Spring

Seared Scallops with Spring Onion and Tarragon Cream

April 13, 2010
5
2 Ratings
  • Serves 4 as a main course, more as a starter
Author Notes

About a year ago I had a wonderful dish of halibut cheeks served with grilled baby leeks and asparagus and a spring onion soubise at one of our favorite Providence restaurants, La Laiterie. That soubise has haunted me, and I’ve been waiting for just the right opportunity to try my hand at making a similar sauce at home. When this challenge was announced, I thought the super sweet Bomster scallops (from Stonington, CT) that we get at our local farmers market would pair beautifully, and happily I was right. The delicate onion flavor, in this instance enhanced with a hint of anise-y tarragon and the subtle tang of (you guessed it) crème fraiche, played really well with the caramelized scallops, and the pale green color of the sauce whispered “spring.” - lastnightsdinner —lastnightsdinner

Test Kitchen Notes

Lastnightsdinner's scallop recipe proves that when it comes to seafood, less is often more. With just a few simple ingredients (spring onions, tarragon, butter, flour and milk), she creates a zippy, creamy sauce that's the perfect foil for sweet flesh of the scallops. And her technique of drying the scallops in the refrigerator before searing them makes for an impeccably caramelized crust. - A&M —The Editors

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • 1 pound wild dry sea scallops
  • 4 tablespoons unsalted butter
  • 1 tablespoon unbleached all-purpose flour
  • 1 cup whole milk
  • Kosher or sea salt
  • 1 bunch spring onions, about ½ lb.
  • 2 tablespoons fresh tarragon leaves
  • grapeseed or other neutral oil
  • 2 tablespoons crème fraiche
  • fresh chives for garnish
Directions
  1. Place the scallops on a plate or platter and refrigerate, uncovered, for 30 minutes.
  2. Trim the spring onions, separating the green tops from the small bulbs. Dice the bulbs and roughly chop the greens.
  3. Melt the butter in a saucepan over medium heat. Add the chopped spring onion bulbs and a pinch of salt, reduce the heat to low, and cook 20-25 minutes, until very soft. Add the green tops, toss through, and cook an additional 5-10 minutes until soft but still bright green. Sprinkle the flour over and cook for a minute or two, just until the raw flour smell is gone. Add the milk, raising the heat to medium, and cook briefly until thickened. Add the tarragon leaves and stir through, then turn off the heat and pour the mixture into a blender. Puree until very smooth, then return to the pan over low heat, cooking until the mixture is thick enough to coat the back of a spoon.
  4. Pour a thin film of grapeseed oil in the bottom of a sauté pan and warm over medium-high heat until shimmering. Carefully add the scallops a few at a time, being careful not to crowd the pan, and sear them just couple of minutes per side until they are nicely browned and caramelized - they should release from the pan easily once they’re ready, and they should still be a little jiggly in the middle, as they will continue to cook off the heat. Set aside and keep warm.
  5. Taste the sauce and adjust salt if necessary. Whisk in the crème fraiche off the heat until the mixture is smooth, then spoon a little of the sauce into the bottom of shallow, warmed bowls, place scallops on top, and garnish with fresh chives.
Contest Entries

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Pescetarianpleasures.com
    Pescetarianpleasures.com
  • Chef Devaux
    Chef Devaux
  • Jordan
    Jordan
  • stephanieRD
    stephanieRD
  • Mark X
    Mark X

94 Reviews

PandorasBox December 20, 2020
Love, love, love it. I've been looking for something to do with scallops and this is it. The tarragon sauce is the greatest. I used it a few days later with salmon and will certainly make it a staple from now on. Thank you for the recipe.
 
PandorasBox December 20, 2020
Love, love, love it. I've been looking for something to do with scallops and this is it. The tarragon sauce is the greatest. I used it a few days later with salmon and will certainly make it a staple from now on. Thank you for the recipe.
 
wynn February 25, 2018
What do you suggest to serve this with in a warm climate?
 
Scallops are one of my favourite things in the world! I´ve never tried them with Tarragon though, this will be a first!
 
Chef D. November 28, 2015
:)
 
cabaniss June 13, 2015
can i do the sauce a day ahead
 
neighome June 13, 2015
I've made the sauce ahead of time without a problem. Just be sure to reheat very gently.
 
