Guest Editors

A Week's Worth of Pie with Four & Twenty Blackbirds

By • November 15, 2013 • 61 Comments

33 Save

If you like it, save it!

Save and organize all of the stuff you love in one place.

Got it!

If you like something…

Click the heart, it's called favoriting. Favorite the stuff you like.

Got it!

For #PieWeek, our guest editors are Emily and Melissa Elsen, the pie mavens behind Four & Twenty Blackbirds in Brooklyn, NY. They will be sharing recipes all week from their first cookbook, and giving away a copy each day!

Today: Pie Week was fun -- good thing the Holidays are around the corner. Don't forget: Today's your last chance to win a copy of the new pie bible.

It's hard not to bring a smile to someone's face when serving up a slice of homemade pie. Thanks to the new Four & Twenty Blackbirds cookbook, we have the power to recreate the feeling in our kitchens, with confidence. This week, our guest editors reminded us that getting a little creative, staying seasonal, and mixing some love into your dough is the best way to come out on top of the pie game. 

More: 6 Ways to Fancy Up Your Pies

Black Bottom Oatmeal Pie

Black Bottom Oatmeal Pie on Food52 


All-Butter Crust

All Butter Crust on Food52

More: Another foolproof pie crust, from America's Test Kitchen.

Cranberry Sage Pie

Cranberry Sage Pie on Food52


Lemon Chess Pie

Lemon Chess Pie on Food52 

Photo by Gentl & Hyers

We're giving away one last copy of The Four & Twenty Blackbirds Pie Book, tell us in the comments: What do you love most about pie? (Unfortunately, we can only ship domestically.)

Tags: pie week, cranberry, sage, oatmeal, pie, lemon

💬 View Comments ()

Comments (61)


over 1 year ago Sarah

I love pie because it's the first real food I made. I spent a summer in college getting my heart broken in the middle of nowhere, far away from friends and family. I didn't know how to make anything at the start, but, needing something to do, I learned to make pie. It was simple and forgiving and its flexibility allowed me to make either dinner or dessert. It made me feel like I knew what I was doing; it got me through.


over 1 year ago Kelsey

A great piece of pie is to be savored and takes you to a place of comfort. After indulging you just feel perfectly satiated. Pie is the ultimate in happiness :)


over 1 year ago Michelle Johnson

I Love Pie because it reminds me of my Grandmother. Our Family would fight over the last piece of her Melloscotch Meringue Pie every Holiday. I was fortunate enough to make a rendition of her Melloscotch Pie for her to try. She was 92


over 1 year ago Lark

The best pies I've eaten were in Germany and now when I make or eat pie, I feel sentimental about that country where I once lived.


over 1 year ago Heather

butter. the best pie crusts are the butteriest ones. and lets face it, savory or sweet, everything is better with butter as its base.


over 1 year ago Zoe

I love pie because, like creating a work of art, I can feel totally and utterly content when my work is done. The process is just as satisfying as the finished pie. From cutting in the butter, to brushing egg yoke onto the top crust... All of it is pure poetry! And even if it doesn't look perfect, it somehow always tastes perfect. :)


over 1 year ago kkajewski

Whatever the occasion a pie will suit. A pie can be sweet or savory. There's nothing better than a chicken pot pie on a chilly night. The smell fills the senses as well as the belly. Yet, come summertime when the stone fruit ripens a creamy caramelized nectarine pie is the talk of the neighborhood BBQ.
Every culture has their form of pies. They may be known by a different name but they are pies all the same. Large or small- I'll eat them all! :o)


over 1 year ago SoVery

Sharing it with someone you love!


over 1 year ago Jamie Dunn

I love the crust and contrasting that with the inside! Plus the creativity and variety you get to put into the filling.


over 1 year ago taste area

the crustiness of the crust combined with the gooeyness/creaminess/juiciness of the filling!


over 1 year ago Andshewas

I love the versatility of pie. Creamy/Fruity. Sweet/Savory. I love that even people who aren't dessert-people like pie. Pies and tarts are "cook's desserts". As opposed to cake, bringing a pie doesn't seem like you're trying to hard. ;)


over 1 year ago Michele C.

making up a pie and seeing how pleased my guests are to get to enjoy a classic dessert!


over 1 year ago Lela Dougal

There are hundreds of desserts, but pie is the most delicious of all..there is something special about a pie and can be used for any time of meal..fancy or simple fare. Everyone likes pie!


over 1 year ago Shack

I love the perfect crust to filling ratio, the satisfaction when an apple pie come out bubbling and brown, the thanksgiving smell that fills my house as my pies bake, and that I can eat pumpkin pie for breakfast the next day!


over 1 year ago Angela

question: what is the pie that is the preview image for the "Everything You Need to Make the Perfect Pie" article?


over 1 year ago Daisy

I love how versatile pie is! It can be made with fruity, sweet, or savory fillings.


over 1 year ago Boulder Butter

My favorite part of pie is eating it the next morning as leftovers with a strong cup of coffee!


over 1 year ago Lil Rinaldi

I love all the varieties that you can make, sweet or savory!


over 1 year ago Sean

The crust.


over 1 year ago chrissyb

I like that you can put cream on fruit pies & whipped cream on pecan or pumpkin pies.