Make Ahead

Cindy Mushet's Italian Jam Shortbread Tart (Fregolotta)

April 11, 2021
4.7
22 Ratings
Photo by James Ransom
  • Serves 8 to10
Author Notes

The dough is one simple shortbread that you use for both the crust and the topping (which will make you wonder why you'd ever make them separately). You can make the entire thing in about an hour, including clean-up, and yet somehow it comes out looking like a Byzantine mosaic. Even though it's perfect for holidays, you should entrench this in your repertory year-round. As long as you have butter, sugar, and flour, you can use whatever jams and nuts are in your pantry. Adapted slightly from Desserts: Mediterranean Flavors, California Style (Scribner, 2000). —Genius Recipes

What You'll Need
Ingredients
  • 12 tablespoons (6 ounces) unsalted butter, softened
  • 1/2 cup (3 1/2 ounces) sugar
  • 1/4 teaspoon pure almond extract
  • 1 1/2 cups (7 1/2 ounces) unbleached all-purpose flour
  • 1/8 teaspoon salt
  • 1/4 cup (2 ounces) not too sweet apricot jam (or other jam of your choice)
  • 1/3 cup (1 ounce) sliced natural almonds
Directions
  1. Heat the oven to 350 °F. Position an oven rack in the center of oven.
  2. Place the butter, and sugar in the bowl of an electric mixer fitted wtih the paddle attachment (a handheld mixer is fine; just allow a little extra time to reach each stage in the recipe). Beat on medium speed until the mixture is very light in color, about 3 to 4 minutes. Use a rubber spatula to scrape down the sides of the bowl. Add the almond extract and blend well, another 30 seconds.
  3. In a separate bowl, whisk together the flour and salt. Add the dry ingredients to the butter mixture and combine on a low speed just until the dough is thoroughly combined, about 30 to 40 seconds. Measure out 1/2 cup of the dough and set it on a small plate, then place the plate in the freezer (this will chill the dough and make it easier to crumble).
  4. Press the remaining dough into a 9 or 9 1/2-inch tart pan in an even layer (the edges can be a little higher than the rest, just be careful that the center is not the thickest point). If the dough is too sticky, just chill it briefly.
  5. Use a small offset spatula or the back of a spoon to spread the jam in a thin, even layer over the surface of the dough, leaving a border of about 1-inch around the edges.
  6. Remove the reserved dough from the freezer and crumble it into small pieces over the layer of the jam, allowing some of the jam to peek through. Sprinkle the sliced almonds evenly over the top of the tart.
  7. Bake for 40 to 50 minutes, or until the topping is a beautiful golden brown. Remove from the oven and place on a rack to cool completely. If your tart pan has a removable bottom, to unmold, center the tart pan on top of a large can so that it balances midair as the rim of the tart pan falls to the counter. Leave the bottom of the pan under the tart for support, or run a large spatula between the crust and the pan, using the spatula to guide the tart onto a plate. Alternately, cut wedges straight from the pan. Serve with tart whipped cream.
  8. Store the tart covered in plastic wrap, at room temperature for 3 to 4 days. The tart can be assembled ahead and frozen for up to 1 month. Assemble the tart, then wrap tightly twice in plastic wrap and freeze on a flat surface -- it may require a few minutes extra of baking time.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • ccsinclair
    ccsinclair
  • LynnATL
    LynnATL
  • Sarah Smith
    Sarah Smith
  • Shannon Jilbert
    Shannon Jilbert
  • Jonathan A.
    Jonathan A.
Genius Recipes

Recipe by: Genius Recipes

67 Reviews

jenncc March 8, 2024
Love this! Have made it several times using apricot or cherry jam. Simple and delicious and I look forward to trying with other nut and jam combos.
 
ccsinclair December 8, 2021
I’ve made this tart since the book came out. It’s a showstopper, and makes you look like a genius pastry chef. Never tell anyone how easy it is to make.
 
LynnATL April 28, 2021
So delicious. Presents like a dessert that took lots of time. Use your favorite jam. Classic and a favorite.
 