Nathan S. May 25, 2015
Awesome recipe. I used scallions instead of spring onions. This amount of sauce could probably be used for 1.5-2lbs of scallops in my opinion. While incredible, I think being conservative with anything accompanying scallops is wise. I used some of the left over sauce with some bucattini and it was perfect.
 
chubert April 13, 2015
Any suggestions for a wine pairing with this dish?
 
Jordan August 26, 2014
This was absolutely devine. The sauce was flavorful and delicious and complemented the sweet scallops perfectly, not to mention the fact that it makes for an absolutely beautiful presentation . Next time I will double the sauce and reserve half for use at another time.
 
stephanieRD July 18, 2014
The sauce is simply AMAZING. Made this for my love's birthday dinner last night, and he loved it. First time cooking scallops every, so I would say I conquered new culinary ground and it exceeded my expectations. Freezing the rest of the sauce and going to use it on something for dinner next week- maybe a good white fish? Shrimp? Possibilities are endless.
 
Mark X. May 8, 2014
Amazing recipe. I substituted leeks for the spring onions and it was a success!
 
Sashinka November 25, 2012
OMG! My husband just served me these and they are scrump-dilee-icitious!!! Thanks so much for sharing this recipe. He's already offered to make these for his parents, so they couldn't have been too much bother.
 
Davaritel November 25, 2012
I guess it goes without saying, but this a sper tasty dish. I had to make a few substitutions though: green onions instead of spring onions; skim milk instead of whole milk and crema mexicana instead of creme fraiche. Nevertheless, it was outstanding dish that I will make very often. The tarragon sauce was really amazing and adds some nice, fun color to the plate. Thanks for sharing!
 
MarieH November 4, 2012
I love this recipe and have made it several times as a company meal. Tarragon is a new herb for me and now I have it planted and cannot get enough. Thanks!!
 
ChefFace September 25, 2012
Thank you for this recipe. I served these as my main dish with citrus spritzed asparagus and some rosemary foccacia, huge hit. I didn't change a thing. LOVELY!
 
noahfactor August 1, 2012
My girlfriend and I made this last night and it was amazing! The sauce perfectly complimented the scallops. And the recipe was not too hard, it was the first time either of us had cooked scallops or made a cream sauce before and it all came out great.
 
neighome June 10, 2012
I finished each plate with a small sprinkle of fennel pollen. My guests loved it!
 
2nd F. April 30, 2012
Made this last night but I used regular green onions and I must say that the cream sauce is to die for I will be making this again
 
chrissyleer April 12, 2012
I found the sauce bland, but that may be because I used scallions. I think a squeeze of lemon juice may have helped!
 
chrissyleer April 12, 2012
I found the sauce bland, but that may be because I used scallions. I think a squeeze of lemon juice may have helped!
 
oldkitcheninflatbush March 28, 2012
I used watercress. i don't like tarragon. Worked great with scallops. Served it with a simple risotto. It was very good. Thanks.
 
oldkitcheninflatbush March 28, 2012
I used watercress. i don't like tarragon. Worked great with scallops. Served it with a simple risotto. It was very good. Thanks.
 
Laurenzim October 5, 2011
This was a fantastic dish and beautiful to plate!!!
 
phyllis August 19, 2011
I cooked this for dinner tonight for my adult children and it was a huge hit. Not the right time of year to get spring onions so I used leeks and scallions. It's a really lovely dish. Thank you.
 
MonicaL May 26, 2011
I'm very excited to try these out for dinner tomorrow. Can you recommend sides to go with this? And how do you ideally present the scallops. As a stand-alone course. In the picture it is by itself so was hoping for some guidance. Thanks!
 
amreiskitchen April 14, 2011
I made this a few nights ago and as everyone has already said, the sauce is to die for. My husband went bananas ha nearly ate the plate! The perfect foil for so many things and so simple. Definitely a keeper.
 
cookie27 April 12, 2011
great recipe for scallops! but the cream sauce is to die for... i've used it in lots of ways, even spread on multigrain bread, covered with a slice of cheese and broiled for lunch. yummm. i'm tempted to eat it with a spoon!
 
lastnightsdinner April 12, 2011
Thank you! I'm so glad you liked it!
 
cookie27 April 12, 2011
forgot to mention... this sauce is great with steamed artichokes too!
 
Sam1148 April 13, 2011
This is why I think it's such a great recipe..that shouldn't just be limited to scallops.
It works in many ways. I used leftovers on asparagus and it keeps beautifully in the 'fridge for a day or so..plus the color makes it look great on a plate.
 
