Food52 Pantry

Best All Butter Pie Crust Dough

March  7, 2021
4.5
68 Ratings
Photo by James Ransom
  • Prep time 15 minutes
  • Cook time 30 minutes
  • Makes one single-crust pie (double easily)
Author Notes

The name says it all—this pie dough recipe is all butter, all the time. Allow plenty of time for chilling, and it'll turn out crazy flaky. —Erin Jeanne McDowell

Continue After Advertisement
Watch This Recipe
Best All Butter Pie Crust Dough
Ingredients
  • 1 1/4 cups all-purpose flour, sifted (150 g)
  • Pinch salt
  • 8 tablespoons butter, cut into 1/2-inch cubes (113 g)
  • 1/4 cup ice water, or more as needed (56 g)
Directions
  1. In a large bowl, whisk together the flour and salt to combine.
  2. Add the butter, tossing the cubes in the flour to coat. Rub the butter into the flour until it is the size of walnut halves (for a flaky crust) or peas (for a mealy crust).
  3. Make a well in the center, and add the water a few tablespoons at a time and mix just until the dough comes together.
  4. Wrap the dough in plastic and chill well before rolling, forming, and baking.
  5. VARIATIONS: Chocolate Pie Dough Replace: ¼ cup/30 grams of the all purpose flour with 1/3 cup/28 grams unsweetened cocoa powder (any kind, but dark or black cocoa powder (see Resources) make particularly intense crusts). Take care not to overbake this crust – look for a dry, matte appearance all over as an indicator. Spiced Pie Crust: Add up to 1 1/2 tablespoons ground spices or a combination of a few! One of my fave combos is 1 ¼ teaspoons ground ginger, 1 teaspoon ground cinnamon, ½ teaspoon ground allspice, and ½ teaspoon ground cloves.
  6. -To Roll Out the Dough: Lightly dust a work surface with flour, and lightly dust a rolling pin, if desired. Roll out the dough to about ¼ inch thick, rotating it as you work to help prevent it from sticking. To transfer the dough to the pan, gently roll it up, wrapping it around the pin, then unfurl it into the pie plate. -To Prepare the Edge for Crimping: On a single crust pie, use scissors to trim away the excess dough, leaving about ½ inch excess all the way around the outside edge of the pie plate. Tuck this excess dough under, pressing gently to make it flush with the edge of the pie plate. On a double crust pie, gently press the top and bottom crust together to flatten the dough slightly, then trim the excess and tuck under ss directed for a single crust pie. -To Par-Bake the Dough: Dock the crimped single crust pie dough with a fork and chill well (at least 30 minutes). Cut a square of parchment paper slightly larger than the diameter of a pie plate, and press it into the base of the pie plate. Fill with pie weights to the top inner rim of the pie plate. Bake in a 425°F oven until the edges begin to lightly brown, 15-17 minutes. Remove the parchment paper and pie weights, and return to the oven until the lower portion of the crust appears dry and set, 2-3 minutes more. Cool completely before filling. -To Blind-Bake the Dough: Follow the instructions for par-baking, but bake until it is fully golden brown. After removing the pie weights, bake for 5-7 minutes. Cool completely before filling.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

I always have three kinds of hot sauce in my purse. I have a soft spot for making people their favorite dessert, especially if it's wrapped in a pastry crust. My newest cookbook, Savory Baking, came out in Fall of 2022 - is full of recipes to translate a love of baking into recipes for breakfast, dinner, and everything in between!

94 Reviews

Nancy L. November 24, 2024
Hi Erin, I have baked hundreds of pies and I learned so much watching this video, so thank you! I can't wait to try some new techniques.
My mom used to use raw rice as pie weights- worked great and the rice was still good to use.
LeBec F. February 22, 2024
i came to your recipe because of the DECORATIVE aspect of this crust. but you don't even tell us how you made it! did you use the cuff end of a pastry piping tip -to make the circles? best, mindy
Faith H. November 22, 2024
Hi! Former pastry chef here. Based on the 'lip' around the edge of the circles, it appears she rolled out some extra dough and cut out circles of dough. (This is evident when you look at the 12- and 1-o'clock area of the picture.) She then overlapped them on the edge of the crust. If you do this, be sure to brush the edge of the crust before placing the circles of dough on top, to ensure they are adhered to the crust.
Ellen B. February 6, 2024
I use foil and not parchment when blind baking to avoid getting my pie weights (which are dried beans and rice) greasy. The butter often comes up through the parchment but won't with foil. Also, as Stella Parks says, you can use sugar as the weight, and toast it slightly during blind baking and it will definitely absorb butterfat if you use parchment.

I'm terrible at pie crusts; they just never work for me. It's ok, I like cake better anyway.
Liz October 14, 2023
I don't know what I did wrong but, I didn’t have enough dough to go all the way up the sides (deep dish). This is my first pie and I'm only trying because Erin is so cool and funny and explains things so that I can understand..
Smaug October 14, 2023
It would seem that you didn't roll it out far enough, this should be plenty for a 9" single crust pie. As I recall from having made the recipe (and a billion pies) the 1/4" thickness called for is just plain wrong- 1/8" or a bit more is the norm and will work with this.
Evin L. November 16, 2023
I have the 9” Emile Henri pie dish that is pretty common and seems like a normal size pie dish. But I always have to make extra dough (usually 1.5x this recipe) and about 25% more filling for it. No one has ever complained to me about a bigger pie.
Julie August 12, 2023
I loved the video on pie dough making and have watched it several times!
However, when I tripled the recipe, it was too soft. 3 sticks of butter for 3 3/4 cups flour?
sika6061 November 25, 2022
This is my go-to pie crust recipe, and it's always a stunner. I get an extra flakey crust by folding the dough a couple of times. It's amazing and delicious. It comes together beautifully. Putting the flour/butter mixture back in the freezer before adding the cold water is the key IMO. Also recommend Erin's The Book on Pie. I've made a bunch of pies from that book, and they're so delicious! I'll be making more this holiday season. Can't wait!
Char November 24, 2022
I made this for the first time today and it turned out far better than I could have ever dreamed! The video is a wonderful guide through the whole pie crust process. Many years ago a local grocery store offered a pie "boot camp" and I didn't come away from that with the confidence I have after watching this video. Erin gives such a wonderful explanation about how much water to use and *shows* exactly how the dough should look! Priceless! I got lots of compliments on my apple pie tonight. Thank you Erin!
Ariella November 14, 2022
Erin,

