Christmas
Black Bottom Oatmeal Pie
Popular on Food52
16 Reviews
scariana
November 1, 2020
i followed this recipe exactly the first time i made it and it tasted so good — like a chocolate chip oatmeal cookie in pie form, but gooier (so therefore better). the second time, i used a pre-made gluten-free crust that i parbaked and substituted pancake syrup (the kind with corn syrup, not actual maple syrup!) for the dark corn syrup and it was just as good, especially with some homemade whipped cream! highly highly recommend
Kathryn M.
July 27, 2017
Read all the comments. It sounded good but smells heavenly while baking. I inceased the recipe by 1/2 and baked it in two 8-inch pans. I had to use @ 1/3 light corn syrup (7/8 cup dark corn syrup, @ 1/8 cup molasses, & 1/2 cup light cirn syrup) because I didn't have enough of dark. Also used Bob's RedMill "quick-cooking" Scottish oatmeal, which should give a nice chew to the texture. It smells so good. Can't wait to share!
Elizabeth F.
November 28, 2014
This pie was a hit at Thanksgiving! One of my favorite pies is chocolate bourbon pecan pie. It's always made me sad that I couldn't share it with my pecan-allergic husband, so this was a great alternative. Next time I'm going to add bourbon. :)
Tracie
November 19, 2014
Could I make this pie the weekend before Thanksgiving? Should I freeze it in between?
missfats
March 12, 2014
Incredibly simple: the ideal pie for everyday eating. The recipe was awesome. Followed the directions to the line and it came out perfectly. The pie reminded me of breakfast so I adapted it to include banana. Welcome to breakfast pie:
http://missfats.wordpress.com/2014/03/11/black-bottom-banana-oatmeal-breakfast-pie/
http://missfats.wordpress.com/2014/03/11/black-bottom-banana-oatmeal-breakfast-pie/
amysarah
December 1, 2013
I made this pie for Thanksgiving and it was fantastic - very sweet, almost more of a confection than a pie, a bit like Momofuku's famous Crack Pie (but even better, I think.) I added about 3/4 - 1 cup toasted coconut along with the oats - inspired by one of my favorite cookies (oatmeal/coconut/chocolate chip.) Made it extra delicious.
Miss F.
November 28, 2013
This pie did not work out for me at all. I cooked it at 325 as suggested for about 70 minutes and it never cooked all the way through or solidified much at all, not sure what happened. But the gooey mess afterwards tasted like it would have been delicious had it cooked properly.
Michelle
November 27, 2013
WOW! Just dug in to ours. Cheated by using a WF Spelt crust - actually am really glad as it created a lovely texture for the pie. I subbed Lyles Golden for the dark corn syrup but otherwise pretty much made as written. I HUGELY recommend.
Bex A.
November 25, 2013
THIS IS MY FAVORITE PIE OF YOURS. I am so excited because you did not offer it for holiday preorder and I was sad.
Hiromi M.
November 24, 2013
It sounds like it is too sweet as is. I wonder I can use 1/2 cup brown sugar and 1/2 syrup. I will have to try...
Chrisi
November 19, 2013
I just made this tonight and am very pleased with the results! I'm telling myself I did it to test for a bake sale donation next week, but, let's face it, I'm a sucker for trying new and unusual dessert recipes!
I try not to use corn syrup, so as a subsitute I used dark brown sugar instead of light and instead of corn syrup I used honey. Taking in SideworkEnds suggestions, I also added a pinch extra of ginger and Mexican vanilla extract instead of standard (it adds a hint of cinnamon - or you could use standard vanilla and cinnamon). I usually make pie crust from scratch, but, because this technically was a test, I used a deep dish 9 inch frozen crust I had on hand, and it worked out just fine.
This is definitely a sweet pie - it's like a deconstructed oatmeal chocolate chip cookie met a pecan pie (minus the pecans). Overall, simple to put together, and great end result!
I try not to use corn syrup, so as a subsitute I used dark brown sugar instead of light and instead of corn syrup I used honey. Taking in SideworkEnds suggestions, I also added a pinch extra of ginger and Mexican vanilla extract instead of standard (it adds a hint of cinnamon - or you could use standard vanilla and cinnamon). I usually make pie crust from scratch, but, because this technically was a test, I used a deep dish 9 inch frozen crust I had on hand, and it worked out just fine.
This is definitely a sweet pie - it's like a deconstructed oatmeal chocolate chip cookie met a pecan pie (minus the pecans). Overall, simple to put together, and great end result!
SideworkEnds
November 18, 2013
I was intrigued by this recipe and made the pie over the weekend as an audition for a Thanksgiving dessert.
I like it a lot, but am not in love with it. I find it just a bit too sweet. I think next time I make this, I will ratchet up the ginger a notch and add a bit of cinnamon as well.
On the positive side, the all butter pie crust recipe is flawless, and given the sweetness factor, this pie is a perfect companion to a strong cup coffee or tea. Also, it doesn't say in the recipe, but in the book the chefs advise lightly buttering the pie plate before laying in the crust. Which is a revelation. I can't believe I never did that before.
I like it a lot, but am not in love with it. I find it just a bit too sweet. I think next time I make this, I will ratchet up the ginger a notch and add a bit of cinnamon as well.
On the positive side, the all butter pie crust recipe is flawless, and given the sweetness factor, this pie is a perfect companion to a strong cup coffee or tea. Also, it doesn't say in the recipe, but in the book the chefs advise lightly buttering the pie plate before laying in the crust. Which is a revelation. I can't believe I never did that before.
See what other Food52ers are saying.