Make Ahead
The Best and Prettiest Apple Pie
Popular on Food52
14 Reviews
Christine
October 11, 2014
i just made this and i'm super excited to try it tomorrow! :) i was a little bit shocked at the amount of butter and was wondering if it might be a mistake, but it just came out of the oven and it looks great! I do have a few questions, though, that I'm hoping you can answer!:
- How did you get your filling to be so pretty and pink? especially after peeling?
- The crumble felt really buttery and hard to crumble, almost like just trying to crumble sticks of butter--is this normal?
- for the crust, you just press in the pan, yes? including the sides?
Mine came out looking more like a cobbler than the above photo.
I didn't use any sugar in the fruit mix (although I sorta wish I put some honey or agave to sweeten it, now), and I cut the sugar down to 1/2 cup instead of 3/4. can't wait to try it tomorrow! Thank you so much for sharing the recipe!!!
- How did you get your filling to be so pretty and pink? especially after peeling?
- The crumble felt really buttery and hard to crumble, almost like just trying to crumble sticks of butter--is this normal?
- for the crust, you just press in the pan, yes? including the sides?
Mine came out looking more like a cobbler than the above photo.
I didn't use any sugar in the fruit mix (although I sorta wish I put some honey or agave to sweeten it, now), and I cut the sugar down to 1/2 cup instead of 3/4. can't wait to try it tomorrow! Thank you so much for sharing the recipe!!!
LorissaLovesPie!
March 11, 2011
I'm a pie fanatic, so it takes a lot to please me when it comes to pie. This pie recipe, however, made one of the best pies I have ever had! Great, great, GREAT recipe!
bobbylieb
March 11, 2011
Without a doubt the best pie I have ever had!! Thank you so much for this recipe!
amadievsky
March 11, 2011
Marvelous! My kids were dying over this. It was so good, I couldn't even keep my hands off it! Splendid, simply marvelous. Keep it up!
jason4522
March 10, 2011
best apple pie ever! My friend's grandma uses the EXACT SAME RECIPE and it's amazing :)
TajMowry
March 10, 2011
This recipe is a winner! Made it for my boys and they raved about it! Absolutely delicious!
Barack O.
March 10, 2011
Thanks so much for publishing this recipe. Tried it once and loved it. Keep up the good work!
afphillips
March 10, 2011
Greatest pie I've ever had!!! My mouth is literally watering just thinking about it.
See what other Food52ers are saying.