Bake

Peanut Butter & Chocolate Chocolate Chip Cookies

December 23, 2019
18 Ratings
Photo by Rocky Luten. Food Stylist: Anna Billingskog. Prop Stylist: Sophie Strangio.
Author Notes

I love pools of chocolate as much as the next cookie monster, but boy am I sick of chopping bars! And juggling bowls. And chilling dough. And sprinkling flaky salt just so. This cookie recipe returns to a simpler time when everything is mixed by hand in one bowl and the baking happens right away. Plus, best of all, it uses actual chocolate chips. If it’s been a while, I encourage you to rediscover how delightful a slightly melted chip can be.

The big twist here is black cocoa powder, the cocoa du jour in baking circles right now. It adds a bitter edge to cut through the sugary base and rich peanut butter notes. It also adds a stunning, coal-black backdrop for the chocolate chips to sparkle.

And do they sparkle.

The other night, I brought a container of these cookies on the subway. The woman sitting next to me asked if I made them and we chatted for a bit. At one point I said, “…is this weird? Do you want one?” She eagerly pulled a rinsed-out salad container from her bag and I gave her one. When I opened the lid to hand over the cookies, the woman sitting on my other side said, "Oh my god, those smell incredible. Can I buy one off of you?" So I gave her one, too (without charge, of course).

I loved that these cookies, a throwback in their own way, brought a few New Yorkers together on a cold, random night on the subway. —Casey Elsass

  • Prep time 10 minutes
  • Cook time 15 minutes
  • Makes 10 cookies
Ingredients
  • 1 stick unsalted butter
  • 1/4 cup all-natural smooth peanut butter
  • 1/2 cup granulated sugar
  • 1/2 cup packed light brown sugar
  • 1 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1 large egg
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
  • 1/4 cup black cocoa powder
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking soda
  • 1/2 teaspoon baking powder
  • 1 cup all-purpose flour
  • 8 ounces semi-sweet chocolate chips
In This Recipe
Directions
  1. Set racks in the center and lower third of the oven and preheat to 350°F. Line two rimmed baking sheets with parchment paper or silicone mats.
  2. Add the butter and peanut butter to a small skillet and set over low heat. Use a rubber spatula to stir occasionally, as the butter melts and the peanut butter softens, to form a cohesive mixture. Remove from the heat and set aside.
  3. In a medium bowl, combine the granulated sugar, brown sugar, and salt. Pour in the melted butter mixture and whisk to form a smooth, cohesive paste, about 1 minute. Add the egg and vanilla extract and whisk again for about 2 minutes, until well incorporated and slightly aerated.
  4. Add the black cocoa powder, baking soda, and baking powder. Use a rubber spatula to fold and fully combine. Add the flour and chocolate chips. Fold again, until just combined.
  5. Use a 1 1/2–ounce cookie scoop, or three tablespoons, to portion the dough onto the baking sheets, leaving 2 inches between each scoop. Bake for about 12 minutes, rotating and turning the sheets halfway through, until the cookies are puffed and slightly spread.
  6. Remove the sheets from the oven. Lift one of the sheets a few inches above the counter and let it drop. Repeat three more times to flatten and spread the cookies. Repeat with the other sheet. Let the cookies cool completely on the sheets.

See what other Food52ers are saying.

  • Melanie
    Melanie
  • Linda V.
    Linda V.
  • Caroline Bailey
    Caroline Bailey
  • mrslarkin
    mrslarkin
  • Catherine
    Catherine

23 Reviews

jonne April 4, 2021
A superstar recipe! Will be making this a lot!
 
Melanie November 23, 2020
These are so easy and so good!
 
julieray13 July 24, 2020
Consistently excellent. Also made with white chocolate chips at my son's request, and also delicious. I get comments like "these are the best cookies I've ever tasted!" Enjoyed and inspired by Amanda's video!
 
