Make Ahead
Cleveland Cassata Cake in a Jar
Popular on Food52
26 Reviews
Elizabeth C.
July 16, 2024
Like other commenters, I am from Cleveland and had no idea the Cleveland cassata cake wasn't traditional cassata cake. I ordered a cassata cake from the local grocery bakery department and was very disappointed - thin layer of custard, ratio of cake to custard and strawberries was disappointing. I set out to find a recipe I could make and found this. Absolutely amazing. I opted to make this like a trifle and it was a huge hit. I loved the lemony flavor of the cake, which melded nicely with the custard, strawberries, and cream but was delicious on its own. Everyone who had it loved it; my son asked why his cassata cake (the store bought one) wasn't like the trifle I'd made. The only change suggested was to add a bit more sugar when making the whipped topping because strawberries aren't always the sweetest, even macerated. Anyhow, many many thanks for this delicious recipe that allowed me to wow my family for my husband's birthday!
rgburack
February 9, 2021
I don’t profess to be a baker-in fact I hate to bake, don’t even like desserts that much. But I made this especially for my sister’s birthday as it’s her favorite. We are from Cleveland and can’t get this anywhere near us in SC.
This is a FABULOUS recipe! Perfect, light, not too sweet. I cut the 9x13 cake in half and made a 2 layer cake and frosted it completely in whipped cream. The custard took awhile (20”) to thicken but was perfect. Directions are spot on-bake timing perfect. Only recommendation is to carefully layer strawberries on top of first layer if you make it like I did. You’ll have less trouble leveling the layers! I will make this again!
Thank you again, Joy, for a great recipe!
This is a FABULOUS recipe! Perfect, light, not too sweet. I cut the 9x13 cake in half and made a 2 layer cake and frosted it completely in whipped cream. The custard took awhile (20”) to thicken but was perfect. Directions are spot on-bake timing perfect. Only recommendation is to carefully layer strawberries on top of first layer if you make it like I did. You’ll have less trouble leveling the layers! I will make this again!
Thank you again, Joy, for a great recipe!
rgburack
January 28, 2021
Dear Joy,
I am so excited to find this recipe! I grew up in Cleveland but never heard about Casasdas until my (much) younger sister and elderly Mother moved down to where I live (SC) about 8 years ago. This is my sister’s favorite cake! We absolutely cannot find it here-I try every year for her birthday, February 8th! I will make it this year instead! Please tell me briefly how to cut cake to assemble it as a full cake instead of using the jars.
Thanks so much!
I am so excited to find this recipe! I grew up in Cleveland but never heard about Casasdas until my (much) younger sister and elderly Mother moved down to where I live (SC) about 8 years ago. This is my sister’s favorite cake! We absolutely cannot find it here-I try every year for her birthday, February 8th! I will make it this year instead! Please tell me briefly how to cut cake to assemble it as a full cake instead of using the jars.
Thanks so much!
eoryans
January 18, 2021
Thank you for this recipe. I grew up in Cleveland and this was a staple at every birthday party. Just can’t find it outside of Cleveland.
Willie J.
November 27, 2020
Great recipe, it's a labor of love, folding the egg whites really does make a difference. The cake & it's spongy yet absorbing flavor was Amazing & airy. Everybody loved it who tried it! #ClevelanderFoodie
Willie J.
November 27, 2020
Great recipe, it's a labor of love, folding the egg whites really does make a difference. The cake & it's spongy yet absorbing flavor was Amazing & airy. Everybody loved it who tried it. #ClevelanderFoodie
Ginamarie216
July 3, 2020
omg.yes!! I left Cleveland 8 years ago and have missed this cake so much! The yummy cake with strawberries in the middle is what I always knew it as haha! Thank you for sharing this!
Alison
April 9, 2020
more of a question, my son saw this a few months back and LOVES cassata cake. We find ourselves in the middle of the pandemic and his birthday is coming up. I'd love to make this for him since the bakeries are mostly closed. What size mason jar did you use for this? We are in CLE! Thank you
Alison
April 16, 2020
I made these yesterday in the half-pint jars (thank you so much for the speedy reply) and they were AMAZING!! Just like the cake we love from Corbo's in Little Italy but cannot because it's presently closed due to the worldwide pandemic. So Thank YOU!! Made my son very happy #cookingathome #shelterinplace
k_wel88
August 23, 2019
I’m from Cleveland and recently moved away. I never knew straws cassata cake (the way I know it) was a Cleveland thing. So happy I found this recipe - making for a friends birthday soon :)
Sue
May 15, 2016
I grew up in Cleveland area too, actually Brooklyn, but I used to get a Cassata cake for my daughter for her birthday, every year from Rito's Bakery in Parma Hts. When we moved to NC I did a mock Cassata for her, nowhere near the same, but she was happy for it. Her birthday is coming up, we've been here for 12 yrs, I think I'm going to surprise her with this recipe, she can eat it whenever it's convenient. Thank you, I look forward to trying this. The recipes on Pinterest are a little different from each other.
Joy H.
May 16, 2016
You're welcome! Good luck, and I hope your daughter loves it as much as I do! =)
Barb1949
September 2, 2019
I have a friend who comes from Cleveland every year to visit his family. We looked all necmver for a cassata cake. How long will these last in these Mason jars. I usually see him Tuesday with our old boss then then he does Thanksgiving on Thursday with his family. Will they be good in two days?
vsalupo
July 18, 2015
I grew up in Cleveland the grandson of Italian immigrants. Cassata cakes were the preferred cake at Italian brides weddings. I never new until moving away that we were the only place these existed. They don't have them in Italy either. Great to have this as a more portable recipe. If ever in Cleveland, get a cake from Baraona's Bakery in Maple Heights, Ohio for comparison. The best Cassata I ever had. I get one occasionally when I go back.
benlbk
November 9, 2015
lol, we had our cassata wedding cake made a baraona's a few years back - it was indeed excelent
stephanieRD
May 12, 2015
OMG I love cassata cake! I've moved away from CLE and haven't thought about it until now. I am definitely going to try to make this! Thank you for sharing this!
Kelly M.
May 10, 2015
I made this dessert for a mothers day BBQ and it was a hit all around. The custard made it very moist along with the juice from the strawberries. I highly recommend this dessert for any event. Especially because the mason jars make it convenient for travel and transportation. I love this site, and every recipe I have used from here has come out fantastic. My only complaint would be the high labor involved in making the dessert, however I believe it was worth the effort. If you have the time to make this wonderful treat, it will be worth it!
See what other Food52ers are saying.