Mint
Andrea Bemis' Fresh Mint Chocolate Chip Cookies
Popular on Food52
16 Reviews
hennanisa
June 22, 2020
These cookies turned out amazing! I was shocked how yummy they are! I was worried the mint would be too overpowering, but it was nice and subtle! I will definitely be making these again in the future!
Janet Y.
September 17, 2019
The cookies came out great but could have been more minty! Is there a particular type of mint you’d recommend for this recipe? I’m almost tempted to add a drop of peppermint extract next time... the ginger added an excellent and unexpected kick!
Emily
August 6, 2019
Sounds great, but I have a question— how can the butter be creamed if it’s still melted? Do you cool it first or just beat it with the sugar?
stefanie
July 6, 2018
Having made these a few times, I find that the recipe works more consistently when I measure out 1/2 cup butter after melting and straining. That often means adding another ~2 tbsp to take into account evaporation.
Depending on what stove I've used, the butter can melt more slowly or quickly than expected, and I've noticed variations as low as 1/4 cup butter after straining, which might explain some people's drier cookies.
Depending on what stove I've used, the butter can melt more slowly or quickly than expected, and I've noticed variations as low as 1/4 cup butter after straining, which might explain some people's drier cookies.
Caitlin
December 18, 2017
Hi there, I love this recipe and the cookies turned out pretty good but they were very tough the next day, not doughy. What would the cause be? Not enough butter?
Jeanne
December 20, 2017
I tried this recipe and I liked the batch I baked after the shorter chilling time vs. the ones I finished baking later and the dough had been chilled for many hours. But the flavor of the mint infused butter cannot be beat. I already know this will be my favorite chocolate chip cookie recipe to pass along.
Bobz
September 4, 2017
These cookies were delicious. Everyone at work loved them. I got a little over-enthused with the butter infusing process and accidentally browned the butter. The mint flavor was nice. Ill be making these again
JoAnn
August 20, 2017
The dough was way too dry. Any ideas about that?
Sarah J.
August 20, 2017
Hmm! Sorry about that! Did you press all of the butter out of the mint? And did you weigh the flour or measure it using cup measures?
Shannon R.
September 4, 2017
The dough was very dry for me too. Does weighing flour vs. measuring cups make a difference? I used the latter.
Sarah J.
September 4, 2017
I weigh the flour—but 180 grams should be close to 1 1/2 cups, so I'd hope it wouldn't make too much of a difference! I just made these again tonight and my dough wasn't dry—the flour also hydrates during the chill time. Let me know if you figure out what's going on!
Jenny
August 10, 2017
Love this cookbook and this recipe! I'd never baked with fresh mint before, but they turned out wonderfully.
bhilz
August 10, 2017
Hello! Looking forward to trying this recipe! I was very intrigued by the ginger mentioned in the method, but I don't see it in the ingredients list. Is it dried, fresh, or crystallized? How much would you add?
Thanks!
Thanks!
bhilz
August 10, 2017
Also, the photo seems to have dark or semisweet chocolate, but the method mentions white chocolate. I noticed the ingredients say any type of chocolate you want, but maybe this could be clarified a bit in the author notes?
Sarah J.
August 10, 2017
Hi bhilz,
Sorry about that! When I used this dough to top a cookie cobbler (https://food52.com/recipes/70673-roasted-berry-mint-cookie-cobbler) I added 1/4 cup of diced crystallized ginger along with white chocolate and it turned out nicely! But dark chocolate—or even chopped peppermints!—would be great, too.
Sorry about that! When I used this dough to top a cookie cobbler (https://food52.com/recipes/70673-roasted-berry-mint-cookie-cobbler) I added 1/4 cup of diced crystallized ginger along with white chocolate and it turned out nicely! But dark chocolate—or even chopped peppermints!—would be great, too.
Nancy
August 11, 2017
Since you've added two ingredients, maybe call the recipe "adapted from Andrea Bemis"...
See what other Food52ers are saying.