Make Ahead
Cinnamon and Rye Shortbread
Popular on Food52
26 Reviews
Brooklyn E.
November 20, 2021
I use cardamom instead of cinnamon, & these are a holiday standard — they keep incredibly well!
Caroeddy
June 2, 2020
It's June 2020. Under this lockdown there's no flour in the shops except Rye, sooo.. I bought a bag not knowing what to do with it. Well I discovered these Rye shortbread and thought I'd give it a bash (not literally) I am so glad I did, they're lovely not crumbly, love the spicy taste. I will definitely be making them again
Anna W.
October 6, 2019
Wonderful, and just what I wanted to make on one of the first fall days! Perfect level of mellow sweet and spice with the earthy rye flavor. I used 1/2 c whole wheat + 1 c AP for the non-rye flour with good results. I'd love to experiment with other warm spices here, too.
AKeyte
January 16, 2019
So deliciously warm and comforting! I used brown butter to amp up the nutty flavours. They were crumbly but weren’t dry at all. I thought that there wasn’t enough sugar in the recipe, but nope the sweetness was just right. I couldn’t find dark rye flour so used light rye flour.
Lee U.
December 9, 2018
These did not turn out well for me. The flavor was great but they were so dry! We regularly make shortbread cookies at our house using the simple flour, sugar butter recipe. So, I don't know what went wrong. Too bad because I needed to bring something for a work party and now I need a Plan B in a hurry.
Nancy
December 9, 2018
Depends on what you have on hand or can quickly buy, also what you know how to make.
Possibilities:
1) make a new batch of the plain shortbread you regularly make
2) turn the dry cinnamon rye shortbread into a pie crust & fill with something you know & like
3) serve the cinnamon rye shortbread with something that will add moisture to a total dessert...lemon curd, ice cream, a Scottish/central European version of tiramisu with the shortbread instead of ladyfingers
Possibilities:
1) make a new batch of the plain shortbread you regularly make
2) turn the dry cinnamon rye shortbread into a pie crust & fill with something you know & like
3) serve the cinnamon rye shortbread with something that will add moisture to a total dessert...lemon curd, ice cream, a Scottish/central European version of tiramisu with the shortbread instead of ladyfingers
Änneken
May 23, 2018
This is a wonderful recipe! They melt in your mouth and are nice and crumbly without being dry.
Nancy
January 20, 2016
The flavor is terrific - just sort of nutty, with the rye and the cinnamon combining but neither dominant. Also great texture. Last, didn't have 9" sq pan so baked in a cast iron frying pan and they came out well (a little thin, but perfectly browned & crispy).
EmilyC
January 21, 2016
So happy to hear that you liked these, Nancy! They're one of my favorite sweet treats. I like your idea of using a cast iron pan to get crispy edges. Thanks for trying these and circling back!
Jacqueline Y.
December 22, 2015
Will this recipe last a couple of weeks in the mail? I'm looking for recipes to send over to my boyfriend in Afghanistan!
Rachel C.
December 12, 2015
Hi! This sounds absolutely perfect for the cookie packages I am giving out this year, I was wondering if the dough could be made in advance and frozen, I just have tons to be baking, that would be a lifesaver.
EmilyC
December 14, 2015
Sorry for my slow response. Rachel -- I've never frozen this dough, but shortbread dough freezes well so I don't know why this one would be any different!!
Adeline C.
December 2, 2015
Hi there! Sounds like a great recipe and definitely gonna try it out!
Quick quest, are there alternatives to using rye flour? Thanks!
Quick quest, are there alternatives to using rye flour? Thanks!
EmilyC
December 2, 2015
Hi Adeline -- I haven't experimented with different flours, but I imagine that others such as oat or buckwheat could be interesting! Or you can't go wrong if you make these with just all-purpose flour, either!
LeBec F.
March 16, 2015
hi em, your thinking outside the box really impresses me here! I'm curous whether you tried any versions, when you were creating this recipe, that did not work so well? I was wondering about rice flour and/or demerara sugar as components of the shortbread itself?
I really love dark rye bread but i would NEVER have thought of making a rye shortbread. And, coincidentally enough, last night i had one of the best restnt pastas ever- a parsnip filled pasta with melted bra duro cheese and smoked hazelnuts, run under the salamander with a topping of crispy rye crumbs!
I really love dark rye bread but i would NEVER have thought of making a rye shortbread. And, coincidentally enough, last night i had one of the best restnt pastas ever- a parsnip filled pasta with melted bra duro cheese and smoked hazelnuts, run under the salamander with a topping of crispy rye crumbs!
Two T.
February 28, 2015
Love them! For anyone looking for smaller pan size: I halved the recipe and I baked in a shallow, 8 inch tart pan with removable botom and scored 16 wedges. So good and crumbly. Perfect texture.
Kris
December 11, 2014
Hi, I am planning to make this for my Christmas gifting at work. I have only a 9x13 and 8x8 pan at home. Can I bake this in a 8x8 pan? how much of the dough should I put into the 8x8 pan? how thick should it be before baking?
EmilyC
December 12, 2014
Hi Kris, I think an 8x8 pan will work just fine. They'll be slightly thicker bars but should still be tasty. Alternatively you can bake the shortbread in a 9" tart pan and score wedges instead of bars (see here for general idea: http://www.marthastewart.com/336979/shortbread-wedges)
Beth100
November 25, 2014
I am definitely trying these soon – with a cardamom twist!
Beth100
December 2, 2014
I made one batch as written, and one with 1 teaspoon cinnamon and 1 teaspoon freshly ground cardamom. The first was delicious, and the cardamom variation was divine, definitely recommend it! The texture is lovely: crisp and firm, but not tough, I'm guessing due to the rye flour curtailing gluten formation? In any case, I'm making these gems for my neighborhood cookie exchange. Thanks for sharing!
See what other Food52ers are saying.