Bean
Sfogliatelle
Popular on Food52
20 Reviews
Tina H.
April 29, 2020
I mean, I had my suspicions about combining 3 cups of flour and 1 cup of water. For the love of God take this down.
Tina H.
April 29, 2020
Please destroy this recipe. Burn it. Bury it and salt the earth. This is a loser. I am not pleased at having wasted 3 cups of flour and one and 3/4 cups of butter during a pandemic. It is way too wet. :(
YS
December 25, 2018
Besides Trump, this recipe is the biggest joke of 2018.
Nina B.
December 29, 2018
Hi, YS. Can't complain about the first part of your comment but curious what you meant about the part concerning the recipe. Just seeking info here. BTW, I've never tried to make sfogliatelle, but the ones I had in Italy were heaven. Wish I had the patience.
YS
December 31, 2018
Hi Nina! The dough was way too wet, so this did not allow for proper folding of the dough. The finished product was like a pie crust, not thin and flaky. I am with you and love sfogliatelle and thought it would be a great addition to our Christmas morning breakfast. I initially read the recipe off my phone which did not have the same comments by readers as pulling the recipe up from a lap top otherwise I would of noticed the other readers comment about the dough being way too wet. I am going to try and find a recipe that shows some success by readers. My comment was aggressive because I felt that if someone is going to post a recipe that is this time consuming and challenging, then they need to test it out numerous times. I truly don't believe this was done. Hope this is helpful :)
Tina H.
May 1, 2020
Agreed. So sad I didn't read the comments or just use comment sense when evaluating this recipe. 3 cups of flour and one cup of water is a recipe for glue, not dough. What a headache!
Caitlin Y.
November 5, 2018
We found that the dough was wayyyyy too wet as written. I do not know how we got such a different result from previous commenters. Other recipes online are typically 500g flour to 175-200 g water. We had to add a lot of flour to get it to a consistency that we were comfortable running through our pasta machine.
ChefJune
July 26, 2018
I've been making these from Nick Malgieri's recipe (Great Italian Desserts) for may years, altho I was lucky enough to have an Italian pastry chef show me how to make them in his bakery. You really do have to get the strips of dough very thin in order to have the many layers of crisp pastry. Probably when you think it's thin enough, take it just a bit farther...
Olga K.
June 18, 2018
I was wondering if you could tell which type of Semolina Flour you used? There are a lot of different types. Thank you.
Barbara
January 21, 2018
Does this make more filling than needed? Instructions say to fill each of 16 pastries with 2 tablespoons of filling (32 T = 2 cups) but the ricotta alone is 2 cups. If there is filling left over, are there other desserts it can be used in?
Nicole
January 21, 2018
Is it possible to make this without a pasta machine? Is it folly to think I might be able to do this with willpower and a rolling pin?
Dixi D.
January 15, 2018
Thank you so much Laura! I have another roll of dough that I put in the freezer out of frustration! I will thaw it and give it another go. I will also watch some more videos. I did squish the dough quite a bit when forming them so I guess it is possible I squashed the layers...
Laura H.
January 15, 2018
No problem! I hope that’s what it was! They come out beautiful when you get the hang of it! I’m glad you still have more dough! I also found a used copy of this book on Amazon and followed his techniques for spreading out the layers: Great Italian Desserts by Nick Malgieri. You want to follow the directions for sfogliatelle ricce. He has illustrations.
Dixi D.
January 15, 2018
I recently made this recipe, took the dough down to a 7 on my kitchenaid pasta sheeter. I followed the directions exactly and when the final product was baked, my pastries were more like pie crust than flaky thin layers. What do you think went wrong?
Laura H.
January 15, 2018
First, I am just an avid home cook, NOT a chef, but having combined a few recipes and made these several times...I’m thinking that it’s possible you squished those layers together when shaping them before filling. I found this website very helpful for watching how to make them: www.sbs.com.au
I watched several videos in Italian (that I couldn’t understand) and looked up several recipes before I first made them.
I watched several videos in Italian (that I couldn’t understand) and looked up several recipes before I first made them.
Laura H.
January 13, 2018
I have watched many videos and read many recipes for sfogliatelle, which have been my favorite Italian pastry since I was little. The recipe I finally came up with is slightly different from yours, but yours sounds delicious as well. I figured I'd offer a suggestion for those making these for the first time. When I lay my sheet down on the counter, and before I start to stretch it out further, I find it easier to smear the butter (I use shortening) on then, this way I don't end up with more tears! I have also doubled my dough recipe to create a larger finished product!
Nina B.
January 12, 2018
Do you recommend supermarket type all-purpose flour (GM usually), or premium AP such as King Arthur, which has a higher protein content? This is too challenging a project to not get this right!
See what other Food52ers are saying.