Easter
Marshmallow Peeps
Popular on Food52
10 Reviews
SCalabretta
March 26, 2016
These are a lot of fun! The recipe filled 2 silicone pans (24 peeps) for me. The trick is to get the marshmallow into the molds as quickly as possible after mixing
awedgirl
April 21, 2014
My fatal flaw was not making sure the mold was properly greased. Didn't have any spray so tried to rub some safflower oil in there, but didn't do a good job. They were tasty, but they didn't look great. Also tried to use two colors of sugar. This also didn't help the looks. :) http://instagram.com/p/nBd41Vkww2/
luvcookbooks
April 21, 2014
Hi, our peeps tasted good but were a bit like Silly Putty and too rubbery to shape to a mold. Can you say a little more about what fluffy means? Is it like holding a soft peak? Starting to see ripples stay in the mixture? I think we beat it too long although it was still less than ten to twelve minutes.
molly Y.
April 21, 2014
Hi Meg,
Yes, soft peaks! I'm sorry the texture was like that. If you're up for trying it again, do stop mixing before the ten minute mark if the mixture gets to be lukewarm and holding soft peaks before then.
Best of luck!
-Molly
Yes, soft peaks! I'm sorry the texture was like that. If you're up for trying it again, do stop mixing before the ten minute mark if the mixture gets to be lukewarm and holding soft peaks before then.
Best of luck!
-Molly
Stephanie C.
April 18, 2014
I made these today. They tasted great, way better than the store bought peeps, but, I had a hard time filling the piping bag. The marshmallow kept sticking to the bag as I filled it. (Perhaps if I spray pam inside the bag it may not stick so I can fill the bag.) I ended up using a ziplock bag, filling it & then cutting a hole in the corner to fill the molds. Tasted great though.
awedgirl
April 14, 2014
Where do you find Peep molds?
molly Y.
April 14, 2014
hi there! michael's has the peep brand mold, and then target has some similar molds as well! http://www.michaels.com/Peeps-Silicone-Mold/bk1536,default,pd.html?cgid=products-bakeware-peeps
awedgirl
April 16, 2014
Thanks very much! Excited to make these for a Ham & Lamb supper I'm going to on Sunday night!
See what other Food52ers are saying.