Michelle July 21, 2020
I watched these cookies being made on IG and just knew I had to try them in a GlutenFree version. Best cookie I have ever made - I used regular cooking cocoa but will look for Black Cocoa. My glutenFree/SoyFree/DairyFree/NutFree customers request this cookies ALL the time! Win Win!
 
beanieweenie May 27, 2020
Loved the flavor! Will definitely be making them again. Mine turned out a bit flat/thin (any tips to make them thicker/fluffier?). I did use almond flour instead of all purpose flour which could have been the issue.
 
fearlessem May 21, 2020
These are my new favorite cookies -- outrageously good. I thought the first batch I made was just a little greasy, so tried a second batch using 6 Tbs of butter rather than 8 and thought that was perfect!
 
fearlessem May 21, 2020
Editing to add that I used about 2 Tbs for each cookie and got 11 out of a batch... 11 doesn't seem like nearly enough, but these are rich rich rich.
 
judy N. May 4, 2020
o.m.g. these cookies are awesome! My 16 yo son has been making at least one-two batches a week with me since corona lockdown started (6 weeks) - I make them smaller than the recipe suggests (a rounded tablespoon) and I used good quality regular cocoa powder - since that's what we have. Banging them to flatten them works. So good.
 
Linda V. April 24, 2020
Amazing!! They are easy and delicious. Freeze well also, so I won't eat them on the first day. Definitely passing this one on!!
 
Camille April 22, 2020
Incredible! Doubled the recipe, made with 1/2 regular (dutched) cocoa powder and 1/2 black cocoa powder, used Trader Joe's smooth natural PB, used a 1 1/2 tbsp scoop so mine were a bit smaller than recipe recommends but that's probably better for my health since I ate so many! Our new favorite one bowl cookie in this house.
 
Holly April 20, 2020
Wow. These were so good. I used regular cocoa and I used almond butter. So decadent. Amazing. I had four today😳!!
 
Caroline B. April 19, 2020
My new favorite cookie. I used Dutch chocolate and chunky peanut butter because it’s what I had and threw in some walnuts. Sprinkled with coarse salt. Yummy!
 
fearlessem May 21, 2020
Oooh, I bet chunky PB would be really good in these!
 
Jenny February 24, 2020
These are so good! I doubled the recipe and used vanilla paste instead of extract (1:1) they're very rich & satisfying without being too sweet. The amount of salt is just perfect to help level out the sweetness and the peanut butter flavor is barely detectable. So very good!
 
kmb February 21, 2020
These are dangerously delicious. I doubled the recipe and used a two tablespoon scoop to get a bigger yield for an event. I mixed them by hand with a silicone spatula and added all the dry ingredients at once instead of cocoa then the rest. I also only banged the pans once as I took them out of the oven and they spread nicely.
 
mrslarkin December 31, 2019
These cookies are fab. I used the stand mixer. And regular cocoa. And chunky pb. Made 20 balls. Baked about 12 min. Delicious!
 
LG December 24, 2019
I made these tonight and was pretty disappointed. Although they were a quick one-bowl recipe to make, the cookies did not spread at all in the oven so they ended up looking like small poops (even after dropping the pan). I tried it a few different ways too, I baked it after putting them in the freezer for 10m, I tried flattening them first, I tried making them smaller - either way it came out the same. Very disappointing because I had such high hopes for this recipe!
 
Catherine January 18, 2020
Did you forget the baking soda, by chance? I've accidentally done that before in other cookie recipes and had similar issues to what you described.
 
Jenny February 24, 2020
It doesn't recommend putting them in the freezer - maybe that was part of the problem too?
 
Michelle April 19, 2020
did you check the date on your baking powder? Ive use powder that was close to the date and had a similar issues.

Did you tap them on the counter before you put them in the oven - the istagram video shows her taping them so they spread.
 
Anne J. February 18, 2021
Good point, I test mine with Luke warm water EVERY TIME I use it. New or old, used it yesterday, I still check. Ingredients are to valuable to waste for a dud.
 
Babs1967 December 24, 2019
These are easy to make and so good! I didn’t have black cocoa powder and just used regular. I also added half peanut butter and dark chocolate chips. Sinfully good!
 
Babs1967 December 24, 2019
These are sinfully good. Easy as well!