Chill
Milk Chocolate Cream Pie
Popular on Food52
5 Reviews
Kara L.
November 24, 2021
I was SO confused about this recipe until I read the comment about the chocolate ganache ingredients that had been left out! That really needs to be fixed!
BUT this pie was AMAZING! The perfect milk chocolate flavor. It was taking much longer than 2-3 min for my custard to thicken on the stovetop, so I bumped up the heat a little bit but then it started to get lumpy, so I guess you just have to be patient during that part. I was able to get all the lumps out with a whisk and it set perfectly in the fridge.
BUT this pie was AMAZING! The perfect milk chocolate flavor. It was taking much longer than 2-3 min for my custard to thicken on the stovetop, so I bumped up the heat a little bit but then it started to get lumpy, so I guess you just have to be patient during that part. I was able to get all the lumps out with a whisk and it set perfectly in the fridge.
Lora S.
November 14, 2021
The recipe above is missing the ingredients for the MILK chocolate ganache:
•113 grams finely chopped milk chocolate
•60 grams heavy cream
I've made this pie 3 times now, all for birthdays, and they were all hits! For your chocolate lovers, I highly recommend this pie!
I made one change, for the ganache, I used Erin's "Black Bottom" ganache recipe from The Book On Pie. I used 60% dark chocolate to compliment to milk chocolate pudding.
Black Bottom Ganache:
113 grams finely chopped dark chocolate
78 grams heavy cream
•113 grams finely chopped milk chocolate
•60 grams heavy cream
I've made this pie 3 times now, all for birthdays, and they were all hits! For your chocolate lovers, I highly recommend this pie!
I made one change, for the ganache, I used Erin's "Black Bottom" ganache recipe from The Book On Pie. I used 60% dark chocolate to compliment to milk chocolate pudding.
Black Bottom Ganache:
113 grams finely chopped dark chocolate
78 grams heavy cream
markp
October 25, 2021
What am I missing here? Looks like there is 5 oz chocolate. But they mention chocolate twice: once for the ganache and once for the filling. Are you supposed to divide it?
scraps
September 19, 2021
I am suuuper picky about my chocolate cream pie. I like the filling like pudding, not mousse. I like a plain pastry crust (not sweet and certainly not Oreos). And lastly, I just want a simple small pie. Not a deep dish behemoth that we can’t finish.
The filling I can do with ease, though I don’t like it too sweet. I was skeptical about this recipe but Erin’s description really sold me that it wouldn’t be overly sweet.
The crust is what gets me every time. I suck at them, and I am otherwise an extremely accomplished home baker. This recipe on its own may not seem like much, but click around and find Erin’s pie crust videos on Food52, and that will explain it all. Not only did my crust turn out pretty good, but from her videos, I know exactly what I can do to improve next time.
Finished pie tasted amazing. 6 of us finished the entire thing, so the size was perfect too. Absolutely 100% not too sweet. Just perfect chocolate pie.
One thing though— my ganache didn’t turn out at all. It was runny like syrup. I’ve made ganache tons of times with dark chocolate; perhaps the milk chocolate is the difference here?
The filling I can do with ease, though I don’t like it too sweet. I was skeptical about this recipe but Erin’s description really sold me that it wouldn’t be overly sweet.
The crust is what gets me every time. I suck at them, and I am otherwise an extremely accomplished home baker. This recipe on its own may not seem like much, but click around and find Erin’s pie crust videos on Food52, and that will explain it all. Not only did my crust turn out pretty good, but from her videos, I know exactly what I can do to improve next time.
Finished pie tasted amazing. 6 of us finished the entire thing, so the size was perfect too. Absolutely 100% not too sweet. Just perfect chocolate pie.
One thing though— my ganache didn’t turn out at all. It was runny like syrup. I’ve made ganache tons of times with dark chocolate; perhaps the milk chocolate is the difference here?
See what other Food52ers are saying.