Mary's Healthy Ice Cream Sandwiches

By • September 6, 2012 • 4 Comments

35 Save

Author Notes: This recipe comes from my father-in-law’s girlfriend, Mary -- an ice cream sandwich is one of her go-to evening snacks. Mary toasts two slices of whole wheat bread, and, while the bread’s still warm, smushes a scoop of chocolate ice cream between the slices. Et voila, an instant ice cream sandwich that's the rag-tag cousin of pain au chocolat. Mary insists the whole wheat bread makes it healthy. I like Mary.Amanda Hesser

Makes 4 sandwiches

  • 8 slices of your favorite whole wheat bread
  • 4 large scoops of your favorite chocolate ice cream
  1. We all know this isn't much of a recipe, but for the sake of getting this combination on record, here goes!
  2. Use a 3-inch cookie cutter to cut a circle from each slice of bread. (Save the bread "frames" for making Toad in the Hole.) Set out your ice cream. While it warms up enough to scoop, toast the bread circles. Place a scoop of ice cream between two warm toast circles. Smush like a panini. When the ice cream squeezes out to the edges, it's ready to hand off to a hungry guest. Repeat with the remaining toast circles!
Jump to Comments (4)

Comments (4) Questions (0)


23 days ago Antigoni Sander McCloud

Ha ha ha! Thank you!


23 days ago Antigoni Sander McCloud

I don't know Mary, but I TOTALLY like her too! This is pretty genius!


23 days ago Amanda Hesser

Amanda is a co-founder of Food52.

I'm having dinner with Mary tonight -- will let her know!


about 2 years ago recipes

looks YUMMY