Sam1148 April 9, 2011
I want to thank you. I made this last it and it was a major hit, a keeper.
I couldn't find really good scallops, so I used up some vac-paced talipa and cooked them with clarified butter and a crust of "Wondera Flour" and some drops of lemon/olive oil to the sauce after plating.
Well done!
 
lastnightsdinner April 9, 2011
Thank you so much! And glad to hear the sauce worked with other seafood - your prep sounds lovely!
 
hazeddazed March 31, 2011
making this tonight! so excited!
 
sygyzy January 22, 2011
I made this tonight and it was really really good. The star of the dish is of course the sauce, which tastes like it could work with almost any protein. I see using it with a firm fish like swordfish or even grilled chicken breast. I used 6 oz of green onion, half a medium yellow onion, and a large shallot. I also used dried tarragon instead of fresh after failing to find it in three stores. Really, amazing recipe.
 
J. A. January 16, 2011
I just made this. It was delicious! I used scallions instead of spring onions.
 
lastnightsdinner January 16, 2011
Thank you so much! Scallions are a perfect substitute :) So glad you enjoyed it!
 
MsChristina September 18, 2010
oh and side note: add toasted pinenuts on top!!!! :D
 
MsChristina September 18, 2010
i absolutely LOVEDDDDD this recipe!!! didn't have spring onion because it's not spring anymore, but used leek stems and diced yellow onions. this was definitely pleasing to the palate :)
 
lastnightsdinner January 16, 2011
Thanks, MsChristina! So glad you tried and liked it, and I love your addition of toasted pine nuts!
 
lastnightsdinner May 2, 2010
Thanks, all, for your congrats, and thank you to all who have tried this and liked it - I'm so thrilled.
 
Veronica May 2, 2010
Oh my heavens--sublime! FINALLY made this last night--my husband and I are still swooning. He's leaving on business tomorrow so I get to finish the sauce, however I please! Thank you for this marvelous addition and CONGRATULATIONS!
 
Kabocha April 30, 2010
I made this last night and it was so delicious... but be careful to not add too much tarragon or the anise flavour will overwhelm the sauce.
 
shayma April 29, 2010
Congrats, Jen, love love love this recipe. You rock. xxxx shayma
 
Refrigerator M. April 29, 2010
This recipe looks amazing. I cannot wait to try it.
 
Kayb April 29, 2010
Congrats! I'm trying this sauce on SOMETHING this weekend. Scallops if I can find decent ones!
 
maryvelasquez April 28, 2010
Lovely! So glad this simple but delicious dish will be in the book.
 
TasteFood April 28, 2010
Congratulations LND. This is a great recipe!
 
coffeefoodwrite April 28, 2010
Congrats LND! looking forward to trying them!
 
melissav April 28, 2010
Congrats LND! You are a force to be reckoned with. If you keep it up, A&M are going to have to rename the cookbook to the "Food 52 & LND Cookbook."
 
lastnightsdinner April 28, 2010
Thanks so much! I was convinced your scallops would win - such a wonderful recipe, and the roasted lemons are inspired! I can't wait to make it at home soon.
 
amreen April 28, 2010
Yay! Congrats ... i love the cobos in this dish ... simple and elegant ... can't wait to try it!
 
MrsWheelbarrow April 28, 2010
I made this last weekend. The sauce was intoxicating. I saved the last little bit from the pot and enjoyed it the next day over asparagus. Really, I'm sure it would be good poured over almost anything, but with the scallops, it's fantastic.
 
Oui, C. April 28, 2010
Congrats, LND on another great win! Gotta keep my eyes open for these Bomster scallops.
 
lastnightsdinner April 28, 2010
I've been in meetings all morning - what a thrill to see this when I came out! Thank you all SO much!
 
drbabs April 28, 2010
Congratulations on the win! I never make scallops--my husband is allergic--but I'm looking forward to trying the sauce.
 
mrslarkin April 28, 2010
Congrats, LND! This is a beautiful recipe.
 
arielleclementine April 28, 2010
congratulations, lastnightsdinner! a beautiful recipe :)
 
SallyCan April 24, 2010
A lovely recipe~I love the mix of spring onions, tarragon and creme fraiche.
 
