Summer
Classic Icebox Cake
Popular on Food52
13 Reviews
MLa
May 27, 2023
Oh SO SAD!!! I was so hankering for this favorite from childhood not too long ago only to find that the Nabisco Chocolate Wafers are no longer a thing. Not to be found anywhere. Anywhere. How is it possible that they were discontinued?? I started wondering though about the very thin Anna's Ginger Wafers. Maybe drizzle with chocolate sauce or shavings?
sdarlin
May 27, 2023
No clue. They have room for approximately 87,000 varieties of Oreos, and Triscuits, but not our beloved wafers. Harumph!
Mepallover
May 28, 2023
I just paid a lot for four boxes on eBay. Just received them. Wanted to make this classic one more time…….
MLa
May 28, 2023
I saw some ebay options but I'm squirmy about buying food on ebay and also had to wonder about whether they might be way stale. Were they stale?
sdarlin
May 27, 2023
I haven’t made this, because Nabisco discontinued their chocolate wafer cookies. Has anyone found a good substitute?
Kathi
May 27, 2023
We've tried this with chocolate graham crackers. We can't always find the Nabisco brand (did they discontinue those too??). In SoCal we found a store brand at Albertsons. The chocolate flavor came through really well. We also tested a brand called Dewey's Bakery but we felt the chocolate flavor wasn't there at all.
sdarlin
May 27, 2023
I was looking for them because I used them for my marble cheesecake. I don't know if they discontinued chocolate grahams, but I remember seeing the chocolate Teddy Grahams when I was looking. I'll probably use those next time I try to make it. Thanks!
andreas97
May 28, 2023
Dewey's Bakery brownie crisp cookies are the closest substitute for the now-discontinued Nabisco wafers. Almost exactly the same!
mdelgatty
August 24, 2020
We used to layer these vertically with whipped cream to form a log, and then slice it on the diagonal. Very pretty striped servings, not too big...
stephanieRD
July 13, 2020
Going to make this for hubby's birthday! First time making an icebox cake!
See what other Food52ers are saying.