Home Decor

How to Tell the Value of Your Antiques—in 5 Simple Steps

If you love flea markets and garage sales, bookmark this guide now.

October 11, 2021
Photo by Garrett Fleming

A few years ago, I drove an hour to snag an old dresser from the garage of a vintage dealer. It was quite a trek, but the piece was too special to pass up. A dimensional crest topped with a waving ribbon was sprawled across its four drawers, and, save for a few chips, it was in wonderful condition. Better yet, it only cost me $100.

The seller couldn’t tell me much about it, other than that he estimated it was built in the 1930s because of its extravagant style. To find out more, I recently DM’d Tilt Top Living’s Hayley and Craig Redmond Cilley, a pair of history buffs who help their followers identify and date their antique or vintage furniture for—get this—just $25. “We wholeheartedly believe that knowing more about your pieces’ stories creates a greater sense of connection and appreciation for them,” Haley says, adding, “There is something really special about knowing an object has experienced a long journey before you and that you get to add to it.”

As it turns out, the dealer was right on the money. With just a few photos to go off of, Hayley and Craig were able to determine my dresser was white oak and machine-made in an American factory in the 1920s as art deco style was coming in vogue. Curious how they did it? Below, accompanied by photos of some of their favorite finds, the duo walks us through five easy ways to figure out the make, model, and age of your furniture.

1. Do your research

“This is a British bookcase with original handles made in the late 1700s. It has the emerging tastes of the neoclassical period with the dentil molding up top and wood pattern on the glass doors. We love its history and beautifully crafted handmade elements,” says Craig. Photo by HAYLEY REDMOND CILLEY

There are dozens of furniture styles out there–baroque, rococo, mission, Edwardian, art deco. The more you know about each, the easier it will be to decode your antiques’ backstories. In short, read up. This handy guide by 1st Dibs is a great place to start.

2. Handmade Vs. Machine-made

Of this 1820s piece, Hayley says, “The foot shape shows a strong Philly influence, (and) the cherry wood suggests an owner with more modest means. Most likely this would have been commissioned by a farming family. Its main purpose was to store–as its name suggests– jellies! It was a very thoughtful housewarming gift from Craig's parents.” Photo by HAYLEY REDMOND CILLEY

The fastest way to determine a piece of furniture’s age is to verify if it’s handmade or machine-made. The giveaway? Its drawer construction. With younger machine-made items, evenly spaced little trapezoids that look like grinding gears connect the front of the drawer to its side. Older antique pieces, on the other hand, have small triangular pins that are more spread out and resemble a bird’s tail. It can be challenging to pick up on the subtle differences, but Tilt Top Living’s Teaching Series will help you tell the two apart.

3. Be a little superficial

Hayley and Craig’s dining chairs mirror the mid-century vibe of their home in Richmond, VA. “We had to compete for them at an auction,” Hayley tells us. “We love that we can honor the period of our home with pieces made in a similar time frame.” Photo by HAYLEY REDMOND CILLEY

Over time, natural wood darkens and shiny finishes lose their luster, so if an item wears a really rich hue and you can’t see your reflection in it, chances are it’s an antique. Keep a lookout for signs of use as well as light nicks, scratches, and the like; they’re great indicators that a piece has been well-loved for generations.

4. Look Out for Labels & Logos

Certain cities are synonymous with specific design styles. Take the decorative rings on the feet of the couple’s 1810s mahogany chest, for instance. They signal it was made in Baltimore, MD, a city which Hayley and Craig say was known for its “unrivaled detailed craftsmanship” at the turn of the 19th century. Photo by HAYLEY REDMOND CILLEY

Labels provide vital clues to unlocking a piece of furniture’s origin story and are typically branded into the wood or stuck inside (or underneath) drawers. They can even be attached to the back: always do a 360 inspection. No label? No problem. Many companies have evolved their branding over time, so all you need is a logo to get a general idea of your antique’s age. Simply do an online image search for “(brand name) old logos” and you’re well on your way to determining the piece’s birthday.

5. Pay attention to pattern

Hayley and Craig found this 1920s wardrobe on Facebook Marketplace. It was built to store men’s formal wear. Photo by HAYLEY REDMOND CILLEY

Veneering, the process of applying thin strips of pricey exotic wood over a less expensive material, was developed in the 1600s as a way to slash production costs. If your wooden furniture features an intricate geometric design or the grain mirrors itself (like the example above) it wears a veneer. The slimmer the veneer, the younger the item. By the 1900s, for example, veneers were paper-thin—think 1/64th of an inch.

Hayley and Craig say the best way to improve your ID’ing know-how is through practice. Explore your local antique malls, hit up estate sales, and scroll through online auctions. You can also hone your skills by bookmarking Tilt Top Living’s growing collection of lessons and tips.

Do any of your antiques tell a story? Share them with us in the comments below.

See what other Food52 readers are saying.

Garrett Fleming

Written by: Garrett Fleming

Interiors Editor & Art Director

1 Comment

Jessiejames946 August 16, 2022
I love antique furniture. I just acquired an Rway Northern Furniture tall chest of drawers from around 1950. Beautiful