Back to School
Extra Oat-y Oatmeal Cream Pies
Popular on Food52
9 Reviews
judy
July 20, 2021
Made these this weekend--minus the filling. Not a fan. But the cookies were delicious. Yes the instructions were out of order, but I figured it out. I reduced the sugar by about 25% as we like them less sweet. A little crumbly due to reduced sugar, but that was ok. Excellent with milk--regular milk for us....
angco4
July 13, 2021
Definitely an incredible recipe. My only modification would be to half the butter, and double the marshmallow fluff in the frosting. At room temperature, the filling gets too liquid
Chanel W.
September 25, 2020
Going to attempt to make these this weekend! I did just want to mention it looks like the recipe steps are out of order towards the end there.
Chanel W.
September 27, 2020
Update: made these today and they are delicious. The brown butter and molasses really stand out in this recipe. Adding this to my regular rotation of baking recipes.
Ironstring
September 28, 2020
Were the steps out of order? If so, what steps did you follow? Thanks.
Chanel W.
September 28, 2020
Yeah, steps 8-11 are mixed up somehow. I chilled the cookies after baking for 15 min (I think that's what the recipe calls for) and then made my frosting while they were cooling in the fridge. The frosting directions are messed up but I basically beat the butter, powdered sugar and oat milk together on med high for about 3 min. Then I added the vanilla, salt and marshmallow fluff and beat for another minute. Assembled the cookies after that. Hope this helps!
Happygoin
September 23, 2020
I'm sure an experienced baker could figure out how to bake and fill these, however, the instructions should be edited for novice bakers. Some of the steps are out of order and some are in there twice.
Erin A.
October 2, 2020
Hey there! I'm so sorry for the confusion on this recipe, it's just been updated. Happy baking!
See what other Food52ers are saying.