Sarah S. June 21, 2020
I had lots of homemade jam in the fridge and wanted to use some of it up. This recipe was ideal! The crust was tender but held together well and the topping was sublime. Perfect complement to coffee. Will make this again and again.
 
Mark R. May 5, 2020
This has become my go-to company dessert. It’s easy and gorgeous! I found a new jam called F.R.O.G. ( fig, raspberry, orange and ginger) for this tart and it’s sensational with sliced almonds. The jam is made by Walnut Creek Foods ( Walnut Creek, Ohio).
 
Shannon J. February 22, 2020
So love.
 
Jonathan A. July 17, 2019
This recipe is incredibly tasty, versatile, and easy to make. I recommend splurging on good quality butter. It makes a difference. You can also chop the nuts finely or grind them with the struessel for a more refined look.
 
Linda January 22, 2019
PS: I put the crust in the freezer x 30 minutes prior to baking... baked for 48 minutes to golden brown. Wish I could post the photo!
 
Linda January 22, 2019
Made this gluten free... used 4 ounces of King Arthur Measure for Measure and 3.5 ounces almond meal. Worked perfectly! Used 1/3 cup homemade raspberry jam and upped the salt to 1/4 teaspoon. Will use this shortbread recipe to make gluten free salted billionaires shortbread! Love this recipe!
 
kbehroozi December 22, 2018
Made this again today and realized that it might be better with a higher jam:crust ratio. Maybe that's just me? Used the Trader Joe's seasonal Sugar Plum jam, which has a flavor similar to spiced cranberry sauce. Delicious!
 
Gardener December 22, 2018
I always use more jam than called for ... it's not just you; somewhere between 1/3 and 1/2 cup.
 
Gwen M. December 5, 2018
I have made this a bajillion times. It is amazing! I make it for my boss at Christmas and her birthday and she loves it. I have used apricot jam, raspberry jam and red plum jam. Amazing and super easy!!
 
DC's P. December 6, 2018
I agree. This is a terrific recipe.
 
Gardener November 22, 2018
For Thanksgiving I made this with a generous 1/3 cup cherry preserves and sliced almonds. Perfection with vanilla ice cream. Simpler, elegant alternative to the cherry pie dessert option.
 
janet V. August 16, 2018
Thank you Cindy for the freezing directions. I've made fregolotta's, but needed to know if they freeze well. Your recipe came up on my Google search. I would have baked it then freeze. Now I will assemble, freeze then bake.
 
Kate's K. August 6, 2017
I recently had my new oven recalibrated since it was running hot. As part of the test to see how the new calibration was working the GE repairman said to "just cook in it to see how it working". I didn't need any more coaxing so I turned to an old fav, Cindy Mushet's Fregolotta to test it out. It's working great cause this was delicious and the last time I made it, it was a little dry. I used Bonne Maman strawberry preserves this time ~ oh so good. I agree with another reviewer to use a tablespoon more of the jam than the 1/4 cup called for in the recipe is a good idea,
 
Alicia March 2, 2017
I LOVE this dish! I have made it multiple times, and as a total baking novice, I really appreciate the specificity of the instructions. It's very tasty, and I've had several people ask me for the recipe.
 
Kerry G. January 21, 2017
I've now made this several times. One version with sour cherry conserves and dark chocolate. Delicious!
 
Jackie April 29, 2020
THIS is a great idea on top of a great idea! Thanks.
 
Kaite December 2, 2016
This was amazing. Everything came together so fast. The dough was a dream to work with. I made mine with cherry jam and pecans. I love the possibility of all the different jam/nut combinations. I ended up adding slightly over 1/4 cup jam, but could still use more next time. It is a sweet treat but a small sliver is a satisfying dessert for me.
 
Jacquie November 6, 2016
Really easy and wonderful with a mini=scoop of gelato
 
Renée R. May 14, 2016
What in the heck is "tart" whipped cream?????
 
witloof July 27, 2017
The directions are to serve THE tart with whipped cream.
 
