Milk/Cream
Homemade Pop Tarts
Popular on Food52
11 Reviews
amanda R.
March 22, 2020
Made these today and they are pretty delicious. I made my own strawberry jam and did get 8 pop-tarts, with re-rolling scraps. I brushed them with milk, and sprinkled with sugar, and baked for about 30 minutes total. Then I made a simple sugar and milk glaze to go on top.
Änneken
November 6, 2016
I made those yesterday and they came out perfectly! I doubled the batch and it yielded 22 pop tarts (3x4 inches). I love that the pastry has only very little sugar in it which creates a great contrast with the sweet jam and icing.
Babette
October 7, 2014
As hard as it is to forget the sugary, artificial deliciousness of real Pop Tarts, these ones can! They are so buttery and sweet, yet aren't nearly as bad for you as the originals. I recommend using all natural or organic ingredients to reduce the "guilt-factor" and also (if you're feeling extra nostalgic) pair these with hot chocolate and a few episodes of your favorite childhood TV show, and you're good to go! http://babetteandbuttons.wordpress.com
Vivian
October 5, 2014
Thank you Isobel. I will try these. My granddaughter loves chocolate pop tarts.
Vivian
October 5, 2014
Hi, if I wanted to use chocolate filling
, how would this work?
, how would this work?
Isobel
October 5, 2014
Hi! I'm not an expert, but I looked this recipe up : http://www.halfbakedharvest.com/homemade-chocolate-fudge-poptarts/
It's a chocolate pop tart recipe and it has instructions for a fudge filling. I think you could probably just use their filling with this recipe and it would work :)
It's a chocolate pop tart recipe and it has instructions for a fudge filling. I think you could probably just use their filling with this recipe and it would work :)
Isobel
September 30, 2014
This is an amazing recipe. My whole family adored my pop tarts (and they don't even like real pop tarts!)
The only problem is that they really don't make that many. It says 8, but I only got 6 out of the pastry. I would suggest either making 2 x 3 rectangles, or doubling the recipe for the dough.
I used mainly raspberry jam for the filling, but I actually put some rose jam in there. I think the rose jam was from a specialty store and made out of rose petals. It was very strong so I just mixed it in with the raspberry jam. It turned out amazing! I dyed the icing pink and decorated with crystalized roses. It turned the pop tarts into gourmet little pastries!
The only problem is that they really don't make that many. It says 8, but I only got 6 out of the pastry. I would suggest either making 2 x 3 rectangles, or doubling the recipe for the dough.
I used mainly raspberry jam for the filling, but I actually put some rose jam in there. I think the rose jam was from a specialty store and made out of rose petals. It was very strong so I just mixed it in with the raspberry jam. It turned out amazing! I dyed the icing pink and decorated with crystalized roses. It turned the pop tarts into gourmet little pastries!
Mandy S.
October 26, 2014
I agree, Isobel, I also only get 6 out of it. My son is nuts and didn't like them but I did!
See what other Food52ers are saying.