Winter
Meyer Lemon Eclairs
Popular on Food52
8 Reviews
dsdarrow
January 30, 2024
The directions for the pate au choux are incorrect. Following the directions I had a pancake batter. I remembered years ago when I made gourgeres, the dough became thick. I looked up another recipe and you bring the mixture in the pan to a boil, then add flour and it tightens up into a ball right away. Also, the recipe mentions an additional egg for the wash. Are three eggs used in the pate au choux? Again, the other recipe I looked at used four eggs so I didn't do the egg wash.
Jamie
May 11, 2022
I agree with JamesM253. The recipe is flawed and not written for someone with little or no experience. The choux was WAY too thin, the filling was too thin as well. I'm so incredibly disappointed.
jamesm253
January 17, 2022
In the most respectful way possible, I am truly not trying to be mean, this is the worst recipe of anything I have ever tried. There are problems in every single step of the process. I am sure the people behind this had good intentions and are great bakers, but this recipe should be reworked completely. Here are the issues:
Filling:
When using the double boiler to make the lemon curd, it is nearly impossible to get to 180º using a normal double boiler setup.
Adding the butter through a blender is a strange and flawed concept and the amount of butter added is too much.
It would be much easier and tastier to make a normal pastry creme/lemon curd using a saucepan, cornstarch, and the usual ingredients. LESS BUTTER
For eclairs, this type of filling is fundamentally wrong. What you end up with is closer to a lemon buttercream for icing a cake rather than a filling. What this should be is a normal lemon curd folded in with whipped cream to make a lemon diplomat cream.
Pastry:
This says to stir the eggs in with the choux flour dough. This is inefficient. Use a stand mixer or hand mixer if available.
Lemon Glaze:
This part of the recipe is just blatantly incorrect. 1-1 1/2 cups of powdered sugar is astronomically less than the amount needed to make a glaze that stays on the eclairs. If you make it as the recipe says, you end up with a lemony sugar liquid. It may be like this because the authors have mixed up the juice of 1 lemon to 1 Meyer lemon. 1 Meyer lemon is much juicer.
Simply put, if the recipe is followed exactly, this turns out poorly.
Filling:
When using the double boiler to make the lemon curd, it is nearly impossible to get to 180º using a normal double boiler setup.
Adding the butter through a blender is a strange and flawed concept and the amount of butter added is too much.
It would be much easier and tastier to make a normal pastry creme/lemon curd using a saucepan, cornstarch, and the usual ingredients. LESS BUTTER
For eclairs, this type of filling is fundamentally wrong. What you end up with is closer to a lemon buttercream for icing a cake rather than a filling. What this should be is a normal lemon curd folded in with whipped cream to make a lemon diplomat cream.
Pastry:
This says to stir the eggs in with the choux flour dough. This is inefficient. Use a stand mixer or hand mixer if available.
Lemon Glaze:
This part of the recipe is just blatantly incorrect. 1-1 1/2 cups of powdered sugar is astronomically less than the amount needed to make a glaze that stays on the eclairs. If you make it as the recipe says, you end up with a lemony sugar liquid. It may be like this because the authors have mixed up the juice of 1 lemon to 1 Meyer lemon. 1 Meyer lemon is much juicer.
Simply put, if the recipe is followed exactly, this turns out poorly.
Nathaniel
February 27, 2019
My cream came out too runny. Did anyone else have that problem? I was careful to heat it to exactly 180 and cool it to 140 before adding the butter. I used a hand blender instead of a stand-up blender. Could that have made the difference?
Justin
April 5, 2016
My éclairs didn't rise enough after I put them in the oven. Before cooking I noticed that my batter was thin so I did add about an additional 1/2 cup of flour. Any advice on what could have gone wrong?
Yamina M.
July 25, 2016
Every time you make choux, do not put the full amount of eggs the recipe calls for, add half of it, and if the consistency isn't right yet, add as much as the recipe calls for, in small quantities. You need the eggs so the eclairs puff up, but too many eggs can make the dough runny affecting the structure.
The whole reason why the amount of eggs varies, is that it'll depend how much you dried the dough beforehand.
The whole reason why the amount of eggs varies, is that it'll depend how much you dried the dough beforehand.
Katheryn's K.
January 11, 2014
Omg- these look amazing- I love anything lemon, especially meyer lemon. The glaze, the cream filling and the cream puffs, what a great combination!
See what other Food52ers are saying.