Make Ahead
Homemade Mint Slice Cookies
Popular on Food52
21 Reviews
Lynn C.
December 3, 2020
Wonderful- made these a couple of years ago for Christmas and my nephew has put them on his Christmas list this year!!! Better get baking... they are delicious !!!
marlzjean
December 2, 2018
Help! I want to make these for a bake-off and did a test batch today. My chocolate coating doesn’t seem to be hardening...where did I go wrong? Thanks!
Nikita
November 22, 2015
I made these yesterday and they were a huge hit with my family! It didn't take long to make and these cookies were such a great reward to eat.
The best part of making these was coating them in the cooled chocolate, which was a fantastic excuse to lick my fingers. Well done!
The best part of making these was coating them in the cooled chocolate, which was a fantastic excuse to lick my fingers. Well done!
Angela G.
November 19, 2015
Planning on making a batch to take to my sister in CA in a few weeks and I'm super excited! One sort of non food-related question...where did you get the dishes in the picture?? I've seen that style before and have searched with no luck!
Sarah C.
December 20, 2015
Hey Angela - these are vintage Crown Devon Stockholm coffee cups and saucers. I love them!
Alex H.
June 11, 2015
These cookies were fantastic! I truly enjoyed the recipe and it was very easy to follow. Although I had to battle it out with the sticky cookie dough and added more water to the frosting to get it to that play-dough consistency those were my only real challenges. The chocolate dip was the perfect amount I covered each of my cookies completely and then had none left over! Finally a topping I'm not wasting! Overall wonderful results so thank you!
~Alex H.
~Alex H.
Sarah C.
June 11, 2015
Yaaay!!! So glad you liked this recipe! Thank you for commenting Alex - and I hate it when there's tons of topping leftover too! x Sarah
Patricia S.
December 18, 2014
What a delicious and special cookie. So excited to add it to my Christmas cookie tray next week. I needed to double water to make mint filling the right consistency. Thank you for sharing.
Erica F.
December 12, 2014
Well I'm a little confused too about the chocolate, not sure what happened. But I will say that they were delicious (even the ones with only a drizzle of chocolate), and even better after a day in the fridge. I don't think the entire batch lasted more than 3 days in our house...
Erica F.
December 7, 2014
Just made these, and had a couple of problems. The peppermint icing was so dry and crumbly, I think it needed a bit more water. Also, the chocolate didn't make enough to coat all 19 cookies, it barely covered half. I had to drizzle over the remaining cookies so those don't look or taste nearly as good...
Sarah C.
December 11, 2014
Hi Erica, the icing should get to the texture of playdough, and I'm a bit confused on the chocolate! It definitely covered all mine!
Amy S.
December 9, 2015
I had the same problems as Erica-- the icing was very dry and fell apart, even after I added the additional recommended water, and the chocolate was about enough for half. I also didn't notice until too late that the recipe doesn't say anything about salt, and as I used unsalted butter, I noticed that the cookie was lacking salt. I tried sprinkling a bit of sea salt over the cookies before baking, but they still tasted undersalted to me. The recipe looks delicious-- unfortunately it didn't quite work out for me.
See what other Food52ers are saying.