American
Sourdough Baps
Popular on Food52
19 Reviews
Tiff
August 10, 2023
Just returned from Ireland and wanted to recreate an amazing breakfast Bap I had in County Clare. This is a perfect analog for the original one. As always, I'm grateful for your great recipes!
Smaug
July 15, 2023
I suppose I'll have to try this, though I generally just wing it on buns; I often make just one or two with starter discards. I also typically use about 75g. dough for a bun (3 1/2" which is what mostly threw me about this- 125 g. seems like an awful lot, even accounting for differences in the consistency of the dough. By the by, I find it useful to use English muffin rings with buns; it leaves a vertical side that makes it easier to split the bun and eliminates thin edges that burn when toasted.
Smaug
July 15, 2023
ps- I also wonder about the term "bench scraper", which seems to have come into common use among recipe writers. I suppose its taken from the woodworking tool of the same name, which looks similar although it functions quite differently, but woodworking takes place on benches, whereas cooking is typically on counters or tables. I generally stick to the traditional "dough scraper", though "counter scraper" has a certain rhythmic appeal.
Karen B.
August 25, 2022
Well worth the time and effort. Great as a hamburger bun. Toasted as a base for sloppy Joe's or pulled pork sandwiches. Husband likes them split, toasted and spread with butter and marmalade for breakfast.
Raydee8
August 26, 2021
Looking forward to making these….but prefer using lard as you mentioned…..how many grams?? Same as oil? Thanks!
Liz S.
August 26, 2021
The second time I made this recipe, I used lard (non hydrogenated fresh leaf lard) and used 64 grams ... same as the oil. I liked the lard version best ... but I did also sub 40 grams of potato flour for same amount of bread flour. I often add some potato flour to "roll" recipes or other bread that I'd like a bit softer. My bread flour (WheatMT) is a hard red spring flour.
Raydee8
August 29, 2021
Nice! I was wondering about liquefying the lard…and love the potato flour suggestion too…..thanks!
Liz S.
August 29, 2021
I feel like I need to do a full disclosure, just in case ... with any bread/sourdough recipe ... so much is dependent on each person's conditions: flour, temp, humidity, method, etc., etc. AND experience with knowing when dough is "ready" at each stage.
I am a huge fan of Maurizio and several of his recipes are my absolute favorites ... BUT ... I vary in method. Long story about why which is not important. I mostly skip overnight levain. I put in stand mixer bowl, in this order: water, starter, oil, flour, salt. (this recipe has some sugar so I add with the salt). Then, I mix at slow speed until all incorporated. Let rest for 30-60 minutes. Then mix at gradually higher speed until full speed and until the dough is on the hook. Typically, I mix late afternoon, then an hour or 2 of "bulk" at room temp, then refrigerate overnight. Shape, rise and bake in the morning. This works FOR ME :) There are lots of reasons for levain and other methods and Maurizio explains all on his site.
The other thing. With these enriched rolls, I found that I needed lower temp and less time than recipe. I don't know why. But, just a heads up to keep an eye on things your first round.
I am a huge fan of Maurizio and several of his recipes are my absolute favorites ... BUT ... I vary in method. Long story about why which is not important. I mostly skip overnight levain. I put in stand mixer bowl, in this order: water, starter, oil, flour, salt. (this recipe has some sugar so I add with the salt). Then, I mix at slow speed until all incorporated. Let rest for 30-60 minutes. Then mix at gradually higher speed until full speed and until the dough is on the hook. Typically, I mix late afternoon, then an hour or 2 of "bulk" at room temp, then refrigerate overnight. Shape, rise and bake in the morning. This works FOR ME :) There are lots of reasons for levain and other methods and Maurizio explains all on his site.
The other thing. With these enriched rolls, I found that I needed lower temp and less time than recipe. I don't know why. But, just a heads up to keep an eye on things your first round.
Maurizio L.
August 30, 2021
What you said there in your comment is exactly what I hope for every baker in the long run: they adapt to the always-changing conditions in their kitchen to make the best bread possible. What works for me will likely need changing in your own kitchen, and vice versa, and I'm always hoping to teach a little more about the "why" something is done to help bakers build up their own intuition. For me, the best thing about baking is the variability, it keeps me on my toes and always engages my critical thinking. And then at the end of it all, we get to eat delicious and healthy bread 🙂 Thanks for the comments as always, Liz!
Kiwi5
August 6, 2021
These came out perfectly. Thanks for the great recipes. Hamburgers are on the menu for tonight
Abryce
August 3, 2021
Absolutely fantastic..my husband is from Scotland 🏴 …had a bacon roll..yum yum 🤤 is all I can say..graci
Liz S.
August 1, 2021
I liked these a lot!! I followed the timeline in the recipe, differed from method slightly as I added all ingredients including oil (canola) and mixed at high speed (after initial incorporation) until all dough was on the hook. Despite a heat wave here in Montana, because I refrigerate my house to 68-70F, I let the bulk and the shaped rise go 1 hour and .5 hour longer. I used the milk wash and flour and they are gorgeous and delicious. I think I have made all of your bun recipes and these plus the ciabatta rolls tie for my personal favorites. Flavor, texture, how they hold ingredients ... both work very well for me. Thank you again, Maurizio! (Photo results on my IG post)
Maurizio L.
August 2, 2021
So happy to hear all of this, Liz! Great work on the adjustments to suit your climate, and even though you added everything at the get-go, it'll still work in the end as long as the dough is mixed to sufficient development—which it sounds like you did 🙂 Enjoy!
See what other Food52ers are saying.