Chocolate
Swedish Biskvi
Popular on Food52
13 Reviews
leilah
March 31, 2023
This recipe is less “adapted” than “plagiarized”, and some of the confusing wording appears to come from that.
The Odense macaroon recipe calls for “scant 1/4 cup egg whites” instead of 1 large egg white. Likely why the directions say whites instead of white. The original says to use 1 tsp of dough, which makes more sense. That recipe with the original directions is here:
https://odense.com/odense-recipes/macaroons-recipe/
The Smitten Kitchen buttercream is “adapted” by multiplying the smaller quantity recipe by 3. Their recipe, again with clearer directions, is here:
https://smittenkitchen.com/2008/07/project-wedding-cake-swiss-buttercream/
Not sure why the author is so snarky - I wouldn’t have checked their work if they hadn’t been rude to folks about legit issues with the recipe. One star for helping me find really good macaroon and buttercream recipes on other sites though!
The Odense macaroon recipe calls for “scant 1/4 cup egg whites” instead of 1 large egg white. Likely why the directions say whites instead of white. The original says to use 1 tsp of dough, which makes more sense. That recipe with the original directions is here:
https://odense.com/odense-recipes/macaroons-recipe/
The Smitten Kitchen buttercream is “adapted” by multiplying the smaller quantity recipe by 3. Their recipe, again with clearer directions, is here:
https://smittenkitchen.com/2008/07/project-wedding-cake-swiss-buttercream/
Not sure why the author is so snarky - I wouldn’t have checked their work if they hadn’t been rude to folks about legit issues with the recipe. One star for helping me find really good macaroon and buttercream recipes on other sites though!
swedishturkey
March 31, 2023
Wow, spending at least 39 minutes of your life commenting on this recipe. I really triggered you. It's not plagiarizing when you reference the original creators and use it in a way different from their end use, hence the adaptation. Recipe bloggers do this ALL the time. What would we do on here without someone to "check work" by calling out everything blatantly and already credited.
Gretel
March 19, 2023
Thank you for this excellent recipe. The chocolate buttercream is devilishly delicious and a thousands better than the cheap powered sugar buttercream that is used so often. These kept so well for over a week in the fridge. Impressive to look at,,fun to make and divine to eat.
Sara A.
December 10, 2019
I'm a very good baker...however I can't make sense of this recipe...is says 1 large egg white, but then states, "Slowly add egg whites", (plural). It also states only use 1/2 teaspoon of dough per cookie....WHAT???? Also, I'm guessing that it should have said to whip the egg whites??? Just a guess, because I followed the recipe and they are flat like pancakes...SO disappointed! My father in law is Swedish and I really wanted to make these for him.
swedishturkey
December 11, 2019
Yes the recipe is correct. As stated in the ingredients list, it's the whites of one egg. The teaspoon is an actual spoon that one eats with... you know where the baking measurement term comes from. These should not be whipped, which I did not state, because who whips egg whites on low speed? The egg white is purely there to bind the almond paste and sugar..
leilah
March 31, 2023
To the author: 1/2 tsp in a recipe is a very clear and standard unit of measurement. If what you actually mean is “half a teaspoon of the kind that the standardized measurement is based on”, say that. Along with what size of teaspoon you mean and whether that’s heaping or level. Maybe just use a standardized measurement instead?
Sara A.
December 10, 2019
I'm a very good baker...however I can't make sense of this recipe...is says 1 large egg white, but then states, "Slowly add egg whites", (plural). It also states only use 1/2 teaspoon of dough per cookie....WHAT???? Also, I'm guessing that it should have said to whip the egg whites??? Just a guess, because I followed the recipe and they are flat like pancakes...SO disappointed! My father in law is Swedish and I really wanted to make these for him.
Sam R.
May 21, 2015
WTF with '18 tablespoons of butter'?!! Who has time for that?! Why isn't it in cups?
swedishturkey
November 17, 2018
Because counting is simple. If you are pressed for time, this isn't the recipe for you.
leilah
March 31, 2023
Likely because it’s the Smitten Kitchen recipe, just with a change to the size. Small recipe x3. Their recipe lists it in tablespoons, but does also include a stick equivalent.
https://smittenkitchen.com/2008/07/project-wedding-cake-swiss-buttercream/
https://smittenkitchen.com/2008/07/project-wedding-cake-swiss-buttercream/
leilah
March 31, 2023
It’s 2 and 1/4 sticks, or 1 1/8 cups. Would’ve taken less time to add it to the recipe than to type out the snarky response, but you do you, I guess.
See what other Food52ers are saying.