Fall
Detroit-Style Pizza
Popular on Food52
10 Reviews
brushjl
May 21, 2023
I used pizza dough from my local deli and spread it out over a sheet pan. Yes, I used all 1 2 oz of pepperoni and thought the cheese was just the right amount, mozzarella of course!
Stephanie D.
January 4, 2022
I find that recipes online use far too little cheese in their Detroit recipes. I have been making Detroit-styles at home and have upped my cheese to 16oz at this point, for a traditional 10x14 pan and I honestly will probably up that by another couple ounces or so. This is a thick dough and it needs and can handle the extra cheese so that it's less cheese bread and more layered. And this helps support a heavier ladle of sauce which should only be put on top and not under the cheese. I also highly recommend the Buholzer Brothers brick cheese if you can get your hands on it. I have found it at Jewel in the Midwest so imagine other comparable grocery stores may have it.
Adam D.
May 26, 2020
This recipe needs a few edits:
1. No way it's 1/4c olive oil in the dough. The original recipe on serious eats called for 2t for 400g of flour, but I used 2T here and it was good. Add it when you add the water (the recipe doesn't say when, just as it mixes up salt and sugar in the machine vs hand sections)
2. If you're using a dough hook, mix the dry and wet together by hand, let it sit for 10 minutes, then use the dough hook. If you're waiting for the hook to do the initial mix you're going to wait a long time :)
I ended up taking it out of the mixer and kneading it while adding maybe another 20g of flour (I didn't measure).
All that said, this was delicious. Nice open crumb, and putting the sauce on after baking was an interesting difference giving yummy chewy cheese that didn't slip off while eating. I used a 14" deep dish heavy steel round pan, so 5" less crust edge but a bit more interior.
1. No way it's 1/4c olive oil in the dough. The original recipe on serious eats called for 2t for 400g of flour, but I used 2T here and it was good. Add it when you add the water (the recipe doesn't say when, just as it mixes up salt and sugar in the machine vs hand sections)
2. If you're using a dough hook, mix the dry and wet together by hand, let it sit for 10 minutes, then use the dough hook. If you're waiting for the hook to do the initial mix you're going to wait a long time :)
I ended up taking it out of the mixer and kneading it while adding maybe another 20g of flour (I didn't measure).
All that said, this was delicious. Nice open crumb, and putting the sauce on after baking was an interesting difference giving yummy chewy cheese that didn't slip off while eating. I used a 14" deep dish heavy steel round pan, so 5" less crust edge but a bit more interior.
VeraM
March 9, 2018
I made this with 220 grams of water and the dough was very wet...it formed a dough that wouldn't stay as a ball but instead ran out into a thick puddle. I then weighed 1 cup minus 2 tablespoons and it weighed only 188 grams. I think the dough would probably be ok with that amount of water.
VeraM
March 9, 2018
12 ounces of pepperoni would be an astonishing amount for a pizza. Maybe 12 slices?
Sarah L.
November 18, 2017
Should it be salt or sugar? For mixer you said salt and recipe says salt but instructions for by hand says sugar.
Conrad S.
November 21, 2017
I tried the recipe (using salt and no sugar), and the dough did not rise.
Sugar is needed to "feed" the yeast to make the dough rise, so I think the recipe should call for 1.5 teaspoons of sugar and then salt the crust to taste.
I might be wrong, but this was the first recipe using yeast that did not explicitly call for sugar.
Sugar is needed to "feed" the yeast to make the dough rise, so I think the recipe should call for 1.5 teaspoons of sugar and then salt the crust to taste.
I might be wrong, but this was the first recipe using yeast that did not explicitly call for sugar.
Laura
April 8, 2018
Hi Conrad, I know I'm 5 months late to the party but I've decided to put my 2 cents in anyway. ;) Yeast doesn't actually require extra sugar to rise, the addition only speeds up the rising process. Most artisan breads are simply flour, water, salt & yeast! As this recipe has a very long proofing time with basically 3 rises, it should be ok. So if your didn't rise, either your yeast is dead or it was killed it accidentally (it happens to all of us). The 'sugar' in the by hand recipe was probably a typo.
b
November 18, 2017
As someone from Detroit I can say you got it right. A few quibbles though. A better pan would be castiron pan will work better, if you have a cast iron grill pan all the better. Use a mix of melted butter and olive oil to coat the pans for much better browning and crisp to the crust. You can use Montery Jack cheese as a substitute for the brick. The sauce should be Basil heavy.
Smaug
January 30, 2021
The "Crispy Cheesy Pan Pizza" recipe so popular on this site is a Detroit pizza baked in cast iron- it does work very well. The traditional pan, though, is rectangular blued steel.
See what other Food52ers are saying.