Drick December 28, 2015
I wanted to make for Xmas but the family all wanted the visuals. I made it 3 days after, the family was WRONG! Soooooo good! Used blackberry jam and added a little more salt. Was ready in 40 mins no longer needed in my oven
 
Drick December 28, 2015
I meant to say family wanted the USUALS not visuals, damn spellcheck
 
Jeanette F. December 16, 2015
This is my go-to recipe for workplace birthdays. It looks beautiful and is so easy! My tart pan is dark metal and the tart is always done in 30 minutes, so if you are making this for the first time you may want to check it on the early side.
 
Darilyn S. July 9, 2015
Not only was it my first recipe from this site, but it has become my favorite desert. Three berry jam, strawberry rhubarb jam, raspberry jam… love them all
 
claire M. May 22, 2015
The simplest tarts are always the best. I LOVE this recipe!
 
Kara March 23, 2015
Made this with apricot jam (homemade) and almonds. Was a total hit with deliciously crumbly pastry that I will definitely be making again. Next go will be with sour cherry jam and macadamias.
 
Cheryl March 22, 2015
I've made this fabulous dessert many times. Instead of a crumble on top, I have a used small cookie cutters for the top dough and decorate for any holiday! This is a family and colleague favorite!
 
Katherine March 22, 2015
This is the first recipe for me from this site. I made this yesterday for a potluck. It was the only thing that was completely gone at the end of the event. "F-ing delicious" was one comment. I used Chez Maman raspberry jam and the only change is to use a little bit more jam the next time around. It may be the size of the tart pan I used, but it also may just be personal preference. Still an out of the park winner. And next time I make shortbread, I'm adding almond extract.
 
Darilyn S. March 3, 2015
This was the first recipe I made from Food 52. Great recipe.
 
li February 5, 2015
Made this last night... used 4 ounces AP flour and 3.5 ounces almond in place of all AP flour and seedless unsweetened raspberry jam.. perfect! Thanks for the great recipe!
 
li February 5, 2015
oops... 3.5 ounces of almond flour...
 
Julieek December 23, 2014
I make this all of the time and absolutely love it! It is the perfect dessert to bring to a holiday party.
 
michele M. December 23, 2014
I made this last Christmas (and will be making it again this year) with tart cherry and raspberry jams. To quote my sister "This is like dessert crack - completely addictive". This recipe is super easy, foolproof, and delicious!
 
Patricia August 15, 2014
I made 4" tarts using oven-safe paper bakeware as my tart pans. 5 batches of dough made 24 tarts. I used cherry jam instead of apricot jam. I am sure these will be a top seller at the bake sale on Sunday. Beautiful and yummy!
 
Julieek July 21, 2014
We loved this! I think that this would make beautiful small/individual tarts. This would also be great to serve at a cocktail party. One doesn't go very far, so I would serve one apricot and one raspberry! So pretty. I am going to make this all of the time. I may even invest in a second tart pan so that I can make two.
 
Rose July 4, 2014
This is a great recipe. I made it with one cup of flour with half cup of almond meal instead of 1 1/2 cup of flour. It was so good.
 
Carol May 3, 2014
Gotta love a tart that doesn't require rolling dough! I've made this three times with homemade apricot jam and people just go crazy over it, which is weird because I don't get the same amount of crazy over my much more difficult desserts.
 
Diana April 27, 2014
I loved the fact that you can freeze this. I've made it with chocolate strawberry spread, orange apricot jam, peach, etc. They all disappear. The cooking time even frozen is more like 30 to 40 minutes. It was a bit over cooked the first time i made it.
 
Laurelb April 12, 2014
This was fabulous. It will be a go to recipe from now on
 
Kate's K. February 22, 2014
Oh this is good! Made with peach jam. Plan to make it with blackberry next time. Thank you!
 
witloof February 2, 2014
Just made this again, this time using blackberry jam mixed with a little lime juice and orange flower water.
 