Your video is a wonderful guide to making a pie crust. Very clear and thorough.
You are the best. Thank you.
bringpeace October 23, 2022
I heard that it's a good idea to partake the crust when preparing a pumpkin pie. Would I follow the same steps that was recommended on the video by baking 2-3 minute more after removing the weights?
You have the best videos, Erin. You're an excellent teacher!
sika6061 November 25, 2022
Answer: yes. However, be sure to watch the crust after you put your pie in with the filling to make sure the crust around the edges doesn't brown too much. You may need to protect it with foil. Happy baking!
123voy138 October 21, 2022
I have used this recipe probably 15 or so times now. I could not recommend this recipe enough as a base for everything from apple pie to tarts, and even savory pies. I would suggest adding a bit of vodka if you are new to baking pies to ensure a more reliable flake. The more you make it, the easier it gets to identify when the dough is ready or if you need more/less flour or water. This is a go-to recipe for me, and probably one of the first I worked with when I started baking as a hobby a year or so ago. It has never let me down. My biggest tip is to always keep the dough chilled to ensure you get a flaky crust.
Pat July 18, 2024
How much vodka ? Instead of the water ? Thank you
Meg October 31, 2024
Up to half of the liquid can be vodka.
Smaug October 4, 2022
This is a good crust, a little more butter than I prefer, but that seems to be the idea. Rubbing the butter in by hand really is the best way to go, though it can be tough on older hands. One caveat, however- by rubbing in the butter you are coating flour with butter much more than you would by cutting it; if you overdo it, it's possible to overshorten the crust to the point that it won't stand up.
A L. September 18, 2022
Easy, quick and delicious - Flaky, crisp crust, tender apples and sweetened perfectly. That addition of bourbon compliments the apples so well!
MrsMcF May 1, 2022
Thank you Erin for your pie videos. They arr so informative about technique. They have taught me a lot about making good pies. I love watching you bake!
TerryL49 April 14, 2022
I always envied my mother's ability to make pie crust, making 6 or more at a time and rolling pie dough like it was child's play. Her crusts however relied on shortening or lard, both of which I tried to avoid with no luck. Then ! After baking biscuits along with Erin and her Dad on her YouTube video I watched her pie crust video and though .. whoaaa far to difficult. But, I trusted my ability to "feel" the dough and lo and behold the single best pie I have ever made. The crust was the hit of the dinner and everyone raved about it. Thank you, Erin !
sherrylr January 25, 2022
I have struggled with pie crusts for some time. Family loves this one and it was so easy and so good!!! I made chicken pot pie and my son said this is different. It is the best you have made. lol....it was the crust that did it.
TruTru December 20, 2021
This is the best teaching video I've ever seen! Most people are great chefs, but not good teachers, because they don't fill in the gaps, assuming students know basic things they know. What a natural teacher! I never would have thought I would watch 1:20 video on crusts, but Erin is so compelling and thorough. This is how you teach someone to bake—or cook. Bravo.
ctate December 11, 2021
How do you keep butter from dripping all over when it (par)bakes? Seems like either I get a ton of shrinking around the sides, or I fill the house with smoke because the butter boils up under the crust and over the lip of the pie dish. :(
Cranky December 12, 2021
- make sure all the butter is covered well with flower before mixing further
- make sure the dough is nice and chilled at every step, especially right before baking (at least 30min in the fridge, do not use the freezer)
- make sure your oven is the correct temperature (in doubt, use a thermometer)

This should minimize the amount of butter dripping out. There could still be some, then it's best to use parchment paper under the pie dish for easier clean-up.
ctate December 12, 2021
My oven's excellent at temperature (dial matches high-quality oven thermometer exactly), I've been extremely careful about chilling and flour-coverage, and still got enormous amounts of butter drip.
Cranky December 13, 2021
Hm, that's tough.
Then all I can think of is maybe try a different, more dry kind of butter.
Or since you're using a high-quality new oven, maybe the heat is distributed "too" well, so maybe crank it up another 10-20 degrees for the first 15 minutes or so of baking.
Sumey44320 December 4, 2021
Just made this as a hand pie and my family loved it. I made the more flat dough in the food processor like she shows in the video. Needless to say my husband wants me to make more.
Jo B. November 25, 2021
I’m glad I didn’t read any reviews before making the best pie crust ever! It was perfect. Flaky top and bottom. I could have made two pies. A keeper for sure!
Smaug November 22, 2021
This is a good basic recipe, but a couple of comments. Some caution should be exercised when rubbing in the butter- if overdone this can result in a too-tender crust that won't hold together. I do it to some extent with most of my crusts, just don't go crazy with it. A quarter inch is awfully thick for a pie crust, and I don't think this amount of crust could come close to filling out a 9" pie plate at that thickness. I like to add some spice to crusts, but the amounts given are huge; a teaspoon of sugar and a half teaspoon of cinnamon, for instance , is enough to transform this amount of crust.