Veronica April 23, 2010
Congratulations and thank you! Can NOT wait to try this. It looks and "feels/smells" gorgeous"!
 
lastnightsdinner April 23, 2010
Thanks again, everyone! You sure know how to make a girl blush :)
 
Oui, C. April 23, 2010
Tarragon is an absolute favorite of mine, and so good with seafood. Congratulations, and thanks for such a great recipe.
 
mariaraynal April 23, 2010
Tarragon is one of those underused, underappreciated herbs. You've elevated it to something truly special in this dish. Congrats!
 
Aliwaks April 22, 2010
beautiful ! i want them in my mouth..now!
 
Kelsey B. April 22, 2010
Congrats! What a yummy and pretty recipe!
 
TheWimpyVegetarian April 22, 2010
CONGRATS on being a finalist with such a great recipe!! I'm buying some scallops today and am planning on this for dinner. It sounds just wonderful!!
 
TasteFood April 22, 2010
Congratulations LND! This recipe sounds simply luxurious.
 
lastnightsdinner April 22, 2010
Thanks so much, everyone! I'm so honored and humbled, particularly going up against such great competition!
 
melissav April 22, 2010
Congrats. This is a great dish. As I mention below, I made it with pompano and then I used the leftover sauce with scallops the next night. And if that wasn't enough, I made the sauce on Monday and tossed it with sauteed summer squash, peas, and pasta. It was delicious.
 
monkeymom April 22, 2010
Yay! Congrats, can't wait to class up my joint by making this.
 
Lizthechef April 22, 2010
Brava, brava and yes, I-told-you-so :)
 
dymnyno April 21, 2010
I made the sauce...somehow way too thick. Delicious but I thought that the amount in your pic was waaay to much for the scallop...soo rich !
 
EmilyNunn April 20, 2010
Oh, my gosh. I'm absolutely dying. Die-ing.

And can I just say that I am so jealous that you have scallops at your farmers market? We don't do that here in Chicago.
 
katekirk April 18, 2010
As promised...made this tonight and wow wow wow delicious. I think I over-thickened the sauce - tasted great, though. I have a dinner party planned in a couple of weeks and will plan on doing this for a starter. Wonderful, thank you!
 
Kayb April 16, 2010
I believe I could eat that sauce with a spoon.
 
Oui, C. April 15, 2010
Tarragon is my favorite herb....period. This is definitely the next way I will be making scallops.
 
lastnightsdinner April 16, 2010
I hope you like it!
 
melissav April 15, 2010
I made the spring onion soubise tonight and served it with a piece of fresh Florida pompano. It took every bit of self-control not to just pour the sauce in a bowl and eat it like a soup. It was that good - and I didn't even add the creme fraiche. Great recipe.
 
lastnightsdinner April 16, 2010
Wow, thank you!

(and I spent a lot of time in Florida when I was younger - there's nothing like fresh pompano. I miss it!)
 
meganvt01 April 15, 2010
That caramelization on those scallops looks amazing. Do you use non-stick or an anodized pan to get that finish?
 
lastnightsdinner April 15, 2010
Thanks! I used an 11-inch All-Clad Stainless French Skillet for the scallops.
 
MrsWheelbarrow April 14, 2010
This is a gorgeous recipe. Yum. My tarragon is just greening up in the garden and I can't wait to give this a try.
 
lastnightsdinner April 15, 2010
Thank you, my friend :)
 
katekirk April 14, 2010
THIS is on my weekend menu.
 
lastnightsdinner April 15, 2010
I hope you like it!
 
lastnightsdinner April 14, 2010
Thanks so much, everyone!

mrslarkin, there are a couple of different types of soubise sauces - Escoffier has a version which is basically onions cooked slowly with a bechamel (which is what I tried to do here), Julia Child did a rice-based version, and there are soubise recipes on the internet that are neither.
 
mrslarkin April 14, 2010
Thanks so much for the tips! Will check them out. P.S. I love all your recipes - they are very inspiring.
 
TheWimpyVegetarian April 13, 2010
Fabulous!
 
monkeymom April 13, 2010
Lovely!
 
mrslarkin April 13, 2010
ohhh....that's very nice. what's soubise? french word for sauce?
 
lechef April 13, 2010
Wow. I want this right now.
 
coffeefoodwrite April 13, 2010
These look absolutely delicious and the photo is beautiful!
 
TasteFood April 13, 2010
OK, now I am officially hungry. These look great.
 
WinnieAb April 13, 2010
Really really great!