Author Notes: Ann Serannes’ Rib Roast of Beef Recipe reminded me of how often I used it and failed to produce perfect rib roast over the past 43 years - until recently, that is.
The quest started July 5th, 1964 when my bride and I returned from our honeymoon and purchased our first three ribs at Bohack’s Supermarket on 11th and Prospect Avenues in Brooklyn. It was .69 a pound then, a princely sum for two kids, and represented a culinary challenge that would continue unmet twice a year until now. We also bought a pound of ground black pepper to season it, hoping it would last awhile. It ran out in ‘98.
In those days the pre - Seranne approach was basically 20 minutes per pound at 350d. Not bad, not great, sort of tender and, if pink at the center, always gray at the edges. So we tried other methods resulting in the development of multi-color time/weight graphs and even considered a recipe for cooking the roast at 450d in a 20lb. rock salt casing.
We started using Anne’s method in 1968, based on a Craig Claiborne article in the New York Times, meeting sometimes with wondrous results but, reflective of comments in the website, often not. The meat was tender, but because we lacked the proper instruments, was always in danger of overcooking in the starting stage - obviously because you can’t cook different weights of meat at 500+ degrees for different lengths of time, in different ovens and expect consistent results. We all know cooking times relative to weight are non-linear and results can vary by meat shape, density, moisture, fat content, fat cover and initial temperature, etc.
Basically, the following recipe is a derivative of Ann Seranne’s and Heston Blumenthal’s approach, which calls for 18 hours at 120d, as presented in Dan Souza’s article in Cook’s Illustrated (November, 2011). The difference is that this recipe's time requirement is shorter than Blumenthal’s, eliminates Ann’s guesstimates based on heat and weight, will consistently yield the precise doneness you want, provides slack time during cooking, will provide edge to edge pinkness, produce as tender a roast as any you ever ate anywhere and is absolutely foolproof. And, though time consuming, is also easy,
The recipe is based on the principle, tested frequently by my wife and me at Country Spirit Restaurant in Henniker, NH, that “slow and low is the way to go”. It approaches the roast from the perspective of time and internal temperature rather than heat and weight, optimizing conditions under which the meat will tenderize itself. It also lays out the actual time you can expect to spend on each phase of the process in addition to providing considerable leisure before you actually carve the meat. The recipe also applies perfectly to other beef cuts like eye round.
The numbers referenced are based on cooking a small, Choice grade rib roast, 2 ribs, 5.6 lbs, to 136d* with an accurate meat probe in an oven that can heat at a low temperature and lots of time - 9 ½ hours in this case.
* "d" indicates degrees.
Serves: 2 persons per rib. because this recipe produces little drippings, if any, use your own recipe for au jus.
Accurate digital temperature probe
Shallow roasting pan
Oven that can heat as high as 550d and as low as 140d ( approx.)
6 tea candles
Standing rib roast, sans short ribs, any weight or number of ribs, “first” or “second” cut, Choice grade or better
Kosher or sea salt
Vegetable or olive oil
- Score fat covering roast and salt well on all sides.
- Let dry age, unwrapped and uncovered, in refrigerator 1 to 2 days.
- Then, set meat on rack in shallow roasting pan at room temperature for 4+ hours. Coat meat generously with oil just before cooking. To protect it, do not insert the thermometer probe into the meat yet.
- Preheat oven to highest temperature and roast meat in lower part of oven. (If set to “Convection Roast” cook four minutes per pound, not to exceed 22 minutes total. Go longer on other settings, but never exceed 30 minutes total.)
- Remove meat, cover loosely with foil and set aside. Insert thermometer probe into meat according to manufacturer's instructions. (Internal temperature of meat will be approx. 55 - 60d at this point.)
- Open oven door to cool it and reset oven temperature to 170d.
- Return roast, without foil, to oven when oven reaches 170d. (Indicated by burner re-lighting - approximately 25 minutes.)
- Cook at oven temperature of 170d until meat reaches 100d internal temperature. (Approximately 1 hour.)
- Lower oven temperature to 140d and find something to do until meat temperature reaches 136d, approximately 7 to 8 hours. (It will take approximately 2 1/4 hours to rise from 100d to 125d. Then, it will slow to a rate of approximately 30+ minutes per degree. A larger cut may take slightly longer.)
- At 136d (medium – medium rare), meat is ready for serving. Or you can just wrap it snugly in foil and let it sit indefinitely in the oven, using the oven light and an additional light bulb and/or candles to maintain an oven temperature of 120 to 130d until you are ready to serve on a heated plate. (One candle adds approximately 3 - 4d to oven temperature).
- Bon Appetite!