Cinnamin January 29, 2014
This looks great! And quite fuss-free too...I like that there's no blind baking involved :)
 
witloof January 29, 2014
I'm teaching a young friend how to bake and we made this together for a dance on Saturday. It FLEW off the refreshments table.
 
beverly December 30, 2013
Where do you find tart whipped cream?
 
witloof July 27, 2017
The directions say to serve THE tart with whipped cream!
 
purljamr September 23, 2017
No, it does say tart whipped cream, but I never noticed & I've made it many times.
 
Kathy December 30, 2013
A wonderful desssssert/snack/treat. I like sweets that are more about the defined flavors than sugar, so this one is very pleasing. I'll share with many friends. Thank you!
 
aimeebama December 26, 2013
Very good AND easy. I used leftover homemade cranberry sauce from Christmas dinner for the jam and it was delicious and not too sweet. To give a more classic shortbread flavour to the crust next time I will increase the salt a bit.
 
Ariane December 25, 2013
Baked this yesterday for Christmas Eve dinner, with jam we made from our apricots last summer. The tart was a huge hit with our guests, and I'll be sure to make it over and over again -- one guest said, with her mouth full, "you should open a store and only make this and sell it." the kind of thing you want to hear at the end of a delicious meal! ;>
 
jevyn December 25, 2013
I liked the idea of this tart so much that I bought the book by Cindy Mushet. I made this for Christmas dinner and it was a huge hit. Super easy to make. I wish my jam had been a bit more tart (I used apricot-raspberry) but I think I was the only one. I can see making this at least once a year.
 
Shanaralane December 23, 2013
This was fabulous with raspberry jam. So quick and easy too.
 
Betsy H. December 22, 2013
I used spiced apricot preserves. (I add ginger, cinnamon, cloves, allspice and nutmeg to bought preserves.) Then I started with dried apricots and made a spiced fruit topping. Both made my friends happy, :).
 
Cadie M. December 17, 2013
This is so simple and creates impressive results. I baked for 35 min. and it was slightly overdone.
 
Elena G. December 16, 2013
Made this with quince jam. A truly lovely and simple dessert. I did find it a bit too sweet for my taste and, although I loved the look of the decorative border, I will spread a bit more jam and much closer to the edge next time while cutting back on the sugar. My edges over-crisped up a tad as well. Took exactly 40-50 minutes in the oven as the recipe states.
 
Renee B. December 18, 2013
I agree. Impressive dessert but we felt it would be better with less sugar and more jam. That said, not a crumb was left! Thank you for sharing such an easy, delicious recipe that impressed our guests.
 
Miyo K. December 22, 2013
I wish I had read your reviews before making it- I agree.. I think that spreadin jam further out to the edge and much less sugar would have made this great
 
beejay45 November 5, 2015
Ooh, I bet that would be good with a little sliver of Manchego. -- the quince jam version. I've been using shortbread for tart crusts for years. So easy, everyone likes it, and it allows you to use a really tart filling if you wish. Thanks for posting this
 
Jeannie E. December 14, 2013
I went for Grapefruit Meyer Lemon jam and it is still baking but I know it is going to be great!
 
Ileana M. December 9, 2013
I made this with apricot jam and hazelnuts, and it was delicious. Cooking time was more like 30 or 35 minutes for me, but that just means less time between me and shortbread tart! Totally a genius recipe.
 
SpaCook December 9, 2013
10 minutes and in the oven, minimal cleanup, delicious. Have been looking for a new item to add to the "I've got the last 20 min of nap to make a dessert" list, and this is definitely it. What more could you ask for?
 
annemai December 9, 2013
This was delicious. I made mine with fig preserves and chestnut paste.
 
walrusgumbo December 8, 2013
this is simply divine. i used fig preserves and pignolis <3 a must make!
 
jcbeard December 8, 2013
Made these today....Beautiful and delish! Thanks for sharing. :)
 
Windischgirl December 8, 2013
I had these in miniature (actually, two-serving size) while in Naples--filled with jam or chocolate ganache. It's a great recipe, open to improv. Yum!