thank you for the recipe!!! It was awesome!!

Dscn3274

3 months ago inpatskitchen

Hi Debbie! So happy you enjoyed. I've kept it a couple of days in the fridge and then gently reheated it.

Default-small

4 months ago Carole

Thanks for the fish stock recipe; really excited to do it all!

Dscn3274

4 months ago inpatskitchen

Thank YOU Carole! Please let me know how it goes..

Default-small

4 months ago Carole

This looks fantastic! I would like to try to make my own fish stock since what I can buy at our local fish store is too heavily salted for my taste. Could you please recommend a method (ingredients and technique) so that I can have a great base for your seafood stew?

Dscn3274

4 months ago inpatskitchen

Hi Carole! If you scroll down through the comments you can find my recipe for fish stock. It involves fish frames, onion, celery, bay leaf and butter. I sure hope you enjoy!

Default-small

4 months ago Andrew

Hi, thanks for posting this recipe. I have never made seafood anything before, and decided to try this since it seems simple. I used defrosted bagged cod, jumbo shrimp, and bay scallops. I put in the correct amount of everything except there was a little less wine because the bottle ran out (not too much less though), and I used refridgerated minced garlic (a little over a tablespoon probably) cause I did not have garlic cloves. I deveined and peeled the shrimp and also peeled and deseeded the tomatos (tedious!). I just have some questions:
1) my broth came out kind of yellow. Any idea why it is not red like the picture?
2) it is a bit bland to me, but obviously a ton of people like it, so I am wondering if it's because I did not use the cloves of garlic? Or perhaps I should just experiment with spices?

Thanks for your time and response. Overal it did taste good though, I am proud of my first seafood stew attempt! Thanks for providing this recipe for me.

Dscn3274

4 months ago inpatskitchen

Hi Andrew! Welcome to Food52! I'm flattered that you tried this but sorry to hear you thought it a bit bland. Maybe it was the garlic (I've never used the bottled) and the tomatoes really need to be at their peak. If you make it again try substituting a 15 ounce can of really good San Marzano tomatoes if very ripe fresh ones aren't available. Some have said they add a little crushed red pepper also. But do make sure you stir in the fresh parsley and basil right at the end. Hope you give it another try!

Default-small

4 months ago Andrew

Thanks for the advice, I definitely will try this again!

Stringio

4 months ago Starmade

I love how quick and simple this is. It is irresistible to mess with it, a bit, if you have other good veg in the fridge, so I fried some small fresh whole okra from the farmers market with the garlic, then added potato diced in about half inch cubes, with the liquids. Added fish when potato was almost done. The broth is a little bit clouded by the potato starch, not clear like the picture, but still pink and fresh and flavorful.

Dscn3274

4 months ago inpatskitchen

Thanks so much Claire! Your version sounds wonderful!

036

4 months ago aargersi

Abbie is a trusted source on General Cooking.

Yay congratulations! Friday dinner is decided!

Dscn3274

4 months ago inpatskitchen

Sure hope you enjoy this Abbie! It really is a family favorite!

Default-small

5 months ago Kaede Sullivan

I just made this for dinner. It is delightful and perfect with crusty baguette! I added some mussels and finished it off with a pinch of red pepper flakes.

Dscn3274

5 months ago inpatskitchen

Thanks so much Kaede! Love the mussels and red pepper flakes! So happy you enjoyed!

Stringio

7 months ago Heather Diamond-Guzzi

Should you add yukon gold potatoes to make it heartier or no?

Dscn3274

7 months ago inpatskitchen

I've never thought of putting potatoes in this stew but I have added pasta to stretch it out a bit. If you try potatoes please let me know how it goes.

Default-small

9 months ago Lisa

Made it for the second time tonight. Accidentally used red wine instead of white...still came out delicious. Served it over brown rice & grains. Also added asparagus...worked nicely.

Dscn3274

9 months ago inpatskitchen

Thanks Lisa! So happy you enjoyed!

Default-small

9 months ago chris

Can you add wild rice to the stew?

Dscn3274

9 months ago inpatskitchen

Hi Chris!
I've never thought of rice of any kind for this stew.....pasta maybe....but you sure could give it a shot. Just make sure to cook the wild rice separately since it requires a long cooking time.

Stringio

10 months ago Gillian McKnight- Tutein

Good googly moogly that was DELICIOUS!!!! So simple, wholesome, hearty, and and and. I could go on and on about this one. Thank you!

Dscn3274

10 months ago inpatskitchen

Thank YOU Gillian!

Anotherfoodieblogger_about_me_image

10 months ago anotherfoodieblogger

I just stumbled upon this recipe browsing the wildcards. YUM! I'm saving this to surprise my husband with, he adores sea food dishes!

Dscn3274

10 months ago inpatskitchen

Thanks! Hope you both enjoy...it's definitely one of our favorites!

Img_0114

11 months ago Petite fee

awesome flavor! merci!

Dscn3274

11 months ago inpatskitchen

Thank you! So happy you enjoyed!