Egg
Classic French Macarons
Popular on Food52
3 Reviews
Food52recipessuck
April 14, 2023
These were the most crusty dusty musty frusty grusty nusty fugly little almond dessert I’ve had in my entire life. The almond overpowered it SO much and the recipe had the nerve to put GRAMS in the measurements instead of cups or spoons. Never ever make these. This also took like two hours to make, and it was disgusting. Now the buttercream is foaming on top and it’s all weird and looks like puke. And now I have to clean up the kitchen after the huge mess. Great. Thanks.
Will
October 18, 2022
The recipe CLEARLY states that this DOESN'T use simple syrup, yet the 9th step in the recipe is for a simple syrup. Also the recipe states it makes 20-24 cookies, but doesn't specify if it's 20-24 with the cream or without. When I made this, I barely had enough for 10 full macarons, not 20. Also step 7 should not be optional, as without resting leads to a higher chance of cracking or breaking of the cookie when baking. And I only got 4 cookies out of this recipe. If anyone wants to make this recipe, make at least 2x or 3x what they call for the cookie, but keep the cream the same.
edibletimes
October 18, 2022
Will,
I'm sorry you found this confusing. The simple syrup in Step 9 is not the method for the macaron batter, but for the French buttercream filling. The macaron batter does not require making an Italian (cooked) meringue with syrup. It is the French method of simply beating granulated sugar with raw egg whites.
I make this recipe several times a week for clients with a template and get 20, 1.5" filled macarons, if not more. If you are piping larger macarons, you will certainly get less. On the subject of resting macarons, it is beneficial to help correct inconsistencies in the meringue or batter and get the signature look of a macaron. But resting is not necessary for everyone in every kitchen.
I'm sorry you found this confusing. The simple syrup in Step 9 is not the method for the macaron batter, but for the French buttercream filling. The macaron batter does not require making an Italian (cooked) meringue with syrup. It is the French method of simply beating granulated sugar with raw egg whites.
I make this recipe several times a week for clients with a template and get 20, 1.5" filled macarons, if not more. If you are piping larger macarons, you will certainly get less. On the subject of resting macarons, it is beneficial to help correct inconsistencies in the meringue or batter and get the signature look of a macaron. But resting is not necessary for everyone in every kitchen.
See what other Food52ers are saying.